Overall Impression
A mixed bag, as anthologies so often are. I much preferred the later sections to the beginning; I wonder if I just don't much like sword and sorcery?
I will say that I found the collection to be a little scattered, a little unfocused. I think it was trying to do too many things at once. It also had an overall grim tone. Still, it was worth a read, and there are a couple of real gems in the mix.
Highlights include: "The Knight of Chains, the Deuce of Stars" by Yoon Ha Lee, "And Wash Out by Tides of War" by An Owomoyela, and "Eaters" by Nancy Kress.
Northern Chess, Tanith Lee 4 stars
Beautifully written, and not in a way that I'm used to. The twist will feel familiar to anyone who's grown up with Lord of the Rings, but it's still a plot device I appreciate.
Anukazi's Daughter, Mary Gentle 2 stars
I didn't much like this story.
Become a Warrior, Jane Yolen 3 stars
Powerful but very bleak.
The Sea Troll's Daughter, Caitlin R. Kiernan 2 stars
This was quite long and didn't really work for me.
Joenna's Axe, Elaine Isaak 4 stars
Very nice! I though this story was very engaging, appreciated the character development, and the ending made me smile (grimly).
Love Among the Talus, Elizabeth Bear 4 stars
A more detached writing style, but I loved the world.
Soul Case, Nalo Hopkinson 4 stars
Short but effective.
The Girls from Avenger, Carrie Vaughn 3 stars
Something about the writing felt just slightly clunky to me, and there's no SFnal element. But it's okay.
In the Loop, Ken Liu 3 stars
Like the idea, not so keen on the execution. The writing style is very "telling", which is not generally what I prefer.
Dying With Her Cheer Pants On, Seanan McGuire 4 stars
This story is just so absurd that you have to like it. Fighting Pumpkins forever!
Prayer, Robert Reed 4 stars
I don't know that I found the ending so satisfying, but this story gets 4 stars just for the totally bonkers world.
England Under the White Witch, Theodora Goss 4.5 stars
History made fairy tale. I very much like Goss's writing - definitely looking forward to reading something novel-length from her.
The Lonely Songs of Laren Dorr, George R. R. Martin 5 stars
Melancholy but utterly lovely.
The Knight of Chains, the Deuce of Stars, Yoon Ha Lee 5 stars
HOLY COW. Can I give this more stars? I want to give this more stars. Gorgeously written, fantastically inventive, the imagery is to die for, the construction is tight. I'm only about halfway through the anthology, but I'm pretty sure this is going to be the highlight.
Boy Twelve, Jessica Reisman 4 stars
I liked this one! A prickly narrator, but Reisman constructed her well. Very inventive in its worldbuilding.
The Application of Hope, Kristine Kathryn Rusch 3 stars
I liked this one too, and possibly enough to foray into the rest of the Diving Universe. However, it felt quite long -- at least novelette length -- and I thought it might be tighter if it were pared down. Plus the prose felt a bit...dry? Unemotional? I'm not certain.
Not That Kind of a War, Tanya Huff 4 stars
Always love me some Torin. Huff is always very insightful about the realities of war and the personalities of those who wage it.
Naratha's Shadow, Sharon Lee & Steve Miller 3.5 stars
This was an interesting sci fi/fantasy blend. I confess myself intrigued enough to investigate a Liaden Universe novel...although, what I was most captivated by was the idea of the scouts and their work finding artifacts and chasing down legends, which mostly happened offscreen in this tale.
Eaters, Nancy Kress 5 stars
Wow! Tight, bursting with energy, complicated characters, ethical dilemmas...an exceptionally strong story.
And Wash Out by Tides of War, An Owomoyela 5 stars
Okay, this one impressed me a lot. I was captivated from the start, and again, really interesting worldbuilding. Will definitely be looking out for more stories by this author.
Hand to Hand, Elizabeth Moon 4 stars
Right, so. I don't know where exactly my opinion stands on the central argument of this story -- but it certainly has one, and one that made me think, and it's well written.
They Tell Me There Will Be No Pain, Rachael Acks 4.5 stars
Grim, but it resonated with me.
Wonder Maul Doll, Kameron Hurley 3 stars
Hurley is pretty much always gory. This story is no exception. It's just universally brutal. I see where it was a challenge to ennui surrounding occupation and war; I see where it was a challenge to, specifically, the invasion of Iraq. I really didn't enjoy the reading experience, though.
The Days of the War, as Red as Blood, as Dark as Bile, Aliette de Bodard 4 stars
Well, that was depressing.