An in-depth history of one of Canada's World War II internment camps that held both Nazis and anti-Nazis alike. For eighteen months during the Second World War, the Canadian military interned 1,145 prisoners of war in Red Rock, Ontario (about 100 kilometres northeast of Thunder Bay). Camp R interned friend and foe Nazis, anti-Nazis, Jews, soldiers, merchant seamen, and refugees whom Britain feared might comprise Hitler's rumoured "fifth column" of alien enemies residing within the Commonwealth. For the first time and in riveting detail, the author illuminates the conditions in one of Canada's forgotten POW camps. Backed by interviews and meticulous archival research, Zimmermann fleshes out this rich history in an accessible, lively manner. The Little Third Reich on Lake Superior will captivate military and political historians as well as non-specialists interested in the history of POWs and internment in Canada. "Most of us have an image of what prisoner of war camps looked like, either from documentary footage about Nazi POW camps, or feature films about World War II, or television situation comedies. The Little Third Reich on Lake Superior shatters all of those stereotypes and, through diligent assembly of public records, multiple library archives and personal interviews, gives us an in-depth picture of a Canadian internment camp. All of this is skillfully organized in a reader-friendly, chronological way." —Michael Sabota, Chronicle Journal "The study shines light on the lesser-known Canadian prisoner of war (POW) camps in World War II. In this well-researched study, Zimmermann describes not only Camp R, but the inmates, guards, military command structure, politicians, and general political environment in Canada and Britain. . . . The work is easy to read and deftly supported by a broad array of sources. Zimmermann's analysis encompasses Canadian and British history. . . . The Little Third Reich on Lake Superior sets a high standard for future research into civilian internment camps." —Anna Marie Anderson, The Journal of Military History
Took a while to read but it was interesting and decently engaging for an academic book. I feel like my understanding of the internment experience during WWII is more nuanced now, although still far from complete.
I found this book randomly at a library in Edmonton and it's actually a great read.
Some slow parts. However, if you can get past the minutiae while maintaining a grasp on the scale of this issue, it is actually quite the page turner. Especially between 1/4 and 3/4's the way through.
Very informative.
Found it to be rather anti-British during WWII, but enlighteningly so. The predicament they put Canada through, imprisoning and deporting "Nazi's" to camps we had not had time to prepare for to protect them from imminent invasion. Or so we thought. We learn they sent also German merchant seamen, Anti-Nazi and Jewish refugees, and first Generation Brits emigrated from Germany who were all deported and Canada was not provided information for. Not even transcripts of the laughable tribunals they had to categorize the deportees. It took over half a year to get any info of the internees, and the Canadian Military primarily but also the government at the time (William Lyon Mackenzie King for those interested) had quite the predicament to roll through.
Learning about life inside this particular camp was enlightening. You learn about some noble people, German, Jewish, British and Canadian alike. Of course, some not so much.
Learning about the attitudes of the public at the time within Britain and Canada, the anti-semitism and fifth columnist delusions at the time, in particular, were of great interest to me.
I did not know the story of the Arandora Star prior to this book, and that is quite the WWII tale.
Great book. Great story around the release of the book after the authors passing as well.
Thanks for the awesome read!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
This is a well-researched book about the heterogenous internment of German non-combatants during WWII. Many mistakes were made as the British netted and imprisoned a wide range of Germans - Jews, Nazis, anti-Nazis deported to and imprisoned by Canada. Many mistakes were made, as we can see in retrospect. A very detailed and very fair analysis.
An informative micro-study of a short-lived Canadian camp for internees who were perceived as prisoners-of-war. Though the study suffers in places from a lack of data being available, it provides a pretty interesting view into an understudied aspect of Canada's WWII experience.