NOTE: I'm going to save myself some time and trouble by doing this one review for all three books in this trilogy. Yes, I am lazy.
That said. . .
The Sign of Seven Trilogy wants so, so, desperately badly to be Stephen King's IT. All the elements are there:
1. ancient evil rises to terrify a town every so often (every 7 years in Sign of Seven trilogy; every 20-30 in IT),
2. group of friends that battled said evil in their youth must reunite to combat the evil again (7 friends in IT; 3 guys in SST that are joined this time by 3 women),
3. a little romance (the one girl in the group hooks up with one of the guys in IT; each of the 3 guys in SST hooks up with one of the 3 women. . .okay, a LOT of romance in that one),
4. paranormal abilities and occurences around the main characters, small clashes with ancient evil lead up to big dramatic final battle (cosmos-spanning battle in IT; for SST, ummmmm. . .not so much), and
5. last but not least, a crappy TV miniseries based on the book (ABC made one for IT in 1987 starring John Ritter, Richard Lewis, and Harry Anderson; there has not been one announced yet for SST but given the Lifetime Network's love of Nora Roberts, it's probably coming).
Basically, again, SST wants to be IT. That was the first thing that came to mind as I was reading the first book, as soon as I got a sense of what's going on.
And it falls so tragically, disappointingly, heart-breakingly short.
I'm not going to compare the trilogy to IT; it's obviously going to come off all the worse for the comparison. But it doesn't do so hot standing on its own, either.
The demonic villain, referred to as Twisse, never seems to say exactly why he wants to destroy the town so badly. If it's just simple vengeance against the ancestors of the people that defeated it centuries ago, really, why not just kill them and go? Why get locked into this stupid cycle? I get that it wants vengeance and all, and that these ancestors hold perhaps the only power on earth capable of killing it, but really, if this one place on the entire planet has exactly what's needed to kill you, wouldn't you stay away from it? Or at least not go giving people a reason to come kill you?
The heroes and heroines are initially very distinct in their personalities, but as the series progresses, they start blurring together so that, towards the end, I found myself having to check again and again to see who's saying what.
The small-town setting is a charming one, and it works well for the story. There is a lot of love and the characters are pretty well developed, at least until the end, in the story, though there are times when the supporting characters are a little more interesting than the heroes. The sex scenes are pretty good, though a couple feel a bit forced and awkward.
All that said, the series is pretty good. . .right up until the end, when it just all falls apart. It falls apart so badly that I subtracted a star and half for the ending alone.
After all the buildup, all the struggle, all the conflict and pain and tears getting to that final battle. . .it's over in less than ten pages, with a very short epilogue. The end was more of a messy amorphic blob than Twisse turned out to be, in the end. Speaking as someone that loves startegy and tactics and fighting games, the final battle is so nonsensical and disjointed that, given the solidity of the structure and writing to that point, I wondered if it had been ghostwritten. It felt very rushed, pushed too far too fast, and it definitely suffered for the impatience. On top of that, one minor line from one of the earlier books is all that saved the climactic ending from being a complete deus ex machina, making it more "deus ex extremely small and unimportant detail."
And in the end, SST still tries to be IT. Gage's journey into a seemingly endless void, Cal's father's view of the destruction raining down on their small town while the battle is being fought elsewhere, the defeat of the beast by both literal and metaphysical destruction of its heart, the reflections upon and glimpses of the damage the beast had done in previous rampages through the town. . .all these things are parallels from IT, and paralleled so much that I more-than-half-expected a Turtle of enormous girth to show up (though, perhaps to avoid copyright issues, it would have been called "a plus-size tortoise").
Stephen King, check your wallet, mate. I think you've been nicked.
What amazes me the most here is, that with such similar setups, King still told the better story 20+ years ago. IT is not a short read; in fact, it's longer than all three books in the SST trilogy put together. But if you're not a die-hard La Nora fan, or a sucker for a semi-action-packed romance, go read IT instead.
This trilogy comprises the first Nora Roberts work I've ever read. I'll give her a try again, because there are enough good things about the characters and story here that the trilogy held on to one star despite its own ending, but I'll also be trying in hopes that whatever I read next from her will be a bit more original and less blatantly derivative.