Los Angeles gangbangers, vengeful spirits...and Edgar Allen Poe? That couldn't possibly work...could it? As it turns out, it does - and pretty well overall.
When I first read the idea behind The Poe Consequence - a story that blends inner-city gang violence with Poe-inspired vengeance - I pretty much knew I'd have to read it, if only to see how wrong it could go. Imagine my surprise when it turned out to be a book that, while not perfect, mostly overcame the early threat of stereotype and told a cracking good story to boot.
On the surface it's a fairly simple story - a single father, whose wife passed away only months earlier, is caught in the crossfire of two warring gangs in Los Angeles and killed right in front of his young son. Soon after, gang members from both sides of the gun battle that killed Warren start to die of sudden, inexplicable heart attacks - events which leave their hearts literally frozen.
The mystery unravels as Warren's surviving family must deal with their loss, while the police and the gangs try to find out why so many young men are dying. Lives intertwine in unexpected ways, anger gives way to understanding, and the possibility of redemption is at hand - for a price.
And yes, the influence of Poe is felt throughout, though honestly not as strongly as I would have liked. Warren, the murdered father, is teacher and a devotee of Edgar Allen Poe. When his spirit tries to protect his son from beyond the grave, it's in Poe's obsession with death that he finds inspiration, and each killing incorporates elements of "The Pit and the Pendulum," "The Fall of the House of Usher," and most especially, "The Tell-Tale Heart." And at first, the effect of these references is chilling - but eventually it gets a little repetitive. With such a rich body of work to draw on, why not dig even deeper with it? Bring in the chilling yowls of "The Black Cat" perhaps, or the impending sense of unstoppable doom of "The Masque of the Red Death," or even the deep-seated subtle horror of "The Premature Burial" would have worked well here. And why, in a story fueled by revenge, would the ultimate tale of cold-blooded vengeance - "A Cask of Amontillado" - not even get a mention? While I very much appreciated the references and allusions to Poe's work in The Poe Consequence, I must confess I was hoping for even more.
Still, all in all, The Poe Consequence is a well-crafted book. Keith Steinbaum's writing style isn't flashy, but it serves the story well, only occasionally showing its seams in a piece of clunky dialogue or curious word choice. The characters, who start out feeling a little flat (the angry child, the troubled alcoholic, etc.), grow past their stereotype into people with dimension, the capacity to change, and with a life beyond the pages. The story is paced well and ends well, satisfying without pandering too much to the reader.
It was an audacious concept, for sure - one I was ready to think wouldn't work at all. Keith Steinbaum's trick in blending the subtle darkness of Edgar Allen Poe with the brash violence of L.A. street gangs shouldn't have worked - but somehow, it did.
----------------
I received a free copy of The Poe Consequence for the purpose of reviewing.