It seems appropriate to finish this book a day after Madoff was sentenced to 150 years. The parallels to today's economic crash and Madoff are striking. A charismatic personality, connections with those in power, "too big to fail syndrome," a gullible and avaricious public coupled with an adoring media had people rushing to give Charles Ponzi their money. He was raking it in so fast that he reached $1 million per week with the possibility of $1 million per day not impossible.And this at a time when the average annual wage was $2,000. He promised returns of 50% in 45 days. Of course, those who cashed in early, willing to take a terrific return but not willing to spin the wheel more than once, did well. Part of the secret was the hint of secrecy, exclusivity, and his charming personality.
Ponzi was an Italian immigrant of financially comfortable origins who landed in New York. He discovered that the streets were covered in an inch of mud rather than paved with the gold he had been promised. He had never worked a day in his life, but over the next four years managed to work at a number of humble jobs finally landing one as a bank teller in Canada. He soon became involved in a scheme at the bank and for his efforts was sentenced to prison in Canada. After his release, he figure it would be wise to return to the U.S. but ever the schemers he became involved with some other Italians and they were arrested at the border, he for suspicion of assisting illegal immigrants. He pled guilty, believing he would get a light sentence but was stunned to get a two-year sentence in a federal penitentiary in Atlanta. (Why they didn't ship him back to Canada seems bizarre.) Anyway, the Atlanta federal prison was pretty cushy, it having been ordered by the feds, I suppose, for the inevitable time, when the legislators might have to go to prison and a gilded cage was better than just any cage. He made friends with Lupo, an Italian mafia gangster, but the warden also noted that Ponzi was always scheming and designing financial intrigues. Little did he know. So all the signs were there.
The irony is that had Ponzi not been such a kind-hearted soul the scheme that bears his name might never have happened. Following his release from prison, he was determined to make some money legitimately. He held down several minor jobs but had a great idea for supplying power to small coal mines (coal was booming in Alabama at the time.) One of his jobs was as a nurse in a clinic. Another female nurse had been badly burned in a fire and the doctor happened to mention to Ponzi one day how difficult it was for him to find skin donors without which she might die. Ponzi was incensed and on the spot offered to be a donor immediately. The first donation was 75 sq. inches, the second determined to be needed a little later was another 50 sq. inches. He was hospitalized in pain and complications for several months. The girl lived but by the time he was released, his idea for supplying power to the mines had been co opted by others and he was forced to seek other menial employment, once as a librarian at a small college where he was eventually fired for his honesty in revealing the dishonesty of a faculty member -- who happened to be a friend of the college president.
After marrying and moving back to Boston, following numerous attempts at get-rich-quick schemes, Ponzi hit upon one that perhaps only he, with his interest in currency manipulation, collecting stamps, and his interest in the Post Office, could have worked out. Before WW I the International Postal Treaty permitted sending postal coupons for use on return mail envelopes. The idea was that $1 in postal coupons would buy the equivalent in, say, French stamps to send mail back from a foreign country. After WW I there were vast differences in currency values. 5 cents in the US would buy a five cent stamp, but in Italy it would buy the equivalent of 10 cents in stamps. Pozi's idea was to purchase huge quantities of international postal coupons in countries with devalued currency and exchange them in the US. In the the example above the immediate profit would be 100%. He soon realized that enormous quantities of these coupons would be needed ($50 would buy a stack of Italian coupons over 73 feet high) and that the Post Office would not redeem the coupons for cash, only stamps. In the meantime, money was rolling in to fund his scheme which purported, in writing, to guarantee 50% profits in 90 days. His legitimate idea soon foundered on logistical problems and it shifted to what we now call the classic Ponzi scheme where early investors are paid off with money from later investors.
The irony of it is -- and this is perhaps true of Madoff also -- that Ponzi really wanted nothing more than to be a legitimate businessman. It had hit upon a scheme that was technically legal and would work in very small amounts, but never at the scale it ballooned into.
A fascinating account of a time with striking similarities to today and a morality tale: "if we don't learn our history, we're doomed to repeat it".