I don't think I can say that I enjoyed this, and I'm not sure that I'd recommend it, but reading this novel was a very moving and sad experience. Caputo has written again about damaged and broken people, and his portrayal of PTSD, with Starkmann's nightmares, hyper vigilance, and paranoia, is particularly haunting.
That the story is set at a time when there was minimal understanding of and sympathy for mental health issues is also striking. Starkmann is ashamed of his mental trauma and symptoms, and the wider cast of characters agree that he is right to be, almost without exception. That sad fact only adds to the sense of isolation that permeates this whole novel. Starkmann is alone even when he is with others, trapped and unable to come to terms with the things he saw and experienced in Vietnam.
That isn't to say that he is an innocent sufferer; far from it. Starkmann is profoundly selfish, and there is an extent to which he wallows in his suffering and self-destructive behaviour. He also does some truly revolting things and acts shamefully towards those around him. Caputo has done a fabulous job of fleshing out Starkmann, and he is a character who inspires pity and disgust in equal measure. That kind of ambiguity is realistic and unsettling, and the supporting cast is also well drawn and believable (particularly June). The setting, Michigan's Upper Peninsula, is used to great effect. It is appropriately bleak and miserable, and the rampant unemployment, alcoholism and loneliness add a backdrop of mundane gloominess that is quite depressing. It's not somewhere that's on my travel bucket list, especially after reading this!
There were also a couple of aspects of the novel that I didn't like. Parts of the writing are unnecessarily graphic and crude, and I think that Caputo could have gotten his point across without all the salacious details. I was also a little bit disappointed by the ending. Redemption isn't evident at all in Caputo's previous books, and I don't think he portrayed it particularly well here. Given all that Starkmann has been through and the terrible things he has done, I'm sceptical that a hospital stay and some time in the wilderness are enough to wipe it all away. The pacing increased noticeably in the last third as Starkmann heads towards complete meltdown, but the tradeoff is that his restoration comes across as slightly trite and superficial. Maybe it's better to see the ending as a turning point, and a first step back towards the light, but it felt a little hollow.
Overall, this is a powerfully written and compelling novel, and it highlights the long-lasting effects of war on those we send to fight it.