What do you think?
Rate this book
Larger Than Life Laura
When Lara Phelps walks into Laney Grafton's fourth-grade class, Laney feels the air change. Lara is fat. Really fat. Finally, there will be someone else for the boys to pick on, Laney thinks. But as the class prepares for the school play, Lara doesn't act the way a fat kid should. She's confident. She's happy. And nothing, it seems, can change her positive attitude. Until one day, when Laney's classmates do the unthinkable.
Bestselling author Dandi Daley Mackall tells this original and poignant story through the use of sparkling language, a winsome narrator, and a clever structure that illustrates just what makes a story a story.
First published January 1, 2006
9 people are currently reading
297 people want to read
About the author
Dandi Daley Mackall
352 books299 followersA professional writer for over 20 years, Dandi Daley Mackall has written dozens of articles for popular magazines and published around 500 books for children and adults alike, with sales of over 4 million.
A frequent guest on radio and television talk shows, she lives in rural Ohio with her husband, three children, horses, dogs, & cats. Awards include the Edgar Award for Best YA Mystery, the Helen Keating Ott Award for Contributions to Children's Literature; Distinguished Alumni Award from Mizzou; ALA Best Book; Christian Children's Book of the Year, Amelia Bloom, Mom's Choice Awards. Her YA novel, My Boyfriends' Dogs, is now a Hallmark movie.
A frequent guest on radio and television talk shows, she lives in rural Ohio with her husband, three children, horses, dogs, & cats. Awards include the Edgar Award for Best YA Mystery, the Helen Keating Ott Award for Contributions to Children's Literature; Distinguished Alumni Award from Mizzou; ALA Best Book; Christian Children's Book of the Year, Amelia Bloom, Mom's Choice Awards. Her YA novel, My Boyfriends' Dogs, is now a Hallmark movie.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews
March 28, 2008
I cringed all the way through this book, at the thoughtless cruelty of kids and the ability of adults to overlook all the mean stuff that goes on in elementary school classes...but I loved the characters and the resolution. Brava! I think it'd be a great read-aloud in any class where the kids are experiencing an empathy deficit.
August 10, 2017
This book pulled at my heartstrings and is a story that will stay with me. It is narrated by Laney, a 10 year old girl who is extremely bright and witty and instantly likable. Laney has a very difficult home life and although she tends to gloss over some of the details, it’s clear that she is not treated well. A new girl named Lara comes to Laney’s school and is instantly targeted by the entire class because of her size. To Laney and the other kids’ surprise, Lara seems to let all the ridicule slide off and takes the “kill them with kindness” approach.
First of all, I loved Laney…she is very honest about everything she sees and the reader can see the pain she feels, even when she tries to disguise it. Lara is also a lovely character…she “lets her light shine” in the face of adversity and strives to make people feel better about themselves even as they taunt her.
There are some very raw and sad moments in this story but I think it accurately portrays how cruel children (and adults) can be. It also shows the consequences for our actions…although this story ends with lessons being learned, it’s not a completely happy ending, it’s very realistic.
I highly recommend this book for kids ages 8 and up, there is eluding to cursing and alcoholism as well as abuse.
My Rating: 5 stars
I received this book from Tyndale House Publishing in exchange for an honest review.
First of all, I loved Laney…she is very honest about everything she sees and the reader can see the pain she feels, even when she tries to disguise it. Lara is also a lovely character…she “lets her light shine” in the face of adversity and strives to make people feel better about themselves even as they taunt her.
There are some very raw and sad moments in this story but I think it accurately portrays how cruel children (and adults) can be. It also shows the consequences for our actions…although this story ends with lessons being learned, it’s not a completely happy ending, it’s very realistic.
I highly recommend this book for kids ages 8 and up, there is eluding to cursing and alcoholism as well as abuse.
My Rating: 5 stars
I received this book from Tyndale House Publishing in exchange for an honest review.
January 25, 2009
This is another book I read with my 3rd grade class. The book was well written and engaged my students, it also gave us a great opportunity to talk about how to treat others and bullying. My kids were very upset at how Laura was treated just because she was big. They also found the ending to be very sad. They still want all their books to have happy endings. I think the book was a good one to read with the class however, I did have to edit a few pages because I felt my students to young to read about a character whose dad had a drinking problem and was abusive.
November 27, 2020
That was just... strange. The book was written in 2006, but it really seems dated to the 80’s or something. Did anyone else feel like things turned “Carrie” on the stage with Lara in the final scene?
I was kind of reminded of another book about an obese girl, “Nothings Fair in the Fifth Grade.” That book was hugely cruel, but it was written in 1981 and that was the quality of YA books back then. You could never get away with that now. “Larger-than-life Lara” is like the transition book, the one that squeaked in, before publishers and readers said enough.
This book is jarring on so many levels... BUT, it certainly made an impression. First, Laney is writing a book, the book you are reading. I found it distracting to know this, as she mentions in every chapter how to write a book and it’s the story (which happens to her) that she’s writing about. I wish she’d just told the story. There’s “hillbilly” language, so at first I was tripping over words until I realized it was her dialect, but it’s not used often (like in Turn Homeward, Hannalee) it’s just laced in sometimes. The way everyone treats Lara is insane. But the way Lara reacts is even stranger. I’ve been reading books with character that are on the spectrum and Lara doesn’t strike me that way, she’s just... strange. I appreciate that she doesn’t let the kids get to her and can smile through it, but the poems?? That’s almost psychotic. I would almost worry that her poems were threats and she would hurt me after school. They weren’t, even though the first one said to Joey a line that included “You’ll get more power if your arm is straight.” I thought she meant she was going to break his arm if he teased her again. No. She was giving him real advice. So the poems thing, honestly reminded me of a Berenstain Bears book. Like two opposing books being written into one.
And then the play. The Play. What can I say? I had visions of Carrie with the blood spilling all over her, but here we have water balloons and stuffed animals, and props.
And the conclusion is that Lara’s parents take her out of school. They’re rightly angry, and I’m so happy they are. At least she’s got parents that will stand up for her. But then the class gets a change of heart? And decides they’ll miss her? And writes her a poem of there own? What? What? No. This book is just so... strange.
It’s good writing but I would not want my children to read this book. As they probably wouldn’t like it either, to be honest. I’m not sure how this book escaped into libraries.
I was kind of reminded of another book about an obese girl, “Nothings Fair in the Fifth Grade.” That book was hugely cruel, but it was written in 1981 and that was the quality of YA books back then. You could never get away with that now. “Larger-than-life Lara” is like the transition book, the one that squeaked in, before publishers and readers said enough.
This book is jarring on so many levels... BUT, it certainly made an impression. First, Laney is writing a book, the book you are reading. I found it distracting to know this, as she mentions in every chapter how to write a book and it’s the story (which happens to her) that she’s writing about. I wish she’d just told the story. There’s “hillbilly” language, so at first I was tripping over words until I realized it was her dialect, but it’s not used often (like in Turn Homeward, Hannalee) it’s just laced in sometimes. The way everyone treats Lara is insane. But the way Lara reacts is even stranger. I’ve been reading books with character that are on the spectrum and Lara doesn’t strike me that way, she’s just... strange. I appreciate that she doesn’t let the kids get to her and can smile through it, but the poems?? That’s almost psychotic. I would almost worry that her poems were threats and she would hurt me after school. They weren’t, even though the first one said to Joey a line that included “You’ll get more power if your arm is straight.” I thought she meant she was going to break his arm if he teased her again. No. She was giving him real advice. So the poems thing, honestly reminded me of a Berenstain Bears book. Like two opposing books being written into one.
And then the play. The Play. What can I say? I had visions of Carrie with the blood spilling all over her, but here we have water balloons and stuffed animals, and props.
And the conclusion is that Lara’s parents take her out of school. They’re rightly angry, and I’m so happy they are. At least she’s got parents that will stand up for her. But then the class gets a change of heart? And decides they’ll miss her? And writes her a poem of there own? What? What? No. This book is just so... strange.
It’s good writing but I would not want my children to read this book. As they probably wouldn’t like it either, to be honest. I’m not sure how this book escaped into libraries.
December 1, 2016
I've been a long-time casual fan of Dandi Daley Mackall's books ever since I picked up a copy of her the first Winnie the Horse-Gentler book at a yard sale a few years ago. I was getting rather sick of horse books at the time because I was realizing they all had the same rather vapid and predictable plot lines, but the book reinvigorated my passion for horse novels. I also later loved Mackall's Starlight Animal Rescue series, which is connected to the Winnie books, and loved them even more. Mackall has a gift for blending realistic characters, hard facts about life, and inspirational messages all together and offering them to her readers in slim, engaging novels. That's why I leaped at the opportunity to review Larger-Than-Life Lara: it looked like a very different book than the other ones I'd read by Mackall, but I was pretty sure she'd still be able to pull off a great story.
And she did. I really enjoyed reading Lara, it felt kind of like a grittier version of The Hundred Dresses . Actually, now that I think about it, I would be surprised if Mackall got the inspiration to write Lara from Dresses. Since I always loved Dresses growing up, that is a very good impression for me to come away with.
The narration in Lara comes from Laney, who has to be on of the best narrators I've read in a while. She's writing the "true" story down the way her teacher taught her to, using all the tricks they learned in school. Every chapter is titled with exactly what it introduces (Villain, Setting, Dialogue, etc.), and Laney prefaces her plot devices or narration decisions with funny, candid explanations like this one:
Isn't that just so cute? I don't know what it is, but I just really love this sort of fourth-wall-breaking narration style.
Anyway, moving on. Laney is a really great character, not just a fun narrator, and I definitely felt for her. The situation at her home is not so great (think three older brothers, no mother, and an alcoholic/likely abusive father), and she is constantly covering for her family at school and hiding her school life from her family. It's not good, at all, and I felt terrible watching her hold everything in. The focus in the end of the book, though, isn't really on her home life; it's on Lara and the way she was being treated at school. Now I haven't had much experience with bullying, but I thought it was absolutely horrible the way everyone treated Lara from day one. The minute she walked in the classroom door, people were calling her ugly names and making fun of her. That's despicable! If she's really that overweight, that's her parents' fault–or the fault of some disorder, maybe, I don't know–but it's definitely not her fault. She's ten years old, people! I don't know, fifth graders are just so barbaric sometimes.
As for Lara as a character, I never really felt like I got to know her that well. She seems sweet, and extraordinarily brave, but almost rather one-dimensional: we never really see Laney have a heart-to-heart with Lara and find out what makes her tick. There were honestly a lot of characters and plotlines whose stories I would have loved to see expanded, which is why I wish the book were a little longer. Barring an updated and heftier re-release of the novel, I'm hoping for a sequel sometime down the road. I think there's a lot of material in Larger-Than-Life Lara that Mackall could use to develop a whole series, actually. It could be, I don't know, "The Paris, Missouri series." Or something catchier. I'm not really a title developer. But anyway, I definitely enjoyed Larger-Than-Life Lara and I'm glad I had the chance to read it. If you've read it, comment below and let me know what you thought!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
And she did. I really enjoyed reading Lara, it felt kind of like a grittier version of The Hundred Dresses . Actually, now that I think about it, I would be surprised if Mackall got the inspiration to write Lara from Dresses. Since I always loved Dresses growing up, that is a very good impression for me to come away with.
The narration in Lara comes from Laney, who has to be on of the best narrators I've read in a while. She's writing the "true" story down the way her teacher taught her to, using all the tricks they learned in school. Every chapter is titled with exactly what it introduces (Villain, Setting, Dialogue, etc.), and Laney prefaces her plot devices or narration decisions with funny, candid explanations like this one:
Mrs. Smith says stories have a beginning, middle, and end. They should get told in a chronological order, which is a fancy way of saying making stuff happen like it did in real life, without jumping back and forth in time like some kind of time traveler. I tried to do that, which is why you can find words like first and next and then, if you go back looking for them in this story.
But I can't figure out how else to tell this one conflict without time traveling backwards. So Mrs. Smith, if you're reading this, I just apologize for this.
Isn't that just so cute? I don't know what it is, but I just really love this sort of fourth-wall-breaking narration style.
Anyway, moving on. Laney is a really great character, not just a fun narrator, and I definitely felt for her. The situation at her home is not so great (think three older brothers, no mother, and an alcoholic/likely abusive father), and she is constantly covering for her family at school and hiding her school life from her family. It's not good, at all, and I felt terrible watching her hold everything in. The focus in the end of the book, though, isn't really on her home life; it's on Lara and the way she was being treated at school. Now I haven't had much experience with bullying, but I thought it was absolutely horrible the way everyone treated Lara from day one. The minute she walked in the classroom door, people were calling her ugly names and making fun of her. That's despicable! If she's really that overweight, that's her parents' fault–or the fault of some disorder, maybe, I don't know–but it's definitely not her fault. She's ten years old, people! I don't know, fifth graders are just so barbaric sometimes.
As for Lara as a character, I never really felt like I got to know her that well. She seems sweet, and extraordinarily brave, but almost rather one-dimensional: we never really see Laney have a heart-to-heart with Lara and find out what makes her tick. There were honestly a lot of characters and plotlines whose stories I would have loved to see expanded, which is why I wish the book were a little longer. Barring an updated and heftier re-release of the novel, I'm hoping for a sequel sometime down the road. I think there's a lot of material in Larger-Than-Life Lara that Mackall could use to develop a whole series, actually. It could be, I don't know, "The Paris, Missouri series." Or something catchier. I'm not really a title developer. But anyway, I definitely enjoyed Larger-Than-Life Lara and I'm glad I had the chance to read it. If you've read it, comment below and let me know what you thought!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
January 4, 2017
5/5 stars (for adults - I really enjoyed this one).
4/5 stars for kids (I think you should know your child before handing them this book, because it wouldn't be a great one for every kid with some of the difficult themes).
Do you ever order a book and then realize later that it is actually a children's book? Don't tell me I'm the only one.
When I ordered Larger-Than-Life Lara by Dandi Daley Mackall, I honestly thought it was a novel for an adult audience, but then I started to suspect that maybe it was more of a middle-grade novel - and it arrived, and indeed it was. The characters in this book are in the fourth grade, so I'm assuming it is meant for that age group, but I have to tell you, I loved this book.
Plot: The book is narrated by a fourth grade girl, Laney, who is trying to write a book about something significant that happened in her class. She jumps into the story telling us about a new girl who arrived, named Lara, who is overweight but incessantly joyful. Even as the other kids bully her, there is something about Lara that can't seem to be beaten down.
All of this is told from Laney's perspective, and she "writes" the book by breaking each chapter down into each story element, like "minor characters", "setting", "climax", etc, which I found really charming. She also keeps insisting that this story is about Lara, not about her, which is cute because as a reader you know it really is about her, and how Lara affects her life.
Content: Laney does not have an easy life though, and there are some elements in this book that might warrant some guidance if a fourth grader were to be the one reading it. Laney's family is poor and her dad does not take good care of them. Laney's dad is an alcoholic, and her three older brothers cuss at her (not spelled out in the book) and call her mean names constantly. There is a reference to magazines that her father does not want her brothers to see. At one point we find out that Laney's dad slapped her on the cheek. This is the extent of physically abusive behavior from her dad that is spelled out in this book, but some more sensitive kids might find this disturbing.
Aside from Laney's troubles at home, most of the story revolves around Lara being bullied at school because of her weight, and it got pretty cringe-worthy. She handles it all with grace and kindness, which is an inspiring aspect to the story.
Spiritual Aspect: Even though this book is published by Tyndale, the Christian message in it isn't spelled out. Parents, you are going to have to do that for your child yourself. Verses like Matthew 7:12, Proverbs 31:26, and Matthew 18:21-22 come to mind. Positive themes that you could expound on would be kindness, forgiveness, and joy.
My Thoughts: The ending of this book was really good and believable. Not everything is resolved at the end of this book - Laney ends with a better relationship with one of her brothers, which means she now has an ally at home, but none of her other home problems are resolved. However, the whole class learns a lesson about bullying, and the example of kindness from Lara in this book would form some great basis for discussion.
As an adult reading this book, I was really invested in the characters and worried about what would happen to them - and the ending left enough strings untied that I still find myself thinking about Laney and worrying about where her life will go. I really kind of wish there would be another book, because I would definitely read it. For kids though...I don't know if I'd let my kids read this before age ten at least. I think it would depend on the kid and how much real-life "hard stuff" they were able to handle at that age. Great book for discussion between parents and kids though - I'd suggest reading this one together.
Note: I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for a review. This is my honest opinion.
4/5 stars for kids (I think you should know your child before handing them this book, because it wouldn't be a great one for every kid with some of the difficult themes).
Do you ever order a book and then realize later that it is actually a children's book? Don't tell me I'm the only one.
When I ordered Larger-Than-Life Lara by Dandi Daley Mackall, I honestly thought it was a novel for an adult audience, but then I started to suspect that maybe it was more of a middle-grade novel - and it arrived, and indeed it was. The characters in this book are in the fourth grade, so I'm assuming it is meant for that age group, but I have to tell you, I loved this book.
Plot: The book is narrated by a fourth grade girl, Laney, who is trying to write a book about something significant that happened in her class. She jumps into the story telling us about a new girl who arrived, named Lara, who is overweight but incessantly joyful. Even as the other kids bully her, there is something about Lara that can't seem to be beaten down.
All of this is told from Laney's perspective, and she "writes" the book by breaking each chapter down into each story element, like "minor characters", "setting", "climax", etc, which I found really charming. She also keeps insisting that this story is about Lara, not about her, which is cute because as a reader you know it really is about her, and how Lara affects her life.
Content: Laney does not have an easy life though, and there are some elements in this book that might warrant some guidance if a fourth grader were to be the one reading it. Laney's family is poor and her dad does not take good care of them. Laney's dad is an alcoholic, and her three older brothers cuss at her (not spelled out in the book) and call her mean names constantly. There is a reference to magazines that her father does not want her brothers to see. At one point we find out that Laney's dad slapped her on the cheek. This is the extent of physically abusive behavior from her dad that is spelled out in this book, but some more sensitive kids might find this disturbing.
Aside from Laney's troubles at home, most of the story revolves around Lara being bullied at school because of her weight, and it got pretty cringe-worthy. She handles it all with grace and kindness, which is an inspiring aspect to the story.
Spiritual Aspect: Even though this book is published by Tyndale, the Christian message in it isn't spelled out. Parents, you are going to have to do that for your child yourself. Verses like Matthew 7:12, Proverbs 31:26, and Matthew 18:21-22 come to mind. Positive themes that you could expound on would be kindness, forgiveness, and joy.
My Thoughts: The ending of this book was really good and believable. Not everything is resolved at the end of this book - Laney ends with a better relationship with one of her brothers, which means she now has an ally at home, but none of her other home problems are resolved. However, the whole class learns a lesson about bullying, and the example of kindness from Lara in this book would form some great basis for discussion.
As an adult reading this book, I was really invested in the characters and worried about what would happen to them - and the ending left enough strings untied that I still find myself thinking about Laney and worrying about where her life will go. I really kind of wish there would be another book, because I would definitely read it. For kids though...I don't know if I'd let my kids read this before age ten at least. I think it would depend on the kid and how much real-life "hard stuff" they were able to handle at that age. Great book for discussion between parents and kids though - I'd suggest reading this one together.
Note: I received a copy of this book for free in exchange for a review. This is my honest opinion.
July 3, 2025
Number of pages: 158
Genre: Children’s fiction
Series: N/A
Age recommendation: 10-12, parental discretion
Summary: Laney is glad she’s not the only one with problems when Lara arrives in their classroom. The new girl is fat, really fat. But when everyone continuously makes fun of her, and she’s only nice back to them, will Lara change the attitude of her classmates?
My thoughts: This book was written in the style of it being the main character, Laney’s, school project (no matter what Laney says, I’m with my sister on this one: she is the actual main character; not Lara or anyone else.) I could definitely see where some other reviewers were coming from saying that the book is not particularly well written, and they didn’t appreciate the tips thrown in (i.e. Mrs. Smith says a story needs this…). Personally, I found it kind of cute at times, but annoying at other times.
This book is not Christian at all. Besides the moral (to treat everyone kindly and respectfully, maybe even turn the other cheek when people are mean to you), there is nothing remotely Christian. Nothing is said about God; the characters don’t even go to church.
There are mentions of Laney’s bad home life, with her father and brothers being verbally and physically abusive to her. Considering the book is written for elementary schoolers, I think some of the things mentioned might be too much for most younger readers.
I also didn’t like the ending. Throughout the book, everyone is extremely mean to her, and no one says anything about it to anyone; the teacher doesn’t even let Lara’s parents know what is going on. That is not right. She ends up getting in trouble for everything even though she is the victim.
I also found it a little weird that Lara responds to people in rhyming poems when they are mean. I understand the turn the other cheek mentality she is displaying, but I think it’s taken too far and Lara allows people to walk all over her unnecessarily. She didn’t have to be a tattletale, but she didn’t have to quietly submit to bullying.
I liked Luke at the end. I kind of wanted to know what made him change, but I also didn’t at the same time.
I didn’t like that Laney kept mentioning, “they said other things too but my book would get burned if I wrote them down” or something like that. I find it makes the reader want to invent the bad stuff the person said which puts their mind and focus on bad things. However, I wouldn’t really want it written out either, so I guess this was better.
I liked that Laney got a good role in the play. I was so proud of her.
Overall, the book wasn’t awful, but I feel like it could have been a lot better. Also, some of the content is too mature for elementary schoolers which I think is the intended audience.
My personal rating: 2.5/5 stars
Link to blog: https://karinaschristianreads.wordpre...
Genre: Children’s fiction
Series: N/A
Age recommendation: 10-12, parental discretion
Summary: Laney is glad she’s not the only one with problems when Lara arrives in their classroom. The new girl is fat, really fat. But when everyone continuously makes fun of her, and she’s only nice back to them, will Lara change the attitude of her classmates?
My thoughts: This book was written in the style of it being the main character, Laney’s, school project (no matter what Laney says, I’m with my sister on this one: she is the actual main character; not Lara or anyone else.) I could definitely see where some other reviewers were coming from saying that the book is not particularly well written, and they didn’t appreciate the tips thrown in (i.e. Mrs. Smith says a story needs this…). Personally, I found it kind of cute at times, but annoying at other times.
This book is not Christian at all. Besides the moral (to treat everyone kindly and respectfully, maybe even turn the other cheek when people are mean to you), there is nothing remotely Christian. Nothing is said about God; the characters don’t even go to church.
There are mentions of Laney’s bad home life, with her father and brothers being verbally and physically abusive to her. Considering the book is written for elementary schoolers, I think some of the things mentioned might be too much for most younger readers.
I also didn’t like the ending. Throughout the book, everyone is extremely mean to her, and no one says anything about it to anyone; the teacher doesn’t even let Lara’s parents know what is going on. That is not right. She ends up getting in trouble for everything even though she is the victim.
I also found it a little weird that Lara responds to people in rhyming poems when they are mean. I understand the turn the other cheek mentality she is displaying, but I think it’s taken too far and Lara allows people to walk all over her unnecessarily. She didn’t have to be a tattletale, but she didn’t have to quietly submit to bullying.
I liked Luke at the end. I kind of wanted to know what made him change, but I also didn’t at the same time.
I didn’t like that Laney kept mentioning, “they said other things too but my book would get burned if I wrote them down” or something like that. I find it makes the reader want to invent the bad stuff the person said which puts their mind and focus on bad things. However, I wouldn’t really want it written out either, so I guess this was better.
I liked that Laney got a good role in the play. I was so proud of her.
Overall, the book wasn’t awful, but I feel like it could have been a lot better. Also, some of the content is too mature for elementary schoolers which I think is the intended audience.
My personal rating: 2.5/5 stars
Link to blog: https://karinaschristianreads.wordpre...
December 13, 2016
Review:
I've been dragging my feet about writing this review for some time. I didn't really like it and momma always said, "If you don't have anything good to say..." Yet, unfortunately for me I also promised the publisher that I would give an honest review in exchange for the book.
So, it comes down to momma going head-to-head verses the Tyndale publishing team. Cage match, live on pay-per-view!
But seriously, the premise is that the story is being written by a 10-year-old girl for a school project. And I guess, in that regard you'd call it a success. The rambling, disconnected thoughts, as well as grammatical and spelling mistakes all combine to give it the feel of an elementary school class assignment.
Of course there are two sides to that coin. The opposite being: I want to read a good quality book, not some kid's class assignment!!!
This 10yo writer's goal is to write a story about something that happened in her life. Intermingled with that she is also learning how to write, so we get little writing tips and suggestions sprinkled throughout.
As a homeschooling father I first I thought this could be used as a teaching tool, but as the story progressed I decided the teacher's methodology wasn't the way I would want to do teach it anyway. And, of course, I've already graduated from elementary school (somehow against all odds), so I have a hard time seeing how this information does anything but slow us down.
Plot:
Laura, the new girl in school, is fat. Really fat.
Even in the face of some pretty brutal bullying, she is able to remain sweet and maintain a great positive attitude.
Bullying is really what the book is about. It is really where the book shines. It doesn't glorify it, nor does it shame the bullies! Rather, it tells it like it is -- all the emotions, the pain and hurt, as well as the peer pressure aspect.
Best of all, it holds a message for the bullies themselves about how they can change.
It really is a great book on bullying!
I just... don't need a book on bulling. (I homeschool, remember?)
Conclusion:
This might be good if you need a book about bullying and the general meanness of kids, written in stumbling language that might make it easier for younger children to relate to.
If, instead, you're looking for a book to teach creative writing, I'd sooner recommend a more complete dedicated resource such as How to Write (And Sell) A Christian Novel by Gilbert Morris
Finally, if none of that applies and you just want a good story to read, well, you know what momma says...
Disclaimer: As stated above, I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an hones,t unbiased review. (Right about now they may be regretting the "honest, unbiased" part of that arrangement.)
I've been dragging my feet about writing this review for some time. I didn't really like it and momma always said, "If you don't have anything good to say..." Yet, unfortunately for me I also promised the publisher that I would give an honest review in exchange for the book.
So, it comes down to momma going head-to-head verses the Tyndale publishing team. Cage match, live on pay-per-view!
But seriously, the premise is that the story is being written by a 10-year-old girl for a school project. And I guess, in that regard you'd call it a success. The rambling, disconnected thoughts, as well as grammatical and spelling mistakes all combine to give it the feel of an elementary school class assignment.
Of course there are two sides to that coin. The opposite being: I want to read a good quality book, not some kid's class assignment!!!
This 10yo writer's goal is to write a story about something that happened in her life. Intermingled with that she is also learning how to write, so we get little writing tips and suggestions sprinkled throughout.
As a homeschooling father I first I thought this could be used as a teaching tool, but as the story progressed I decided the teacher's methodology wasn't the way I would want to do teach it anyway. And, of course, I've already graduated from elementary school (somehow against all odds), so I have a hard time seeing how this information does anything but slow us down.
Plot:
Laura, the new girl in school, is fat. Really fat.
Even in the face of some pretty brutal bullying, she is able to remain sweet and maintain a great positive attitude.
Bullying is really what the book is about. It is really where the book shines. It doesn't glorify it, nor does it shame the bullies! Rather, it tells it like it is -- all the emotions, the pain and hurt, as well as the peer pressure aspect.
Best of all, it holds a message for the bullies themselves about how they can change.
It really is a great book on bullying!
I just... don't need a book on bulling. (I homeschool, remember?)
Conclusion:
This might be good if you need a book about bullying and the general meanness of kids, written in stumbling language that might make it easier for younger children to relate to.
If, instead, you're looking for a book to teach creative writing, I'd sooner recommend a more complete dedicated resource such as How to Write (And Sell) A Christian Novel by Gilbert Morris
Finally, if none of that applies and you just want a good story to read, well, you know what momma says...
Disclaimer: As stated above, I received this book from the publisher in exchange for an hones,t unbiased review. (Right about now they may be regretting the "honest, unbiased" part of that arrangement.)
December 13, 2018
I'll be upfront: I picked this up for the title. Didn't even read the summary. I've an unusual name, and I'm certainly anything but larger than life, so that combination made me giggle every time I saw it on the shelf.
For a book I read completely based on the title, I was really pleasantly surprised! This is an emotional book. You see bullying, family problems, children trying to come into their own and figure things out, forgiveness, apologies, rising above. You see some childhood cruelty, in all its viciousness, and the effects and consequences (positive and negative both) that our words and actions can have. I'd recommend it to be read more than once by students as they grow older. It's the sort of story that you'll get more out of each time you read it.
For the writing style, it's very conversational, written from a 4th grader's POV. So, expect some incorrect grammar, more colorful language, etc. I liked how she tied storytelling elements from her English class into the story that she's telling.
For a book I read completely based on the title, I was really pleasantly surprised! This is an emotional book. You see bullying, family problems, children trying to come into their own and figure things out, forgiveness, apologies, rising above. You see some childhood cruelty, in all its viciousness, and the effects and consequences (positive and negative both) that our words and actions can have. I'd recommend it to be read more than once by students as they grow older. It's the sort of story that you'll get more out of each time you read it.
For the writing style, it's very conversational, written from a 4th grader's POV. So, expect some incorrect grammar, more colorful language, etc. I liked how she tied storytelling elements from her English class into the story that she's telling.
July 20, 2019
Several family members read Dandi Daley Mackall’s Just Sayin’ recently and loved it. So when I spotted Larger-Than-Life Lara , I got a copy right away and read it aloud to my children over the course of a week. My husband got in on the book a couple chapters in and was as eager as our children to hear how the story unfolded.
The story centers on Lara, the title character, who is the object of intense bullying at her new school. Yet she forgives freely and treats her attackers with kindness and compassion. The story is told from the perspective of one of Lara’s classmates. With chapters such as Setting, Dialogue, Conflict, Suspense, and Cliff Hanger, readers learn about what makes a good story even as they’re reading one.
Mackall is such an imaginative storyteller; she has quickly become one of my new favorite authors. I’ve already ordered a third of the nearly 500 books to her credit.
The story centers on Lara, the title character, who is the object of intense bullying at her new school. Yet she forgives freely and treats her attackers with kindness and compassion. The story is told from the perspective of one of Lara’s classmates. With chapters such as Setting, Dialogue, Conflict, Suspense, and Cliff Hanger, readers learn about what makes a good story even as they’re reading one.
Mackall is such an imaginative storyteller; she has quickly become one of my new favorite authors. I’ve already ordered a third of the nearly 500 books to her credit.
May 26, 2017
There's one thing that I know is true. I knew it from life, and this book brought back a lot of feelings and memories: kids are mean.
Bonus one: As emotional as this book is (even though, pre-motherhood I never would have cried, but....) it gave me hope. It gave me an inspiration to do all that I can to raise my daughter to be kind and strong.
Bonus two: the chapter titles!!!! I love reading, and I loved English class. And I loved writing (even though my writing days are somewhat confined to documentation at work and book reviews right now) Oh, a child after my own heart, As heartbreaking as the book got, the chapter titles kept me going.
Con one: This book is so short! I guess it falls in line with the premise that a fifth grader is writing it, but there's so much more of Laney and Lara's world that I want to know and read about.
Con two: I wish the ending had been more like a fairy tale, but it's also important that it was realistic. So, I guess not really a con?
Overall, a great read. Thank you Tyndale publishers for letting me review this.
Bonus one: As emotional as this book is (even though, pre-motherhood I never would have cried, but....) it gave me hope. It gave me an inspiration to do all that I can to raise my daughter to be kind and strong.
Bonus two: the chapter titles!!!! I love reading, and I loved English class. And I loved writing (even though my writing days are somewhat confined to documentation at work and book reviews right now) Oh, a child after my own heart, As heartbreaking as the book got, the chapter titles kept me going.
Con one: This book is so short! I guess it falls in line with the premise that a fifth grader is writing it, but there's so much more of Laney and Lara's world that I want to know and read about.
Con two: I wish the ending had been more like a fairy tale, but it's also important that it was realistic. So, I guess not really a con?
Overall, a great read. Thank you Tyndale publishers for letting me review this.
April 21, 2022
Beautiful book for mid grades about an overweight student who arrives in a school where kids are made fun of and only the popular, rich, attractive kids are welcomed (isn't every school like that?). The author skillfully tells the story, not from the overweight student's point of view, but from that of a child changed by the new student's positive attitude. The storytelling is enhanced by extras like the character sharing the meanings of the different parts of a story -- description, anticipation, climax -- and then seeing it played out in the book.
The climax is devastating -- but handled so skillfully that it brought tears along with hope that maybe bullies can change.
This author never disappoints. Highly recommend for school libraries and could be used in discussion groups with kids.
The climax is devastating -- but handled so skillfully that it brought tears along with hope that maybe bullies can change.
This author never disappoints. Highly recommend for school libraries and could be used in discussion groups with kids.
November 3, 2018
The author presents a great lesson in bullying, as seen and told through the eyes of a 10 year old girl. The author hints at the many layers of hurts and emotional needs within the various characters, showing the underlying effects of home and family – or the lack there of – as a contributing factor of the bullying and of the impolite language that is spoken throughout the book. In fact, discerning parents will want to read along and discuss both the impolite language and the mean actions of the various children. I applaud Mackall for her very creative writing and for the way she magnificently portrays the victim, Lara. Lara’s response to the teasing and unfair actions of her peers and even the teachers is so touching. She is the hero. Kindness and forgiveness win.
December 24, 2017
Mackall, Dandi Daley Larger-Than-Life Lara 151 p. Penguin –
Laney’s fourth grade class is stunned the day that Lara, the fattest girl they have ever seen, walks into their classroom. This girl is so fat, that she needs a special desk. Lara’s parents have instilled her with a healthy sense of self-esteem, but she is hard pressed to keep her chin up against the unreasonable prejudice of her fellow students. This book will make you cry and it should be read to every child every single year.
EL, MS, HS – ESSENTIAL
Laney’s fourth grade class is stunned the day that Lara, the fattest girl they have ever seen, walks into their classroom. This girl is so fat, that she needs a special desk. Lara’s parents have instilled her with a healthy sense of self-esteem, but she is hard pressed to keep her chin up against the unreasonable prejudice of her fellow students. This book will make you cry and it should be read to every child every single year.
EL, MS, HS – ESSENTIAL
May 2, 2018
It's not often that I read a book that is "written" by a 10 year old. I say "written" because the main character is ten and the story is written as if she's the one writing it. If ever there was a book about bullying that should be in every classroom, I really think that this is the one. It shows just how cruel children (and adults) can be and while lessons were learned, there isn't always a happily ever after.
February 9, 2022
Two opinions on this book. One is that I'm not a huge fan of books that are written in first person for kids and use bad grammar. I get why it's done that way but I would hesitate to buy them, especially more than once. Second is that the book does have a great message and it stays with you. It doesn't have a tidy ending and that packs a punch. Some mistakes can't be undone. I don't think I'll ever forget what this book was about! So I've given it four stars for content.
March 27, 2018
Fourth grader Laney, who has a rough life at home, meets new student Lara, who is overweight and bullied by her classmates. The students learn a valuable lesson from Lara during the book. I thought this book was interesting, and a look into school bullies. My daughter enjoyed it, and passed it along to me.
July 13, 2018
This is a very simple, sweet, middle grade book about the repercussions of bullying. It doesn't go deep, but it goes deep enough. Told from the perspective of a fourth grade girl, this book has a lesson for all kids, that words and actions have consequences. Like I said, its it's a simple story, but its perfect for a young reader.
November 14, 2018
Miss Lori REALLY enjoyed this creative storytelling adventure. Bullying, dysfunctional home life, and an interesting way to tell her story, the main character is a good girl stuck in a difficult situation.
5th grade and up are the target audience for this book (middle school especially).
5th grade and up are the target audience for this book (middle school especially).
November 19, 2017
#writing #obesity #diversity
Good read along the lines of "Gooney Bird" in the sense that it elucidates the elements of story-telling embedded in the story.
Good read along the lines of "Gooney Bird" in the sense that it elucidates the elements of story-telling embedded in the story.
April 28, 2018
This book is great, except that she has to leave at the end and Laney never becomes good friends with her.
September 3, 2019
Did get boring a little bit throughout but then it would pick up, it's a decent book but it's just not my kind of book.
November 26, 2019
This book was exceptionally well written. A truly beautiful mid grade read with an extremely important message.
September 17, 2020
Beautiful message with a clever presentation.
"Lara Phelps... She saw stuff. And I was going to try to see stuff too. Everywhere I'd go for the rest of my life, she'd be there, larger than life."
"Lara Phelps... She saw stuff. And I was going to try to see stuff too. Everywhere I'd go for the rest of my life, she'd be there, larger than life."
April 8, 2023
We cringed our way through this as a 5th grade read aloud. Wonderful discussions around prejudice & bullying. Leaves me wondering why I still so often draw conclusions based on another’s appearance…
November 2, 2016
This book that should be read by all young kids! It that tackles a difficult topic in a beautiful way.
Laney Grafton is a ten-year-old writing a story about what happens when her class gets a new girl who isn’t like everyone else. When Lara shows up in class, it is obvious from looking at her that she will be the target of bullying. She is larger than anyone these fourth graders have ever seen. Instead of letting the bullying beat her down, Lara surprises everyone and smiles through it all. Several of the kids go above and beyond with how harsh and cruel they are. Throughout it all, Laney stays quiet since she is being left alone for once. With crafty titles about storytelling and an overall extraordinary tale about a girl that is able to transform an entire class, Larger-Than-Life-Lara shows us the best and worst in every single one of us.
Bullying is such a horrible aspect of growing up that unfortunately almost everyone has to deal with at some point. Larger-Than-Life Lara tackles this subject in a unique way. By telling the story from Laney’s point of view, we see how everyone is affected in many different ways. This is a book that I think should be in all schools and read and discussed together. Kids of all ages could get so much out of this book. The way that Lara reacted to the treatment of the other kids shows how she is Larger than Life in more ways than just here size. We could all learn from all of the characters in this book, either in how to act or how not to treat someone. At times, the writing style seems a little odd but since the narrator is a ten year old it worked out really well. The book is short, less than 200 pages, making it an easy read. I finished it in one day. I hate to see the need for books like this, but it is needed now more than ever. So many kids are bullied in one way or another and being over weight is probably one of the hardest to deal with. Mackall did an excellent job setting up this story in a way that will make an impact with readers while also not being too lengthy and losing younger readers. Overall this was an excellent read that I will be high recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The views and opinions expressed within are my own.
Laney Grafton is a ten-year-old writing a story about what happens when her class gets a new girl who isn’t like everyone else. When Lara shows up in class, it is obvious from looking at her that she will be the target of bullying. She is larger than anyone these fourth graders have ever seen. Instead of letting the bullying beat her down, Lara surprises everyone and smiles through it all. Several of the kids go above and beyond with how harsh and cruel they are. Throughout it all, Laney stays quiet since she is being left alone for once. With crafty titles about storytelling and an overall extraordinary tale about a girl that is able to transform an entire class, Larger-Than-Life-Lara shows us the best and worst in every single one of us.
Bullying is such a horrible aspect of growing up that unfortunately almost everyone has to deal with at some point. Larger-Than-Life Lara tackles this subject in a unique way. By telling the story from Laney’s point of view, we see how everyone is affected in many different ways. This is a book that I think should be in all schools and read and discussed together. Kids of all ages could get so much out of this book. The way that Lara reacted to the treatment of the other kids shows how she is Larger than Life in more ways than just here size. We could all learn from all of the characters in this book, either in how to act or how not to treat someone. At times, the writing style seems a little odd but since the narrator is a ten year old it worked out really well. The book is short, less than 200 pages, making it an easy read. I finished it in one day. I hate to see the need for books like this, but it is needed now more than ever. So many kids are bullied in one way or another and being over weight is probably one of the hardest to deal with. Mackall did an excellent job setting up this story in a way that will make an impact with readers while also not being too lengthy and losing younger readers. Overall this was an excellent read that I will be high recommend.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The views and opinions expressed within are my own.
December 4, 2016
In Larger-Than-Life Lara, Dandi Daley Mackall approaches a difficult subject, one that is a life lesson every child should be taught at a young age, with grace, care and a pinch of humor. A book that should be required reading in every school class room, Lara handles herself well in every situation—well, almost every one.
What’s even more cool about this book is it not only deals with the topic of bullying but it also teaches readers the different parts of telling a story as each chapter deals with one of these elements (Dialogue, Setting, Rising Action, Details, Cliff-Hangers, and Climax are all addressed).
Ten-year-old Laney Grafton is a tad relieved when the new girl enters her classroom because everyone’s mean words and teasing shifts away from her and onto Lara Phelps. But here’s the thing about Lara: she doesn’t react like she should. Nope. Instead, Lara accepts the bullying and returns each action with a kindness. And while the storyteller (Laney) doesn’t intervene, she does begin to change. As will every reader of this book.
As a reader, I felt Laney’s hardships as well as Lara’s as I was taken along for the ride through the eyes of a fourth-grade girl shares a story through her eyes. The author portrays this excellently through the writing of the story. I was there in that class room with Laney and as she shares this impactful time in her life all the while commenting on what’s she’s learned about telling a story. And the results are sometimes humorous, sometimes heart-breaking, but always memorable.
If you have young children who are being bullied or if you know young children you want to encourage to help a friend who is being bullied or if you want to share how one person can make a difference, then Large-Than-Life Lara is a way in which to do it impactfully.
****I receive complimentary books for review from publishers, publicists, and/or authors, including Netgalley. I am not required to write positive reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255.
November 5, 2016
Dandi Daley Mackall wrote some of my favorite book series growing up: Winnie the Horse Gentler and Horsefeathers, back in the day when stories about horses composed 80% of my reading. Seeing another book of hers pop up on the Tyndale Blog Network intrigued me, even if this book is technically a republication (Larger-Than-Life Lara was originally published 10 years ago, in 2006).
Larger-Than-Life Lara is a short, but wholesome, book. Laney is a wonderful protagonist, and the hints at her home life never reveal too much or hide too little. Her voice is funny and the crafting of the story is smart—as a teacher, I found myself reading and thinking, “This is a perfect book to read to help explain story elements.”
It’s also a perfect book to discuss with a younger audience. Lara’s actions, Laney’s feelings, and the entire attitudes and behaviors of the class, are rich for discussion. The story is poignant, sweet, and heartbreaking in turns, and it’s just as much about Laney as it is about Lara and her effect on the fourth-grade class.
My favorite aspect of the book, though, is that Larger-Than-Life Lara communicates so much of the Christian message without even mentioning God once. Lara’s actions are beautifully Christ-like, with her capacity to forgive, her willingness to take fault when she herself did nothing, and the transforming effect her actions have on her classmates. There’s so much there for young readers to think and talk about. Larger-Than-Life Lara was a joy to read, and it’s nice to see that even if the works I read by Mackall as a child have worn old over the years, there are still some of her works that delight me.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy from the publisher. No review, positive or otherwise, was required—all opinions are my own.
Larger-Than-Life Lara is a short, but wholesome, book. Laney is a wonderful protagonist, and the hints at her home life never reveal too much or hide too little. Her voice is funny and the crafting of the story is smart—as a teacher, I found myself reading and thinking, “This is a perfect book to read to help explain story elements.”
It’s also a perfect book to discuss with a younger audience. Lara’s actions, Laney’s feelings, and the entire attitudes and behaviors of the class, are rich for discussion. The story is poignant, sweet, and heartbreaking in turns, and it’s just as much about Laney as it is about Lara and her effect on the fourth-grade class.
My favorite aspect of the book, though, is that Larger-Than-Life Lara communicates so much of the Christian message without even mentioning God once. Lara’s actions are beautifully Christ-like, with her capacity to forgive, her willingness to take fault when she herself did nothing, and the transforming effect her actions have on her classmates. There’s so much there for young readers to think and talk about. Larger-Than-Life Lara was a joy to read, and it’s nice to see that even if the works I read by Mackall as a child have worn old over the years, there are still some of her works that delight me.
Disclaimer: I received a free copy from the publisher. No review, positive or otherwise, was required—all opinions are my own.
January 5, 2017
Larger-than-Life Lara by Dandi Daley Mackall is a book about bullying. Yes. That's it. Of course in every story, there's more to it than a simple word, but in this case, the main objective is that. It's written in the perspective of a 10 year old. Grammar and sentence structure may be questionable, but based on what the author is trying to achieve in authenticity of a 10 year old's narration, it's successful. Larger-Than-Life Lara is a good story. It's good despite all the minor qualms I have with it. It's good simply because it focused on one social issue (bullying) and was able to deliver the impact it has on kids and others. There are other issues from other characters that lurks in the background, but the author doesn't dive into it, but remain focus on Lara and bullying. True, we meet Laney, our narrator and does get to know a little more about her, but even Laney narrates and says this story is about Lara. There are some realistic elements in Larger-Than-Life Lara and definitely a great story to read with kids and discuss the ramifications of the actions in the book. Again, I would not dwell too much on grammar and writing, but focus on the theme at hand. It's profound, simple and worth a read, especially if parents would like a starting point to discuss this social epidemic.
This review first appeared on Just Commonly blog.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. This is my honest opinion.
For my review policy, please see my Disclosure page.
This review first appeared on Just Commonly blog.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. This is my honest opinion.
For my review policy, please see my Disclosure page.
September 10, 2010
Fourth-grader, Laney Grafton, tells her story using the writing techniques taught to her by her teacher, Mrs. Smith. Her story is full of characters, events, and lessons which serve to teach and ponder over. Laney, rather small for her age, and her family, are a rag-tag bunch of wild and free members ever since her mother left. Her brothers are mean and her father is practically non-existent and frequently drunk when around. She is teased by her classmates...that is until someone new comes to class who the bullies latch right on to. Lara Phelphs, is big... no not big, but obese. Every day she suffers through taunts and jeers.
When Mrs. Smith announces that the fourth graders will be putting on a play, everyone is forced to try out for parts. Everyone will have a hand in the play but whether it will be a character role in the play or behind the scenes, is dependent on their try-out. Even though everyone knows Lara had the best performance at try-outs, she does not get a part in the play.
Nonetheless, and even with constant badgering and teasing, Lara is upbeat and smiling. She ignores the hurtful words and antics of her classmates and helps everyone with their lines. But when most of the kids, led by head bully, Joey Gilbert, plan a humiliating and demeaning trick on Lara, her cheerfulness is tough to muster.
Larger-Than-Life Lara is the story of bullies and their victims. This story ends with the children seeing what their actions actually do and they try to make amends. Is it too little, too late? Possibly. A great story for contemplation, reflection, and discussion.
When Mrs. Smith announces that the fourth graders will be putting on a play, everyone is forced to try out for parts. Everyone will have a hand in the play but whether it will be a character role in the play or behind the scenes, is dependent on their try-out. Even though everyone knows Lara had the best performance at try-outs, she does not get a part in the play.
Nonetheless, and even with constant badgering and teasing, Lara is upbeat and smiling. She ignores the hurtful words and antics of her classmates and helps everyone with their lines. But when most of the kids, led by head bully, Joey Gilbert, plan a humiliating and demeaning trick on Lara, her cheerfulness is tough to muster.
Larger-Than-Life Lara is the story of bullies and their victims. This story ends with the children seeing what their actions actually do and they try to make amends. Is it too little, too late? Possibly. A great story for contemplation, reflection, and discussion.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 83 reviews