What does it mean to be “truly human?” In Christological Anthropology in Historical Perspective, Marc Cortez looks at the ways several key theologians—Gregory of Nyssa, Julian of Norwich, Martin Luther, Friedrich Schleiermacher, Karl Barth, John Zizioulas, and James Cone—have used Christology to inform their understanding of the human person. Based on this historical study, he concludes with a constructive proposal for how Christology and anthropology should work together to inform our view of what it means to be human.
Many theologians begin their discussion of the human person by claiming that in some way Jesus Christ reveals what it means to be “truly human,” but this often has little impact in the material presentation of their anthropology. Although modern theologians often fail to reflect robustly on the relationship between Christology and anthropology, this was not the case throughout church history. In this book, examine seven key theologians and discover their important contributions to theological anthropology.
Marc Cortez (PhD, St Andrews) is professor of theology at Wheaton College. He is the author of Resourcing Theological Anthropology, Christological Anthropology in Historical Perspective, Theological Anthropology: A Guide for the Perplexed,and Embodied Souls, Ensouled Bodies.
Probably more of a 3.5 star. This was a good book, but I found that I didn’t love the structure. Cortez demonstrates how various theologians have used Christology to inform their Anthropology, and he does a good job of sketching the various positions. My main problem was that I would have really preferred to have the basic approach of Christological anthropology laid out and then used these theologians as case studies.
I thoroughly enjoyed Cortez's work. While the topic is very much in my field of interest, Cortez made me interact with theologies I would not have soon volunteered to interact with. (Namely, Julian, Schliermacher, and Cone) I especially benefitted from his generous treatment of Schliermacher. (I do not want to be generous to Schliermacher, which is a good indication that I need such treatments in my life.)
Of particular interest to me is his discussion in the conclusion regarding Soteriological Universalism vs. Anthropological Exclusivism, as I believe Irenaeus exemplifies the tension between these quite vividly. My own academic interests were centered around this very problem.
Needless to say, I am excited to read further works in what promises to be a series by the author.
I really enjoyed this book. It was very interesting to see how various historical figures, from different theological traditions, attempted to deal with anthropology through the lens of Christology. More than anything else, Cotez's abilities in analytic work shines through in this volume. There's hardly any overlap between each of the figures surveyed in this volume, and Cortez is still able to treat each one fairly and extensively. It's really impressive.
The most pressing question throughout the book, for me, was the one he brings up at the end; namely, does adopting a Christological Anthropology force one into adopting either an anthropological exclusivism or a soteriological universalism. In other words, if Jesus Christ reveals and constitutes, through inauguration or transformation or whatever means you insist on, a "true humanity," does that mean you have to affirm either (a) not every human is "truly human" (i.e., non-Christians), or (b) *all* humanity is "in Christ" or "transformed by Christ" or "constituted in Christ," etc.? Is that a dilemma every Christological Anthropology is unavoidably faced with? Cortez concludes by essentially saying, "Maybe not, but the dilemma hasn't been avoided yet."
This is a survey, so Cortez really isn't carving anything new out. In fact, he explicitly states that this survey is intended to set up his next work, which will propose a way forward. This is why the blurb on the back of the back is straight up false advertisement. "Based on this historical study, he concludes with a constructive proposal for how Christology and anthropology should work together to inform our view of what it means to be human." No he doesn't. He absolutely does not conclude with a constructive proposal. He flat out *says* that he does not offer a constructive proposal in *this volume,* but intends to *in his next one.* But as far as this book is concerned, he basically concludes it with a shrug, concluding that the methodological move of developing an anthropology through the lens of Christology doesn't answer "the question of the human," it only raises more questions.
So, not satisfying if what you're after is a tidy example of a anthropological-problem-solving Christological Anthropology, but *very* satisfying if what you're after is a historical survey of how Gregory of Nyssa, Julian of Norwich, Martin Luther, Friedrich Schleiermacher, Karl Barth, John Zizioulas, and James Cone attempted to develop Christological anthropologies. If that's your itch, this book will scratch it.
We are all contextual theologians. This book brilliantly demonstrates how the thought and environments of theologians across the time of the church have been influenced by their surroundings. Thoughts concerning humanity have varied considerably, often falling in line with the philosophy of the day. Some of the rational behind some of these theologians was difficult to make sense of in this day and age. This is a good book for those doing thinking in this area.
Sharp treatment of a variety of christological anthropologies in an effort to fashion a better understanding of what a christological anthropology really is. In the process, Cortez offers us a look into a diverse (historically and otherwise) group of theologians that bring a surprising and often invigorating perspective to the question of anthropology.
So, lets be clear up front, as you read many of the reviews of this book you will come to understand rather quickly that it is a "textbook" and not just a casual read. It is intended for students of the Bible and students of Theology, Anthropology and Sociology. So, just know up front that the writing is from a professor who is writing in an academic style and for academic students at large.
That said, while at times the book may appear difficult to read and hard to comprehend it is a text that has delved into the issue of "humankind" and how the Bible and specifically Jesus Christ intersect with Anthropology (the study of humankind). If you studied Anthropology in college you will most likely have studied a "Secular" viewpoint of the subject. You will have learned quite a bit about culture, ethnicity, relationships and history. They would have been good studies. But most would not study it from the subject of the Bible and how God relates to Anthropology.
This text delves into the subject using the background of scripture and Theology to form a base understanding of Anthropology. It is well conceived and addresses the subject in a very straight forward manner. Yes, it will be difficult to comprehend at times, but if you are truly interested in the subject it is well worth your effort.
Thank you Professor Cortez for giving us a good text to indulge in and learn from.
This is a book that attempts to relate the doctrine of man to the doctrine of Christ, in such a way as to show how the latter informs the former. Because man was created after the image of God , and the apostle Paul tells us that the image is the Son in relation to the Father, therefore to be in the image of God, is to be in the image of the Son. This anchors anthropology in the Trinity and implies riches for the church's Christology.