In 1917 Meg Pritchard is a woman on the run. What better place to hide than a country at war? France, ravaged by the bombs and battles of World War I, is exactly where Meg plans to disappear. But while Meg may be running from, she's also running to ~ to new friends and lovers, to redemption, and to life with purpose. To a new life altogether. Maybe there's hope for Meg's future, after all - if only she can make peace with her past.
I'm going to rate this book a four of five. I don't think that I'll ever read it again, but wow, the first time was great. (Wish I could give it 4.5—I think I'll go back and re-read certain sections again.)
I liked it partially because I'm from Cleveland and I enjoy stories set in historical Cleveland. Not sure how this book got on my Kindle, but that could be a reason. I think it's neat that when a character turns a corner or heads to the YWCA that you know where they are and that you've been there, too.
But! I primarily liked this book because of the characters and character development. The author spends a great deal of time and energy developing the four main characters (MP counts as two) as well as the various supporting characters.
Yes, the diary style (tone?) is not what you're used to, but bear with it—Hasley uses it for a purpose, and to great effect.
While not exactly a mystery, there are certainly twists and turns and there is mystery in it. As the story builds, we see further and further into this MP person and her character(s). Setting the story in the WWI teens was brilliant and, while I'm not a scholar of those times, Hasley got all the details I needed to enjoy the story right enough for me.
It's OK to have a longing for a different ending—to have a sense of loss—this is not a disney princess story.
Please don't give up on the story because of the style—persevere and you'll be rewarded by a good read.
The writing in this book is very different from other books. I wondered as I was reading it if it was a diary. It was of sorts. The narrator knew all of the facts that would occur. She was recalling the events of her life during the 1st world war. And those things that occurred when she arrived home. The story was interesting enough to present a surprise ending. You kept wondering what she was running from. That was a good thing.
It's very odd to run INTO war war zone to get away from your past, but that's what Meg decides she needs to get a fresh start. Meg is not a very likable character, in fact I found myself constantly annoyed by her, but her life was quite fascinating.
This is almost like two books in one: the first part where Meg becomes a WW1 ambulance driver, and the second part where she returns to Ohio to face what she's been running from. The historic details of WW1 really made the story shine.
There are two supporting characters that befriend Meg: Lucy and Mac. Meg is at times rude and dismissive to both of them, yet Lucy is determined to be her friend, and Mac is half in love with her. This is where the story falters a bit for me, I couldn't understand why Lucy and Mac kept trying so hard. Meg gave them almost nothing in return, and yet they were so persistent! It was especially baffling after the story went back to Ohio.
Points to the author for an unconventional ending, I think Meg ending up living the exact life she was meant to.
This is definitely a women's book but a large smattering of a style of personal history and how war affects the behaviour of all people, no matter what class or background of the people. Ms. Hasley writes well and her topic is interesting. There are a few proofreading errors that detract from an English teacher's enjoyment, but they may be found in later editions of the book.
A very moving, well-written memoir about a young woman escaping a terrible event and ending up finding a new version of herself as an ambulance driver in France during WWI. The images are graphic, the characters well-drawn and believable, and mostly I felt some compassion for the main character, Meg. However, the ending was way too surprising and obvious at the same time, and the reader is not prepared for the outcome, too quickly, in my mind. Like the book's trying to trick the reader. Not okay.
This book was entered and was a finalist in The Wishing Shelf Book Awards. This is what our readers thought:
Title: Magnificent Farewell Author: Karen J. Hasley Star Rating: 4.5 Stars Number of Readers: 27 Stats Editing: 9/10 Writing Style: 9/10 Content: 10/10 Cover: 8/10 Of the 27 readers: 25 would read another book by this author. 9 thought the cover was good or excellent. 23 thought the author worked well with speech to develop the characters. 27 thought the setting was vital to the success of the story. 27 thought the ending was powerful and well-plotted. 5 felt the first half needed cutting slightly to improve pacing.
Readers’ Comments ‘Meg is an interesting character, and pretty tough too. But it was the setting that was most interesting to me. Historically fascinating.’ Male reader, aged 43 ‘An interesting drama. The hero is Meg who develops in the face of so many problems. Well-written and, undoubtedly, well-researched. The cover did not grab me but the story did.’ Female reader, aged 57 ‘A very different take on World War 1. Anybody interested in this time will get a lot from this. As will any reader who is looking for a strong drama and a strong female character.’ Female reader, aged 32 ‘A little slow to get going but, with the characters and setting well defined in the first half, the second half picks up pace. The ending was clever and completed an excellent read. I will hunt out more of this author’s books.’ Male reader, aged 66 ‘A very enjoyable read.’ Female reader, aged 51
‘A fascinating World War 1 saga. A FINALIST and highly recommended.’ The Wishing Shelf Book Awards