Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Endnotes 4: Unity in Separation

Rate this book
Endnotes is a journal/book series published by a discussion group based in Germany, the UK and the US. It is primarily oriented towards conceptualising the conditions of possibility of a communist overcoming of the capitalist mode of production and of the multiple structures of domination which pattern societies characterised by that mode of production starting from present conditions. As such it has been concerned with debates in communist theory, and particularly the problematic of "communisation"; the question of gender and its abolition; the analysis of contemporary struggles, movements and political economy; the dynamics of surplus population and its effects on capital and class; capitalist formations of "race"; value-form theory and systematic dialectics; the revolutionary failures and impasses of the 20th Century. Endnotes 4 (Unity In Separation) Survey of the global situation; Balance sheet of the 20th century left and the worker s movement; Black Lives Matter; Balkan Spring; Chris Wright on US suburbanism; and Abject subjects and surplus populations.

302 pages, Paperback

Published October 1, 2015

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Endnotes Collective

6 books54 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
46 (46%)
4 stars
40 (40%)
3 stars
12 (12%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
2 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews
244 reviews
May 7, 2018
Fantastic collection of fresh and insightful and thought-provoking Marxist political philosophy, that makes a decisive break with old traditions and orthodoxies. Each essay is great, and weaves in between contemporary observations, historical analysis, and theoretical frameworks. The specific focus areas are fascinating, too, ranging from Black Lives Matter to riots in Bosnia to the 20th-century European workers' movements. However these aren't necessarily easy reads, and probably requires a certain level of experience with Marxist theory and jargon.
153 reviews6 followers
Read
November 10, 2026
The ‘History of Separation’ essay that makes up the bulk of this has vexed me since I read it nearly ten (!) years ago. Its conceptual tools were almost impossibly esoteric for me having only just started to go through some kind of politicisation in the early Corbyn years, let alone engaged in any sustained way with Capital or Marxism more broadly. I think there must have been an aesthetic element to my interest given how little of of the content I was able to grasp (reading in the reissued hard copy I don’t feel embarrassed about this, it is still very cool). I think everything I’ve read since has been motivated by trying to both understand what it was getting at and later trying to disprove it. It’s funny what encountering an idea at the right (or maybe wrong!) time can do.

It is well overdue a critical reassessment given how much of contemporary ‘left’ discourse is ranged against it (whether consciously or not). The Prometheus gang had a good go recently but the idea that it is “economistic” is just wrong. Reading it today it still provokes and the questions it poses still hold relevance. I find myself basically persuaded by the argument but resistant to accepting its more totalising conclusions. Maybe this is just an intellectual weakness on my part (along the lines of “you’re right but i don’t agree with you”). It is also far less doomer than its reputation or my memory suggests. In many ways it feels totally contemporary to the moment even after covid, left populism etc and the language it deploys has totally become common sense - even in more mainstream outlets like the relaunched tribune - because the theoretical problems they identify have yet to be overcome in practice. The “Endnotes decade” isn’t over yet it seems.
Profile Image for virgilisdead.
16 reviews1 follower
November 6, 2026
Je n’ai pas pris de notes au cours de cette lecture, par manque de temps et pensant qu’il faudrait de toute façon que je revienne sur certains de ces articles plus tard, mon avis va donc être assez succint.

Certainement un numéro important d’Endnotes, qu’il est là encore intéressant de lire plus de 10 ans après sa publication originelle.

Dans l’analyse de luttes alors récentes, on retrouve BLM 1.0 (2013 - 2015) et les luttes en Bosnie-Herzégovine de 2014.

Pour des articles plus historiques, A History of Separation, probablement l’un des articles d’Endnotes qui a fait couler le plus d’encre. De mon point de vue, c’est un texte important pour réfléchir sur l’histoire du mouvement ouvrier et son déclin depuis les années 70. Il y a sans doute de réelles limites (une importante me paraît être au moins sa focalisation sur les pays du centre capitaliste), mais il me faudra revenir dessus et aller vers d’autres lectures pour que je puisse les formuler avec assurance.

De même, An Identical Abject-Subject ? revient sur les analyses concernant la crise du surplus de population et de travail énoncées dans Endnotes 2.

J’ai enfin pas mal apprécié Its Own Peculiar Decor, qui étudie l’urbanisme américain, plus spécifiquement les tensions de classe et de race qui ont sous-tendu l’extension massive de l’habitat individuel après la Seconde Guerre Mondiale. Il complète Notes on the New Housing Question d’Endnotes 2.
Profile Image for sube.
187 reviews76 followers
July 30, 2022
The major essay of the book ("A History of Separation") stakes out the rise and demise of an 'affirmable workers' identity', i.e. the generalisation of an identity around the european/white, male semi-skilled proletariat, which was the basis of the workers' movement and around which the demands of which it wasp resented, as well its demise due (1) to external restraints (never universalising, i.e. becoming the majority of population) nor (2) internal limits (only a portion identifying with the class identity as primary over other identities). The present, even if it is the generalisation of proletariat lacks such a subject & is likely impossible to be reproduced atm.

The essay on abjection stakes out Endnotes' analysis of the growth of surplus population as not meaning a new revolutionary subject, but lack of it due to heterogenity of it - furthering it via concept of abjects (those cast off from wider working class, facing repression...). The article on housing is interesting but my ignorance of the topic made me only semi-interested in it - but the resolution of the collapse of workers' movement via disorganization geographically in form of suburbs in US was interesting. The last two articles discuss the 2014 protest mvmt in Bosnia & Ferguson and are interesting in showing limits of it as well as what they meant.
314 reviews28 followers
May 23, 2019
Weird. Every sentence seemed significant, every paragraph and every chapter the same. However, it’s not clear exactly what point the whole thing is trying to make or what we are to do with it.

I liked it...I liked that the authors give no one and no ideology some god like status. They actually look at the real history of the real world...and go from there (correctly or not)
Profile Image for Taneli Viitahuhta.
Author 5 books18 followers
May 14, 2020
I just read "A History of Separation, The Construction of the Workers' Movement", and it is by far the best exposition on the subject I have come across. I'm interested to delve deeper into the construction of the image of worker.
Profile Image for Jimmy.
49 reviews
January 23, 2020
The multi-part essay "A History of Separation" steals the show despite its length, and well represents the Endnotes perspective. It's worth reading even if you don't have time for the rest.
Profile Image for (yz).
67 reviews3 followers
January 8, 2026
5 estreles sobretot pel capítol d’introducció a mode de crítica d’algunes de les tesis que planteja Endnotes q es perfecte 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Profile Image for Harley Moore.
4 reviews
June 29, 2026
Kind of bad writing at times. Sentences that make no sense and are unnecessarily complicated. I learned a lot, but mostly because my friend was able to translate. I agree with a lot of the arguments.
Displaying 1 - 10 of 10 reviews