What do you think?
Rate this book
Books of Dalthia #4
Painting Rain
How do you heal your heart after tragedy leaves you broken? When the person you loved didn’t deserve it and they can’t earn your forgiveness because they’re already dead? How do you move on, and heal, and love?
If you’re Princess Lorraina, you paint.
A year ago Lorraina watched Tobias die, and she still doesn't know how she's supposed to heal—or forgive. How can she when she’s still running away? In an attempt to reinvent herself, she steps outside her comfortable life as princess and seeks the tutelage of a master painter—a man who is not at all impressed by her pedigree, and demands not just talent, but emotional honesty.
Struggling to learn what’s being taught, she finds herself drawn to someone who not only knows her secrets, but who she once considered far below her notice. Now she is compelled to seek him out despite knowing their relationship would be forbidden if discovered. Staying away from him doesn’t seem possible when discovering him may be the key to healing her heart and rediscovering herself.
If you’re Princess Lorraina, you paint.
A year ago Lorraina watched Tobias die, and she still doesn't know how she's supposed to heal—or forgive. How can she when she’s still running away? In an attempt to reinvent herself, she steps outside her comfortable life as princess and seeks the tutelage of a master painter—a man who is not at all impressed by her pedigree, and demands not just talent, but emotional honesty.
Struggling to learn what’s being taught, she finds herself drawn to someone who not only knows her secrets, but who she once considered far below her notice. Now she is compelled to seek him out despite knowing their relationship would be forbidden if discovered. Staying away from him doesn’t seem possible when discovering him may be the key to healing her heart and rediscovering herself.
217 pages, Paperback
Published February 20, 2016
43 people are currently reading
763 people want to read
About the author
Annette K. Larsen
23 books534 followersI love words. I always have. In songs, in poems, in books, in movies—words move me. In my younger years, I dabbled in writing as a therapy and an escape, but I never expected it to become more than that. While deep in the depths of mommying several small children, I took seven years to write my first book, Just Ella. During that time, I taught myself how to write a novel through a whole lot of trial and error. Not the most time-efficient method, but it gave me an education I wouldn’t have received from a class or a how-to book. Something about the struggle of writing without a formula or rules worked for me. I wrote for me. I wrote from my heart space, and I think that’s the reason that Just Ella has found room in so many of my readers’ heart spaces.
I write clean romance because I love it. I love the discovery of new love. I love the relationship building that’s done with looks, words, brushing fingers, and tentative kisses. Jane Eyre is the hero of my youth and taught me that being true to yourself and clinging to your convictions will be hard, but it will bring you more genuine happiness than giving up on yourself ever can.
I am an extraordinarily happy wife, and a mother of five kids. I’ve lived in Utah, Arizona, Missouri, and Virginia, but my heart is now firmly ensconced in Idaho where we’ve built a home and a community.
I love chocolate, waterfalls, pretty teacups, the sight and sound of ocean waves, and most especially my husband and my five littles. I love books that leave me with a sigh of contentment, and I aspire to write stories that do the same for my readers.
Find me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/annetteklar...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/authoraklarsen
Follow me on twitter: @AnnetteKLarsen
Contact Me: http://www.annetteklarsen.com/contact...
I write clean romance because I love it. I love the discovery of new love. I love the relationship building that’s done with looks, words, brushing fingers, and tentative kisses. Jane Eyre is the hero of my youth and taught me that being true to yourself and clinging to your convictions will be hard, but it will bring you more genuine happiness than giving up on yourself ever can.
I am an extraordinarily happy wife, and a mother of five kids. I’ve lived in Utah, Arizona, Missouri, and Virginia, but my heart is now firmly ensconced in Idaho where we’ve built a home and a community.
I love chocolate, waterfalls, pretty teacups, the sight and sound of ocean waves, and most especially my husband and my five littles. I love books that leave me with a sigh of contentment, and I aspire to write stories that do the same for my readers.
Find me on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/annetteklar...
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/authoraklarsen
Follow me on twitter: @AnnetteKLarsen
Contact Me: http://www.annetteklarsen.com/contact...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 130 reviews
August 13, 2025
3 stars ⭐️ Clean Fiction - YA Fantasy (Non-magical / Historical setting)
Trigger Warning: main character was in a toxic relationship and the effects of it are mentioned and shown often.
Welp, another book in this series has kept me up way to late. I really ought to know better by now.
In the first book of this series, Lorraina is a piece of work. But in the second book, we see a different side of her and a tragedy that strikes her as well. Now in this fourth book, we finally get her story.
And bless her. She’s been through it and has scars to show for it. In the prior book, we see her sister Marilee who has been through domestic abuse, but I think many readers would say that Raina was also in a very toxic relationship with a man. That relationship and the man have done a number on Raina, her self-worth, and how she views—and distances herself from—others. I was pretty amazed at the layers the author was able to capture with Raina and her emotions. It was heartbreaking to see how he influenced her and continues to even from the grave, but it added a depth and interesting dynamic to the book.
(Side note: I’d like to file a petition for this series to be renamed Angst of Dalthia rather than Books of Dalthia. If you read any of the books in this series, start bracing for angst impact about 65% in because it’s coming and it will be a doozy. 😅)
All of the art details like making the canvas or what they get their pigmentations from was actually really interesting.
I almost want to reread this book because I was pouting for the entire beginning because of the hinted love triangle. I want a refund for the first third, thankyouverymuch. I had my pompoms out for one guy and narrowed my eyes whenever the other one appeared. I’m very glad with how it went by the end in this regard and I was proud of Raina realizing she needed to be able to stand for herself and by herself without being dependent on someone else for her happiness. I’m not usually a fan of the whole “main character has to find herself” trope in books or movies because I don’t believe in that as a Christian, but it thankfully wasn’t a beating over the head about Raina having to do that, just her having to grow for her own sake and not for the sakes of others.
I will say that this one was probably the kissy-est (kissiest? most kissy) of the series so far. The forced proximity trope definitely didn’t come to play here and they were kissing a bit more than I cared to read about. 😅 I debated my rating because of it, actually, and ended up dropping it a star because of a very intimate posing session that the two of them do together which was too much for me.
I was a little surprised when The End popped up. I was expecting it to go longer and I’m bummed it didn’t. I wanted reactions from her family and to see the sisters all together as I don’t know if that will happen with the final book of this series being Ella’s sister-in-law’s story.
Main Content-
(spoilers for Book #2 of this series in this review)
A teacher has a unique teaching method that makes Raina ask another if the man sees himself as “some sort of hateful god” due to his control and influence (the other person says the teacher is not and just is not patient); A teasing comment about speaking to someone like a spirit in the shadows.
A mention of a man putting his wife through hell (Book #3); A mention of a artistic education turning someone into a heathen.
No major language, instead minor phrases like ‘saints above’/saints, and ‘cares a fig’ are said; Some eye rolling.
Remembering the death of a lover who was killed & grief about it all (recalled on-page and mentioned again a few times, up to a handful of sentences).
Mentions of miscarriages and the mother feeling pain and grief during one.
Mentions of a death, a body, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of kidnappings, attacks, someone being shot with an arrow and killed (up to a few sentences); Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of Marilee (Book 3) and her manipulative husband (and her having to rebuild herself after his death); A few mentions of gambling & drinking; A couple mentions of animal glue being used; A mention of burnt bones being used for black paint.
Raina was in a pretty toxic relationship with a guy and there’s many mentions of the number he did on her (such as his volatile temper, how he had the power to charm and also hurt her with his words, his mocking and cruelty and how he would bring out that side of Raina as well (after realizing this after his death, she tries to change herself to be kinder than she’s been to others as she didn’t want to inflict the kind of cruelty that became second nature for her), his twisted love for her, prior to meeting him Raina didn’t think anyone could love her, she comments about loving the man he could have been, she doesn’t feel like she’ll ever be able to escape the darkness from that time of her life, Raina also has his thoughts and words running through her head to the point she doesn’t know if it’s him or her thinking them, &her feeling unwanted and alone, thinking she will never be perfect).
6 hand/palm/fingers kisses,
4 head/forehead kisses,
3 cheek kisses,
2 almost kisses (lasting 1-4 sentences),
9 kisses lasting a sentence,
1 unwanted kiss that lasts a couple of sentences,
3 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
3 kisses lasting a few sentences,
2 kisses lasting 5-8+ of sentences,
Remembering kisses & wanting to kiss (up to a few sentences).
Lots of touches, embraces, hand holding, nearness, warmth, shivers, & noticing (up to a handful of sentences); Some flirting, blushes, & winks; One man comes to Raina’s door at night (with “noble intentions”, but they do share a kiss).
Raina also recalls her reactions and blushes to the toxic guy when they would be near each other, touch, and kiss (up to a few sentences); *Spoiler* .
Raina and the love interest are posed by another painter to be like lovers in a few different poses (very intimate and causes a lot of feelings for Raina, being so near him).
Mentions of kisses & kissing (up to a couple sentences); Mentions of a man often trying to touch Raina when teaching her; Mentions of loving someone so much you’ll change for the person for better & those saying they will, but never do; Mentions of flirting & a man liking to spend time with women; Mentions of poses of models for painters/sculptors that are intimate (such as being draped in only fabric and others asked to press against one another in the pose of lovers); A few mentions of trysts and clandestine meetings between lovers; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of married couples kissing; A couple mentions of philanderers; A mention of a man making advances on Raina with an unwanted kiss; A mention of a man looking delectable in a certain outfit.
Trigger Warning: main character was in a toxic relationship and the effects of it are mentioned and shown often.
Welp, another book in this series has kept me up way to late. I really ought to know better by now.
In the first book of this series, Lorraina is a piece of work. But in the second book, we see a different side of her and a tragedy that strikes her as well. Now in this fourth book, we finally get her story.
And bless her. She’s been through it and has scars to show for it. In the prior book, we see her sister Marilee who has been through domestic abuse, but I think many readers would say that Raina was also in a very toxic relationship with a man. That relationship and the man have done a number on Raina, her self-worth, and how she views—and distances herself from—others. I was pretty amazed at the layers the author was able to capture with Raina and her emotions. It was heartbreaking to see how he influenced her and continues to even from the grave, but it added a depth and interesting dynamic to the book.
(Side note: I’d like to file a petition for this series to be renamed Angst of Dalthia rather than Books of Dalthia. If you read any of the books in this series, start bracing for angst impact about 65% in because it’s coming and it will be a doozy. 😅)
All of the art details like making the canvas or what they get their pigmentations from was actually really interesting.
I almost want to reread this book because I was pouting for the entire beginning because of the hinted love triangle. I want a refund for the first third, thankyouverymuch. I had my pompoms out for one guy and narrowed my eyes whenever the other one appeared. I’m very glad with how it went by the end in this regard and I was proud of Raina realizing she needed to be able to stand for herself and by herself without being dependent on someone else for her happiness. I’m not usually a fan of the whole “main character has to find herself” trope in books or movies because I don’t believe in that as a Christian, but it thankfully wasn’t a beating over the head about Raina having to do that, just her having to grow for her own sake and not for the sakes of others.
I will say that this one was probably the kissy-est (kissiest? most kissy) of the series so far. The forced proximity trope definitely didn’t come to play here and they were kissing a bit more than I cared to read about. 😅 I debated my rating because of it, actually, and ended up dropping it a star because of a very intimate posing session that the two of them do together which was too much for me.
I was a little surprised when The End popped up. I was expecting it to go longer and I’m bummed it didn’t. I wanted reactions from her family and to see the sisters all together as I don’t know if that will happen with the final book of this series being Ella’s sister-in-law’s story.
Main Content-
(spoilers for Book #2 of this series in this review)
A teacher has a unique teaching method that makes Raina ask another if the man sees himself as “some sort of hateful god” due to his control and influence (the other person says the teacher is not and just is not patient); A teasing comment about speaking to someone like a spirit in the shadows.
A mention of a man putting his wife through hell (Book #3); A mention of a artistic education turning someone into a heathen.
No major language, instead minor phrases like ‘saints above’/saints, and ‘cares a fig’ are said; Some eye rolling.
Remembering the death of a lover who was killed & grief about it all (recalled on-page and mentioned again a few times, up to a handful of sentences).
Mentions of miscarriages and the mother feeling pain and grief during one.
Mentions of a death, a body, & blood/bleeding; Mentions of kidnappings, attacks, someone being shot with an arrow and killed (up to a few sentences); Mentions of lies, lying, & liars; Mentions of jealousy; A few mentions of Marilee (Book 3) and her manipulative husband (and her having to rebuild herself after his death); A few mentions of gambling & drinking; A couple mentions of animal glue being used; A mention of burnt bones being used for black paint.
Raina was in a pretty toxic relationship with a guy and there’s many mentions of the number he did on her (such as his volatile temper, how he had the power to charm and also hurt her with his words, his mocking and cruelty and how he would bring out that side of Raina as well (after realizing this after his death, she tries to change herself to be kinder than she’s been to others as she didn’t want to inflict the kind of cruelty that became second nature for her), his twisted love for her, prior to meeting him Raina didn’t think anyone could love her, she comments about loving the man he could have been, she doesn’t feel like she’ll ever be able to escape the darkness from that time of her life, Raina also has his thoughts and words running through her head to the point she doesn’t know if it’s him or her thinking them, &her feeling unwanted and alone, thinking she will never be perfect).
6 hand/palm/fingers kisses,
4 head/forehead kisses,
3 cheek kisses,
2 almost kisses (lasting 1-4 sentences),
9 kisses lasting a sentence,
1 unwanted kiss that lasts a couple of sentences,
3 kisses lasting a couple sentences,
3 kisses lasting a few sentences,
2 kisses lasting 5-8+ of sentences,
Remembering kisses & wanting to kiss (up to a few sentences).
Lots of touches, embraces, hand holding, nearness, warmth, shivers, & noticing (up to a handful of sentences); Some flirting, blushes, & winks; One man comes to Raina’s door at night (with “noble intentions”, but they do share a kiss).
Raina also recalls her reactions and blushes to the toxic guy when they would be near each other, touch, and kiss (up to a few sentences); *Spoiler* .
Raina and the love interest are posed by another painter to be like lovers in a few different poses (very intimate and causes a lot of feelings for Raina, being so near him).
Mentions of kisses & kissing (up to a couple sentences); Mentions of a man often trying to touch Raina when teaching her; Mentions of loving someone so much you’ll change for the person for better & those saying they will, but never do; Mentions of flirting & a man liking to spend time with women; Mentions of poses of models for painters/sculptors that are intimate (such as being draped in only fabric and others asked to press against one another in the pose of lovers); A few mentions of trysts and clandestine meetings between lovers; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of married couples kissing; A couple mentions of philanderers; A mention of a man making advances on Raina with an unwanted kiss; A mention of a man looking delectable in a certain outfit.
February 21, 2016
Such a great book! I loved reading Lorraina's story. This is a companion novel with characters who have been introduced in previous books but it can stand on its own if you haven't read them. Very much enjoyed this story.
Content: Clean
Source: Ebook review copy
Content: Clean
Source: Ebook review copy
December 4, 2017
Have you ever read a book that must be read no matter what you are doing. I started it last night and finished it the next evening. I read at work, while blow drying my hair, I tried to figure out how to read in the shower but didn't want to destroy my electronics. I wasn't sure I would like this book. The story line was not my thing. Raina started to get in my heart during Marilee's story which I highly recommend reading, you would lose a lot by not reading that first. Annette writes with a passion and flow I love. I fell into this book and loved every minute. This is a great 4 book series starting with Just Ella that is still my favorite series. Can't wait to see what this author has NEXT:}
February 23, 2016
LOVED it. I have really enjoyed all of Annette K. Larsen's books. This one was no exception. I'll just be honest- I was seriously crushin' on West, Raina's guard- like for the entire book. It was ridiculous. But anywho...
Lorraina is the least likeable sister in the series. She's very worried about acting as royalty should act. Although this book can stand alone, you should probably at least read Missing Lily so you have a little bit of background on what Lorraina is working through. She had been in love (or what she thought was love) with Tobias, and he was killed in front of her. For a year she's been trying to work through those emotions, and find herself. However, after "acting the part" for so long, she isn't sure she knows who "Raina" really is. Lorraina has never felt she was the noticed princess or even someone to really be loved. She begins to confide and lean on someone who has been a constant in her life... and then he leaves. Will Lorraina be able to see and find the real her? Can she finally heal and learn to live?
I just adored this book. I never really disliked Lorraina in the other books. I just KNEW there had to be more to her! I loved seeing her discover herself. And I loved, and reread several times this one part of the ending: "Then he looked up toward the castle - toward me- and dropped his sword. He took off at a sprint, heading for the nearest doors leading inside. It took me a moment to realize what was happening. Was he truly running to find me? Could I inspire such action in a man?" Oh my word, y'all. I want a man to sprint to find me. :)
I have this on my kindle- as I was given a copy for an honest review. But when I finished the book last night, I ordered the paperback to complete my set. I know it's one I will read over and over again.
Lorraina is the least likeable sister in the series. She's very worried about acting as royalty should act. Although this book can stand alone, you should probably at least read Missing Lily so you have a little bit of background on what Lorraina is working through. She had been in love (or what she thought was love) with Tobias, and he was killed in front of her. For a year she's been trying to work through those emotions, and find herself. However, after "acting the part" for so long, she isn't sure she knows who "Raina" really is. Lorraina has never felt she was the noticed princess or even someone to really be loved. She begins to confide and lean on someone who has been a constant in her life... and then he leaves. Will Lorraina be able to see and find the real her? Can she finally heal and learn to live?
I just adored this book. I never really disliked Lorraina in the other books. I just KNEW there had to be more to her! I loved seeing her discover herself. And I loved, and reread several times this one part of the ending: "Then he looked up toward the castle - toward me- and dropped his sword. He took off at a sprint, heading for the nearest doors leading inside. It took me a moment to realize what was happening. Was he truly running to find me? Could I inspire such action in a man?" Oh my word, y'all. I want a man to sprint to find me. :)
I have this on my kindle- as I was given a copy for an honest review. But when I finished the book last night, I ordered the paperback to complete my set. I know it's one I will read over and over again.
October 10, 2019
While I've enjoyed all of the books in the Books of Dalthia series, I was a bit hesitant to read Painting Rain, as the protagonist, Lorriana, has always been one of my least favorite characters, and I wasn’t too keen to read an entire story from her perspective. I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it. This was not only an incredibly sweet romance, but such a beautiful story in general.
What I loved the most was the self-discovery and internal focus of the plot revolving around Lorraina's growth. Despite my initial dislike for her, I really related to her struggles—her need to achieve perfection, her lack of inner confidence when she felt she wasn't measuring up to who she wanted to be, and her desires to change for the better. I felt I experienced Lorraina’s journey along with her as she learned to love and accept herself and her life, imperfections and all.
I absolutely adored Lorraina's guard, West. He was such a wonderful character, and I thought the romance between him and Raina was absolutely adorable. He was such a sweet, gentle, patient, and good man who was such a friend and support for Raina, helped her see the good in herself, and helped her grow to her potential. He and Raina's relationship had a wonderful development, many cute scenes, and a delightful forbidden romance element.
I also really enjoyed the focus on art in this novel. Although I'm not a painter myself, I really appreciate paintings, and found Raina's art instruction and her process of developing her artistic talents fascinating. I loved watching Raina grow in her abilities to learn to paint with her heart and soul, and to find her passion for her craft within herself.
All in all, Painting Rain was another cute romance with a delightful fairy tale feel. This is such a sweet series that I really enjoy; this book especially is one of my favorites romances, one I’ll reread many times.
What I loved the most was the self-discovery and internal focus of the plot revolving around Lorraina's growth. Despite my initial dislike for her, I really related to her struggles—her need to achieve perfection, her lack of inner confidence when she felt she wasn't measuring up to who she wanted to be, and her desires to change for the better. I felt I experienced Lorraina’s journey along with her as she learned to love and accept herself and her life, imperfections and all.
I absolutely adored Lorraina's guard, West. He was such a wonderful character, and I thought the romance between him and Raina was absolutely adorable. He was such a sweet, gentle, patient, and good man who was such a friend and support for Raina, helped her see the good in herself, and helped her grow to her potential. He and Raina's relationship had a wonderful development, many cute scenes, and a delightful forbidden romance element.
I also really enjoyed the focus on art in this novel. Although I'm not a painter myself, I really appreciate paintings, and found Raina's art instruction and her process of developing her artistic talents fascinating. I loved watching Raina grow in her abilities to learn to paint with her heart and soul, and to find her passion for her craft within herself.
All in all, Painting Rain was another cute romance with a delightful fairy tale feel. This is such a sweet series that I really enjoy; this book especially is one of my favorites romances, one I’ll reread many times.
March 14, 2016
I love reading books by Annette Larsen. She has such a wonderful way of writing that draws me in from the beginning. Her characters have personality, depth and growth and this book was no exception.
We have seen glimpses of Lorraina in previous books where her sisters had the spotlight. She plays a minor role but you see the beginnings of a character shift for her. I'm so glad we finally got to Raina's story so I could really know and understand her.
Raina has fantastic growth in this book. As a reader, I just couldn't help but be so proud of her. She knows that in the past she has made mistakes. She is constantly trying to change and become better- to be open to new feelings and ideas. How can you help but love her for that? Raina is just endearing.
Princess Lorraina is an artist- a painter. I know absolutely nothing about painting and I have zero talent for anything in that artistic realm so the romp into the world of a painter was fun for me. I enjoyed the setting and the magical world painting created for me.
I loved this book. It was so sweet and beautiful. I was sad to see it end.
Content: Clean. A few instances of kissing.
We have seen glimpses of Lorraina in previous books where her sisters had the spotlight. She plays a minor role but you see the beginnings of a character shift for her. I'm so glad we finally got to Raina's story so I could really know and understand her.
Raina has fantastic growth in this book. As a reader, I just couldn't help but be so proud of her. She knows that in the past she has made mistakes. She is constantly trying to change and become better- to be open to new feelings and ideas. How can you help but love her for that? Raina is just endearing.
Princess Lorraina is an artist- a painter. I know absolutely nothing about painting and I have zero talent for anything in that artistic realm so the romp into the world of a painter was fun for me. I enjoyed the setting and the magical world painting created for me.
I loved this book. It was so sweet and beautiful. I was sad to see it end.
Content: Clean. A few instances of kissing.
February 21, 2024
This review and many more can be found on my blog: Feed Your Fiction Addiction
Painting Rain is a sweet story about a woman coming to understand herself and learning to stand on her own two feet. Princess Lorraina was introduced in the first three books in this series, but each of the books can be read as a standalone - I missed book three, and while it was referenced a couple of times, I didn't feel like I was missing anything that was important to the current story. However, I do suggest reading at least the second book because that's where Raina's story truly begins. This book takes place in the aftermath of that second book.
What Fed My Addiction:
Raina's Growth.
When the book started, I have to admit that I had a bit of a hard time relating to Raina - mostly because I had just reread my reviews of the first two books and remembered all the reasons I didn't like her in book two! She had rubbed me the wrong way and I believed that she was to blame for much of the tragedy that occurred with Tobias (read the synopsis if you want to know more about that). So, the fact that Raina had won me over by midway through the book was quite an accomplishment. In this book, Raina has realized her own culpability in everything that happened. She's realized that she's spent her life pushing people away and she is truly trying to change. She's rebuilding her relationships and making a real effort to better herself. At first, I was skeptical, but she eventually won me over and I saw her truth more clearly.
West.
There was nothing I didn't love about West. He had spent years making sure that Raina was safe and he had seen the good in her, even when others weren't able to. In fact, I think it was eventually seeing Raina through West's eyes (even though we weren't getting the story from his POV) that made me eventually soften toward Raina. He saw her in her unguarded moments - the times that she fell apart when others weren't watching - and he had seen her vulnerabilities. Moreover, he appreciated her art and encouraged her in a way that no one else could.
Art.
I loved Raina's artistic instruction and how she learned to paint, not just technically well, but with her whole heart and soul. There were lots of interesting details about painting instruction that fascinated me as well. And I loved the fact that Raina had to learn to put her passion into her work and she couldn't rely on West or anyone else to find that passion.
What Left Me Wanting More:
Excuses?
Like I said, I wasn't a fan of Raina in the previous books. And, at first, I felt like the beginning of the book had to backtrack too much and give us excuses for Raina's behavior. In the end, her perspective won out and I was able to see her pain in the situations that led us to book two, but it definitely took me a while to warm up to Raina.
If you're a fan of historicals and/or clean romances, I'd definitely give this series a read. While none of the books have struck me quite the way that first one did, I have thoroughly enjoyed reading them all. (I need to pick up the third book in the series, since I apparently missed that one!) I give this book 4/5 stars.
***Disclosure: I received this book from the author via I Am a Reader in exchange for an honest review. No other compensation was given and all opinions are my own.***
Painting Rain is a sweet story about a woman coming to understand herself and learning to stand on her own two feet. Princess Lorraina was introduced in the first three books in this series, but each of the books can be read as a standalone - I missed book three, and while it was referenced a couple of times, I didn't feel like I was missing anything that was important to the current story. However, I do suggest reading at least the second book because that's where Raina's story truly begins. This book takes place in the aftermath of that second book.
What Fed My Addiction:
Raina's Growth.
When the book started, I have to admit that I had a bit of a hard time relating to Raina - mostly because I had just reread my reviews of the first two books and remembered all the reasons I didn't like her in book two! She had rubbed me the wrong way and I believed that she was to blame for much of the tragedy that occurred with Tobias (read the synopsis if you want to know more about that). So, the fact that Raina had won me over by midway through the book was quite an accomplishment. In this book, Raina has realized her own culpability in everything that happened. She's realized that she's spent her life pushing people away and she is truly trying to change. She's rebuilding her relationships and making a real effort to better herself. At first, I was skeptical, but she eventually won me over and I saw her truth more clearly.
West.
There was nothing I didn't love about West. He had spent years making sure that Raina was safe and he had seen the good in her, even when others weren't able to. In fact, I think it was eventually seeing Raina through West's eyes (even though we weren't getting the story from his POV) that made me eventually soften toward Raina. He saw her in her unguarded moments - the times that she fell apart when others weren't watching - and he had seen her vulnerabilities. Moreover, he appreciated her art and encouraged her in a way that no one else could.
Art.
I loved Raina's artistic instruction and how she learned to paint, not just technically well, but with her whole heart and soul. There were lots of interesting details about painting instruction that fascinated me as well. And I loved the fact that Raina had to learn to put her passion into her work and she couldn't rely on West or anyone else to find that passion.
What Left Me Wanting More:
Excuses?
Like I said, I wasn't a fan of Raina in the previous books. And, at first, I felt like the beginning of the book had to backtrack too much and give us excuses for Raina's behavior. In the end, her perspective won out and I was able to see her pain in the situations that led us to book two, but it definitely took me a while to warm up to Raina.
If you're a fan of historicals and/or clean romances, I'd definitely give this series a read. While none of the books have struck me quite the way that first one did, I have thoroughly enjoyed reading them all. (I need to pick up the third book in the series, since I apparently missed that one!) I give this book 4/5 stars.
***Disclosure: I received this book from the author via I Am a Reader in exchange for an honest review. No other compensation was given and all opinions are my own.***
December 24, 2018
I knew this book was going to be amazing. If you read Annette K. Larsen's previous books which I highly recommend, Just Ella,Missing Lily,Saving Marilee you get to know a little about Lorraina or Raina and who she is. I am so glad a book was written about her. I felt after reading this I had a better opinion of her and the struggles she faced. No novel would not be complete without a hero. I became smitten with West from the beginning. He is a good man and even handsome as Raina perfectly describes him. I would love to hear his point of view someday! One of my favorite moments in the book which brings out my romantic side is towards the end and this even says what kind of person West is. " I love you, Raina. I want you to know that. I can't say when exactly it happened only by the time I recognized it, I was so in love with you that I knew there was no going back, no getting out of it. And even if there was, I didn't want a way out." Be still my heart!! If you are looking for clean romantic novels, this is it!! 4.5 stars.
February 22, 2016
A Great Addition to the Series
I enjoyed the rest of the books in this series, and while this book could stand alone, I'd recommend reading the second book, Missing Lily first.
Lorraina was the unlikable sister in the other stories. She's sharp and exacting, and unsympathetic. In Painting Rain, we see her a year after the events in Missing Lily. She's been broken, but she is trying to put herself together as someone that she would actually like to be. Raina leaves the castle to study painting with a master. There she learns humility, technique, and how to express (and even find) herself.
I loved watching Raina grow. This book also made me wish I knew more about art. I would have been itching to paint, if I knew anything about how to do it. Even lacking that knowledge, I enjoyed being in the studio with Raina, and I loved the descriptions of her artwork.
The romance was sweet, and well developed. I only wished for an epilogue! I loved our hero for his patience and gentleness with Raina.
Are there anymore unwed sisters? I think Raina was the last, and that is very disappointing.
Content: clean (some kissing, no language, mild violence-someone was shot and killed by arrows, no grizzly description)
I enjoyed the rest of the books in this series, and while this book could stand alone, I'd recommend reading the second book, Missing Lily first.
Lorraina was the unlikable sister in the other stories. She's sharp and exacting, and unsympathetic. In Painting Rain, we see her a year after the events in Missing Lily. She's been broken, but she is trying to put herself together as someone that she would actually like to be. Raina leaves the castle to study painting with a master. There she learns humility, technique, and how to express (and even find) herself.
I loved watching Raina grow. This book also made me wish I knew more about art. I would have been itching to paint, if I knew anything about how to do it. Even lacking that knowledge, I enjoyed being in the studio with Raina, and I loved the descriptions of her artwork.
The romance was sweet, and well developed. I only wished for an epilogue! I loved our hero for his patience and gentleness with Raina.
Are there anymore unwed sisters? I think Raina was the last, and that is very disappointing.
Content: clean (some kissing, no language, mild violence-someone was shot and killed by arrows, no grizzly description)
April 18, 2019
Simply Beautiful!
I adored this book, and can’t believe I let myself go so long before reading it! I have loved each of her other Books of Dalthia, and this one was no exception. I’ve felt drawn to reread the series, and the further I got into them, the more I ached for Princess Lorraina and just HAD to know her story.
This story was poignantly beautiful- Raina embarks on a journey to learn from a master painter, to get away from the tragedy of her past, and ultimately, to find herself. There was such detail to the painting methods, and the paintings themselves spoke volumes about Raina’s emotions and feelings.
Don’t get me started on the love story- I stayed up way too late to enjoy every bit of this toe-curling romance. I don’t want to spoil with whom, but yikes the hero was definitely swoony! Annette Larsen brings the characters to life, and I loved reading about Raina’s journey of self-discovery as well as finding a real and lasting love.
I’m sad to see the end of Dalthia- I love these characters and their stories! If you haven’t yet read one, start with Just Ella and be prepared to get sucked into these amazing stories for quite some time!
I adored this book, and can’t believe I let myself go so long before reading it! I have loved each of her other Books of Dalthia, and this one was no exception. I’ve felt drawn to reread the series, and the further I got into them, the more I ached for Princess Lorraina and just HAD to know her story.
This story was poignantly beautiful- Raina embarks on a journey to learn from a master painter, to get away from the tragedy of her past, and ultimately, to find herself. There was such detail to the painting methods, and the paintings themselves spoke volumes about Raina’s emotions and feelings.
Don’t get me started on the love story- I stayed up way too late to enjoy every bit of this toe-curling romance. I don’t want to spoil with whom, but yikes the hero was definitely swoony! Annette Larsen brings the characters to life, and I loved reading about Raina’s journey of self-discovery as well as finding a real and lasting love.
I’m sad to see the end of Dalthia- I love these characters and their stories! If you haven’t yet read one, start with Just Ella and be prepared to get sucked into these amazing stories for quite some time!
March 7, 2016
I love this author. She knows how to write such moving stories. And best of all, her characters are so good! They are trying to be good and moral and kind.
The main character in this book, Lorraina, has been in her other books. She was not a beloved character. But she is changing and wants to be better, and I loved that. I found her completely inspiring in this book. And our hero was so good. The kissing was great and clean. I would have no problems recommending this to my niece or friend.
I highly recommend all of Annette's books. Finding Ella and Painting Rain are my faves so far, but they are all good.
The main character in this book, Lorraina, has been in her other books. She was not a beloved character. But she is changing and wants to be better, and I loved that. I found her completely inspiring in this book. And our hero was so good. The kissing was great and clean. I would have no problems recommending this to my niece or friend.
I highly recommend all of Annette's books. Finding Ella and Painting Rain are my faves so far, but they are all good.
February 24, 2016
I was so happy when I heard that Lorraina would be getting her own book. Painting Rain did not disappoint! I loved reading Lorraina's story and getting to see her grow as a character. And can I just mention how great West is? Seriously, I loved him. I've been a follower of Annette K. Larson since Missing Lily came out. So I'm sad that the Books of Dalthia are over, but I can't wait to read whatever Ms. Larson writes next. She definitely one of my favorite authors
March 18, 2016
Well that was pretty much awesome. There was a bit of rambling in the middle and I'm sure the kissy stuff was so against the society rules and would have ruined her but it was still good. West. Aww west. Swoon worthy.
June 27, 2025
I only wish it had taken them longer to make their feelings known to one another.
January 15, 2023
forbidden romance and artsy angst
Lorraina has always been the odd one out among the princesses — prickly, particular, and not too popular with the men. After suffering through a tragic love affair and a failed engagement, she’s lost and lonely, but ready to move forward with life. Does she have what it takes to study painting with the premier master, or will she run back to the castle and hide behind her caustic exterior?
This was a fun read and much lighter in tone than the previous book, although it did have some heavy elements (death of a former love interest). I enjoyed Lorraina’s character growth and the love story was very sweet.
Lorraina has always been the odd one out among the princesses — prickly, particular, and not too popular with the men. After suffering through a tragic love affair and a failed engagement, she’s lost and lonely, but ready to move forward with life. Does she have what it takes to study painting with the premier master, or will she run back to the castle and hide behind her caustic exterior?
This was a fun read and much lighter in tone than the previous book, although it did have some heavy elements (death of a former love interest). I enjoyed Lorraina’s character growth and the love story was very sweet.
April 25, 2017
I enjoyed Lorraina's story. Like Marilee's story, it was more self discovery and internal plot than the first two books of Dalthia. I enjoyed the flowing plots of the first two books more than the internal struggles of the last two books of the series. But it was wonderful to be part of their world again regardless and get to know the final character.
July 19, 2018
This is the third book I read by Annette K. Larsen after being instantly charmed by her fist novel Just Ella. Painting Rain is the fourth book in the Book of Dalthia series. Each book is a stand-alone and tells the story of each of the Princesses of Dalthia.
Painting Rain tells the story of Lorraina, the fourth sister. She is not yet married and I remembered her as being portrayed as aloof and unfeeling in the previous novels. A year ago, she watched Tobias, the young man she loved, die and she has mourned his death. That event has made her question who she really is and how she could change to be the person she now wants to be.
Once again, I was captivated by Larsen's writing. She knows how to create believable characters that are strong, yet vulnerable. This story is very character-driven and sticks mainly to how Lorraina becomes her own person. Lorraina does this by indulging in her love of painting. She begins to study under the tutelage of a master artist and through this experience learns about herself and what she wants in life. I loved learning about the artistry of painting, such as how they created their own paints, prepared the canvas, and the different techniques used.
There is romance in this story, but at its heart, this is a coming-of-age story. I thoroughly enjoyed Lorraina's personal journey and I particularly liked how Larsen showed that happiness does not only come from discovery of loving another person. It comes from being fulfilled through one's own means of dealing with life. The love between the two characters reflected this. This wasn't some flighty love based on purely physical attraction, although the young man was swoon-worthy for sure. It was solidly based on true friendship.
I love YA historical fiction with such great messages for our teen girls. And I admire authors who write clean romance with substance. Having read this novel, I now want to read the third book I missed in this series titled Saving Marilee. And I hope to read many more from talented Annette K. Larsen.
Painting Rain tells the story of Lorraina, the fourth sister. She is not yet married and I remembered her as being portrayed as aloof and unfeeling in the previous novels. A year ago, she watched Tobias, the young man she loved, die and she has mourned his death. That event has made her question who she really is and how she could change to be the person she now wants to be.
Once again, I was captivated by Larsen's writing. She knows how to create believable characters that are strong, yet vulnerable. This story is very character-driven and sticks mainly to how Lorraina becomes her own person. Lorraina does this by indulging in her love of painting. She begins to study under the tutelage of a master artist and through this experience learns about herself and what she wants in life. I loved learning about the artistry of painting, such as how they created their own paints, prepared the canvas, and the different techniques used.
There is romance in this story, but at its heart, this is a coming-of-age story. I thoroughly enjoyed Lorraina's personal journey and I particularly liked how Larsen showed that happiness does not only come from discovery of loving another person. It comes from being fulfilled through one's own means of dealing with life. The love between the two characters reflected this. This wasn't some flighty love based on purely physical attraction, although the young man was swoon-worthy for sure. It was solidly based on true friendship.
I love YA historical fiction with such great messages for our teen girls. And I admire authors who write clean romance with substance. Having read this novel, I now want to read the third book I missed in this series titled Saving Marilee. And I hope to read many more from talented Annette K. Larsen.
February 29, 2016
I've loved each of Annette Larsen's books, and though I was nervous about whether I would like seeing the world through Raina's perpective, I did. I enjoyed her story to overcome her need for perfection - one that's made her miserable - in order to love herself and her life, imperfections and all. With all the art in this story, the writing itself paints a pretty picture.
The hard part for me is the compassion I think is missing for Tobias, Raina's lost love. Pity for HIM alone, separate from herself. I feel for Raina when she's angry, lost, and confused because she still loves him (really well done). But all perspectives agree that Tobias was dangerous and caused mayhem. Not much sympathy. The story summary doesn't work for me when it says how do you recover from loving someone *not deserving* of your love. I think everyone is in need of love and compassion. I also get uncomfortable with *earn* forgiveness. That doesn't seem quite it. He could never apologize or never ask for forgiveness, and she could still forgive. He didn't need to earn it. It's not for him. It's for her personally.
On a much more positive side, which is the focus of Raina's story, it's nice to see Raina try something new. I like seeing her temper flare up. She's tried so hard to live up to her role and the high expectations she's set for herself, always wanting to be better and more and right now! It's taken it's toll on her relationships in her family and in her own contentment with life. I like her journey.
Raina goes to study painting with a great artist. I loved seeing the beauty she sees in the world and the artistic lens of her world view. The romance is SO SWEET and captures the joy of falling in love with someone who's really good for you. I love how their story plays out.
The hard part for me is the compassion I think is missing for Tobias, Raina's lost love. Pity for HIM alone, separate from herself. I feel for Raina when she's angry, lost, and confused because she still loves him (really well done). But all perspectives agree that Tobias was dangerous and caused mayhem. Not much sympathy. The story summary doesn't work for me when it says how do you recover from loving someone *not deserving* of your love. I think everyone is in need of love and compassion. I also get uncomfortable with *earn* forgiveness. That doesn't seem quite it. He could never apologize or never ask for forgiveness, and she could still forgive. He didn't need to earn it. It's not for him. It's for her personally.
On a much more positive side, which is the focus of Raina's story, it's nice to see Raina try something new. I like seeing her temper flare up. She's tried so hard to live up to her role and the high expectations she's set for herself, always wanting to be better and more and right now! It's taken it's toll on her relationships in her family and in her own contentment with life. I like her journey.
Raina goes to study painting with a great artist. I loved seeing the beauty she sees in the world and the artistic lens of her world view. The romance is SO SWEET and captures the joy of falling in love with someone who's really good for you. I love how their story plays out.
March 6, 2018
Oooooooh. I LOVED this book. Annette's Dalthia books just keep getting better! :D It started at a leisurely pace and built up beautifully into a sweet, deep, heart-throbbing romance with intense chemistry!
The descriptions of Lorraina's development in painting were deeply moving and enlightening to me as a mostly-self-taught artist. I've never before understood WHY artists deviate from painting exactly the scene in front of them, but now I can understand how and why, in certain circumstances, you'd want to alter the colour and lighting and details to convey a certain mood. It's all quite fascinating, as is the development of Raina's character. I really like Raina and it's wonderful to see her develop and gain confidence and move away from her lonely, tragic past.
I didn't fully understand West at first - seemed hard to pin down his character - but that seemed intentional as Raina herself had to learn to "see" him. As she gets to know him, he became my favourite male lead character in the Dalthia books. I love how her perception of his personality and looks develops as time goes on. It's as if he's a bit undefined at first, but then she notices more and more details as she becomes more and more aware of him as a person. And those details are incredible! :D
I loved this book so much that I read most of it again twice right after finishing it. The ONLY downside was that it ended too soon for me!! I would have loved to see the interactions of the whole family with West once their relationship became known. Ah, well, we have imaginations! ;)
The descriptions of Lorraina's development in painting were deeply moving and enlightening to me as a mostly-self-taught artist. I've never before understood WHY artists deviate from painting exactly the scene in front of them, but now I can understand how and why, in certain circumstances, you'd want to alter the colour and lighting and details to convey a certain mood. It's all quite fascinating, as is the development of Raina's character. I really like Raina and it's wonderful to see her develop and gain confidence and move away from her lonely, tragic past.
I didn't fully understand West at first - seemed hard to pin down his character - but that seemed intentional as Raina herself had to learn to "see" him. As she gets to know him, he became my favourite male lead character in the Dalthia books. I love how her perception of his personality and looks develops as time goes on. It's as if he's a bit undefined at first, but then she notices more and more details as she becomes more and more aware of him as a person. And those details are incredible! :D
I loved this book so much that I read most of it again twice right after finishing it. The ONLY downside was that it ended too soon for me!! I would have loved to see the interactions of the whole family with West once their relationship became known. Ah, well, we have imaginations! ;)
March 29, 2016
Hard life lessons are often learned after trial. Princess Lorraina is not a stranger to trial. The man she loved was killed before her eyes after he betrayed her. She spent her life separating herself from her sisters and was friendless.
This is book four in a series about Princess sisters. Each of them can be read as a stand alone, but this story was introduced in Missing Lily. It is a easier to follow along if you know what has happened before.
I have read all four of the books and highly recommend them. Each of the sisters have their unique story and personality. Romance is part of this book but I feel it was really about the growth of Lorraina. She comes to know herself and her priorities. Her artwork is a way for her to express herself and let go of her past.
I loved the way she was able to loose herself in painting. She also was taught about the process of creating art, it added a depth to my knowledge and perception as a reader. It was fascinating.
This book contained a little bit of violence and a forbidden love with kissing.
This is book four in a series about Princess sisters. Each of them can be read as a stand alone, but this story was introduced in Missing Lily. It is a easier to follow along if you know what has happened before.
I have read all four of the books and highly recommend them. Each of the sisters have their unique story and personality. Romance is part of this book but I feel it was really about the growth of Lorraina. She comes to know herself and her priorities. Her artwork is a way for her to express herself and let go of her past.
I loved the way she was able to loose herself in painting. She also was taught about the process of creating art, it added a depth to my knowledge and perception as a reader. It was fascinating.
This book contained a little bit of violence and a forbidden love with kissing.
March 3, 2016
This story focuses on Princess Lorraina. It’s a stand-alone book, but goes along with her sister’s books—Just Ella and Missing Lily. Lorraina was kind of the jerk sister in Just Ella, but a year has passed and she is trying to become a better person. The truths revealed about herself in the tragedy that happened in the last book haunt her, and she wants nothing more than to put the past behind her. The tone of this story was subdued. She goes off to study under a master artist for six months and falls in love with a man who once was beneath her notice. The romance was sweet, the character growth was beautiful to watch unfold, and I really loved the painting theme. Larsen did an amazing job of helping me see the beauty in Raina’s paintings through mere words, to feel her angst when she couldn’t connect with her emotions, and to open my heart to the depth of the human soul. Bravo!
*I received a copy of this book in exchange for my fair and honest review.
*I received a copy of this book in exchange for my fair and honest review.
March 18, 2016
Painting Rain is another winner by author Annette K. Larsen! It is packed with emotion, and although one might think a big adventure or royal threat will take place, the story mostly comes from Raina's internal struggle. She feels so many expectations and responsibilities, and happiness seems just out of her reach at times. The story really pulled me in, and I became deeply invested in Raina's happiness.
I read this very quickly and really enjoyed Raina's emotional transformation. Much of the focus is on art and how she was able to do her best work when she painted what she felt instead of what was expected. I'm not very artistic, but the descriptions of what she was learning and painting were well done, and were a great part of the story.
The characters were all great and many were so likable. Painting Rain is a great story. It is a clean read, and definitely one I'd read again.
I read this very quickly and really enjoyed Raina's emotional transformation. Much of the focus is on art and how she was able to do her best work when she painted what she felt instead of what was expected. I'm not very artistic, but the descriptions of what she was learning and painting were well done, and were a great part of the story.
The characters were all great and many were so likable. Painting Rain is a great story. It is a clean read, and definitely one I'd read again.
April 28, 2024
First read 2/22/16
4.5-With each of Annette Larsen's books, she does a great job a capturing each character's voice. Lorraina's voice and personality in the other books has been a person I wouldn't want to meet or be her voice, but I think her character development throughout the other books and this as well was very well done. I loved the premise of having personal strength first, and loving yourself and was very happy when that theme pulled through. Also, loved a story about personal growth and change, especially in the heroine. Great, clean, easy read.
2nd read 12/16/16
4.5-With each of Annette Larsen's books, she does a great job a capturing each character's voice. Lorraina's voice and personality in the other books has been a person I wouldn't want to meet or be her voice, but I think her character development throughout the other books and this as well was very well done. I loved the premise of having personal strength first, and loving yourself and was very happy when that theme pulled through. Also, loved a story about personal growth and change, especially in the heroine. Great, clean, easy read.
2nd read 12/16/16
February 29, 2016
Beautiful
I wondered how I would like this book, because I didn't love Raina in the other books of this series. I love this author! She is amazing at writing in a way that connects you to the characters, and I loved it. Raina is an artist. It was amazing to me how the description of her art and feelings while she was working on her art and working through her past could be so intense at times! The love story was so sweet. I know my description does it no justice at all, so I'll just say that this book is beautiful! Read it!
I wondered how I would like this book, because I didn't love Raina in the other books of this series. I love this author! She is amazing at writing in a way that connects you to the characters, and I loved it. Raina is an artist. It was amazing to me how the description of her art and feelings while she was working on her art and working through her past could be so intense at times! The love story was so sweet. I know my description does it no justice at all, so I'll just say that this book is beautiful! Read it!
May 10, 2017
Only seconds lapsed after I finished this amazing book before I wrote this review. From a simple story of love between two mismatched people, Annette created a novel so full of life and passion that it swept me completely, tossing all other cares aside. Raina's character grew by leaps and bounds, from her painting to her relationships to finding herself. West was the compass that guided her. Together they created a beautiful romance that is unparalleled. I'd recommend this novel to anyone wanting to feel true emotion and delight.
January 6, 2018
I looked forward with great anticipation to Lorraina's story knowing it was going to be so different than her other sisters. Annette Larsen writes her characters so individually the personalities of each of the sisters really comes through. She did a wonderful job giving Raina a journey that made her a character you can relate to and finally connect with.
September 14, 2022
Just like the previous books before, Painting Rain is a beautiful, clean romance. What I liked about this one was Raina's character development. I enjoyed reading her change and journey through this book. Again, I still want more after the story is done.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 2, 2023
I love this series! This book was a tad different than the others however: There was less external action, and more (all) of the conflict was internal-- not a bad thing. I loved seeing Raina's change... I adored West. Overall I was very satisfied with the story as a whole.
February 21, 2016
Soooo good and so sweet! This is the fourth book in this series and I love how we have gotten to know Raina in the previous books and her transformation in this one.
March 14, 2016
Well worth the read. Thank you for a clean read!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 130 reviews