When we last saw Remy and Michael at the end of Poz, the book that precedes All That Is Solid Melts into Air, Remy was graduating from high school in California while Michael had one more year to go. Remy made mistakes, one of which left him HIV-positive. He credits Michael with saving his life by standing by him when Remy wouldn’t tell anyone about his condition. Both of them are rowers, with plans for the future that includes rowing, college and each other. Remy ends Poz by saying, “I knew one thing: He would always be my friend.”
As we begin another year in the lives of Remy and Michael, Remy and Michael have grown closer and are lovers. Remy is poz (HIV-positive), but with medication and a healthy lifestyle, his viral load is undetectable. Remy is a subby bottom and Michael is a toppy dominant, which they discovered together last year. They are not in the BDSM lifestyle but are sexually in a D/s relationship. They plan on going to college on the East Coast, but Remy’s parents put the halt to those plans at least temporarily by insisting that Remy attend college near home for at least his first year.
This is a story of change and growth in people, no matter how old they are. Remy’s parents will either drive Remy away or they will change their relationship with him. Remy’s twin brother is also caught up in the changes that engulf the family. Remy and his coaches discover a talent for rowing that eclipses anything he has done before or even dreamed of. As for Michael, who is still in high school, the question becomes whether there is room for him in Remy’s life and also whether his parents and Remy’s parents will permit the boys to continue down the path they have chosen. With the maturity and concentration Remy displays as an athlete, it’s sometimes difficult to remember he’s only 19 years old, still a kid in many ways, but trying so hard to make his own life choices, and Michael is a year younger.
As I read this book I sometimes loved Remy and Michael, and sometimes I was so angry at one or the other of them. The story is told from Remy’s POV, so Michael’s thoughts and actions are filtered through Remy’s eyes and heart. It leaves the reader having to decide which boy is right when they disagree and whether what happens is justified. Will they remain lovers or even the friends that Remy swore they would always be? This is a real roller-coaster ride that will leave you breathless and perhaps wishing some things turned out differently. The angst gets turned up to high and never quite goes back down to sweetness and light. As Remy learned, to his cost, a year ago, you can’t turn back the clock and get a do-over in life. All you can do is decide what to do going forward. I highly recommend this book, but bring tissues. Lots of them. Oh, and if you are not familiar with rowing terminology, keep Google open.