What a debut Hillary Monahan had. MARY: The Summoning, released in 2014, was one of the best horror novels I've read, a labyrinth of claustrophobic action scenes and profound metaphors relayed via the story of a notorious American haint who was more frightening in Ms. Monahan's novel than in any other version I've encountered. This Mary Worth is a grotesque, black-toothed ghoul who fixates on individual victims for years without allowing a day's respite. Shauna learned that in the first novel, after her friend Jess persuaded her and two other teen girls to perform a summoning in the bathroom mirror to get a glimpse of Bloody Mary in all her feral "glory." Jess's carefully researched methods of confining Mary to the mirror failed, and the vile harpy began stalking Shauna, showing up not only in mirrors, but any vaguely shiny surface. On the verge of a nervous breakdown but knowing her mother wouldn't believe her claims about Mary, Shauna turned to Cody Jackson for help, a mid-thirties spinster whom Mary hounded for years...until turning her attention to Shauna. A fierce, paranoid loner, Cody had advice to keep Shauna alive for a while, but it was Jess who ultimately delivered Shauna from the curse. Attempting another summoning in hopes of foisting Mary off on another girl, Jess unwittingly became the ghost's new target. Shauna wishes she could forget about Jess; the popular, assertive teen is getting what she deserves after dragging Bloody Mary into their lives in the first place, but can Shauna actually leave Jess to a long, torturous death at Mary's filthy hands?
Jess has advantages Shauna did not during her own bout with Mary. Jess is a descendant of the Worth lineage, and can consult her elderly aunt Dell for ways to keep Mary at bay until they configure a permanent solution. Dell refers Jess, Shauna, and their friend Kitty to the Hawthorne family in the town of Solomon's Folly. Elizabeth Hawthorne, one of Mary's tormenters during her natural life, was connected in some way to the mysterious circumstances of Mary's 1864 death, presumably at the hands of Pastor Philip Starkcrowe. If Jess can piece together the historical account, she may discover a way to disable Mary's supernatural reign of terror once and for all. Shauna and Kitty are loath to incur Mary's interest by spending time near Jess, but their safeguard is taken away one night when Jess makes a critical error, allowing Mary to escape the mirror and remain in the real world. The putrid monster is no longer restricted to shiny surfaces in her pursuit of Jess and the others.
Dell and Cody are crucial assets as Mary closes in on her coterie of victims. Anyone hunted by Mary knows the horror of it, but Dell and Cody spent enough years as helpless prey, and will risk death or disfigurement to stop the cycle. Conversations with Sheriff Hawthorne about his family's checkered past unearth relevant information surrounding Mary's death and burial. If they can find her desiccated body and incinerate it, maybe Bloody Mary's days of causing torment will end. Mary isn't ignorant about the plan; she's ready to fight with every ounce of insanity in her body, and as Shauna and her companions key in on the final solution to the mystery, Mary unleashes her most stomach-turning assault yet on one member of their group. The brutality wrought by Bloody Mary on her victims inside and out will never fade, but can they deliver a Mary-free future for every young girl from now on?
MARY: The Summoning was a disciplined, painfully evocative thriller loaded with allegorical import. MARY: Unleashed has moments of deeply unsettling horror, but isn't as effective. Mary shows up less, and as a result this book isn't as claustrophobic as the first. We despise Mary in that book, craving to see her hurt as badly as she harms Shauna and the other girls; the desperation of Shauna's situation feels raw and uncomfortably personal to the reader. Perhaps we hate Mary in this book too, but only because of the graphic violence she inflicts on her final victim. If you've read the book, you know what I speak of. MARY: Unleashed is less immediate and intuitive than MARY: The Summoning; it features more research and abstract theorizing than ingenious new venues for Mary's attacks, but I'd probably rate it two and a half stars. I wish there were a stronger conclusion after that barnburner of a first novel, but the duology is worth reading to its end.