Because I don’t naturally gravitate to romance novels, and because I am charged with being familiar with a variety of genres, I thought it would be a good exercise to volunteer as a judge for the Booksellers Best Awards from the Romance Writers of America. My first assignment was "Taming the Texan".
Based on the ridiculous sub-title (could she be the one to tame him?) and cheesy picture, I expected…I don’t know what I expected. But it wasn’t as bad as whatever I had anticipated. Tess has fled from a violent and unhappy past to a Texas ranch, and has inherited half of the ranch from the old guy who insisted she marry him just before passing away. Clint, the bitter, hateful, and naturally estranged son arrives to buy out Tess’s half of the ranch in order to divide it up to sell. She refuses to sell, and I’m sure you can guess the rest.
Sands applies contemporary time frames to an historical setting, which I found distracting. Could Tess really have the buggy hitched up, ride to town, visit her friend and be back at the ranch before lunchtime? In 1883, without telephone, e-mail or social networking sites, could Tess really have engineered a gathering of 30 women on a Wednesday afternoon? Maybe, but I doubt they would have called themselves a “sisterhood”. Or would they? I don’t know, but for me it didn’t seem to fit.
Despite these incongruities I was entertained and the typical romance reader will be satisfied, despite the far-fetched twist at the end.