Colin is not in love with Amalya. He is obsessed. What he does is selfish and horrible. Love is for the living not the dead. If you believe in reincarnation, Colin when he died would have move on and been reunited in his next life with Amalya. But no, he builds a gateway to spirit world, buries his wife there. Then instead of living his life raising there son Jonathan. He gives him away, has him inherit the house then feeds him the history of Amalya and him through dreams after he enters the spirit world and dies in his dead Amalya's arms. Has Jonathan will the house to the reincarnated Amalya, Emily. In the end, he kills Emily by getting her sick with her heart condition, then purposely locks her out of her house to get her even sicker. So, just before Emily dies, he takes her spirit, so they can walk the spirit world together. Romantic? bah, Selfish, Emily wanted love, a husband and children before she left this mortal world. This writer has no idea what love is. Passion, obsession, but love, NO!!!!