What do you think?
Rate this book
World of Warcraft #1
Cycle of Hatred
The Burning Legion has been defeated, and eastern regions of Kalimdor are now shared by two nations: the orcs of Durotar, led by their noble Warchief, Thrall; and the humans of Theramore, led by one of the most powerful mages alive -- Lady Jaina Proudmoore.
But the tentative peace between orcs and humans is suddenly crumbling. Random attacks against Durotar's holdings suggest that the humans have renewed their aggression toward the orcs. Now Jaina and Thrall must avert disaster before old hatreds are rekindled -- and Kalimdor is plunged into another devastating war.
Jaina's search to uncover the truth behind the attacks leads her to a shocking revelation. Her encounter with a legendary, long-lost wizard will challenge everything that she believes and illuminate the secret history of the world of...
But the tentative peace between orcs and humans is suddenly crumbling. Random attacks against Durotar's holdings suggest that the humans have renewed their aggression toward the orcs. Now Jaina and Thrall must avert disaster before old hatreds are rekindled -- and Kalimdor is plunged into another devastating war.
Jaina's search to uncover the truth behind the attacks leads her to a shocking revelation. Her encounter with a legendary, long-lost wizard will challenge everything that she believes and illuminate the secret history of the world of...
272 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published January 31, 2006
86 people are currently reading
5315 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 157 reviews
August 10, 2015
Cycle of Hatred describes the relations between Theramore and Durotar, and of their rulers Jaina Proudmoore and Thrall, with a plot hatched by a demon to spice things up.
This one did a better job than any of the others of actually leading readers/players into the game. So I would probably recommend this one as a go-to book for people who are new to this universe.
I'm positively surprised.
This one did a better job than any of the others of actually leading readers/players into the game. So I would probably recommend this one as a go-to book for people who are new to this universe.
I'm positively surprised.
July 16, 2018
As a WoW player myself, the best part of this book for me was just being in the world. What lets Cycle of Hatred down is the writing and story...which are pretty important in a book. The writing was kind of boring and a strange mix between high-fantasy and really modern witticisms/slang/etc. The WoW game itself mixes the two as well, but it just felt like the author of the book couldn't figure out the right way to mix the two.
For the most part the characters also felt contrived and characterized wrongly. About 90% of what the three main women characters talk about is how hard it is to be a woman while being a solider, leader, mage, etc. All the characters seemed one-sided and flat, and I couldn't really invest in any of them as they were written.
The story itself seemed like a placeholder story...nothing really happened, and the "boss fight" at the end lasted about - literally - two sentences.
That said, it had some good moments and if you are a World of Warcraft player it's fun to read books set in Azeroth!
For the most part the characters also felt contrived and characterized wrongly. About 90% of what the three main women characters talk about is how hard it is to be a woman while being a solider, leader, mage, etc. All the characters seemed one-sided and flat, and I couldn't really invest in any of them as they were written.
The story itself seemed like a placeholder story...nothing really happened, and the "boss fight" at the end lasted about - literally - two sentences.
That said, it had some good moments and if you are a World of Warcraft player it's fun to read books set in Azeroth!
November 21, 2009
World of Warcraft: Cycle of Hatred, by Keith R. A. DeCandido
Set a year prior to the opening of the World of Warcraft MMO, "Cycle of Hatred" would perhaps better be titled "Cycle of Blah." Unlike most novels set in the Warcraft universe, this one doesn't really add anything at all to the world.
The plot is mediocre and has no twists or turns - it's straightforwardly flat. You easily guess what's going to happen. Jaina Proudmoore and Thrall aren't true to their established characterization; it feels like the author didn't do any research before writing this book. There are three strong female characters in the book; DeCandido constantly harps on how a woman has to work harder than a man to be in power. It's very overdone, and I was rolling my eyes the second time it came up, let alone the third, the fourth, etc. The characters and plot feel very flat, very one dimensional.
For me, this is the worst of the World of Warcraft novels. I've read all multiple times, and this is my least favorite and the least enjoyable. It's blah - not good, not bad - just blah. If you're a WoW player, or curious about the universe, and want to read some of the books, I recommend you pick something other than this one.
1/5.
Set a year prior to the opening of the World of Warcraft MMO, "Cycle of Hatred" would perhaps better be titled "Cycle of Blah." Unlike most novels set in the Warcraft universe, this one doesn't really add anything at all to the world.
The plot is mediocre and has no twists or turns - it's straightforwardly flat. You easily guess what's going to happen. Jaina Proudmoore and Thrall aren't true to their established characterization; it feels like the author didn't do any research before writing this book. There are three strong female characters in the book; DeCandido constantly harps on how a woman has to work harder than a man to be in power. It's very overdone, and I was rolling my eyes the second time it came up, let alone the third, the fourth, etc. The characters and plot feel very flat, very one dimensional.
For me, this is the worst of the World of Warcraft novels. I've read all multiple times, and this is my least favorite and the least enjoyable. It's blah - not good, not bad - just blah. If you're a WoW player, or curious about the universe, and want to read some of the books, I recommend you pick something other than this one.
1/5.
September 6, 2019
Firstly, I haven't played much World of Warcraft. I'd played the strategy games in highschool, and have enjoyed a bit of Hearthstone over the last couple of years, but my WoW experience goes as far as playing a character up to lv.20 for the Hearthstone unlockable. That said, there's been times when I've really enjoyed Hearthstone and had an interest in learning more about the world's lore. So, when I saw this book for sale at a second-hand store, I thought, 'why not?'
The book isn't so much a complete story as an episode between W3 and WoW. It's set after the demons have been defeated, and the orcs and humans are trying to keep their post-war alliance alive. Well, Jaina and Thrall are. Most the other characters seem to have bad-blood with the other race, due to past interactions, and this is what the majority of the book is about.
When I started reading it, I was also watching some episodes of Z Nation (it's ridiculous, but a guilty pleasure) that focused on zombies that had regained their humanity. The plot was an us-and-them situation with race-themed tensions building depending on individuals situation. It kinda sucked to have both the book I'm reading and show I'm watching playing on the same themes, but Z Nation did it much better.
Aside from the multiple PoVs of race-related tension rising, there's a lot of heavy descriptions on certain characters (especially everyone's height) and locations. I assume that a lot of these locations where places in WoW, and the author was trying to convey layouts properly rather than focusing on the story. It also wandered off on tangents at times, going into lineage and lore, rather than focusing on what was going on at the moment. Not knowing a lot of these characters (but many I did through Hearthstone), I found myself losing interest.
In the end, we discover it's not just human (and orc) nature that's leading the world to war. It's also demons. Damn demons. Fortunately, all the strong women get together . Huzzah!
I hadn't actually realised that Cycle of Hatred is book 1 in the series. Not sure if the book sets the scene for the rest of the books, or it's chewing gum to hold you over. Regardless, I think you need to be a huge World of Warcraft fan to truly love this story.
The book isn't so much a complete story as an episode between W3 and WoW. It's set after the demons have been defeated, and the orcs and humans are trying to keep their post-war alliance alive. Well, Jaina and Thrall are. Most the other characters seem to have bad-blood with the other race, due to past interactions, and this is what the majority of the book is about.
When I started reading it, I was also watching some episodes of Z Nation (it's ridiculous, but a guilty pleasure) that focused on zombies that had regained their humanity. The plot was an us-and-them situation with race-themed tensions building depending on individuals situation. It kinda sucked to have both the book I'm reading and show I'm watching playing on the same themes, but Z Nation did it much better.
Aside from the multiple PoVs of race-related tension rising, there's a lot of heavy descriptions on certain characters (especially everyone's height) and locations. I assume that a lot of these locations where places in WoW, and the author was trying to convey layouts properly rather than focusing on the story. It also wandered off on tangents at times, going into lineage and lore, rather than focusing on what was going on at the moment. Not knowing a lot of these characters (but many I did through Hearthstone), I found myself losing interest.
In the end, we discover it's not just human (and orc) nature that's leading the world to war. It's also demons. Damn demons. Fortunately, all the strong women get together . Huzzah!
I hadn't actually realised that Cycle of Hatred is book 1 in the series. Not sure if the book sets the scene for the rest of the books, or it's chewing gum to hold you over. Regardless, I think you need to be a huge World of Warcraft fan to truly love this story.
January 12, 2019
Storia flebile, personaggi legati in modo esile e ambientazione assente. Eppure questo libro ha un suo punto di forza: Il valore dei singoli; su cui si concentra particolarmente dedicandogli molto più spazio che al racconto stesso. Non è una lettura per tutti ma a me personalmente, da amante di Warcraft, come libro è piaciuto e non poco… anche per via del cameo della mia accoppiata preferita ^^
“Per molti anni, Rexxar, ultimo del clan Mok’Nathal, aveva viaggiato per il continente di Kalimdor in solitudine, salvo che per la compagnia della grande orsa marrone, Misha. Nato per metà orco e per metà ogre, come buona parte del suo defunto clan, aveva finito per averne abbastanza delle liti, della crudeltà e delle guerre senza fine che caratterizzavano quella che, risibilmente, veniva definita civilizzazione.”
“Per molti anni, Rexxar, ultimo del clan Mok’Nathal, aveva viaggiato per il continente di Kalimdor in solitudine, salvo che per la compagnia della grande orsa marrone, Misha. Nato per metà orco e per metà ogre, come buona parte del suo defunto clan, aveva finito per averne abbastanza delle liti, della crudeltà e delle guerre senza fine che caratterizzavano quella che, risibilmente, veniva definita civilizzazione.”
December 6, 2014
The Cycle of Hatred was a nicely developed book because it included many details and lore pertaining to the history of the Warcraft Universe. The lore was interesting and made me want to read on because I simply love the Warcraft Universe and play World of Warcraft, a game based upon this universe. However, the reason that this book was rated lower was due to the lack of a real conflict and upon reading this book it seemed to not really have a 'danger' to make you want to keep reading. If you were to read this book without playing any of the Warcraft games or being interesting in the universe before hand then you would most likely not find a real want to continue reading due to the entire book going over the lore of Warcraft with a small amount of conflict. I believe that the lack of conflict is due to it being a part of a series that will likely gain more conflict as you read more. Overall this book is very enjoyable to read if you know of, and already love, the Warcraft universe but if you were to read it without those then it would not be as enjoyable as it could have potentially been.
April 6, 2022
Nach dem ersten Kapitel abgebrochen, da es zu viele Übersetzungsfehler beinhaltet, die mich beim Lesen stören.
June 11, 2014
Of all of the Warcraft Novels that Bookworm has read Cycle of Hatred has been considered one of the worst.
Is this true?
Let’s find out:
The Burning Legion has been defeated, and eastern regions of Kalimdor are now shared by two nations: the orcs of Durotar, led by their noble Warchief, Thrall; and the humans of Theramore, led by one of the most powerful mages alive -- Lady Jaina Proudmoore.
But the tentative peace between orcs and humans is suddenly crumbling. Random attacks against Durotar's holdings suggest that the humans have renewed their aggression toward the orcs. Now Jaina and Thrall must avert disaster before old hatreds are rekindled -- and Kalimdor is plunged into another devastating war.
The Flaws
The main flaw is that the plot is rather dull. The whole premise is avoiding an epic battle. A worthy pursuit but ultimately does not fit in with Warcraft as epic battles are its backbone, hence its name. Overall, the plot does sag in a few places and can seem anticlimactic. Lots of buildup but little payoff.
Another point of criticism toward the text is how it portrays women in a way that some would interpret as sexist. There is surprise by the fact that Jaina Proudmoore is a ruler and wizard and a woman, and several other characters bring this up as well. Some readers take offense to that, viewing it as sexist. A sad fact is though, that it’s true, both in Real Life and in Warcraft it would appear. Women often do like to work twice as hard as men to though half as good. Warcraft does strike Bookworm as a world with traditional values regarding women, at least among humans.
The Good
While there may be plot elements that fall short, the main reason this book has its rightful place in Warcraft Lore is its message.
Hatred is a powerful force. One group commits a crime against another and they retaliate and they retaliate back over and over again until both are utterly devastated. Unless, they want the death and destruction to stop they need to swallow their pride and break the cycle of hate. Only then will there be peace. This stressed constantly and even mentioned in the subplot with Jaina Proudmoore about letting go of past mistakes and working towards a better future.
This is a message that we in the Real World desperately need to embrace.
Also not every single book needs to bring something brand new to the lore. Sometimes it is interesting to explore familiar elements in a new light and see how things work in between discovering the new things.
Final Verdict.
While perhaps not the strongest Warcraft, its message and its characters make it a worthy edition to the lore. So no…Bookworm does not think that this is the worst Warcraft Book ever written. Not the best but not the worst.
Three out of Five Stars.
Is this true?
Let’s find out:
The Burning Legion has been defeated, and eastern regions of Kalimdor are now shared by two nations: the orcs of Durotar, led by their noble Warchief, Thrall; and the humans of Theramore, led by one of the most powerful mages alive -- Lady Jaina Proudmoore.
But the tentative peace between orcs and humans is suddenly crumbling. Random attacks against Durotar's holdings suggest that the humans have renewed their aggression toward the orcs. Now Jaina and Thrall must avert disaster before old hatreds are rekindled -- and Kalimdor is plunged into another devastating war.
The Flaws
The main flaw is that the plot is rather dull. The whole premise is avoiding an epic battle. A worthy pursuit but ultimately does not fit in with Warcraft as epic battles are its backbone, hence its name. Overall, the plot does sag in a few places and can seem anticlimactic. Lots of buildup but little payoff.
Another point of criticism toward the text is how it portrays women in a way that some would interpret as sexist. There is surprise by the fact that Jaina Proudmoore is a ruler and wizard and a woman, and several other characters bring this up as well. Some readers take offense to that, viewing it as sexist. A sad fact is though, that it’s true, both in Real Life and in Warcraft it would appear. Women often do like to work twice as hard as men to though half as good. Warcraft does strike Bookworm as a world with traditional values regarding women, at least among humans.
The Good
While there may be plot elements that fall short, the main reason this book has its rightful place in Warcraft Lore is its message.
Hatred is a powerful force. One group commits a crime against another and they retaliate and they retaliate back over and over again until both are utterly devastated. Unless, they want the death and destruction to stop they need to swallow their pride and break the cycle of hate. Only then will there be peace. This stressed constantly and even mentioned in the subplot with Jaina Proudmoore about letting go of past mistakes and working towards a better future.
This is a message that we in the Real World desperately need to embrace.
Also not every single book needs to bring something brand new to the lore. Sometimes it is interesting to explore familiar elements in a new light and see how things work in between discovering the new things.
Final Verdict.
While perhaps not the strongest Warcraft, its message and its characters make it a worthy edition to the lore. So no…Bookworm does not think that this is the worst Warcraft Book ever written. Not the best but not the worst.
Three out of Five Stars.
November 8, 2015
first read 11/4/2011,
reread 11/8/2015
Pretty good so far, with a somewhat choppy writing style.
However, I was just jarred out of the story by an idiotic mistake that any speaker of English ought not make: on page 87 "she destroyed only his avatar....until [she] sired..." end of idiocy. At least thus far.
(For those who are not native English speakers, a she cannot SIRE anyone. A she can produce, birth, create, or have, but to sire requires male input (pun intended).)
Okay - another complaint. SITE is not the same as SIGHT: the first is a location the second refers to seeing. pg 115
Also, pp 118-119: if the humans say okay, then the book says the other group "isn't able to be seen violating ... when the humans were". I can figure out what it means, but really some one needs to think and proofread, not just publish the first scribbles that come out of the crayon.
********************************
Finished the book, now for a follow up comment.
Pros - good strong women in lead roles
Cons - almost all the men are bad guys
Pros - although based in a magic realm the entire story was not about magic
Cons - we have to bring back a century old mage to solve an issue
Overall though, even with the complaints above, this was a good book. It dealt with the age old issue of "us" against "them" which pops up in every culture, in a believable way for most of the story. It had demons and dwarves, elves and mages, half breeds and invaders. It had a recent war, and a land that was being rebuilt. Overall, I think this is worth reading again, although the bad writing does cause me to tend to treat this as something written by a beginning writer, and a draft at that.
Followup from 11/8/2015 - obviously it is worth rereading, even with the mistakes mentioned (and the author's bio states they have several books in print, which supports my theory this must have been a first draft released to print)
reread 11/8/2015
Pretty good so far, with a somewhat choppy writing style.
However, I was just jarred out of the story by an idiotic mistake that any speaker of English ought not make: on page 87 "she destroyed only his avatar....until [she] sired..." end of idiocy. At least thus far.
(For those who are not native English speakers, a she cannot SIRE anyone. A she can produce, birth, create, or have, but to sire requires male input (pun intended).)
Okay - another complaint. SITE is not the same as SIGHT: the first is a location the second refers to seeing. pg 115
Also, pp 118-119: if the humans say okay, then the book says the other group "isn't able to be seen violating ... when the humans were". I can figure out what it means, but really some one needs to think and proofread, not just publish the first scribbles that come out of the crayon.
********************************
Finished the book, now for a follow up comment.
Pros - good strong women in lead roles
Cons - almost all the men are bad guys
Pros - although based in a magic realm the entire story was not about magic
Cons - we have to bring back a century old mage to solve an issue
Overall though, even with the complaints above, this was a good book. It dealt with the age old issue of "us" against "them" which pops up in every culture, in a believable way for most of the story. It had demons and dwarves, elves and mages, half breeds and invaders. It had a recent war, and a land that was being rebuilt. Overall, I think this is worth reading again, although the bad writing does cause me to tend to treat this as something written by a beginning writer, and a draft at that.
Followup from 11/8/2015 - obviously it is worth rereading, even with the mistakes mentioned (and the author's bio states they have several books in print, which supports my theory this must have been a first draft released to print)
May 8, 2014
I love all most things that are Sci-Fi/Fantasy: books most, then games and movies. I have been playing World of Warcraft since friends introduce to it when Burning Crusade game out. I love the idea of the the game, especially the cut scenes or quest that tell you the back story. Finally I thought I would read one of the WoW novels, plus my friend had been bugging me too. I read Cycle of Hatred (World of Warcraft #1) by Keith R.A. DeCandido. This is my first novel from Blizzard, as well as, WoW. I enjoyed the to plot and familiar characters. It was an entertaining read, with a few grammar/phrasing issues; like that Aegwynn sired a son. Men sire, women conceive or birth. I did like that the speech of the Orcs and Trolls was like in game, I could hear the Jamaican type accent when the Trolls were speaking.
Here are my pros for the this book: fantasy and adventure that keep me interested and turning the pages, strong female characters (hey I am a girl so I like strong women), and the fact it is based on WoW and Warcraft game lore.
Here are my cons: most of the male characters (besides Thrall) were either villains, curopt, or wimps; variations on what I know for the geography in WoW (Durotar have fishing, I have fished there I game so I know); and to me the epilogue was predictable.
Over all I enjoyed the book. I wish I could give it 3.5 stars, but I can't bring myself to round up to 4.
Here are my pros for the this book: fantasy and adventure that keep me interested and turning the pages, strong female characters (hey I am a girl so I like strong women), and the fact it is based on WoW and Warcraft game lore.
Here are my cons: most of the male characters (besides Thrall) were either villains, curopt, or wimps; variations on what I know for the geography in WoW (Durotar have fishing, I have fished there I game so I know); and to me the epilogue was predictable.
Over all I enjoyed the book. I wish I could give it 3.5 stars, but I can't bring myself to round up to 4.
June 10, 2015
Cycle of Hatred was a fun, easy, read rich with lore from the World of Warcraft characters I adore.
Lady Jaina Proudmoore takes center stage and I adored reading about Jaina. Revered as one of the most powerful mages alive and a leader Jaina has a lot on her plate. With the Burning Legion pushed back Jaina focuses on working on the alliance between humans and orcs. While she is eager to work with Thrall to come to a solution not all the humans who follow Jaina are eager for that solution to come into effect.
Thrall, the proud leader of the Horde wants peace between the orcs and the humans as much as Jaina. Yet with all the accidents and mishaps occurring for the orcs Thrall is unsure if that will ever happen. Busy with keeping the orcs under his command Thrall wants to believe Jaina but also does not want to call his followers liars. Walking a delicate line Thrall searches for the truth of what is happening to push the orcs and humans to war once again.
The writing was smooth and well done. I did not stumble or get confused with who was talking despite many points of view being shared. Once again I look forward to reading more of the lore books pertaining to World of Warcraft.
Lady Jaina Proudmoore takes center stage and I adored reading about Jaina. Revered as one of the most powerful mages alive and a leader Jaina has a lot on her plate. With the Burning Legion pushed back Jaina focuses on working on the alliance between humans and orcs. While she is eager to work with Thrall to come to a solution not all the humans who follow Jaina are eager for that solution to come into effect.
Thrall, the proud leader of the Horde wants peace between the orcs and the humans as much as Jaina. Yet with all the accidents and mishaps occurring for the orcs Thrall is unsure if that will ever happen. Busy with keeping the orcs under his command Thrall wants to believe Jaina but also does not want to call his followers liars. Walking a delicate line Thrall searches for the truth of what is happening to push the orcs and humans to war once again.
The writing was smooth and well done. I did not stumble or get confused with who was talking despite many points of view being shared. Once again I look forward to reading more of the lore books pertaining to World of Warcraft.
September 18, 2012
World of Warcraft: Cycle of Hatred written by Keith R. A. DeCandido.
This book starts out right after the war againest the Burning Legion. The orcs and the humans made an alliance during the war and, as the title describes, things are on thin ice between the two. Lady Jaina Proudmoore and Warchief Thrall are the leaders of the two races and are feverishly working to keep the alliance between the two races. While Thrall and Jaina are working on keeping the alliance, a force is trying to rip the alliance apart. That is where the story begins.
Reading this book with little to no prior of Warcraft lore, I didn't expect most of the twists. I like this book mostly due to the fact that it is a World of Warcraft book, which is one of my favorite computer games. Due to this extreme like for World of Warcraft there wasn't much I didn't like in this book.
This book starts out right after the war againest the Burning Legion. The orcs and the humans made an alliance during the war and, as the title describes, things are on thin ice between the two. Lady Jaina Proudmoore and Warchief Thrall are the leaders of the two races and are feverishly working to keep the alliance between the two races. While Thrall and Jaina are working on keeping the alliance, a force is trying to rip the alliance apart. That is where the story begins.
Reading this book with little to no prior of Warcraft lore, I didn't expect most of the twists. I like this book mostly due to the fact that it is a World of Warcraft book, which is one of my favorite computer games. Due to this extreme like for World of Warcraft there wasn't much I didn't like in this book.
January 31, 2013
Being that this is only the second WoW book I've ever read, I only have one other book and author to hold it up to and that's Christie Golden's Athas... This book in comparison is really not that good.
But, as usual, I still loved Jaina Proudmore AND Colonel Lorena was an awesome new character for me to get to know and enjoy. This book had three powerful woman at the hem of it and that's the reason it got a 3 star instead of a 2 from me. Jaina, Lorena, and Aegwynn were refreshing to read and quite enjoyable to get to know. Leaning about the Burning Sword was also quite interesting. But, alas, that is where all the 'like' ends for me.
The story over all didn't excite me, and I found myself having to push my way through in order to finish it. I really wasn't all that devoted to the plot. It wasn't as exciting as it could have been and that is what took away from this tale for me.
But, as usual, I still loved Jaina Proudmore AND Colonel Lorena was an awesome new character for me to get to know and enjoy. This book had three powerful woman at the hem of it and that's the reason it got a 3 star instead of a 2 from me. Jaina, Lorena, and Aegwynn were refreshing to read and quite enjoyable to get to know. Leaning about the Burning Sword was also quite interesting. But, alas, that is where all the 'like' ends for me.
The story over all didn't excite me, and I found myself having to push my way through in order to finish it. I really wasn't all that devoted to the plot. It wasn't as exciting as it could have been and that is what took away from this tale for me.
April 10, 2021
If you're into World of Warcraft, then this is a pretty good book. It describes the conflict of the two sides of the world, namely the Alliance and the Horde. It shows how easy it is to demonise each other as monsters when in reality we all just want the same things. Peace, food on the table, safety for our families and somewhere to belong. I liked this book because it shows the humanity in both sides of the conflict.
December 27, 2007
My brother gave this to me as a joke for Christmas, since we both play World of Warcraft with tongue planted firmly in cheek.
The book, of course, is deadly serious about things like orc/human race relations...
I think it's funny and mostly harmless, thought it may be killing my brain.
The book, of course, is deadly serious about things like orc/human race relations...
I think it's funny and mostly harmless, thought it may be killing my brain.
January 2, 2016
Very dry, didn't hook me into the story even though I'm a WoW player and usually into lore. Just because your readers are probably WoW fans, it doesn't mean you should skip describing landscapes... or anything else for that matter.
March 24, 2023
Not nearly as good as the forsaken one, but there’s still some lively, better than YA stuff, and hey, I’ve been in the world of Warcraft for years so it’s a kick to know the places here better than some of the characters.
April 16, 2018
A bit boring and confusing in the first third, the book is a fun read that gives some insight into Jaina, Thrall and Aegwynn. There were some fun references from the game, such as the neutral and opportunistic mentality of the goblins, but other than that the book feels as a filler.
September 5, 2018
This novel was very short, under three hundred pages, and there was also many different characters that we read from so it ended up feeling very quick with mostly action or a quick moving plot. I prefer my books more fleshed out with more set-up behind a story or character's motives but I can understand the appeal of a go, go, go book and it was great to read one after a little slump.
November 3, 2021
První dílo ze série World of Warcraft s docela vleklým příběhem. Kniha není k zahození, ale je zaměřena spíš na fanoušky World of Warcraft a pro ty ostatní to může vypadat spíš jako tahanice dvou znepřátelených skupin se zárodkem diplomacie. Přečetl jsem ji spíš tak trochu "do sbírky" a mám z ní spíš smíšené pocity.
January 8, 2015
Alright, so there a couple of expectations you need to set before you attempt any Warcraft book. First, you need to expect that geography will play a huge part and that your familiarity with Azeroth (and, in certain cases, Draenor) will benefit you hugely. Second, you need to expect a very different sense of experience from the gameplay, especially in World of Warcraft, where the subtleties of warfare and magic are boiled down into easily repeated animations operating on a time-based set of mechanics. Third, and perhaps most importantly, you should expect a decided lack of true climax or resolution because, after all, these books are designed to motivate you to play the games and experience the true drama of this universe for yourself that way.
Approach Cycle of Hatred with all these in mind makes for a good read. Like the other novels from this canon, it operates within a limited timeframe that explores the complex geopolitics on the eastern shores of Kalimdor, where Thrall, the orcish shaman who leads the new Horde, and Jaina Proudmoore, a powerful human mage who heads the human bastion of Theramoore, work together closely to maintain the alliance between their peoples. This alliance is what helped the residents of Azeroth, both native and alien, to overcome the demonic onslaught of the Burning Legion and their attempts to keep it functional are due in large part to the horrors of that war and the war before it which brought the orcs to Azeroth under the demons' power in order to destroy the lives of species such as the humans. With all that backstory floating around--and a lot of it is succinctly but meaningfully laid out early in this book--it might be easy to lose sight of the relatively small skirmishes that constitute most of this novel's action.
What DeCandido brings to the table, however, is a focus on key characters and events that keeps the rising action of this book moving. As the reader uncovers the influence of the Burning Blade, discovers what Jaina finds in what is supposed to be an uninhabited region, and keeps up with Thrall's evolving leadership, he or she feels the tension that grips Azeroth despite its unformed nature. The genuine threats to the world's stability, masked and cloaked as they are, are slowly revealed and dealt with.
But let's be real. This is still a novelization of a video game, and any critical reader will feel the limitations this imposes on the work. While respectable fantasy in its own right, this is not Tolkien or Martin or even Rowling. Like any book designed to market a franchise from across another medium, this one is best appreciated when the reader already has an investment in the lore of the universe it is set in.
Approach Cycle of Hatred with all these in mind makes for a good read. Like the other novels from this canon, it operates within a limited timeframe that explores the complex geopolitics on the eastern shores of Kalimdor, where Thrall, the orcish shaman who leads the new Horde, and Jaina Proudmoore, a powerful human mage who heads the human bastion of Theramoore, work together closely to maintain the alliance between their peoples. This alliance is what helped the residents of Azeroth, both native and alien, to overcome the demonic onslaught of the Burning Legion and their attempts to keep it functional are due in large part to the horrors of that war and the war before it which brought the orcs to Azeroth under the demons' power in order to destroy the lives of species such as the humans. With all that backstory floating around--and a lot of it is succinctly but meaningfully laid out early in this book--it might be easy to lose sight of the relatively small skirmishes that constitute most of this novel's action.
What DeCandido brings to the table, however, is a focus on key characters and events that keeps the rising action of this book moving. As the reader uncovers the influence of the Burning Blade, discovers what Jaina finds in what is supposed to be an uninhabited region, and keeps up with Thrall's evolving leadership, he or she feels the tension that grips Azeroth despite its unformed nature. The genuine threats to the world's stability, masked and cloaked as they are, are slowly revealed and dealt with.
But let's be real. This is still a novelization of a video game, and any critical reader will feel the limitations this imposes on the work. While respectable fantasy in its own right, this is not Tolkien or Martin or even Rowling. Like any book designed to market a franchise from across another medium, this one is best appreciated when the reader already has an investment in the lore of the universe it is set in.
February 6, 2013
It's been on my to-do list for ages to read all the Warcraft novels out there. I've been playing the games since Warcraft 2, might as well owe up to it! Years ago I read Day of the Dragon and genuinely disliked it. As Blizzard put just about all their lore developments prior to MoP in books and comics, I wanted to read up.
Goodreads told me this is the first book, so off I went. It's incredibly short. Set three years after Warcraft 3, pretty much at the start of the World of Warcraft, it is set in Kalimdor. Trouble is brewing between the Theramore humans and the Horde in Kalimdor. On both sides the conflict is fanned by a mysterious group called the Burning Blade. Jaina and Thrall try to solve this conflict, as it looks like war might break out.
So far so good. There's not really a whole lot of action in the book. A lot of vignettes about rising trouble, and some investigative work, an interlude with Aegwynn and stories about her past, and then the force behind the Burning Blade is defeated. It sometimes felt like fan-fiction and not a real professional novel. Characters were incredibly flat. I guess Jaina is the main protagonist, but she doesn't really stand out as having a personality. None of the characters really do. There's an air of non-seriousness about everything, even the bloody battle scenes.
Why still three stars? Because I enjoyed reading about Kalimdor, and familiar names. I am the odd person who gets the shivers and feels at home when entering The Barrens, so it felt like reading about my home. Yeah, weird, I know. Of course that also drove me a bit mad, because the book's Durotar is very different from the game's version. Forest around Thunder Ridge, farmland, no fishing? I don't think so.
Despite all the flaws I was decently entertained, so it's 2.5 stars rounding out to 3. I'll take this over Knaak any day!
Goodreads told me this is the first book, so off I went. It's incredibly short. Set three years after Warcraft 3, pretty much at the start of the World of Warcraft, it is set in Kalimdor. Trouble is brewing between the Theramore humans and the Horde in Kalimdor. On both sides the conflict is fanned by a mysterious group called the Burning Blade. Jaina and Thrall try to solve this conflict, as it looks like war might break out.
So far so good. There's not really a whole lot of action in the book. A lot of vignettes about rising trouble, and some investigative work, an interlude with Aegwynn and stories about her past, and then the force behind the Burning Blade is defeated. It sometimes felt like fan-fiction and not a real professional novel. Characters were incredibly flat. I guess Jaina is the main protagonist, but she doesn't really stand out as having a personality. None of the characters really do. There's an air of non-seriousness about everything, even the bloody battle scenes.
Why still three stars? Because I enjoyed reading about Kalimdor, and familiar names. I am the odd person who gets the shivers and feels at home when entering The Barrens, so it felt like reading about my home. Yeah, weird, I know. Of course that also drove me a bit mad, because the book's Durotar is very different from the game's version. Forest around Thunder Ridge, farmland, no fishing? I don't think so.
Despite all the flaws I was decently entertained, so it's 2.5 stars rounding out to 3. I'll take this over Knaak any day!
February 15, 2015
his was the second book I read in the Warcraft Universe. The first being Arthas and it was a pleasent novel so I grabed this one because of Jaina Proudmoore. I wanted to know more of her. I was dissapointed it. Well DeCandido doesn't understand that much the warcraft universe. I've checked and he has written a dozen novels for a dozen different universe spanning Starcraft, Warcraft, Star Trek, Young Hercules, Resident Evil, Command and Conquer, Serenity, Buffy, Spider-Man and many others. I think the only book he has written by himself was Dragon Precinct. But this doesn't go without merit. He has written more than 40 novels. And if still does it it's because people find him good. So...
What I thought? Very well... Thrall and Jaina are not that well portrayed. No character in this novel was. One think that upsets me is that this novel has no new lore. I am an avid reader of Black Library books and Forgotten Realms book. I expect not only a good novel but something new... some new fluff... some new insight. This novel didn't had any. The plot is this: Someone is threating the orcs and human alliance and Jaina and Thrall can't understand who. After some investigation and with help of some old old wizard they find out and stop the bloodshed. Nice isn't it? I couldn't understand this novel... The orcs are woman haters and human females threat the man's part as weak and corrupted with tendencies to be lazy. It was awful.
If a man hates a women is he mysoginist? And the other way around? Well... I didn't enjoy the book for all it's faults. Can I continue to read some Warcraft novels? Let us see...
What I thought? Very well... Thrall and Jaina are not that well portrayed. No character in this novel was. One think that upsets me is that this novel has no new lore. I am an avid reader of Black Library books and Forgotten Realms book. I expect not only a good novel but something new... some new fluff... some new insight. This novel didn't had any. The plot is this: Someone is threating the orcs and human alliance and Jaina and Thrall can't understand who. After some investigation and with help of some old old wizard they find out and stop the bloodshed. Nice isn't it? I couldn't understand this novel... The orcs are woman haters and human females threat the man's part as weak and corrupted with tendencies to be lazy. It was awful.
If a man hates a women is he mysoginist? And the other way around? Well... I didn't enjoy the book for all it's faults. Can I continue to read some Warcraft novels? Let us see...
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 18, 2010
This book makes me wish there was a 3.5 stars. I dunno, it certainly wasn't bad and had its moments, but I'd reserve a 5 star rating for "classics" and a 4 star rating for stuff like my favorite Warcraft novel, "The Last Guardian".
Anyways, this book. As I said, not bad for what it is, which is Warcraft-related light reading. My main issues with it were primarily that a.) there is never really a huge sense of danger, and b.) there's nothing really gripping about the story as a whole. You're reading about characters like Jaina, Thrall, etc. who clearly survive (this book is pre-WoW), and the the "climactic final battle" lasts about... one page, maybe? And the bad guy is never really all that scary.
Still, I wouldn't peg much of this as being the fault of the author's; he did well with what he had to work with. There are some fun character moments sprinkled throughout. (The author is really good at making minor characters more interesting than the major ones.) It's also pretty obvious that he's played WoW-- at least enough of it to get through Durotar and the Barrens, as various in-game landmarks from both areas make prominent appearances, to the point that it almost (but not quite) feels like "trying too hard".
Overall, not a bad read for what it is, but seems to be missing something. If I had to pick a group of people to recommend it to, it'd be people who played Warcraft 3 but haven't started WoW yet and need some background on what led up to the Alliance/Horde rivalry starting anew. (You know, all two people in the world who fall into that category.)
Anyways, this book. As I said, not bad for what it is, which is Warcraft-related light reading. My main issues with it were primarily that a.) there is never really a huge sense of danger, and b.) there's nothing really gripping about the story as a whole. You're reading about characters like Jaina, Thrall, etc. who clearly survive (this book is pre-WoW), and the the "climactic final battle" lasts about... one page, maybe? And the bad guy is never really all that scary.
Still, I wouldn't peg much of this as being the fault of the author's; he did well with what he had to work with. There are some fun character moments sprinkled throughout. (The author is really good at making minor characters more interesting than the major ones.) It's also pretty obvious that he's played WoW-- at least enough of it to get through Durotar and the Barrens, as various in-game landmarks from both areas make prominent appearances, to the point that it almost (but not quite) feels like "trying too hard".
Overall, not a bad read for what it is, but seems to be missing something. If I had to pick a group of people to recommend it to, it'd be people who played Warcraft 3 but haven't started WoW yet and need some background on what led up to the Alliance/Horde rivalry starting anew. (You know, all two people in the world who fall into that category.)
January 11, 2015
Like all of the World of Warcraft novels, I enjoyed this book. Familiar, beloved characters were featured while at the same time new characters were also introduced. This story takes place after the Burning Legion has been defeated by the combined efforts of humans and orcs. Now, an uneasy alliance has been formed. Jaina Proudmoore and Thrall work together to solve their problems. Unfortunately, those that serve underneath them do not see things as they do. Tensions continue to build up between the two factions. Now that the demons have been defeated, old arguements begin to foam back up to the surface. Underneath it, though, something is causing things to heat up. It is up to the two leaders to figure it out before things get out of hand. I found the plot to be almost too predictable. As opposed to previous stories, there does not seem to be as many plot twists. Also I was increasingly frustrated as I read. I had just finished reading "Arthas: Rises of the Lich King". In that book, there is mention of the Burning Legion and its defeat. Then I read this book and it skips over that entire era. However, it constantly makes references to events that happened during that war. There was enough tidbits that I was able to piece together what happended, but I still really would have perfered to have actually been able to read it. Perhaps I am missing a book? Also this book seems to be more of a build up to another book. There was not much action, just a setting up of scenarios for things to come. Despite all this, I found it to be a good read.
February 18, 2015
Cycle of Hatred is a story set in the Warcraft universe created by Blizzard Entertainment. Despite being listed as the first in a series, relies heavily on the reader being aware of previous story.
A time of tense peace has settled over the continent known as Kalimdor. Two States have emerged following a war against demonic forces. One, of humans ruled over by the most powerful wizardess to have ever lived. The other, a nation of Orcs, former slaves of both the Demons, and then the Humans, under a charasmatic shaman. This is not a world of tranquility though. This peace, based on a war-time alliance against a common foe is only maintained by the leaders' respect for each other. The common people believe the worst of the other.
The title is apt and especially true for the Orcs as they are trapped in a cycle of oppression, hatred, and violence that few can, or want to see their way out of. A parallel is the stories of 3 human women presented, showing their own captivity, and freedom in a male dominated world. However, none of these stories is explored in much detail, the eBook being only 272 pages.
I enjoyed the book as a player of the games and someone interested to see more stories set in that universe. However, this is not an example of high literature, but more a pulp novel that tells a simple narrative without twist or turn that you don't see coming.
A time of tense peace has settled over the continent known as Kalimdor. Two States have emerged following a war against demonic forces. One, of humans ruled over by the most powerful wizardess to have ever lived. The other, a nation of Orcs, former slaves of both the Demons, and then the Humans, under a charasmatic shaman. This is not a world of tranquility though. This peace, based on a war-time alliance against a common foe is only maintained by the leaders' respect for each other. The common people believe the worst of the other.
The title is apt and especially true for the Orcs as they are trapped in a cycle of oppression, hatred, and violence that few can, or want to see their way out of. A parallel is the stories of 3 human women presented, showing their own captivity, and freedom in a male dominated world. However, none of these stories is explored in much detail, the eBook being only 272 pages.
I enjoyed the book as a player of the games and someone interested to see more stories set in that universe. However, this is not an example of high literature, but more a pulp novel that tells a simple narrative without twist or turn that you don't see coming.
October 30, 2016
Cycle of Hatred is actually a prequel to World of Warcraft and sets a whole year before the events of WoW, telling the story of Orcs and Humans on Kalimdor, living in the somewhat peace that both Thrall and Jaina Proudmoore have created. However, the tension between these two unlike races is still there and old hatred is not easily being forgotten.
Basically, this novel is all about how easily the peace between Orcs and Humans is being disrupted, how hard both Thrall and Jaina try to keep it but no matter what they do, their races are still about to fight each other once again.
It's a nice read, really. The story was more focused on Jaina and her finding a way to restore peace than on Thrall and his orcs. Jaina's side provided some nice additional information on how magic works, as well as some background on Aegwynn and the Guardians of Tirisfal.
All in all, the book provides some nice-to-have-information but doesn't exactly add anything essential to the whole lore of Warcraft. It's a nice read though but that's really all it is.
Basically, this novel is all about how easily the peace between Orcs and Humans is being disrupted, how hard both Thrall and Jaina try to keep it but no matter what they do, their races are still about to fight each other once again.
It's a nice read, really. The story was more focused on Jaina and her finding a way to restore peace than on Thrall and his orcs. Jaina's side provided some nice additional information on how magic works, as well as some background on Aegwynn and the Guardians of Tirisfal.
All in all, the book provides some nice-to-have-information but doesn't exactly add anything essential to the whole lore of Warcraft. It's a nice read though but that's really all it is.
June 5, 2015
I liked it! It gives me serious WoW aches...like I want to play it so bad, but nothing will bring me back to how I originally felt. Nostalgia is a powerful fucking drug! The second it mentions dreadmist peak at the end I got a flashback of my first time finding that mountain while playing the beta 10+ years ago and being like "holy shit this is so cool wtf is this place!!!!" and calling a friend over to check it out. It definitely does what it set out to do - it's not amazing but definitely lotsa fun. It also captured the infuriating message of warcraft well: hate and ignorance of difference destroys everyone. One of the main reasons I've loved the games as much as I have through the years - they have a good message.
October 31, 2015
A small story that bridges the gap between the end of 'The Frozen Throne' and the beginning of World of Warcraft. In that sense, I enjoyed the extension of continuity between the two. It was nice to see Thrall and Jaina in the focus, since they are two of the more interesting, non-evil characters still alive in the franchise. The conflict in this book is also a cute nod to the original conflict in the franchise. The addition of a third character from way back in the Warcraft lore was also a nice touch.
All in all, it wasn't half bad. In terms of video game novelizations, it's square in the middle of the spectrum. There are better and worse Warcraft outings to be read.
All in all, it wasn't half bad. In terms of video game novelizations, it's square in the middle of the spectrum. There are better and worse Warcraft outings to be read.
January 20, 2013
It appears that (thankfully) the first book with "World of Warcraft" trademark would be its worst. Book is full of non-existant characters and the pacing is much like playing original Worlf of Warcraft. Also, in some parts it tries to mimic modern thrillers which didn't work the way it should have. Real bad and easily forgettable.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 157 reviews