I'm usually a huge fan of Melissa Hill's work, yet here, something was missing. The first story was very nice, as I have read "Something from Tiffany's" it was really nice to have a sequel. But I didn't feel the magic other books, as "The charm bracelet" had on me. It was the same with the short stories and then the final story in Venice : it was all very nice, but I didn't clicked as I usually do, I didn't cry at the end.
This book is still as well written as the other works of Melissa Hill, but I was a little disappointed, because all the Christmas things, New York, Venice, the common theme was magic, yet I didn't feel any of it. Perhaps it's just me not getting on with the "short novel" format.