I can't remember the last time I was this conflicted about rating a book. In this case, the content wasn't the primary issue but rather the main character of the series. I ended up opting for three stars when, under other circumstances, I might have been more inclined to tip in favor of four. Let me explain...
What I liked about British Manor Murder:
Well-paced - Considering I read the book in about two-and-a-half days, the story itself was clearly engaging and kept me pushing forward. I never had a chance to get bored or feel bogged down.
Engaging mystery - A bit predictable and not that much of a challenge to unravel, but I did enjoy the way it all unfolded.
What I didn't care for:
Lucy - Here is one of my key issues with this entire series, especially the deeper we get into it. Lucy is a Debbie Downer. She's negative and whiny and a general drag. Everything with Lucy is "not quite what she expected" and never in a good way. It really makes me wonder if the author doesn't share some of these personality traits as well. Maybe that isn't fair of me, but constantly being pessimistic is unappealing to me, and I wonder if the author sees Lucy's life through her own similar lens. It isn't a personality trait I have, and I think it would be difficult for me to write in a way that I don't naturally think. Yes, I understand that reality offers challenges, but constantly complaining and moaning about how unfair life is...eh, turnoff.
Oh, look, politicized again! - My ongoing beef with this series, really. It takes on hot-button topics in multiples, and expresses them with strong myopic opinions. This time around: mental health, drug use, and social class. Yes, these are important issues to consider, but cramming all three into less than 300 pages was overbearing, and the judgmental tone taken didn't help matters. Again, it makes me wonder if the author isn't using her novels as a platform for her own personal opinions. It's almost like reading a Facebook page...and makes me glad Ms. Meier isn't in my feed.
Tried too hard to be relevant - In addition to loading up on the political agenda, the ridiculous number of pop culture references felt forced and uncomfortable.
So why do I continue with these books when so much often grates on my nerves? Same as my reviews of earlier works: I feel committed to seeing this series through to the end. (Please, oh please, let it end soon...I don't know how much more I can take.) Thankfully, at least I occasionally get one, such as this, where the content amuses, such as it is.