A young man enters the culverted remains of an ancient Glasgow stream, looking for thrills. Deep below the city, it is decaying and claustrophobic and gets more so with every step. As the ceiling lowers to no more than a couple of feet above the ground, the man finds his path blocked by another person. Someone with his throat cut. As DS Rachel Narey leads the official investigation, photographer Tony Winter follows a lead of his own, through the shadowy world of urbexers, people who pursue a dangerous and illegal hobby, a world that Winter knows more about than he lets on. And it soon becomes clear that the murderer has killed before, and has no qualms about doing so again.
During his 20-year career with a Scottish Sunday newspaper, Craig Robertson has interviewed three recent Prime Ministers; attended major stories including 9/11, Dunblane, the Omagh bombing and the disappearance of Madeleine McCann; been pilloried on breakfast television, beaten Oprah Winfrey to a major scoop, been among the first to interview Susan Boyle, spent time on Death Row in the USA and dispensed polio drops in the backstreets of India.
“Urbexing” – the noble art of exploring derelict and deserted parts of a city’s history: abandoned buildings, tunnels, towers etc. Supermarket worker Remy Feeks is exploring the Molendinar Burn tunnel when he discovers a dead body. Not wishing to be implicated in the death, Remy places an anonymous call through to Glasgow Police. Newly promoted DI Rachel Narey is placed in charge of the investigation which soon discovers another body in an abandoned cinema. Could a serial killer be targeting urbexers? Meanwhile, Rachel’s secret boyfriend, photographer Tony Winter , thinking he recognises the first victim, decides to investigate on his own, having more knowledge of urbexing than he initially lets on. This, unsurprisingly, not only could compromise the official investigation, but also irreparably damage his relationship with Rachel. Craig Robertson, once again, manages to take us on a thrilling trip through the shadier side of Glasgow life featuring all manner of weirdos and hustlers. An intricately plotted novel which manages to seamlessly weave the personal into the public.
In Place of Death – A Great Glasgow Crime Thriller
In Place of Death is the latest Glasgow Crime Thriller from Craig Robertson, shining a light in to the darkest parts of Glasgow. This is an excellent police procedural thriller that has a fantastic dynamic between the two leading characters DI Rachel Narey and crime scene photographer Tony Wilson. There are some fantastic lines that Robertson uses to illustrate characters that just make you smile and think he has that spot on.
With the reorganisation of the Police in Scotland and the creation of Police Scotland, Rachel Narey has just been promoted to a detective inspector in the major incident team that covers Glasgow. Her promotion will have earnt her plenty of snide comments as well as enemies; Narey not only has to battle the criminals but the sexism within her own force.
Tony Wilson is a police photographer specialist, who has managed to hang on to his job in the reorganisation of Police Scotland. Again like Narey he has enemies and his line manager is the man that wants him gone in a heartbeat. All this is complicated by the fact that Wilson also happens to be dating Rachel Narey.
A body is found in the Molendinar Burn and it looks like he has been there for a while, taking the pictures Wilson is shaken as he may know the victim. Later another body is found in the Odeon in central Glasgow, there seems to be no connection other than the bodies are hidden in places where nobody is ever expected to find them.
The investigation takes Narey too many places that she wishes it did not; leads take her to the Rosewood Hotel, a hostel for the homeless, more like a waiting room for the grim reaper to Urbexing via the notorious Mullen crime family. She finds that people want her to fail so they can point to the fact is she is female and was only promoted for that reason.
At the same time Winter re-enters a world he thought he had left behind years ago, when he too used to enjoy urbexing across Glasgow. As he gets further back in to the urbexing world he seems to place himself in the way of danger while at the same time crossing the line in to the Police investigation.
As the investigation heads towards a conclusion there are some wonderful twists towards the end that you do not see coming. There are some interesting turns within the body of the thriller that help to give the characters depth and make them seem more human.
This is an excellent crime thriller and Craig Robertson is going from strength to strength and this new series will get even better as the characters develop and we get to examine the dark underbelly of Glasgow.
Excellent as ever. Full review to follow in due course (STILL catching up on full reviews for my Christmas reads!) But it will be saying all the good things. :)
I enjoyed returning to some of the familiar characters in this series, but it has been a long while since I read the previous book, so a bit of this enjoyment was muted. I do also appreciate it when I'm familiar with the setting, as I was to some extent with this Glasgow-based police procedural.
However, it all felt a bit mixed. Partly this is not Craig Robertson's fault - I have in the past two or three years become a little jaded with the elements of formula in the crime / police procedural / Scottish noir genre, having read so many books in this field, some aspects are bound to recur and feel a bit 'seen this before'. However, this effort (urban explorers, a link with possible aggressive property developers, the usual soap opera of police officers and those they love and hate) did feel a bit muddled throughout the middle, and a touch rushed in the denouement. The big reveal confirmed the bad guy was a suspect who I'd completely forgotten about and who had been mentioned only in passing some couple of hundred pages earlier - it felt a bit unsatisfying a solution and a way to deal with the solving of the case.
Jumping into this series on the fifth book, because I'm a rebel. Not totally sure what I missed out on, but it seemed to work as a stand-alone story well. The start was a little confusing with its various PoV characters, and it took me a little while to work out who the main character(s) are (possibly only because I haven't read the earlier books though). Once I got myself situated it became a real page-turner and I blasted through it. Rebus is the easy comparison - good police-procedural, interesting cases, flawed main characters that get themselves into bother and caught up in the crime somewhat. I also really enjoyed the Urbexing theme, but I get the feeling I'd have appreciated it so much more if I knew Glasgow better. Good shout from Emma - will check out the rest of the series.
I really enjoyed this by the time I finished it but felt it lost its way a little in the middle. A good read all in all though and I’m impressed that the characters are actually developing rather than sticking o their established roles from the previous books.
This was a brilliant read. Number 5 in the Narey/Winter series. Though Number 5 in the series and there is some backstory it can be easily read as a stand alone. it concerns a group of people called urbexers (urban explorers) One is Remy Feeks who when exploring an under ground stream makes a gruesome discovery. A body that he reports to the police via an anonymous phone call. Then he takes a step back and leaves it to the authorities; and this is where the story takes off. Craig's writing is such that he makes it easy to follow a story, which at times is twisted and complicated, with ease. He is comfortable in the area about which he writes and his descriptions of Glasgow and the places the story is set is spot on. Don't let this put you off. Though appealing to a Glasgow boy like me it could easily be set in any major city with abandoned buildings and people willing to enter them to stir up the past. A book that draws the reader in with superb writing and descriptive powers that conjure up the area in which it is set. A book full of ghosts of past lives and places; also ever present greed and man's inhumanity to man. A book I have read and chosen to review. I enjoyed it and would recommend to all who like a gritty story.
‘In Place of Death’ is a whodunit novel surrounding the theme urbexing. Rachel Narey, a police officer, and Tony Winter, a crime photographer, a couple who works together but has hidden their romantic relationship from their co-workers, investigate the recent murders happening in popular urbexing sites around the city of Glasgow.
The exploration of abandoned buildings, dark and chilling, you may never know what’s hidden in the case of Remy Feeks, a character whose storyline I’ve quite enjoyed. Rachel and Tony’s relationship begins to crumble when Tony recognized one of the victims and embarked on a mission of his own to rid a pang of guilt that’s eating him from the inside.
The first plot twist was incredible but the second one felt cliché and unnecessary. I didn’t know that this book is part of a series but it works fine as a stand-alone.
This is the 5th in the Rachel Narey and Tony Winter series and revolves about urbexing (urban exploring), which is, apparently, a hobby involving visiting derelict buildings. Frankly, it does not sound fun to me, but when a young urbexer finds a body in a tunnel beneath Glasgow, it involves Rachel in a case which will threaten both her career and her relationship with Winter.
I am working my way through this series, which just gets better and better, and I love the central characters. This instalment not only allows the author to explore more of Glasgow, but to touch on Winter's past and to look at social issues such as redevelopment and the places where the poor and vulnerable can end up. Although there have been no new books in this series for a while, I am hopeful that, by the time I get to the last book, the author would have been inspired to write more.
I’ve marked this so high as a measure of delight in finding Craig Robertson and his books on Glasgow police and crime detection.The culture of Strathclyde police as it was is well brought out but the real star of the book is Glasgow.The book centres round a real life practice called Urbexing which involves the exploration of abandoned buildings and railway lines ,a number of which are mentioned and bring out the character of such places .Plot is almost incidental but winds its way to a conclusion that can be anticipated and is perhaps the weakest point of the book
Crime is not my go-to genre and I often struggle with police procedurals, but I had a good time with this read. It’s fast paced and a decent page turner, and I was a big fan of the Glasgow setting and urbexing theme running throughout.
Only real niggle is that the ending took a while to wrap up and I felt it dragged. This is probably to do with it being a series, where as I came to it as a stand-alone without any background on the main characters.
Urban explorers are at the heart of this book in the series. A body is found in an underground tunnel and Tony takes the pics but it ends up being someone he knew. Then more explorers are dead so who is killing them all... Rachel is on the case while Tony runs his own investigation on the side .... what could go wrong... almost everything. Really good book, Their relationship takes big steps.
I had never heard of urbexing and enjoyed that thread as well as the crimes and the detecting. I like the way the characters are developing especially Tony. It will be interesting to see how his new job works out.
5 stars again for me. This is my favourite genre combined with history of hidden Glasgow. Anyone who loves crime should read these books. I'm straight on to the next,
6/10 16%. An interesting book as I was unaware of exploring abandoned or derelict buildings had a name, likeable characters too, but not exactly a cliff hanger of a story / I guessed most of the ending just over half way through. Won’t read again but will try more by this author
DI Narey investigates the murder of a man whose body is found in a tunnel underneath the city of Glasgow. Her partner, police photographer Tony Winter, becomes anxious and things get complicated when another body is found.
An excellent police procedural murder mystery that actually vindicates police procedure, with all its flaws. That doesn't prevent a lot of adventurous heroics along the way. I've never been there so I don't actually know, but it also nicely evokes contemporary Glasgow. This continues a good series. Also I want to give a shout out to Gordon MacKinney's wonderful "Follow Me Down", another novel about urbexing that takes place in Cincinnati and has a different emphasis, but portrays this fascinating new pastime.
the characters at the Gritty language was right up my alley. the downside was I listened to book no5 first, will read the other quickly before moving forward. a must read.
I enjoyed the characters very much. The setting of Glasgow was familiar and it was interesting learning of places that were new to me. I will definitely read more.
This is the second book I've read by Craig Robertson and I have to say he is quickly becoming one of my favourite authors. Brilliant story, well written and exciting right up to the end.