Rating is for all the works of Stuart McGill I have read so far.
It’s what it says on the cover: evidence based back health… but also a lot more.
To some extent the writing is lacking, it’s more for a general audience than professionals. But this only means there is less Kauderwelsch and more down to earth sentences. Also some insight into legal matters, although not detailed it will make some decisions by doctors very see-through for the patient.
Most clinical evidence in the book also appears to reflect whatever professional athletes and workers practice.
Doctors would say the deadlift is dangerous, practice says the form makes weights less dangerous and so does this book backed by research.
It was about time an engineer looked into how the body works.
If I could go back in time I would take Arnold’s book from my hands after finishing it, slap myself as hard as needed to sober up and put “Ultimate back fitness and performance” into my hands.
Either way, buyer beware: all the works heavily deal with dynamic disc bulges, or the flexion type of back hurt with only minor mentions of other types of issues. This is me included whose master clinician found I was actually extension intolerant and had bad hips.
Information in the books is very needed though as I would have offended myself less and had been off happier if I had not heeded to locally acknowledged medicine based on mythological claims by “musings of individuals who have reached the end of their expertise” as McGill puts it.
If you know someone with back troubles, stop sending them instagram reels from randos and send them a podcast with the Doc on it - it’ll help more.