What do you think?
Rate this book
Payback
New York City in the boomtown '80s, where fortunes are made with the drop of a dime. The lucrative construction rackets are in the hands of the Irish mob, sparking the envy of the Mafia, the attention of the feds, and all-out war.
Two brothers are caught in the cross fire. Paddy Adare, a failed boxer turned enforcer for the Irish gangs, and Billy, a college graduate toiling in the tunnels as a sandhog before going to law school. As greed and hatred fuel the fight that is blazing in the streets, honor and loyalty will be put to the ultimate test.
Two brothers are caught in the cross fire. Paddy Adare, a failed boxer turned enforcer for the Irish gangs, and Billy, a college graduate toiling in the tunnels as a sandhog before going to law school. As greed and hatred fuel the fight that is blazing in the streets, honor and loyalty will be put to the ultimate test.
323 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published January 1, 1997
2 people are currently reading
52 people want to read
About the author
Thomas Kelly
230 books26 followersThomas Kelly (b. 1960) is the author of three novels set in New York City. Born in New York, Kelly spent ten years as a construction worker and sandhog—working in the subway tunnels beneath the city—before attending Fordham University and Harvard University, where he received a master’s degree in public administration. Kelly parlayed his experience in union politics into a job as an advance man for the campaign of New York City mayor David Dinkins, an experience which would form the basis for some of his fiction.
Kelly began writing in the mid-1990s, and published his debut, Payback, in 1997. A gritty look at the overlap between construction and the Mafia, it was critically acclaimed and adapted to film by David Mamet. Kelly’s other works are The Rackets (2001), which was inspired by Kelly’s experience working for City Hall, and Empire Rising (2005), a historical novel about the construction of the Empire State Building.
Kelly began writing in the mid-1990s, and published his debut, Payback, in 1997. A gritty look at the overlap between construction and the Mafia, it was critically acclaimed and adapted to film by David Mamet. Kelly’s other works are The Rackets (2001), which was inspired by Kelly’s experience working for City Hall, and Empire Rising (2005), a historical novel about the construction of the Empire State Building.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews
January 17, 2012
I really had mixed feelings about this book. On the one hand, the nitty gritty details on mob violence, police procedure, working conditions in the tunnels below NYC were incredibly thorough and totally convincing. Thomas Kelly has a real talent for creating terror and suspense and for putting ruthless criminals into explosive situations.
On the other hand, the emotional drama of the story is composed entirely of groaning cliches and stereotypes, the good guys are almost laughably predictable in who they are and what they do. The bad brother who coulda been a contendah in the fight game -- the good brother who gets an education and wants to leave the neighborhood behind -- are you kidding me with this stuff?
It doesn't help much that Thomas Kelly is writing from the Irish perspective and only from the Irish perspective. What I mean is, any crime, no matter how hateful or loathsome, is okay if the Irish are doing it. But when they Italians do exactly the same thing they are portrayed as vicious, insane, cowardly, dishonest, etc. Man does that double standard get old fast. Italians are all lying, treacherous, greasy Dago backstabbers -- the Irish are all crazy, sure, and violent, but only because they're such romantics at heart and they love a good fight.
Bone-crunching violence and cloying sentimentality do not mix. Throw in phony liberalism of the most one-dimensional sort (Ronald Reagan was a bad man, sure, but he did not invent racism, in or out of the Irish community) and you get a book that is incredibly compelling one minute and all but unreadable the next.
For all the visceral reality of the construction battles, Kelly's picture of NYC seems almost unreal at times. Where are all the blacks? Where are the Jews? Where are the Latinos, the Orientals, the homosexuals?
At times PAYBACK is a weird exercise in wishful thinking, STUDS LONIGAN reimagined as wistful nostalgia rather than outraged expose.
For all that, however, I have to say this book is a gripping read and one I have never forgotten.
On the other hand, the emotional drama of the story is composed entirely of groaning cliches and stereotypes, the good guys are almost laughably predictable in who they are and what they do. The bad brother who coulda been a contendah in the fight game -- the good brother who gets an education and wants to leave the neighborhood behind -- are you kidding me with this stuff?
It doesn't help much that Thomas Kelly is writing from the Irish perspective and only from the Irish perspective. What I mean is, any crime, no matter how hateful or loathsome, is okay if the Irish are doing it. But when they Italians do exactly the same thing they are portrayed as vicious, insane, cowardly, dishonest, etc. Man does that double standard get old fast. Italians are all lying, treacherous, greasy Dago backstabbers -- the Irish are all crazy, sure, and violent, but only because they're such romantics at heart and they love a good fight.
Bone-crunching violence and cloying sentimentality do not mix. Throw in phony liberalism of the most one-dimensional sort (Ronald Reagan was a bad man, sure, but he did not invent racism, in or out of the Irish community) and you get a book that is incredibly compelling one minute and all but unreadable the next.
For all the visceral reality of the construction battles, Kelly's picture of NYC seems almost unreal at times. Where are all the blacks? Where are the Jews? Where are the Latinos, the Orientals, the homosexuals?
At times PAYBACK is a weird exercise in wishful thinking, STUDS LONIGAN reimagined as wistful nostalgia rather than outraged expose.
For all that, however, I have to say this book is a gripping read and one I have never forgotten.
June 21, 2022
Definitely an interesting read, but the story doesn't seem to really build up tension. I stopped reading on page 281, because I didn't care about the ending, but I got some insight into 80's New York.
March 30, 2010
During the '80s building boom in New York, Billy Adare was a sandhog (tunneler). He attended school at night with a goal of getting his law degres. His brother, Paddy, is an enforcer for Jack Tierney, who runs the construction racket in the West Side.
We learn of the difficulty these sandhogs had, building the tunnels under the skyscrapers. Most of the sandhogs were Irish and the Mob wanted to replace the Irish with newly immigrated Poles, pay less and pocket the difference.
When a union rep is beaten to death by Tierney's crazed brother, Butcher Boy, Billy's friends ask him to check with his brother, Paddy, to see if he can learn who is strong-arming them.
The authro does a good job describing New York amidst the building boom. He also seems to be writing about the last of a kind, the Irish sandhogs in the Bronx. There is a great deal of violence and much of it is against these sandhogs who want nothing more than to make a decent living.
We also see the view of the wealthy towards the working man, represented by Billy. This is seen in the way he is treated by the family of his girlfriend. He was considered less than desireable for their daughter because he worked with his hands.
Well done and interesting.
We learn of the difficulty these sandhogs had, building the tunnels under the skyscrapers. Most of the sandhogs were Irish and the Mob wanted to replace the Irish with newly immigrated Poles, pay less and pocket the difference.
When a union rep is beaten to death by Tierney's crazed brother, Butcher Boy, Billy's friends ask him to check with his brother, Paddy, to see if he can learn who is strong-arming them.
The authro does a good job describing New York amidst the building boom. He also seems to be writing about the last of a kind, the Irish sandhogs in the Bronx. There is a great deal of violence and much of it is against these sandhogs who want nothing more than to make a decent living.
We also see the view of the wealthy towards the working man, represented by Billy. This is seen in the way he is treated by the family of his girlfriend. He was considered less than desireable for their daughter because he worked with his hands.
Well done and interesting.
March 24, 2013
As a former sandhog myself, this book is intimately close to my roots. Both my grandfather and my father were sandhogs. Thomas Kelly captures the details of his own turf in this tale of gangsters and hard-boiled characters. I'm not much for the genre (I like the films better) but I own a signed copy of Payback that my father picked up at one of Mr. Kelly's signings. It remains a family heirloom. Mr. Kelly, as a former sandhog, has also served as inspiration for my own book, Spiked Snowballs & Flaming Cats. I recommend Payback because it takes the reader to places they probably didn't even know existed.
March 8, 2008
There are not many fiction books that credibly capture the world of the building trades in NYC where all too often unions have been corrupted and are not worthy of the good union members that they are supposed to serve.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
July 17, 2009
His first book, and you can tell somewhat, but it does not distract from a rather tight bit of business I would call city noir. No really good guys, Unions, Sandhogs, the Irish and the Italians all stirred up
into a nasty bit about family relationships of all kinds. Well worth a read.
into a nasty bit about family relationships of all kinds. Well worth a read.
May 22, 2012
Just ok, not into mob violence...
January 22, 2016
Interesting read about a labor dispute in the building of New York subways.
Displaying 1 - 9 of 9 reviews