Tanith's grandmother tells her a mysterious story that has haunted her family for generations. It is a story without an end, a riddle that she must solve, and to do so she must enter the dangerous world of the city, where lone children like her live on the edge, cast out by society.
I didn’t have any expectations when I started this book, didn’t really know what it was about. I enjoyed it, it has a spin on the Pied Piper story, set in a dystopian world filled with horrors. This is the third book almost back to back of a retelling, which wasn’t on purpose, but it was not bad. The writing was good, the story interesting, though it felt a bit rushed and unfinished. I would have liked more meat to the story, some background on how the world was the way it was, how Tanith became so strong despite or in spite of her disabilities and what was story was. Overall an enjoyable book.
A very, very good book. It took a little while for me to get into it but once I did I was hooked. I constantly felt sorry for Tanith and I loved Crow and some of the things mentioned in this book were quite horrifying. But all in all a good book. I probably would have given it 5 stars had it not been for the ending; I think there definitely could have been more action and drama, but it seemed quite... unfinished. And the romance in the book was quite sweet until Asta was brought in as a sudden third wheel.
I definitely think a sequel could be made of this book, but very much worth a read.
This has always stuck out for me as one of the most amazing books I read as a child/teenager.
2025 reread was full of nostalgia and was amazing to get an adult perspective on this book. Crow was 100% my first mortally grey MMC and has set the foundations for all the adult versions I now read.
Cover great topics, great pacing and sticks with you. Would recommend to all.
I loved this book. I couldnt stop thinking abou it once i finished it. i was disapointed with the ending though, it definatly could have had a better one, it would be nice if she wrote a sequal.
First thing first, I LOVED THE COVER. I think it was the main reason why I picked it up.
What I like most about the book is Crow's character: he wasn't strong, tough and smart like the usual male characters but rather a very typical teenager boy who can be anxious, afraid and unwise.
Surprisingly, a very quick read. Yes, I consider this quick!