Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Cottage in the Woods

Rate this book
For fans of Shannon Hale, Adam Gidwitz, and Michael Buckley comes a luminous new twist on a tale readers only thought they knew. . .
 
Once upon a time, there was a girl with golden locks. But that’s just the beginning of this tale. The real story begins with a bear.
 
Ursula is a young she-bear who has come to work as a governess at the Vaughn estate. Although she is eager to instruct her young charge, Teddy, she is also frightened, especially when inexplicable things happen in the huge house after dark. Ursula is sure she has heard footsteps in the hallways at night, and that something is following her during her walks in the Enchanted Forest. Then there is Mr. Bentley, a young bear also employed by Mr. Vaughn, whose superior disposition is enough to drive Ursula to tears . . . and yet why does he also make her heart race? As Ursula works to unravel the mysteries of the Vaughn manor, she will have to be very, very careful. After all, true love, justice, and a girl with golden locks are at stake. And in the Enchanted Forest, not every fairy tale is destined for a happily ever after.

400 pages, Paperback

First published February 10, 2015

22 people are currently reading
1089 people want to read

About the author

Katherine Coville

41 books32 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
176 (30%)
4 stars
233 (40%)
3 stars
120 (21%)
2 stars
30 (5%)
1 star
11 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews
Profile Image for Tamora Pierce.
Author 99 books85.2k followers
April 30, 2015
This is one of the most unusual fairytale retellings I have ever read--I'd say so even if I didn't know the writer! In a way it's a new look at "Goldilocks and the Three Bears" from the point of view of the bears, but in a far larger way it is not. The bears are well-to-do, civilized people, citizens of a town that is half human and half beings from what we would recognize as fairytales.

Coville has introduced some new wrinkles, particularly racism on the part of both populations, with violence rising in the human community. There is also a wonderful touch of romance for Ursula, the bear governess who comes to work with the family's son and ends up sheltering a human child who has been badly abused. Coville gives the fairytale characters their own, unique personalities, seldom all good or all bad. Ursula is a female hero who grows from girl into woman during the course of the book, finding the source of her own bravery, and the court trial is absolutely wonderful.

It is a read for more advanced young readers, but I'd also recommend it for adults to read aloud to younger childen. It's the kind of book that begs for someone to interpret the different voices and talk about the ideas that are raised. Adult readers too will find it a fascinating read, and Katherine Coville a wonderful new writer to watch! (Yes, the name isn't a coincidence--she's kidlit king Bruce Coville's wife and often illustrator who has found a wonderful new string to her bow.)
Profile Image for Aeicha .
832 reviews110 followers
February 18, 2015
Jane Eyre + The Three Little Bears, this is what Katherine Coville’s The Cottage in the Woods is...and yet, it is so much more. In the Enchanted Forest, home to humans, enchanted animals, and regular animals, there is is a cottage. Well, really it is a vast estate. This is the home of Mr. and Mrs. Vaughn and their young cub, Teddy. Fresh out of school Ursula has come to the cottage to be Teddy’s governess. Ursula soon finds herself wrapped up in a golden haired mystery, the unlucky nemesis of a grumpy nurse, in the middle of a community war, and losing her heart to the infuriatingly handsome Mr. Bentley.

The Cottage in the Woods is one of the most original and loveliest fairytale/classic retellings I’ve ever read. I’ll admit that I had my doubts when I first learned of this book and its Jane Eyre inspired, full of talking bears premise...but Coville certainly squashed my doubts and impressed me with her captivating storytelling. This story may be full of fairytale elements and talking animals, but it is anything but childish. With its classic, Victorian prose and dialogue, The Cottage in the Woods has such an eloquent and refined air about it, without feeling stiff or flowery. Coville creates a wonderfully charming, believable setting with the Enchanted Forest, the Vaughn estate, and the little hamlet around it. The fairytale elements are just the right mix of whimsical, humorous, and refreshing. Coville introduces many well known fairytale stories and characters in completely new and entertaining ways!

One of the things I like best about this book, is the way that after the first few pages, I almost forgot that the main characters were enchanted animals and merely saw them as complex, interesting characters. Our heroine Ursula is a sweet, smart girl who isn’t afraid of a little adventure and I really liked getting to know her. Ursula is surrounded by an eclectic and amusing group of enchanted animals and humans, from fun Teddy, endearing Goldilocks, nasty Nurse, lovable Mr. Wright, and of course, the handsome Mr. Bentley.

But The Cottage in the Woods isn’t all fairytales and romance. With the brewing tension between the enchanted animals and a sect of humans, Coville makes a poignant and relevant statement about prejudice and human nature.

My Final Thoughts: Unique, enchanting, clever...The Cottage in the Woods is all of this and more!
Profile Image for Cate Brooks.
240 reviews30 followers
April 23, 2015
Fun little lark of a read in the fractured fairy tale meets period romance - I think the line being used is "Goldilocks meets Jane Eyre." Very unusual, witty and well done - the only trouble will be who to recommend this one to. It will take the right kid who has a pretty sophisticated sense of humor and range of vocabulary but is young at heart and wants a very Austen/Bronte kind of romance...with bears from an enchanted forest. There's a niche for all books but I don't see high circ stats on this. Just hitting the spot with a few of my old soul readers. There are a handful of those in these parts. And as one myself, I really enjoyed this one.
Profile Image for Monica Edinger.
Author 6 books354 followers
September 20, 2014
my blog review.

I love fairy tale reworkings. At the same time their popularity of late has resulted in a lot of mediocrity and so when I come across something new I'm both excited and wary. Is it going to be a goofy-movie-Shrek-imitating-like thing or more in the vein of Michael Buckley's Fairy Tale Detectives, Christopher Healy's Hero's Guides, or Adam Gidwitz's Grimm series?  And if YA dark is it going to be a lame bodice-ripper or something with heft, like Tom McNeal's Far Far Away? And so seeing a  description of Katherine Coville's debut novel The Cottage in the Woods on Edelweiss,  I requested it on a whim and began reading it with very low expectations.  And so what a lovely surprise when it turned out to be completely engrossing, a book I read steadily until I was done. In other words, reader, I liked it very much.

The story is a unique melding of a Regency Romance/Victorian Gothic set within a fairy tale world. Our heroine and narrator is Ursula Brown, a very proper young bear who has come to the Cottage in the Woods, the wealthy Vaughn family's estate near Bremen Town, as their young cub's governess. The three Vaughn bears live an elegant and refined life and Ursula slips into it without much difficulty, tolerating Mr. Vaughn's stern admonitions, appreciating Mrs. Vaughn's kind gestures, and falling very much in love with her sweet young charge, Teddy.  But life in the area is not easy. The Enchanted -- those animals who talk, dress, and act as humans do --- are struggling with envy, prejudice, racial hostility, and out-and-out vigilantism from some of their human neighbors.

The publisher indicates that this is a reworking of "Goldilocks and the Three Bears." It is indeed, but I don't wish to give away just how. I will say that I found it an enormously clever rethinking of that particular story, very much in keeping with the literary tradition Coville is working in, that of the Victorian novel.  I've been reading and listening to a lot of them these days and so I was very impressed with how well Coville used those tropes in her story. Ursula is very introspective, the various Enchanteds in her world are as proper and polite as anyone in an Austen, Bronte, Eliot, or Trollope novel. There is plenty of drama here, but not the swashbuckling sort of some of the other fairy tale workings. And while somber on occasion it isn't as dark as some of the YA ones around.

There are so many clever fairy tale/nursery rhyme touches that also allude to the Victorian novel tradtion. For instance, Teddy's nurse is an illiterate tippling badger who is quite jealous of our heroine and an amusing contrast to the cozy cute ones of Potter and others. Best of all is the Goldilock's plot thread --- it is a brilliant rethinking of the story within a classic Victorian Gothic setting.  And I love the representation of the doctor who comes to examine her at one point with his Freud-like Viennese accent.

So keep an eye out for this one. I can't wait to see what others make of it.
Profile Image for J.
281 reviews3 followers
January 13, 2015
The Cottage in the Woods is an odd book. It's largely a Gothic romance with enchanted forest animals as the main characters intermingling with the odd human here or there. The story is told in first person by Ursula Brown, a young bear taken on as governess at the Cottage in the Woods. Her ward is young Teddy who she finds to be smart and trusting. But there are mysteries and dangers afoot including the discovery of a young girl that could cause the tensions between enchanted creatures and humans in Bremen Town to come to a head.

While the publisher states this book is aimed at 10+, it reads more like an Austen or Bronte sisters novel. In fact, some bits have directly been pulled from Austen or Bronte stories, but also a number of Grimm's fairy tales appear and play large in Miss Brown's telling of her story. I suspect that, as an adult, I pick up on and appreciate the references much more than a child or teen who is unfamiliar with the hinted at texts. Even more, I suspect that the target group will have a hard time getting into the rhythm of the book. Katherine Coville's writing is quite dense and littered with SAT vocab words, a few of which this experienced reader had to look up. If it weren't for the interminable adjectives and overly verbose explanations of happenings, I would have flown through rather than slogged toward the end. At times the book is compelling, but mostly it's a long winded, detail filled account with a hefty amount of allegory about race relations thrown in. I didn't hate the book. I just wanted it to not feel like a chore to get to the inevitable conclusion.

Note: ARC received via Amazon Vine in exchange for a review.
Profile Image for Shoshana.
619 reviews53 followers
February 5, 2015
In two words: absolutely phenomenal.

In more than two words:

The book opens with Ursula, a she-bear, introducing her story of her time as a governess at The Cottage. From the get-go it has a very "Jane Eyre" feel - now, "Jane Eyre" is my favorite book in all the evers, and I have to admit at first I kept a wary eye out for this just being a JE re-telling, but with bears. But it's so, so much more. Yes, the Bronte-like tone carries throughout the book, but the story is very, very much its own. (Even as a Goldilocks retelling.)

Characters from other stories - Mother Hubbard, Peter Pumpkin Eater, among others - peep in and out of the story, giving it color and fairy-tale feel. Setting the story in Bremen was a stroke of genius on Coville's part. Of COURSE the figures of tales would live in the city with the folklore of the animal musicians.

Ursula exists in full, not just as a mouthpiece for the story. All three bears and Goldilocks are fully realized and grow in their own ways throughout. The subplots of "racial" discrimination never feel shoe-horned or out of place, and serve to give the story depth and realism.

I can't really sing this book's praises enough. Fans of Austen, Bronte, Shannon Hale, Patricia C Wrede, and Tamora Pierce should all give it a go. And everyone else too.
Profile Image for Munro's Kids.
557 reviews22 followers
January 11, 2018
In this retelling of Goldilocks and the Three Bears, we see through the eyes of the new young governess hired by the Vaughn family (AKA the three bears) to educate their young son Teddy. She quickly realizes that the household carries secrets: who or what scurries around the house at night? And who is young Mr. Bentley, the arrogant but compelling bear who shows up when least expected?

That's probably the best way I could paint this book. I really have no idea who the intended audience is: the writing style really clashes with the content. This book is basically a Jane Austen and Charlotte Bronte mash-up that tries to retell a classic fairy tale while throwing in cameos of many others: the Pied Piper, Mother Hubbard, Peter Pumpkin-Eater, the little old lady who lives in a shoe, the Musicians of Bremen Town, etc. It was just too much. The author also brought in a lot of moral issues into the book: racism, family values, alcoholism, etc. which made me wonder exactly who this book is for.

To sum up: while well-written, the classical Austen/Bronte tone and complex moral issues clashed with the "kiddish" context of Goldilocks and the Three Bears, making this book difficult to recommend.

My biggest complaint by far, though: they really missed out on an opportunity to call this book "Jane Beyre" (Bear/Eyre? Eh? Eh? Humour me here....)
Profile Image for R.E. Banks.
31 reviews6 followers
June 27, 2017
The ending made me cry.
At first, I got the impression that the story was going to be boring and silly, with the whole plot revolving around the mysterious walker in the night. Oh, and the Mr. Bentley, which we are told from the blurb that he 'makes her heart race'. Sigh. Predictable.
Not so.
This book had several issues revolving around it, with surprisingly deep and more serious concepts than usually found in children's books. This is NOT one of those empty, dumbed-down books for children. (And it's a rather hefty novel, if I do say so myself.) THE BLURB DOES NOT DO IT JUSTICE! It only focuses on the minor aspects of the plot, and makes it seem like the book is full of magic. IT IS SO MUCH BETTER THAN YOU FIRST THINK.
The romance -- where to begin?
WHY CAN'T YA BOOKS HAVE LOVE LIKE THIS? It's all, "Oh my gosh! Like, he's so hot, like, that must mean I love him! *dreamy sigh* He's so MUSCLY!! And flirty!"
BUT THIS BOOK FOCUSES ON QUALITIES! PERSONALITY! The kind of love you know is true, and will last. The feelings that will never go away. The author does a SPECTACULAR job, writing out the emotions and feelings you can't describe. Cliche is abandoned here. I had to stay up until midnight to finish it, which is highly unusual for me.
So unpredictable.
I cried at the end because it had the same kind of Whisper-Of-The-Heart feeling of true love. BY THE WAY, I can't remember the last time I cried over a book. This novel is truly moving. Actually, it made me want to chuck my own novel in the garbage in despair, because I'll never be able to craft a romance like this. Oh yeah, and there was a plot besides that too. *scratches nose sheepishly* But what was truly astounding was the love. I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR A LOVE STORY LIKE THIS FOR AGES.
The last two pages or so I wasn't too big on, but overall, great climax, great unpredictable romance, great story.
I will re-read this for sure.
Profile Image for Liviania.
957 reviews75 followers
February 24, 2015
I love fairytale retellings, and was familiar with Katherine Coville's art from the work she did on her husband Bruce Coville's novels. I was quite curious to see what she would do with the story of "Goldilocks and the Three Bears." It turns out that she would marry it to Victorian romance and social issues in an engrossing pastiche.

Ursula travels to the Vaughn home to be a governess to Teddy, an unusually well-behaved child. She soon discovers that the house holds a secret, a young blonde human. Meanwhile, she finds herself drawn to Mr. Bentley, a fellow employee of the house, despite a disastrous first meeting. She also finds herself involved in local politics, as the Enchanted of the town work to live with the humans as equals, not lessers.

I loved how the fairytale story weaved together with a Pride-and-Prejudice-esque plotline for Ursula and the tensions between the Anthropological Society and the men's choir (as the pro-humans and equality factions are known). What I'm not so sure is that the middle grade audience will enjoy it. It's a long story, and the style is somewhat old fashioned. I think it's a treat, but would a ten year old?

I think it is worth a try for any fan of fairytales. The twists on Goldilocks are clever, as are the references to other stories such as "The Musicians of Bremen." At the very least, it might make a good read-aloud book. But I think the main audience is older, the sort who enjoy classic literature as well as a bit of whimsy.
Profile Image for Bonnie Jean.
452 reviews3 followers
June 25, 2015
Jane Eyre meets Goldilocks and the Three Bears is probably the best one line summary that I could give this novel. Throw in cameos by several fairy tale and literary figures and a plot that revolves around racism (speciesism?) with a dash of regency romance and you end up with a very odd but fun to read book whose intended audience leaves me puzzled. I found this book on the new reads shelf of the children's section, probably because of the fractured fairy tales aspect, but I'm pretty sure that it doesn't really belong there. The writing and storyline are very much like one might expect from someone like Jane Austen, the adventures and romance of a governess... except that the setting is the Enchanted Forest, and our heroine is a young bear. The writing style and vocab used would probably be a bit off putting to the younger crowd (I'm not sure I can remember the last book I read that used words like "physiognomy" or "vituperation"), and I'm pretty sure that many of the literary cameos would go over their heads (Edwin Drood makes an appearance, for instance). Older readers who love both period romances and fractured fairy tales might get a kick out of it, though. The romance aspect of it was tied up a bit hastily at the end, and the book seemed to end rather abruptly, but overall I enjoyed the book a lot and I found the plot compelling- definitely kept me wanting to find out what came next.
Profile Image for ✨Jinglemarco✨ .
586 reviews52 followers
September 17, 2017
WOW!! I had so high expectations for this book! =D
...
And they were fully rewarded! <3

Wonderful book! Gorgeously written and built, it is THE Goldilocks and the three bears retelling - with a flavour of Jane Eyresque victorian age!

Profile Image for Dana Grimes.
942 reviews
February 28, 2018
I loved this story and if you like fairy tale retellings, Gregory Maguire, and Jane Austen novels then this is the book for you! That being said...it's hard to imagine what child I would recommend this too apart from my own (on audiobook).

5 stars for narration and story, 4 stars for its limited audience (since this is intended for middle grades, but it would have to be middle grade readers who don't mind a slower story.)

The audiobook is narrated by the amazing Katherine Kellgren so definitely listen to this one! The audiobook world is just not going to be the same without her!!!!
24 reviews
July 22, 2022
Very interesting book. It is not at all what I expected. It's a fairytale but it's so much deeper than a fairytale. I read a review before I read the book that said it has "echoes of Jane Austen" and after reading it, I completely agree with that. Somehow it's a fairytale, a Victorian novel, and a deeply themed allegory all in one. The characters all had their own personalities, quirks, and shortcomings, and there was a bit of tragic romance as well. I'm still trying to wrap my head around all the emotions that it made me feel (joy, outrage, despair, shock, love, puzzlement, sadness, wonder, etc). So, all in all, I enjoyed this book and the whirlwind it took me through.
Profile Image for Fran.
1,191 reviews2 followers
July 1, 2022
What a cute unique story. What happens when The Three Bears want to adopt Goldilocks? How does Mother Hubbard fit into the story? What happens when the Lady who lives in the Shoe gets involved? So many fairy tale characters involved, it was both nostalgic and a breath of fresh air. What a wonderful adaptation.
Profile Image for Rena.
764 reviews5 followers
September 24, 2017
5 stars. I loved this book. Not really for children, despite being a "children's book." So topical to the times we live in right now
547 reviews
May 26, 2015
I thought I would like this book more than I did. It's Goldilocks and the Three Bears told with some twists and in a Regency setting. Fairy tales and Bronte/Austen leanings. What could go wrong with that? Apparently, for me, a few things.

Primarily, I thought this was directed at a different audience. This book was in the juvenile section of the library, so I naturally assumed it would be for younger readers. Instead it seemed to be for an older audience. I'm not really sure why it was in the children's section, other than the fairy tale bit. There is nothing in the story that would be inappropriate for older kids, but even the smartest kids might need a dictionary nearby with words like "concatenation," "vituperation," and "physiognomy." (I mean, couldn't the author just have written "appearance" or "facial features"?) I also found some passages to be bit too wordy, especially if you are trying to keep the attention of a 10- or 11-year-old. I found myself skimming some of the purely descriptive passages. I'm sure authors agonize over every word in their stories - I'm not a writer and I do that with reviews and blog posts - but I thought this book could have been pared down a little. The romantic part of the story ended a bit too abruptly, and in whole might not interest younger readers.

Also, having grown up in a place where bears are common sights, I had trouble picturing them in period clothing, or running gracefully in a dress. The word "lumbering" kept coming to mind.

I did like the story. Particularly the elements of other fairy tales woven in, and the extended story of Goldilocks. Plus, I liked that so many of the characters were quite complex. Very few of them were simply good or bad, but rather a mixture, like most of us. I just would've liked the book better if it was a bit shorter and simpler in some places. There's a lot of praise for it out there. You might like it better than I did.
Profile Image for Gail Gauthier.
Author 15 books16 followers
May 6, 2015
"The Cottage in the Woods has been described as Jane Eyre meets Goldilocks and the Three Bears. It certainly is. Jane Eyre fans can have a fantastic time picking out the connections. A young, powerless, single female enters a large house as the employee of a wealthy man. This is a wealthy, married man with a family, which is one of the ways this book is different from Jane Eyre. But he's also a bear, as is the young female, Ursula. (Relating to ursine, I'm guessing.) Ursula is there to act as a governess to the bear's son, Teddy. (Oh, my gosh. Teddy Bear!!! No, actually his last name is Vaughn.) Ursula has a love interest, and, shades of Mr. Rochester, he's not free to love her. There is a mystery in this house, as there is in Jane Eyre. And it's related to a female, as is the mystery in Jane Eyre. This female, though, is young, with golden hair."

Excerpt from Original Content
Profile Image for Sarah A.
2,260 reviews19 followers
May 11, 2015
Wow. Thanks to Tamora Pierce for recommending this. Where to start - it's a combination of Goldilocks and the 3 bears, Mother Goose nursery Rhymes, Jane Eyre, Pride and Prejudice and a book on the U.S. civil rights movement.
The closest I've ever come to this style and fantastical writing before is Jasper Fforde's Nursery rhymes Crime books.
I really enjoyed this book and found it a real page turner. It has amazing characters, huge twists and beautiful writing.
Ursula Brown, a young bear of good education, takes the job of governess at the Cottage in the Woods, a manor house.
Along the way we have romance, intrigue, racism or rather speciesm (is that a word?), mysteries, action and adventure.
I am not sure what age should read it, I think it contains some pretty controversial and dark elements for younger readers but understand it is a YA book. Many adults won't get all the references - ok have to go and read it again now!!
Profile Image for Catie.
1,586 reviews53 followers
March 25, 2015
Loved this book! Very clever and fun retelling of Goldilocks and the Three Bears with a dash of Brontë mixed in.
Profile Image for Amanda.
389 reviews
October 18, 2015
I love a book with talking animals.

It wasn't my absolute favorite story but it did leave me thinking about it and the Bears days after I finished so I guess that counts for something!
Profile Image for Rose Q. Addams.
Author 5 books21 followers
July 3, 2022
I'd describe this one as a cross between Jane Eyre and Goldilocks, if you can believe it.

The main character is a young governess-bear named Ursula. Her charge? The youngest of the Three Bears within the aforementioned fairytale, and through her perspective a tale is woven of intrigue, conspiracy, true love, and the people (whether human or no) in this alternate reality where Enchanted things mingle freely with the world we know (albeit Victorian-era).

This book was highly unique, refreshing, and presented a pleasingly realistic fairytale world, where things are not always sunshine and roses, but where, through sincerity, effort, and love of one’s fellow man (or beast), happily-ever-afters are possible. I’d say this is one book you should look at, if you have any interest in the fantasy genre or fairytale retellings in general.

Plot aside, the names for some of the characters were extremely clever; Ursula, for example, means “she-bear”, and her charge, named Theodore, is affectionately named “Teddy”. The character based on “Old Mother Hubbard” is known by her first name, Lavinia— which is a name for the legendary mother of the Roman people. An opposing lawyer is surnamed “Cheater”, though that one is pointed out clearly within the plot as ironic. There are probably more examples of the author’s wit, but you’ll have to look for them yourself.

As for more detailed parental warnings:

**MINOR SPOILERS HERE: God’s name is used as a curse once in the book that I remember, by a villain, and one character drinks on the sly (this is presented as wrong from the start). A character is beaten up, and another is shot, though we do not see it. People threaten one another (with an attempt at blackmail thrown in for good measure), one character smokes, and the protagonist hugs her love interest and thinks about him often, though not in a crude way. When she realizes he is betrothed since birth to a cousin of his, she tries to put away thoughts of him or think of him in a strictly platonic light, which is not always successful, but again, not crude and she deals with it through frequent prayer and attempts to redirect her thoughts. An ugly and unlikeable character dies nobly in the end, sacrificing themselves by knocking an attacker off a cliff and falling to their own death in the process.**

Positive takeaways include gentle, loving admonition of those who are wrong (by the priest and those under his guidance); active and/or peaceful means of caring for and protecting others by many characters, frequent examples of prayer, and a character protecting someone at the cost of their life. Repentance and/or reformation is also shown in some character arcs.

If I wanted to spoil it for you, I would tell you all the details; but as it is, I shall just urge you to read the book. I enjoyed it thoroughly, and I’d recommend it for 12 and up due to thematic elements; there is a party of evildoers set on making sure that humans and Enchanted peoples are separated, and violence comes out of it, as well as a gang of urchins being trained for theft by their mother.
Profile Image for Caroline.
Author 9 books62 followers
February 18, 2023
Personal rating: 2 Stars
Given rating: 3 stars (read on to find out why!)

Adorable cover. Adorable concept. Great start! And then.... it dragged. But the ending was good!

Before I go on, I have to preface this review with the following: I am not the target demographic. My daughter loved this book, I struggled. This is not a BAD book, it just wasn't for me personally.

Back to our regularly scheduled programming...

My 11-year old daughter picked this book out at the bookstore, brought it home, and devoured it. I had read the back cover and asked if I could read it next, and she of course said, "Yes!"

So I started reading it. And it took almost 2 months to get through it.

Like I said above, the beginning of this book was great. The introduction of "baby bear" (Teddy's) new governess, Ms. Brown, was a unique take on the Goldilocks and the Three Bears tale. But then it got depressing. Nobody was nice to Ms. Brown! Nurse was down right MEAN, right up until the bitter end! Papa Bear jumped to conclusions and never let Ms. Brown defend herself! But I kept reading, and thinking to myself, how did my daughter get joy from these miserable characters?

The middle of the book dragged. For me, it was one of those books that I'd think about quitting but push on, then something interesting/redeeming happened, only to drag again. And repeat.

The story is told in a very old writing style, and it was at times reminiscent of when I struggled through reading Pride & Prejudice and swore off books written before my own youth.

There are plenty of good things about this book.
1. It's a unique spin on the classic tale. This wasn't a tiny, rickety, old cottage, it was more of a grand manor belonging to very well-off bears in the Enchanted Forest.
2. There's a strong message for tolerance and against racism/prejudice. The parallels between our world and this fictional one are obvious, but done in a way for children to truly understand and be interested in.
3. Even the worst character was allowed some redemption, the author was able to develop them enough so that I still hated them, but I was able to understand where they were coming from.
4. The book is very well written!

Ultimately, this was not a book for me. It is however, a great book for the target audience (young readers) and truly does belong in elementary school libraries.
Profile Image for Debra.
2,074 reviews11 followers
July 4, 2019
I have put off this review as I am so conflicted. I loved the book and the rewriting of of the Three Bears and Goldilocks tale in an updated story of social conflict, racism, child abuse and romance. The story unfolds slowly and is a wonderful read. My library placed this book in the juvenile section where I can tell you it will not circulate. The story is too deep and the vocabulary too difficult for even an excellent young reader. In this day of fairy tale twist books I think it could find an audience among adults.

I loved the way familiar characters were rewritten. Goldilocks is an abused child raised by a nefarious Mrs. Shoe (from the woman in the shoe who had so many children...). The Three Bear family named Vaughan are a family of enchanted bears who are very well educated, prosperous and respected in their community. Ursula, a young enchanted bear is the governess for the family and arrives just as the town is being split by accusations against the enchanted animal population and a call for the community to divide and control these potentially dangerous animals.

I just can't stop thinking about this book and how it would make an excellent discussion book among students and a vocabulary boost for middle school and high school. I also thought about how the classics are no longer promoted, where you find this wonderful writing and vocabulary stretch. Would our current students even notice the themes from Pride and Prejudice, Jane Eyre and To kill a Mockingbird? I know I am ready for another offering from this writer.
Profile Image for Melissa.
739 reviews5 followers
September 1, 2018
By combining the beloved fairy tale characters of Goldilocks and the Three Bears, the style and themes of Jane Eyre, and a quaint forest setting, Coville presents a story filled with charm that tugs at heartstrings.

The composition of The Cottage in the Woods makes it difficult to decipher the best audience for the title. Young readers will more readily and eagerly gravitate towards a story featuring anthropomorphized characters but the expansive vocabulary necessitates a more experienced reader who will likely be more reluctant to read a fairy tale. There is certainly a niche group who will both enjoy and understand the book but this combination will make for a smaller readership.

All that being said, this is a wonderful story with meaningful commentary and strong characters. Coville creates a world that is composed of fantasy and familiar elements as the Vaughn bears and other Enchanted creatures struggle with an issue even bigger than the mysterious Goldilocks. This delightful story delves beyond being simply picturesque and addresses real issues in society.
Underneath this fairy tale world lurks a group who hold a prejudice against the Enchanted, creating an opportunity for social commentary that was artfully executed for a children's story.

This unique fairy tale spin-off will engage readers in new ways every chapter as they unravel the story of Goldilocks, grip the cover during chase scenes, and fall in love with each of the characters.
1 review
October 16, 2021
This was the first novel that I ever read. I was in the fourth grade, and up until then all I had ever read were comic books and graphic novels, and stories that I had to read due to school. My teacher urged my me to read books that were more around my age level, and I went into the library and chose the biggest book I could find to try and appease her as well as my mom. Little did I know, this book would lead me to fall in love with literature, and ever since then I have made it my personal mission to try and read it once a year. I've always heard people say that when they re-watch a movie, or re-read a book, they always get something new out of it, and I thought that was all bs, but honestly whenever I read this book again I always find something that I hadn't noticed before. I've always related to Ursula, the main protagonist, in the fact that I've always felt alone most my life, but seeing her make something of herself, and find a home, gave nine year old me so much hope and courage that would eventually help me get through the toughest of times, which is why I absolutely love this book and would recommend it to anyone, especially young adults :)!
Profile Image for Anthony.
254 reviews1 follower
September 18, 2018
I absolutely loved this book.

An amalgamation of fractured fairy tale characters fill a story that at first glance feels like a droll bit of Victorian literature, turns into a story that is a bit more enthralling.

Ursula is a governess for a rich family who lives in a stately manor. Ursula is also a bear as are her employers. They live near Bremen town where humans and enchanted animals coexist. However, currently that coexistence is tense, as their are certain humans who do not like their animal counterparts. The Humans are attempting to relegate the enchanted animals to second class citizens.

This story moves along with engaging plots and sublots of romance, suspense, and social commentary. This book can not only entertain, but provide much fodder for discussion.
Profile Image for Hannah Potantus.
301 reviews
May 28, 2022
When I heard this book was a combination of Jane Eyre and Goldilocks I was weary of what that meant. That description is not wrong. Jane Eyre as bears is exactly what I just read. I’m just not sure if that’s a good thing or not…

The style of writing and the plot both seem geared toward older readers (7/8th grade) but the fact that they are bears and it’s a retelling of the Goldilocks fairy tale makes it seem more suited to a younger audience.

Putting aside my confusion as to whom this book is actually written toward, I think that it was very entertaining. The beginning was a bit slow, but by the last dozen chapters or so I couldn’t put it down.
Profile Image for Zahirah.
468 reviews17 followers
May 10, 2017
A bit skeptical when reading a book by a family member of a great author but I'm pleasantly surprised with this one. Delightful writing, never boring. However the plotline may be a bit flat with only little spikes of thrill here and there. But still enough to engage me till the end. Another beef that I have with this book is that there was no illustrations. According to the author's blurb she illustrated more than 30 books. Why can't she illustrate one of her own? We all know that any stories that involves fairy tale and enchanted creatures would need illustrations, right? Right? 🤔
Profile Image for Cynthia Parkhill.
375 reviews14 followers
June 25, 2019
Delightful gothic adventure, worthy of Jane Austen or the Bronte sisters, with the notable distinction that the characters are re-imagined out of European fairy tales and nursery rhymes. It's told in first-person by Ursula, a she-bear working as governess to the wealthy Vaughns, a family of bears who live in the titular cottage. The story of the family and the secret they are protecting is set against a backdrop of prejudice by humans against Enchanted animals like themselves. Additional themes, including freedom of the press, make for an exciting tale.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 141 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.