When evaluating YA literature, I usually look for titles that bring a little something different to the genre or do something unique, as to me the “YA coming of age story” trope is often re-hashed a thousand-and-one times over again, just swapping out character names and locations. Unfortunately, in the case of “Aim”, I didn’t really feel as if the book added anything fresh, exciting, or intriguing into the mix.
For a basic plot summary, “Aim” tells the story of 14-year old Junior Bledsoe, who is living in North Carolina at the outset of America’s involvement in World War I (1941-1942). Junior’s father, Axel, is killed in an alcohol-infused situation, and Junior must come to terms with what that means for his future. Will he stay in school like his mother wants, join the Army like his cantankerous grandfather pesters him to do, or get a job at the local mill and try to provide for the family even better than his father ever could? His penchant for fixing things and helping others goes a long way for him, but he also owns a troublesome streak that seems to bite him at the least opportune moments.
The main reason I didn’t enjoy “Aim” as much as I would have liked is because it seems to be chock full of all the standard YA tropes, such as: patriotism, importance of schooling, fatherly advice, family history, budding romance, and same-age friendship. Basically, everything you would expect from the book from looking at the cover and reading the back matter is exactly what you are going to get. That isn’t a bad thing, necessarily, but in order to take on such a large workload there has to be an equally large payoff in the end…something I didn’t experience whatsoever. In short, I felt like all the elements present throughout the novel didn’t mesh together in the end to contribute to Junior’s character growth & decisions (or if they did, it was in the most simplistic way possible). I would have preferred it, I think, if the story would have focused on one of those ideas and made it the central theme all the way through.
I wonder, though, if not having read “Blue” or “Comfort” (Hostetter’s previous two books that take place in the same “universe”) in some fashion hinders my enjoyment of “Aim” (which is actually a prequel for those two). I know that the appeal of prequels is often the return to a certain setting or set of characters, and as a “stand-alone reader” I’m completely missing that element.
Overall, though, I just didn’t enjoy “Aim” quite as much as some other recent YA historical fiction that I have read. I think that the book will do fine with the youngest of the YA crowd, but for those looking for something a bit meatier that gives them more to think about beyond the rote circumstances inherent in the novel, it may not fit the bill.