Some reviewers claimed that this is not only the best baseball novel ever written by a woman, but the best baseball novel ever written. It depends, I guess, on what a person is seeking in a baseball novel. If you seek sentimentality this book is not for you. If you seek warm-heartedness and inspirition, this book is not for you. If you seek a discussion of the American "idea" in the context of baseball, like Philip Roth did in his "Great American Novel", this book is not for you. If, however, you seek a novel about a trailblazing female sports writer in the baseball locker room of the fictional second coming of the expansion Washington Senators, owned by the founder of a religious TV network as payback for delivering the Conservative Christian vote to a (Republican) president, a shocking, to some, portrait painted through a female sports reporter's eyes, exposing (the locker room exposed) team with with compassion and uncommon grace, this novel is for you. I didn't know quite what to think of it at the beginning, but as the novel moved along, everything started falling into place. And when I finished I joined the camp of the reviewers who claim that this is the best baseball novel ever written. I am rating it five stars. I note that the overall rating for the book in Goodreads is three and a half stars. That is understandable.
This book will not appeal to the sensibilities of all readers. True Puritans will not like it at all. It is the kind of book book burners would like to burn because it contradicts all their warm feeling about their diamond heroes and is "a corrupting influence" on their children. Jane Leavy, who rests her reputation more on the laurels of her best-selling biographies of Sandy Koufax and Mickey Mantle, writes without fear of such reactions. She has a writer's heart, one that takes her wherever the story leads her. I have nothing but admiration for writers with that kind of heart. Words are precious. They have the power not only to move hearts and move minds, but shake the very foundations and presuppositions of society. I have not read her Koufax bio, yet. I have read "The Last Boy", the Mickey Mantle one, though. I plan to read Koufax soon. I am like a fly and good books about baseball are like flypaper to me. I can't resist them. Especially ones like "Squeeze Play". Especially one some, including me, consider to be the best baseball novel ever written.