What do you think?
Rate this book


320 pages, Hardcover
First published November 1, 2016
Of all the powerful spells that fiction casts upon us - absorbing plots, believable characters, vivid language - one of the least celebrated is its ability to make us feel transported to another time and place. — Laura Miller
How to review this book?
This is a book that doesn't quite know what it wants to be. With so many contributors it was going to take a serious effort to keep the book consistent. It appears to me like the range of contributors were just asked to write about the world of the book without being asked to answer any specific questions. Some discuss the cultural influence, some the world-building, some the world itself, some the plot and some a mix of two or more. A few like the section on Almut raise good points but don't fully explain them. By the end of the book, I found my interest in the section depended on the contributor writing it and which angle they took. But the art and imagery is well chosen and breaks up the words. The portraits are a nice touch. The is also a nice variety in the books chosen, as a librarian, I knew nearly all the titles even if I knew little about the books themselves.
What I will say is that it did make me want to read quite a few of the titles in it, Some like Peter Pan in Kensington Gardens because I didn't know they existed, others like Metamorphoses and The Thousand and One Nights because of their cultural impact, others like 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea, A Wizard of Earthsea and The Divine Comedy were written in ways that intrigued me. Others like The Bloody Chamber and other stories, Herland and Kindred just pushed my buttons. Neuromancer especially was intriguing after watching Dicebreaker play Cyberpunk Red (oh Matt don't change).
I want to say I didn't hate this, I think I'm just kinda neutral about it. Maybe I read it too fast, maybe it's not what I wanted/expected/needed. If it appeals to you try reading it. It's not a bad book, it's just not for me.
I leave to others all the sordid and uninteresting worries about so-called practical life, and share with you those joys and experiences which make that life desirable... but seriously, what can you have been thinking about when you said 'only' books, music, etc., just as if these weren't the real things! — C.S. Lewis
A representative gif: