The Challenge of the Exception: An Introduction to the Political Ideas of Carl Schmitt Between 1921 and 1936

Contributions in Political Science #248

by George Schwab

The Challenge of the Exception is the key that unlocked the ideas of Carl Schmitt, a leading political theorist and jurist who influenced the thoughts of, among others, Hannah Arendt, Carl Joachim Friedrich, Otto Kirchheimer, Hans Morgenthau, Franz Neumann, and Leo Strauss. Professor Schwab clearly articulates Schmitt's key concepts and relates their centrality to politics and the state, to the political theory of liberalism, democracy and authoritarianism, and to international relations. When Schwab treats Schmitt's interpretations of constitutional questions, for example, he shows how political theory in Germany is inextricably linked with constitutional law, legal theory, and the country's history.

Not content to merely deal with Schmitt's profound contributions to twentieth-century thought, Schwab devotes considerable space to the unconscionable compromises that he made with the Third Reich. This, however, failed to help him become the political and legal theorist of Hitler's Germany. Schwab shows how the new Schmitt was suspect from the beginning and, by 1936, Schmitt the hunter had become Schmitt the hunted. Schwab's presentation of the multifaceted Carl Schmitt exposes the reader to a truly interdisciplinary excursion into the humanities and social sciences.

Genres: Politics

174 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 1970

Reviews

[Colm Gillis · Rating 5 out of 5]

Quite simply, the best book on Schmitt that is out there. What I loved about this book was the very clear writing. At the same time, Schwab kept the tone at a high, academic level. Outstanding research and plenty of surprises, especially the degree to which the German government after WWII continued to rely on Schmitt while outwardly denying any association.