What do you think?
Rate this book
Joe Grey #19
Cat Shout for Joy
From award-winning author Shirley Rousseau Murphy comes the next charming mystery
in the critically acclaimed Joe Grey series . . .
Joe Grey and Dulcie are thrilled to be awaiting their first litter, but their joy is bittersweet. They are also sad for Pan’s father, the old yellow cat Misto, whose time on earth is drawing to a close.
While the proud parents await the birth of their babies, the criminals are busy, too. The Molena Point PD has stepped up patrols to apprehend a street prowler who has been attacking the village’s elderly citizens. Neither the police nor the cats have a clue about the culprit’s identity or what is motivating the attacks. There are no witnesses, and even more puzzling, the assailant has left no clues behind at any of the scenes, not even a trace of evidence—no hairs or fabric particles, not even a lost button. It’s as if the perpetrator is a ghost.
The case becomes a homicide when one of the victims dies, leaving everyone in the town—including Joe Grey and his furry sleuthing companions—on edge, just as the kittens arrive . . .
in the critically acclaimed Joe Grey series . . .
Joe Grey and Dulcie are thrilled to be awaiting their first litter, but their joy is bittersweet. They are also sad for Pan’s father, the old yellow cat Misto, whose time on earth is drawing to a close.
While the proud parents await the birth of their babies, the criminals are busy, too. The Molena Point PD has stepped up patrols to apprehend a street prowler who has been attacking the village’s elderly citizens. Neither the police nor the cats have a clue about the culprit’s identity or what is motivating the attacks. There are no witnesses, and even more puzzling, the assailant has left no clues behind at any of the scenes, not even a trace of evidence—no hairs or fabric particles, not even a lost button. It’s as if the perpetrator is a ghost.
The case becomes a homicide when one of the victims dies, leaving everyone in the town—including Joe Grey and his furry sleuthing companions—on edge, just as the kittens arrive . . .
327 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published February 23, 2016
200 people are currently reading
711 people want to read
About the author
Shirley Rousseau Murphy
62 books516 followersShirley Rousseau Murphy is the author of over 40 books, including 24 novels for adults, the Dragonbards Trilogy and more for young adults, and many books for children. She is best known for her Joe Grey cat mystery series, consisting of 21 novels, the last of which was published when she was over 90. Now retired, she enjoys hearing from readers who write to her at her website www.srmurphy.com, where the reading order of the books in that series can be found.
Murphy grew up in southern California, riding and showing the horses her father trained. After attending the San Francisco Art institute she worked as an interior designer, and later exhibited paintings and welded metal sculpture in the West Coast juried shows. "When my husband Pat and I moved to Panama for a four-year tour in his position with the U. S . Courts, I put away the paints and welding torches, and began to write," she says. Later they lived in Oregon, then Georgia, before moving to California, where she now enjoys the sea and views of the Carmel hills.
.
Murphy grew up in southern California, riding and showing the horses her father trained. After attending the San Francisco Art institute she worked as an interior designer, and later exhibited paintings and welded metal sculpture in the West Coast juried shows. "When my husband Pat and I moved to Panama for a four-year tour in his position with the U. S . Courts, I put away the paints and welding torches, and began to write," she says. Later they lived in Oregon, then Georgia, before moving to California, where she now enjoys the sea and views of the Carmel hills.
.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews
February 26, 2016
Originally published at Reading Reality
I think the art on the cover of this entry in the Joe Grey series is intended to represent Dulcie and Joe Grey’s impending kittens. The calico is Courtney, the white cat is Buffin and the dark one is Striker.
Of course I could be wrong about the picture, but I’m right about the kittens. The joy in this book is that Dulcie is expecting, and part of the story is Joe Grey’s, and everyone else’s, reaction to Dulcie’s impending motherhood.
No one except the old cat Misto is certain whether the new kittens will be speaking cats like both their parents. Joe Grey is uncertain about which instincts will rule him, his intelligence or his feline instincts. He is more than smart enough to know that whatever happens, the kittens bring change.
This is also a story where one door closes, and another door opens. As Dulcie enters her last days of pregnancy, the old seer cat Misto breathes his last. All the humans and all the speaking cats love the old tom, and he and his sometimes otherworldly wisdom will be missed.
And in the midst of all of this emotional upheaval, Joe Grey, and Max Harper, the police chief, have a case. At first, it seems like someone is targeting the frail and elderly in Molena Point, for “shits and giggles”. At first no one is harmed and nothing is stolen. But a series of elderly residents are attacked from behind and knocked to the ground while their assailant runs away in glee.
But the attacks are on the frail, and as the list of “prank” victims rises, so does the accidental death toll. Until one of Ryan’s young assistants is shot on a job site, and it’s suddenly clear that whatever is going on, there is someone out there masking a killing spree with a series a nasty muggings.
Partly because he needs to distract himself from all of the emotional upheaval, and partly because he can never resist a good mystery or the opportunity to put away a bad person, feline detective Joe Grey puts himself into the thick of the investigation, sniffing out important clues and pretending to be an innocent kitty as he listens in to evil plots and evil people who plan to escape their consequences.
It is Joe who provides the vital links between the series of muggings and a heinous San Francisco crime, but it’s a force of nature that delivers the baddies to their just rewards.
Escape Rating B+: The fun in this series is watching the cats figure out ways to both investigate the crimes and to give the police the evidence they need without revealing themselves. In this age of caller ID and instant tracking of everything everywhere, concealing their identities is an ever increasing challenge.
And they know they must conceal themselves. Not only would revealing themselves to the police endanger any evidence they provide, but there is always a risk that someone will discover who and what they are and want to take them away for experimentation. The more people who know their secret, the greater the risk.
In this entry in the series, it’s the emotional issues that hold the forefront, and the case is often in the background. This book represents huge changes for the characters. Joe Grey and Dulcie now have kittens to train. While they are proud of their new family, the kittens also increase the risk. How does one teach an intelligent, curious and playful baby that it is not safe to talk or burble in front of the humans? Joe Grey and Dulcie discovered their voices in adulthood, they don’t know what it is like to raise speaking kittens. Assuming that they will have speaking kittens, which is not certain to anyone but old Misto.
At the same time, the passing of Misto is sad and beautiful. As is so often the case, Misto is ready to go, but his loved ones are far from ready to let the wise old cat leave. Readers who have experienced the loss of a beloved companion animal will need lots of tissues to get through his passing. Just thinking about this part of the story gets me in the feels.
The mystery takes a back burner in this entry in the series. As we discover, the killers and their rationale are both more than a bit nuts. Also, one of them is so completely unlikable that readers will find themselves hoping she is guilty of something from the very beginning, just so she gets what’s coming to her. And that’s well before we think she’s guilty of anything beyond being a bitch. The ending of the mystery occurs offstage, and loses a bit of its cathartic value at being reported second-hand.
From the moment in the first book in this series, Cat on the Edge, when Joe Grey uses his new-found voice to order delivery from his favorite deli and charges it to his human, the big grey tom snagged a piece of my heart in his claws, and he hasn’t let go yet.I hope that there will be a 20th book in this marvelous series, and soon. I enjoy my visits to Molena Point, and I can’t wait to see what trouble the kittens will get themselves, and their parents, and their humans, into next!
I think the art on the cover of this entry in the Joe Grey series is intended to represent Dulcie and Joe Grey’s impending kittens. The calico is Courtney, the white cat is Buffin and the dark one is Striker.
Of course I could be wrong about the picture, but I’m right about the kittens. The joy in this book is that Dulcie is expecting, and part of the story is Joe Grey’s, and everyone else’s, reaction to Dulcie’s impending motherhood.
No one except the old cat Misto is certain whether the new kittens will be speaking cats like both their parents. Joe Grey is uncertain about which instincts will rule him, his intelligence or his feline instincts. He is more than smart enough to know that whatever happens, the kittens bring change.
This is also a story where one door closes, and another door opens. As Dulcie enters her last days of pregnancy, the old seer cat Misto breathes his last. All the humans and all the speaking cats love the old tom, and he and his sometimes otherworldly wisdom will be missed.
And in the midst of all of this emotional upheaval, Joe Grey, and Max Harper, the police chief, have a case. At first, it seems like someone is targeting the frail and elderly in Molena Point, for “shits and giggles”. At first no one is harmed and nothing is stolen. But a series of elderly residents are attacked from behind and knocked to the ground while their assailant runs away in glee.
But the attacks are on the frail, and as the list of “prank” victims rises, so does the accidental death toll. Until one of Ryan’s young assistants is shot on a job site, and it’s suddenly clear that whatever is going on, there is someone out there masking a killing spree with a series a nasty muggings.
Partly because he needs to distract himself from all of the emotional upheaval, and partly because he can never resist a good mystery or the opportunity to put away a bad person, feline detective Joe Grey puts himself into the thick of the investigation, sniffing out important clues and pretending to be an innocent kitty as he listens in to evil plots and evil people who plan to escape their consequences.
It is Joe who provides the vital links between the series of muggings and a heinous San Francisco crime, but it’s a force of nature that delivers the baddies to their just rewards.
Escape Rating B+: The fun in this series is watching the cats figure out ways to both investigate the crimes and to give the police the evidence they need without revealing themselves. In this age of caller ID and instant tracking of everything everywhere, concealing their identities is an ever increasing challenge.
And they know they must conceal themselves. Not only would revealing themselves to the police endanger any evidence they provide, but there is always a risk that someone will discover who and what they are and want to take them away for experimentation. The more people who know their secret, the greater the risk.
In this entry in the series, it’s the emotional issues that hold the forefront, and the case is often in the background. This book represents huge changes for the characters. Joe Grey and Dulcie now have kittens to train. While they are proud of their new family, the kittens also increase the risk. How does one teach an intelligent, curious and playful baby that it is not safe to talk or burble in front of the humans? Joe Grey and Dulcie discovered their voices in adulthood, they don’t know what it is like to raise speaking kittens. Assuming that they will have speaking kittens, which is not certain to anyone but old Misto.
At the same time, the passing of Misto is sad and beautiful. As is so often the case, Misto is ready to go, but his loved ones are far from ready to let the wise old cat leave. Readers who have experienced the loss of a beloved companion animal will need lots of tissues to get through his passing. Just thinking about this part of the story gets me in the feels.
The mystery takes a back burner in this entry in the series. As we discover, the killers and their rationale are both more than a bit nuts. Also, one of them is so completely unlikable that readers will find themselves hoping she is guilty of something from the very beginning, just so she gets what’s coming to her. And that’s well before we think she’s guilty of anything beyond being a bitch. The ending of the mystery occurs offstage, and loses a bit of its cathartic value at being reported second-hand.
From the moment in the first book in this series, Cat on the Edge, when Joe Grey uses his new-found voice to order delivery from his favorite deli and charges it to his human, the big grey tom snagged a piece of my heart in his claws, and he hasn’t let go yet.I hope that there will be a 20th book in this marvelous series, and soon. I enjoy my visits to Molena Point, and I can’t wait to see what trouble the kittens will get themselves, and their parents, and their humans, into next!
February 21, 2016
Joe and Dulcie are prowling the roofs of Molina Point looking the person who is knocking down the elderly. Dulcie is concerned about Joe's reaction to her news. Misto is dying and has a few prophecies. Pan and Kit travel to the Netherworld.Their human friends are busy trying to solve why someone is targeting the elderly and not robbing them. Mabel is out with surgery and her relief does not like cats. So access to Max office is not easy.
Looking forward to more adventures of Joe and friends.
Disclosure: I receive a free copy from the publisher through Edelweiss for an honest review. I would like to thank them for the opportunity to read and review this book. The opinions are my own.
Looking forward to more adventures of Joe and friends.
Disclosure: I receive a free copy from the publisher through Edelweiss for an honest review. I would like to thank them for the opportunity to read and review this book. The opinions are my own.
February 10, 2016
Princess Fuzzypants here:
Before there was Diesel or Hamlet or any of the many kitty heroes in the world of cozies, there was Joe Grey, Dulcie and Kit with all their friends human and furred.
It has been such a trip reading about their adventures from the time when they first discovered they could speak to their humans. Not only could they speak, but they turned out to be the most reliable snitches that the Molena Point PD ever had. From initial suspicion to eventual acceptance and respect, Police Chief, Max, has solved many crimes with their circumspect feline help.
Many humans share their secret but many do not, including aforementioned Max. Keeping their secret has been a challenge to all.
We have watched Joe and Dulcie fall in love. Now they are about to be parents and it's going to get harder to keep the secret. While Dulcie must take things easier, Joe is hot on the trail of a murderer who has disguised the real intentions with what appears to be random attacks on innocent seniors.
We've enjoyed all the books in the series but I purred even louder during this one. It's a good mystery with the usual subterfuge. But as Dulcie and Joe approach parenthood, it has an extra element of sweetness.
It is however bittersweet as one of the beloved characters must go to the Bridge. THe emotions ring true and the cats are drawn in a most believable way.
This is a series that should be savoured sequentially but even if this is your first foray, I know you will enjoy it.
Five big purrs and two paws up!
Before there was Diesel or Hamlet or any of the many kitty heroes in the world of cozies, there was Joe Grey, Dulcie and Kit with all their friends human and furred.
It has been such a trip reading about their adventures from the time when they first discovered they could speak to their humans. Not only could they speak, but they turned out to be the most reliable snitches that the Molena Point PD ever had. From initial suspicion to eventual acceptance and respect, Police Chief, Max, has solved many crimes with their circumspect feline help.
Many humans share their secret but many do not, including aforementioned Max. Keeping their secret has been a challenge to all.
We have watched Joe and Dulcie fall in love. Now they are about to be parents and it's going to get harder to keep the secret. While Dulcie must take things easier, Joe is hot on the trail of a murderer who has disguised the real intentions with what appears to be random attacks on innocent seniors.
We've enjoyed all the books in the series but I purred even louder during this one. It's a good mystery with the usual subterfuge. But as Dulcie and Joe approach parenthood, it has an extra element of sweetness.
It is however bittersweet as one of the beloved characters must go to the Bridge. THe emotions ring true and the cats are drawn in a most believable way.
This is a series that should be savoured sequentially but even if this is your first foray, I know you will enjoy it.
Five big purrs and two paws up!
March 19, 2016
I was delighted to find this book available as I try to follow the Joe Grey books. And I was not disappointed. Once again there are strange things going on and Joe Grey is quick on the ball to make sure that Molena Point's Police Department hears from their "snitch" about things that couldn't possibly have known any other way; helping them in a murder investigation.
Although all of the Joe Grey books are mostly about the cats this one has even less emphasis on the crimes, although Joe and a very pregnant Dulcie help out again.
Joe has noticed that his lady love is not quite herself and she finally tells him that " Kittens ... Kittens are coming". He runs around on the rooftop when she tells him and jumps for joy. Later when he returns home to his human companions he can't hide the smile he has and is at first annoyed with his housemates but then delighted to tell them that "Kittens are coming."
Meanwhile Joe and Dulcie's little tortie companion, Kit, is on adventure with the love of her life, Pan, as they explore the lowest regions where an area still has magic (this is probably the origins of the "talking" cats.)
Kit's housemates, Lucinda and Pedric have taken a cruise to Alsaska while Kit is away and both the humans and their feline companion can't wait to get home to each other.
Pan's father is a aged yellow Tom ,Misto, who does more than just "talk". His age has given him great wisdom and he has memories of his past lives plus insight into the future. The saddest part of the book is that Misto is dying but he tells Dulcie that her litter will be two boys and one calico girl who is very special, Courtney, who has had past lives as well.
Towards the end Joe is torn between his need to contact the Police with clues regarding the murders in Molena Point and his sense of obligation and love to Dulcie. Joe manages to do both: help the police to solve their case and be there for his lady love when he becomes a father. By then Kit and Pan and Lucinda and Pedric have returned and all are there to both witness Misto's passing to something new and better and later to welcome the new kittens.
A very satisfying read! I think any animal cozy lover will be enchanted reading this. For me, reading the Joe Grey books always makes feel closer to my own feline companions and to just for a second think perhaps they will become enchanted and say something to me. It makes me focus on the communication we do have and how I can be a good human companion to my three 17-year-old feline "babies".
Although all of the Joe Grey books are mostly about the cats this one has even less emphasis on the crimes, although Joe and a very pregnant Dulcie help out again.
Joe has noticed that his lady love is not quite herself and she finally tells him that " Kittens ... Kittens are coming". He runs around on the rooftop when she tells him and jumps for joy. Later when he returns home to his human companions he can't hide the smile he has and is at first annoyed with his housemates but then delighted to tell them that "Kittens are coming."
Meanwhile Joe and Dulcie's little tortie companion, Kit, is on adventure with the love of her life, Pan, as they explore the lowest regions where an area still has magic (this is probably the origins of the "talking" cats.)
Kit's housemates, Lucinda and Pedric have taken a cruise to Alsaska while Kit is away and both the humans and their feline companion can't wait to get home to each other.
Pan's father is a aged yellow Tom ,Misto, who does more than just "talk". His age has given him great wisdom and he has memories of his past lives plus insight into the future. The saddest part of the book is that Misto is dying but he tells Dulcie that her litter will be two boys and one calico girl who is very special, Courtney, who has had past lives as well.
Towards the end Joe is torn between his need to contact the Police with clues regarding the murders in Molena Point and his sense of obligation and love to Dulcie. Joe manages to do both: help the police to solve their case and be there for his lady love when he becomes a father. By then Kit and Pan and Lucinda and Pedric have returned and all are there to both witness Misto's passing to something new and better and later to welcome the new kittens.
A very satisfying read! I think any animal cozy lover will be enchanted reading this. For me, reading the Joe Grey books always makes feel closer to my own feline companions and to just for a second think perhaps they will become enchanted and say something to me. It makes me focus on the communication we do have and how I can be a good human companion to my three 17-year-old feline "babies".
January 17, 2016
I read this series off and on and this is a great addition. Joe and Dulcie are expecting kittens as they are trying to solve a series of muggings and murders. Misto has predicted that one of their newborns will be an incarnate of an ancient cat known for his wisdom. I love the idea that cats can speak to humans and are so intelligent. A wonderful addition to the Joe Grey series.
March 11, 2019
My reading group, Novel Conversations, selected animal stories for this month's discussion. It couldn't be a book that has animals in it, but must have part of the story told from the animal's viewpoint. I like cats, so I picked this mystery series. I have read other books in it, so the characters were familiar. The only conceit in the story is that some of the cats can talk. Otherwise, they behave like normal cats.
The mystery comes from pretty far afield. Somebody is running around town, knocking mostly old people down. There is no robbery. The victims are usually only hit once. But some of them have died. The police are at a loss because they can't figure a motive or a connection between the victims. Even when they just focus on the people who died they don't find anything beyond the fact they all moved to town recently. If not for Joe's evesdropping, they would have had to table the investigation. Joe, the cat, acts as an informant for the police chief, who does not know Joe is a cat.
As this series has gone on, it seems to me to be becoming more of a cozy than a police procedural with a cat informant. Even so, I like the series. Eventually I will read them all.
The mystery comes from pretty far afield. Somebody is running around town, knocking mostly old people down. There is no robbery. The victims are usually only hit once. But some of them have died. The police are at a loss because they can't figure a motive or a connection between the victims. Even when they just focus on the people who died they don't find anything beyond the fact they all moved to town recently. If not for Joe's evesdropping, they would have had to table the investigation. Joe, the cat, acts as an informant for the police chief, who does not know Joe is a cat.
As this series has gone on, it seems to me to be becoming more of a cozy than a police procedural with a cat informant. Even so, I like the series. Eventually I will read them all.
December 18, 2017
I hadn't read a Joe Grey book in awhile, and this is a good one, though not one of her best. As always, the best parts are the cats, and the long-running human characters. In this episode, Joe Grey and Dulcie have kittens! There's a murder mystery too, which strains WSOD at times. And a trip to Netherland, a fantasy underworld that didn't do much for me. After 19 books, I suppose it's hard to come up with a book's worth of fresh material. Cautiously recommended to fans. If you're new to the series, this wouldn't be the place to start.
July 12, 2019
I have been away from this series for awhile and now I remember why. Although the mystery is well developed and solved there is too much time devoted to the mysterious nature of the cats and the Netherworld. I also feel that as the series progressed too many humans were included in the secret of the talking cats. I liked the earlier books better where Clyde struggled to deal with Joel Grey’s talent.
December 24, 2023
Concept of this book was cute, idk if it was because I did not read the other books (even though it generally made sense on its own) but I just didn’t get that into it. Was just reading words
February 27, 2017
I chose to read Cat Shout for Joy by Shirley Rousseau Murphy for the 2017 Popsugar challenge - cat on the cover (four cats to be precise). This book is part of a long series of cat detective mysteries (number 19) - in which the talking cats of Molena Point - a small touristy town near Sans Francisco - help their human friends solve crime.
A prankster is pushing over elderly people in Molena Point, injuring and in some cases killing them. The Molena Point Police Department suspect that deadly pranks may be a cover for more targeted murders and their secret snitches, talking cats Joe Grey and Dulcie and (later) Kit, agree. The case takes a drastic turn when a friend is brutally murdered. In the meantime, the cats (who reveal their unique abilities to a trusted few) are sad that old Misto is dying (of cancer), Misto's son Pan and friend Kit are travelling in the fantastical underworld and Dulcie, Jo Grey's lady, is pregnant with kittens.
I enjoyed this gentle story. While clearly a lot has happened in previous books, I was able to understand what was going on without the author dumping too much backstory (occasionally a bit heavy). There were a lot of names to remember (which was confusing at times), but I liked the characters of the cats and their humans and there were many clever or humorous moments. At times, the cats and their human friends’ lives seemed to dominate the narrative, overshadowing the mystery - which wasn't particularly hard to solve. And the end seemed a bit dragged out as poetic justice was dealt, travellers returned and (mild spoiler- or maybe not really) kittens were born and named. Still, it was an entertaining read with a well-developed world in which a few cats can talk. And the cat characters were well done with lots of cat mannerisms and quirks.
An enjoyable book for a cat - or animal - lover (who doesn't quail at the occasional literary mouse and gopher snacks).
A prankster is pushing over elderly people in Molena Point, injuring and in some cases killing them. The Molena Point Police Department suspect that deadly pranks may be a cover for more targeted murders and their secret snitches, talking cats Joe Grey and Dulcie and (later) Kit, agree. The case takes a drastic turn when a friend is brutally murdered. In the meantime, the cats (who reveal their unique abilities to a trusted few) are sad that old Misto is dying (of cancer), Misto's son Pan and friend Kit are travelling in the fantastical underworld and Dulcie, Jo Grey's lady, is pregnant with kittens.
I enjoyed this gentle story. While clearly a lot has happened in previous books, I was able to understand what was going on without the author dumping too much backstory (occasionally a bit heavy). There were a lot of names to remember (which was confusing at times), but I liked the characters of the cats and their humans and there were many clever or humorous moments. At times, the cats and their human friends’ lives seemed to dominate the narrative, overshadowing the mystery - which wasn't particularly hard to solve. And the end seemed a bit dragged out as poetic justice was dealt, travellers returned and (mild spoiler- or maybe not really) kittens were born and named. Still, it was an entertaining read with a well-developed world in which a few cats can talk. And the cat characters were well done with lots of cat mannerisms and quirks.
An enjoyable book for a cat - or animal - lover (who doesn't quail at the occasional literary mouse and gopher snacks).
June 5, 2017
Molena Point, California is alive with the activities of its human and feline populations. Sentient cat Joe Grey’s lady love Dulcie has good news for everyone: she is expecting kittens! Joe Grey is beside himself with joy and wonder as Dulcie’s pregnancy progresses. However, they are saddened as the old yellow cat Misto is dieing. He says it is only his time on earth that is ending. He gives them many prophecies and says an exciting future awaits them all. He predicts that Dulcie will have three kittens, one of which will be a calico marked with the ancient markings of three black bands on her front paw. This kitten will have lived before and will bring an ancient adventurous spirit.
While everyone protects Dulcie and her unborn babies, their humans have their hands full with a mugger who attacks the elderly, leaving them injured and humiliated. When one victim dies, it becomes a homicide for Captain Max Harper and his men to solve. Of course, Joe Grey is there to help as the “snitch” who calls in tips to the Molena Point Police Department. The reader must suspend their disbelief over this community of talking cats. Their secret is only known by a select few humans, and they prefer to stay anonymous to protect their secret. Keeping silent can be a daunting task.
Kate Osborne is busy after buying the old Pamillon estate, including the ruins of the Pamillon mansion where the wild band of felines is currently living. It is on this estate that Ryan Flannery is building a new cat shelter to serve the volunteer effort of rescuing cats. During the noisy stages of building, several of the sentient feral cats lead Kit and her new beau Pan to the secret netherworld from whence the talking cats have arisen. It is a harrowing trip through tunnels, dark places, and decay. The cats above worry about their return. Misto, Pan’s father, knows they are safe and allays their fears.
This twentieth entry in the Joe Grey series is a bittersweet mix of happy and sad, endings and beginnings. As Misto passes from this world, Dulcie has her three kittens including the calico girl he predicted. The other two kittens are boys; one is named Striker and the other is Buffin, both tan colored tabbies. While the cats and their humans wonder over their birth, the rest of Molena Point is still plagued by the street prowler. With no witnesses and few clues, they are at a loss as to who the criminal is and why he is preying on the elderly.
Shirley Rousseau Murphy has written another enchanting tale which follows in the series beautifully. It can, however, also be read as a standalone mystery with some back story provided throughout. Mrs. Murphy creates a mystery full of twists and turns in the midst of a charming feline tale. There are many storylines swirled together. Narrator Susan Boyce leads us through them with ease.
Highly recommended.
While everyone protects Dulcie and her unborn babies, their humans have their hands full with a mugger who attacks the elderly, leaving them injured and humiliated. When one victim dies, it becomes a homicide for Captain Max Harper and his men to solve. Of course, Joe Grey is there to help as the “snitch” who calls in tips to the Molena Point Police Department. The reader must suspend their disbelief over this community of talking cats. Their secret is only known by a select few humans, and they prefer to stay anonymous to protect their secret. Keeping silent can be a daunting task.
Kate Osborne is busy after buying the old Pamillon estate, including the ruins of the Pamillon mansion where the wild band of felines is currently living. It is on this estate that Ryan Flannery is building a new cat shelter to serve the volunteer effort of rescuing cats. During the noisy stages of building, several of the sentient feral cats lead Kit and her new beau Pan to the secret netherworld from whence the talking cats have arisen. It is a harrowing trip through tunnels, dark places, and decay. The cats above worry about their return. Misto, Pan’s father, knows they are safe and allays their fears.
This twentieth entry in the Joe Grey series is a bittersweet mix of happy and sad, endings and beginnings. As Misto passes from this world, Dulcie has her three kittens including the calico girl he predicted. The other two kittens are boys; one is named Striker and the other is Buffin, both tan colored tabbies. While the cats and their humans wonder over their birth, the rest of Molena Point is still plagued by the street prowler. With no witnesses and few clues, they are at a loss as to who the criminal is and why he is preying on the elderly.
Shirley Rousseau Murphy has written another enchanting tale which follows in the series beautifully. It can, however, also be read as a standalone mystery with some back story provided throughout. Mrs. Murphy creates a mystery full of twists and turns in the midst of a charming feline tale. There are many storylines swirled together. Narrator Susan Boyce leads us through them with ease.
Highly recommended.
March 3, 2016
A light-hearted mystery that will tug at your heart-strings, CAT SHOUT FOR JOY by Shirley Rousseau Murphy will also keep you guessing as to the reason and the culprit of the crimes.
This delightful mystery features the antics and sleuthing techniques of a gray tomcat named Joe Grey and his dark striped companion Dulcie, along with several other furry investigating companions and a few humans.
This story begins with a mixture of emotions. Joe Grey and Dulcie’s friends, Pan (the red tomcat) and Kit (a tortoiseshell) are off on an adventure. Pan’s father Misto (the old yellow cat) is dying but isn’t afraid since he says he’s lived many lives. Joe Grey and Dulcie are expecting their first kittens and even though Dulcie hasn’t told Joe Grey yet, Misto tells her there will be three kittens and one will be a little calico girl who will be special.
Meanwhile, the humans in Molena Point are having their own problems too. What starts out as a street prowler attacking the elderly in the village soon escalates to murder when one of the victims dies. With no witnesses and no clues, the humans and felines are at a loss as to who the killer is and why they are attacking the elderly.
Author Shirley Rousseau Murphy does an excellent job blending the cats’ adventures with the humans’ activities to create a plausible world where the four-legged sleuths aide in the investigations. The story moves at a steady pace and holds your attention with its twists and turns.
The characters are well-developed and likable. The small town setting adds charm and enhances the story. The author’s rich descriptions and eye for detail makes the reader feel a part of the adventure.
You don’t have to be a cat lover to enjoy this tantalizing tale. In addition, CAT SHOUT FOR JOY is a standalone read and it’s not necessary to have read the previous book in order to keep up with the story.
Cats and humans, criminals and murder all combined with morsels of humor, a little sadness and a celebration to create an entertaining mystery you won’t be able to put down.
FTC Full Disclosure – A copy of this book was sent to me by the publisher in hopes I would review it. However, receiving the complimentary copy did not influence my review. The thoughts are completely my own and given honestly and freely.
This delightful mystery features the antics and sleuthing techniques of a gray tomcat named Joe Grey and his dark striped companion Dulcie, along with several other furry investigating companions and a few humans.
This story begins with a mixture of emotions. Joe Grey and Dulcie’s friends, Pan (the red tomcat) and Kit (a tortoiseshell) are off on an adventure. Pan’s father Misto (the old yellow cat) is dying but isn’t afraid since he says he’s lived many lives. Joe Grey and Dulcie are expecting their first kittens and even though Dulcie hasn’t told Joe Grey yet, Misto tells her there will be three kittens and one will be a little calico girl who will be special.
Meanwhile, the humans in Molena Point are having their own problems too. What starts out as a street prowler attacking the elderly in the village soon escalates to murder when one of the victims dies. With no witnesses and no clues, the humans and felines are at a loss as to who the killer is and why they are attacking the elderly.
Author Shirley Rousseau Murphy does an excellent job blending the cats’ adventures with the humans’ activities to create a plausible world where the four-legged sleuths aide in the investigations. The story moves at a steady pace and holds your attention with its twists and turns.
The characters are well-developed and likable. The small town setting adds charm and enhances the story. The author’s rich descriptions and eye for detail makes the reader feel a part of the adventure.
You don’t have to be a cat lover to enjoy this tantalizing tale. In addition, CAT SHOUT FOR JOY is a standalone read and it’s not necessary to have read the previous book in order to keep up with the story.
Cats and humans, criminals and murder all combined with morsels of humor, a little sadness and a celebration to create an entertaining mystery you won’t be able to put down.
FTC Full Disclosure – A copy of this book was sent to me by the publisher in hopes I would review it. However, receiving the complimentary copy did not influence my review. The thoughts are completely my own and given honestly and freely.
February 27, 2016
An intriguing magical story.
Molena Point, California has had an increase in attacks. What makes these attacks interesting is that the victims are all elderly. They are attacked when they are alone, at different times of the day. The attacks involve being hit on the head and pushed down. There’s no robbery and the perpetrator seemingly disappears. Unfortunately, several of the attacks have lead to the victims’ deaths. Police are at a loss as to what’s going on and why. It’s time for Joe Grey and his cat friends to get involved.
Cat Shout for Joy is the 19th book in the Joe Grey Mystery series. However, it is the first book I’ve read. For the most part, I found the story to be a standalone read. I did, however, find myself being a little confused and intrigued by the magical cats (Misto, Joe Grey, Dulcie, Pan, and Kit). It took me awhile to understand where they came from and what their abilities were. To say I was completely fascinated with them would be an understatement. Each cat has their own personality and demeanor, making them all individuals. They all have a need to investigate and love their humans madly.
I liked the plot and storyline. I found the mystery to be good with a couple of misdirects thrown in. I’m not sure I can say I liked the way the mystery was resolved, but I can say justice was served. Cat Shout for Joy balanced the death of wise and charming Misto well with the birth of Joe Grey and Dulcie’s kittens. While Misto dying is sad, he was happy, comfortable, and ready to move on to a new world/adventure. For me, that in and of itself made his passing less sad.
Cat Shout for Joy marks my first time reading about an animal doing any type of investigation. It’s different from the normal cozy mysteries I read. I loved that the cats could talk, read, and knew how to do normal human things. I looking forward to reading more books like this.
**Received a copy of the book courtesy of William Morrow for an honest and unbiased opinion.**
Molena Point, California has had an increase in attacks. What makes these attacks interesting is that the victims are all elderly. They are attacked when they are alone, at different times of the day. The attacks involve being hit on the head and pushed down. There’s no robbery and the perpetrator seemingly disappears. Unfortunately, several of the attacks have lead to the victims’ deaths. Police are at a loss as to what’s going on and why. It’s time for Joe Grey and his cat friends to get involved.
Cat Shout for Joy is the 19th book in the Joe Grey Mystery series. However, it is the first book I’ve read. For the most part, I found the story to be a standalone read. I did, however, find myself being a little confused and intrigued by the magical cats (Misto, Joe Grey, Dulcie, Pan, and Kit). It took me awhile to understand where they came from and what their abilities were. To say I was completely fascinated with them would be an understatement. Each cat has their own personality and demeanor, making them all individuals. They all have a need to investigate and love their humans madly.
I liked the plot and storyline. I found the mystery to be good with a couple of misdirects thrown in. I’m not sure I can say I liked the way the mystery was resolved, but I can say justice was served. Cat Shout for Joy balanced the death of wise and charming Misto well with the birth of Joe Grey and Dulcie’s kittens. While Misto dying is sad, he was happy, comfortable, and ready to move on to a new world/adventure. For me, that in and of itself made his passing less sad.
Cat Shout for Joy marks my first time reading about an animal doing any type of investigation. It’s different from the normal cozy mysteries I read. I loved that the cats could talk, read, and knew how to do normal human things. I looking forward to reading more books like this.
**Received a copy of the book courtesy of William Morrow for an honest and unbiased opinion.**
March 15, 2016
Someone seems to be pranking the elderly. Sneaking up behind them and surprising them. Unfortunately the surprises start getting more and more vicious until they start dying. It’s up to Joe Grey and the team to figure out who is causing the deaths and to find out why.
On top of this, Joe and Dulcie are expecting kittens. There is some stress about the whole parenthood thing along with if the kittens will be able to talk and how to keep their secret safe. But it is also bitter sweet since it is coming to the time for Misto to go over the Rainbow Bridge, but not before a couple predictions.
I have been meaning to read the Joe Grey mysteries for a while but I have never gotten around to them. So, when I was asked to review Cat Shout for Joy I was doing a happy dance. I loved the mystery, it was a good who-dunnit and I was kept guessing until the end. But I found most of the story revolved around Joe and Dulcie’s kittens and the passing of Misto.
I loved the mystery and want to start the series from the beginning. But as a cat lover it was just like being home and interacting with my furry children. This is a great story and if you like cozy mysteries and cats you will love this book.
I received Cat Shout for Joy for free from the publisher and Edelwise in exchange for an honest review.
On top of this, Joe and Dulcie are expecting kittens. There is some stress about the whole parenthood thing along with if the kittens will be able to talk and how to keep their secret safe. But it is also bitter sweet since it is coming to the time for Misto to go over the Rainbow Bridge, but not before a couple predictions.
I have been meaning to read the Joe Grey mysteries for a while but I have never gotten around to them. So, when I was asked to review Cat Shout for Joy I was doing a happy dance. I loved the mystery, it was a good who-dunnit and I was kept guessing until the end. But I found most of the story revolved around Joe and Dulcie’s kittens and the passing of Misto.
I loved the mystery and want to start the series from the beginning. But as a cat lover it was just like being home and interacting with my furry children. This is a great story and if you like cozy mysteries and cats you will love this book.
I received Cat Shout for Joy for free from the publisher and Edelwise in exchange for an honest review.
May 10, 2017
Can't wait for the next in the series! Will be fun to know more of the kittens' story!
FYI:
The first book in the series introduces Joe and Dulcie and tell how they realized they could speak.
They and other characters (including the humans!) are best understood when reading the series roughly in order. Don't miss "Cat On The Money" (#6.5) which can be read online at http://www.joegrey.com/money01.htm. (link accurate at the time of this review.)
For more of Misto's story, read "The Cat, the devil and Lee Fontana" and "The Cat, the devil and the Last Escape." They fit in before #17 Tales or #18 Gifts, but I read them later.
The "Catswold Portol" is not tied to the Joe Grey series except its setting is the underground world mentioned in some books.
All books written by Shirley Rousseau Murphy. He husband J.J. co wrote the Fontana books.
Enjoy!
FYI:
The first book in the series introduces Joe and Dulcie and tell how they realized they could speak.
They and other characters (including the humans!) are best understood when reading the series roughly in order. Don't miss "Cat On The Money" (#6.5) which can be read online at http://www.joegrey.com/money01.htm. (link accurate at the time of this review.)
For more of Misto's story, read "The Cat, the devil and Lee Fontana" and "The Cat, the devil and the Last Escape." They fit in before #17 Tales or #18 Gifts, but I read them later.
The "Catswold Portol" is not tied to the Joe Grey series except its setting is the underground world mentioned in some books.
All books written by Shirley Rousseau Murphy. He husband J.J. co wrote the Fontana books.
Enjoy!
March 15, 2016
Senior citizens are being attacked in Molina Point. Someone is sneaking up on them, pushing them over and vanishing leaving no clues. The police and the cats are baffled and angry.
Then a couple of the victims end up dead.
Are the attacks random? Were the deaths accidents?
Another victim is shot. The hunt is on for the motive as this was no accident.
As usual there are numerous subplots. Some feed into the main plot. Others are part of the series stories.
Even though the book is part of a series, it does stand on its own. Some of the meaning will be lost if previous ones are skipped.
The plot may be a murder mystery but the cats take center stage. They add a depth to the book a mere mystery wouldn't have.
The book is a fast, good read for cat mystery fans who don't mind a bit of fantasy thrown into the mix.
Then a couple of the victims end up dead.
Are the attacks random? Were the deaths accidents?
Another victim is shot. The hunt is on for the motive as this was no accident.
As usual there are numerous subplots. Some feed into the main plot. Others are part of the series stories.
Even though the book is part of a series, it does stand on its own. Some of the meaning will be lost if previous ones are skipped.
The plot may be a murder mystery but the cats take center stage. They add a depth to the book a mere mystery wouldn't have.
The book is a fast, good read for cat mystery fans who don't mind a bit of fantasy thrown into the mix.
January 17, 2016
There has been a series of attacks on the elderly in Molena Point.When one of the victims dies it becomes a homicide investigation.The crime solving cats help out the police with anonymous phone calls giving helpful info.This was my first experience with the Joe Grey mysteries and anthropomorphic animals.I enjoyed this unique mystery and am planning to read the rest of the series to get the background and history of the characters,especially the cats.I was enchanted by Joe Grey,his mate Dulcie,friend Misto and the other magical talking cats.
February 28, 2016
This series just keeps getting better. If you are new to these stories, you really need to read them in order to understand the evolving plotlines. Talking cats! Really! In this series it doesn't really seem so outlandish. And you've got to love the interaction between the cats and their humans. Especially when one is giving the other the "hairy eyeball". It isn't murder at its best, but it's a fun, relaxing way to keep the outside world at bay, and maybe dream just a little of a world of talking cats.
March 9, 2016
I've read all of the Joe Grey series and have loved each one. This one is no different. Its a mystery and Joe Grey is a talking cat. He always gets involved with the solving the dilemma. Some of the humans in the book know Joe and a few of his friends can talk but most don't. Joe and the others can only speak at times when no one else is around except their owners. As a result Joe is a CI and calls in his findings. The Chief of Police doesn't know its a cat he's talking to, but has trusted the info that's been called to him. Its mystery reading on a lighter side.
November 4, 2016
Cat Shout for Joy begins a new episode in the Joe Grey saga. A terrible villain, a reunited family, a loss and a gain. I'm holding my breath until the next book comes.
There are 2 reasons why it took so long for me to read this book: firstly, I love SRM's work so much that I savor each page; second, this book deals with a difficult cat situation close to my heart (no spoilers).
There are 2 reasons why it took so long for me to read this book: firstly, I love SRM's work so much that I savor each page; second, this book deals with a difficult cat situation close to my heart (no spoilers).
March 2, 2016
I enjoyed this the most out of the recent additions to the series. Brought together many of the recurring storylines. These are entertaining believable cozy mysteries without any silliness. I like the animal rescue and Celtic mythology subplots.
March 18, 2016
One of her best involving these adorable cats! I absolutely love this series but not one of my friends, co-workers or family members are readers, let alone are anywhere near understanding the concept of "talking" cats. Well done Shirley!
March 23, 2016
I have read every one of the Joe Grey books and also The Catsworld Portal. I so look forward to each new one and this one didn't disappoint. I have to admit to shedding some tears. I just may read this book a second time before returning it to the library.
March 2, 2016
This is one of the series I always pre-order from Kindle as soon as it is announced. It never disappoints.
June 17, 2017
3.3 stars. I'm a longtime fan of this light, cozy, but not-too-silly mystery series. Though I've found some installments more gripping or appealing than others, it's always nice to visit Molena Point's talking cats and their friends and allies, some in on the secret and others not. Suspense-plot-wise, this one is average or a smidge below, but there are emotional developments to balance that.
I guessed part of the motivation (), but not the details, and when we learned more, it didn't really have any greater impact than the basic premise of the M.O. — attacks on vulnerable, mainly elderly, people — did from the start. That should have, if anything, been written more powerfully, so we'd really feel the anger and determination of all those trying to catch and stop the perpetrator[s]. If you're familiar with my reviews, you know I rarely discuss much of the plot, though.
Here are my random positive and negative musings...
Aged Misto, struck by a fast-moving feline cancer, is more serene about his approaching death than those who love him can be, though they do their best. His memories of past lives and adventures make him eager for what lies ahead. SRM once again inserts a bit of "message": if your pet is in terrible pain, ease their passage with a gentle death, surrounded by love, rather than prolonging their suffering. I'm not fully behind the trap-neuter-release feral-cat policy she also espouses (knowing how much wildlife falls victim to the depredations of a species introduced into the vulnerable ecosystem by human disregard), but this I can support, even more when you're NOT talking about sentient beings with intellectual understanding of their circumstances.
Both Joe and Dulcie feel a mix of joy and worry about their impending parenthood: hopes and pride in the babies, which will probably (but not definitely) be rare, miraculous, talking kittens, vs. concern over how Dulcie's physical changes and the new responsibilities will restrict the active and risk-taking lives they're used to leading. Yet their human friends' care is a bit stifling.
N.b., Misto predicts that one of their kittens will be a calico girl with a great destiny. Joe, as usual, is amusingly discomfited by such mysticality intruding on his life. What struck me as incongruous, though, was the name that Misto says she has borne before, "throughout much of time": Courtney. It's a perfectly nice name, but seriously, who believes that's an appellation with timeless resonance?!
As to the other timeless/ mystical/ fantastical plot-thread that underlies the series, the Netherworld where the talking cats' origins lie, and many other impossible creatures and beings dwell, I'm glad it doesn't play a bigger part "onscreen" this time. I like high fantasy, too, but it doesn't seem to fit with the mainly-realistic tales of a contemporary town. Kit and Misto's son Pan have, at the beginning of the book, recently left to brave an exploration there, but we only see a bit of their return, and hear a few stories they recount afterwards. This may disappoint some readers, but not me; I was like, not dwarves and harpies, please. (Was that friendly harpy as big as a roc, BTW, or at least definitely bigger than a human? She flew carrying nine cats at once on one occasion, apparently.)
One note re. another of the author's questionable minor "messages": Kit and Pan wax idealistic over their hopes that the free farmers of the one Netherworld nation not crushed by the abuses of a ruler will someday rise and restore the whole Netherworld's light and magic. I however, must pragmatically point out that anarchy (no leadership) doesn't tend to work long term among large-scale groups, nor in non-annihilation-type military efforts. Reasonable taxes, for example, allow for social services (such as the police, you know!) — even Mercedes Lackey recognizes that fact; see The Lark and the Wren. Maybe I'm reading too much into the fact that the only Netherworld leaders mentioned were those corrupted by greed and evil, but how does SRM imagine this revolution working?
Still, the story was overall entertaining, with some touching interactions. My quibbles are re. far-from-central points. I certainly will be reading the new book as soon as I can. (This was a belated reading of last year's volume, because I didn't realize we'd missed it until I saw the latest announced as forthcoming soon, and talking about kittens — oops!)
Hardcover read from the library. Will I reread it, and/or buy the paperback? Maybe.
I guessed part of the motivation (), but not the details, and when we learned more, it didn't really have any greater impact than the basic premise of the M.O. — attacks on vulnerable, mainly elderly, people — did from the start. That should have, if anything, been written more powerfully, so we'd really feel the anger and determination of all those trying to catch and stop the perpetrator[s]. If you're familiar with my reviews, you know I rarely discuss much of the plot, though.
Here are my random positive and negative musings...
Aged Misto, struck by a fast-moving feline cancer, is more serene about his approaching death than those who love him can be, though they do their best. His memories of past lives and adventures make him eager for what lies ahead. SRM once again inserts a bit of "message": if your pet is in terrible pain, ease their passage with a gentle death, surrounded by love, rather than prolonging their suffering. I'm not fully behind the trap-neuter-release feral-cat policy she also espouses (knowing how much wildlife falls victim to the depredations of a species introduced into the vulnerable ecosystem by human disregard), but this I can support, even more when you're NOT talking about sentient beings with intellectual understanding of their circumstances.
Both Joe and Dulcie feel a mix of joy and worry about their impending parenthood: hopes and pride in the babies, which will probably (but not definitely) be rare, miraculous, talking kittens, vs. concern over how Dulcie's physical changes and the new responsibilities will restrict the active and risk-taking lives they're used to leading. Yet their human friends' care is a bit stifling.
N.b., Misto predicts that one of their kittens will be a calico girl with a great destiny. Joe, as usual, is amusingly discomfited by such mysticality intruding on his life. What struck me as incongruous, though, was the name that Misto says she has borne before, "throughout much of time": Courtney. It's a perfectly nice name, but seriously, who believes that's an appellation with timeless resonance?!
As to the other timeless/ mystical/ fantastical plot-thread that underlies the series, the Netherworld where the talking cats' origins lie, and many other impossible creatures and beings dwell, I'm glad it doesn't play a bigger part "onscreen" this time. I like high fantasy, too, but it doesn't seem to fit with the mainly-realistic tales of a contemporary town. Kit and Misto's son Pan have, at the beginning of the book, recently left to brave an exploration there, but we only see a bit of their return, and hear a few stories they recount afterwards. This may disappoint some readers, but not me; I was like, not dwarves and harpies, please. (Was that friendly harpy as big as a roc, BTW, or at least definitely bigger than a human? She flew carrying nine cats at once on one occasion, apparently.)
One note re. another of the author's questionable minor "messages": Kit and Pan wax idealistic over their hopes that the free farmers of the one Netherworld nation not crushed by the abuses of a ruler will someday rise and restore the whole Netherworld's light and magic. I however, must pragmatically point out that anarchy (no leadership) doesn't tend to work long term among large-scale groups, nor in non-annihilation-type military efforts. Reasonable taxes, for example, allow for social services (such as the police, you know!) — even Mercedes Lackey recognizes that fact; see The Lark and the Wren. Maybe I'm reading too much into the fact that the only Netherworld leaders mentioned were those corrupted by greed and evil, but how does SRM imagine this revolution working?
Still, the story was overall entertaining, with some touching interactions. My quibbles are re. far-from-central points. I certainly will be reading the new book as soon as I can. (This was a belated reading of last year's volume, because I didn't realize we'd missed it until I saw the latest announced as forthcoming soon, and talking about kittens — oops!)
Hardcover read from the library. Will I reread it, and/or buy the paperback? Maybe.
February 16, 2018
Ok, apparently I started with #19 of a series. Honestly, not sure how this series has lasted so long. I love cats, but that wasn't enough to make up for the sheer stupidity in this book. I'm fine with the talking cats, less fine with morphing the cats into pseudo-human in their sensibilities, but what the heck was with the mystery?? It was so illogical! Ben was taking photos of SHOES?? The police somehow missed that the convicted rapist/killer had a MOTHER? Not only a mother, but apparently a father and brother also???? I would also like to note that it's ridiculous that so many elderly people were serving on a jury at one time. And that half of them moved to the same tiny town. And that Ben happened to take notes about them. And after getting shot in the head was able to hide his notebook/diary and phone without the killer seeing him. The whole rationale behind all of it was completely ludicrous.
August 6, 2017
When I’m reading a series, I don’t normally write reviews for individual books, but this one was so good that it deserves its own entry.
The theme of the book reminds me of the old Ben Casey series opening: Man, Woman, Birth, Death…Infinity.
I can’t really review the book without giving any of the plot line away, but I found the story compelling and the mystery to be top-notch. I will say that it’s sad in some places, joyful in others. The book is a contrast of good versus evil, birth versus death, life fulfilled versus a life of revenge.
As good as this book is, this is not the book to start the series, but if you make your way through the series as I have (and I’m finally all caught up!), it’s well worth the journey.
The theme of the book reminds me of the old Ben Casey series opening: Man, Woman, Birth, Death…Infinity.
I can’t really review the book without giving any of the plot line away, but I found the story compelling and the mystery to be top-notch. I will say that it’s sad in some places, joyful in others. The book is a contrast of good versus evil, birth versus death, life fulfilled versus a life of revenge.
As good as this book is, this is not the book to start the series, but if you make your way through the series as I have (and I’m finally all caught up!), it’s well worth the journey.
May 11, 2018
This book actually deserves a 4 1/2 star rating but the system doesn't do halves. It's not quite a five by my reckoning because I want the killer's motive to be fleshed out more. Why did her family go along with her? Where did Arnold come from? There was no mention that he was related to her son the killer. Was he actually her son. Big age difference if he was. Why was she having the house remodelled? Was she actually planning to live in Molena Point after she killed some the people that lived there? Did she really think she could live there and not be discovered?
I was sad that Misto and Ben both died. Upsetting just like they just killed off a well liked character from a TV show I like.
Happy about Courtney, Buffin and Stryker! Looking forward to what develops with them!
I was sad that Misto and Ben both died. Upsetting just like they just killed off a well liked character from a TV show I like.
Happy about Courtney, Buffin and Stryker! Looking forward to what develops with them!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 31, 2023
This is the 19th book in this beloved cozy cat series by Shirley Roussou Murphy. I have read the entire series and always enjoy returning to Joel Grey, Dulcie and their human counterparts. This next in series is adventure for the cats, new life, saying goodbye to a dear old cat friend and investigating crimes against the elderly in Carmel Village. The author has a special talent for writing of cats and their habits. She writes atmospheric and beauitfully of Carmel and all its charms.
This series is a pure delight from start to finish. Great characters, a beautiful setting of Carmel and lots of intriquing sleuthing. I look forward to the next in series.
Pure catnip for cozy cat lovers.
This series is a pure delight from start to finish. Great characters, a beautiful setting of Carmel and lots of intriquing sleuthing. I look forward to the next in series.
Pure catnip for cozy cat lovers.
July 24, 2017
Joe and Dulcie prepare for an exciting event.
With the attacks on the elderly residents of Molina Point, Joel Grey and the talking cats band together to try to find the absolute evil person that is causing all of the strife among the e elderly residents. Along the way Kit and Pan have gone to the netherworld only Misto is coming to the end and everyone is worried that Kit and Pan won't be able to get back in time. Dulcie finally takes Joel in her confidence. Three people have succumbed to the attacks. Are they at random? Are they on purpose? Need to read to find out. I could not put this book down.
With the attacks on the elderly residents of Molina Point, Joel Grey and the talking cats band together to try to find the absolute evil person that is causing all of the strife among the e elderly residents. Along the way Kit and Pan have gone to the netherworld only Misto is coming to the end and everyone is worried that Kit and Pan won't be able to get back in time. Dulcie finally takes Joel in her confidence. Three people have succumbed to the attacks. Are they at random? Are they on purpose? Need to read to find out. I could not put this book down.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 104 reviews