Aquinas and the Theology of the Body: The Thomistic Foundations of John Paul II's Anthropology

Thomistic Ressourcement Series #7

by Thomas Petri

Pope John Paul's Theology of the Body catecheses has garnered tremendous popularity in theological and catechetical circles. Students of the Theology of the Body have generally interpreted it as innovative not only in its presentation of the Church's teaching on marriage and sexuality, but also as radically advancing that teaching. Aquinas and the Theology of the Body offers a somewhat different interpretation. Fr. Thomas Petri argues that the philosophy and theology of Thomas Aquinas substantially contributed to John Paul's intellectual formation, which he never abandoned. A correct interpretation of the Theology of the Body requires, therefore, a thorough understanding of Thomistic anthropology and theology, which has been mostly lacking in commentaries on the pope's important contributions on the subject of marriage and sexuality.

After offering an historical narrative describing the gradual departure from the theology of Thomas Aquinas, which led to a deficient theological method in the early twentieth century as implicated in the debates surrounding birth control, Aquinas and the Theology of the Body then surveys John Paul's pre-pontifical work. A thorough examination of the late pope's corpus reveals a definite respect for Aquinas even as he was intrigued by the consciousness-based school of phenomenology. In his many defenses of Humanae Vitae , John Paul II argued that since the human body represents the person to the world, the body speaks a certain language and has an inherent spousal meaning. While John Paul II did not offer any positive reference to Aquinas in his Theology of the Body catecheses, he did in other works. Finally, this study explores Aquinas's mature work, comparing and contrasting it with John Paul II's, to conclude that the Angelic Doctor's metaphysical anthropology provided the foundation for John Paul II's notion of the spousal meaning of the body, which is a seminal concept articulated in the Theology of the Body catecheses.

While there has been much scholarly study on the philosophy of Pope John Paul II, and of his indebtedness to Aquinas's thought, this is the first book to connect The Theology of the Body with Thomistic ideas.

Genres: Theology, Philosophy, Catholic

368 pages, Hardcover

Published April 20, 2016

Reviews

[Santiago Pinzon · Rating 4 out of 5]

A much-needed contribution to the discourse surrounding Theology of the Body. It treats TOB not as a novel work to be taken on its own terms, but rather as a work that (1) is focused on responding to particular moral issues, (2) is the culmination of years of sustained and evolving reflection, (3) presupposes a certain objective metaphysical framework which is helpful for understanding St. John Paul II’s themes in TOB, and (4) must be interpreted as being in continuity with the church’s previous teachings on sexual ethics.

[Patrick Bouchard · Rating 3 out of 5]

Good background in history. Need new information cause I knew too much beforehand. Useful for theology majors.

[Matthew MacDonald · Rating 5 out of 5]

An important book to understand Aquinas influence on John Paul II forming TOB, while recognizing TOB as going beyond Thomas at the same time but not contradicting him. The author stresses that a correct reading TOB will see both its uniqueness and how it is tied to Thomas and the tradition of the Church. It can be a thick read at times but nonetheless this is an important book well worth one's time.