When your grandparents make bathtub gin and go shopping with funny money, and your dad flaunts his degree from the school of hard knocks, you grow up learning that "life ain't no got-dem picnic." These lessons are handed down to Cathy Curran by Eastern European immigrants who learned how to survive, caring little for aesthetics-"if it worrrks, who gives a got-dem what da hell it looks like." Lucky for Curran, her mother is a gentle soul with a dry wit. Lillian Low's homespun values-people come in all flavors just like ice cream-bring joy and humor into the Low house. When restless Joe Low ditches one suburb for another because he wants a do-over, Lillian tells him, "How the hell many do you need? Don't you know that wherever you go, you've got to take yourself with you?" Along for the ride is the colorful, extended Low clan, who turn up to celebrate the arrival of Joe and Lillian's army of kids. They eat, sing, Joe gets plastered, and all too often, scotch-fired arguments lead to some good old-fashioned fistfights. The mayhem that actually started the brawl gets swept under the carpet, and when Curran finally pulls it up, pandemonium emerges from hell with a vengeance. Through the vision of a sensitive young girl with a wickedly funny voice, "Secondhand Scotch" uncorks some harsh realities, but never ceases to warm and entertain.
I couldn't put this Memoir down, it's very well written - I love the 'warts & all' way it's presented. The dynamics between the Author, her siblings and especially her parents and grandparents are hard-hitting, loving, turbulent, 'scary' and it's all put together so well. Eastern European immigrants - settling in the US is where it begins. Joe, the father, is so complex at times - is going to make his million and as well as having regular work - also likes making his own deals. The family, despite growing in number, move around quite a bit initially - it's a tough tough life. Scotch can be a real 'deal-breaker' a mind-changer - turn a pussy-cat into a bear in a matter of minutes but cannot be blamed for the 'way you have learnt from your own upbringing' - rather than 'change' attitudes - they just get carried forward through families - its tough. I really felt for the Author, her mum and her siblings - and in a funny way I could really picture Joe, the Author's dad - I could see him smiling (on the odd occasion) - standing in the bar... yelling, fighting, dealing out the licks !! feel his anger ready to explode (and despite it all kind-of get how you do love this person) - I personally think that's down to good writing and I know it's what can happen. Can't explain clearly enough the impact this Memoir made. I also loved the way the language is used. I have no problem recommending this book and I really want to read more by this Author.
Written over a ten year period, this extraordinarily well-researched memoir tells the story of the author’s Eastern European family from the late 1800s when, as immigrants, they settle in the United States.
With very little money but an uncompromisingly tough attitude, and great resourcefulness to back them up, her great grandparents survive and create decent lives. But it is hard, especially for the children. Each family member is expected to pull their weight and failure to do so results in a summary beating. This is the culture that Cathy’s father, Joe, is born into. Rather than learning from the mistakes of his Russian father, Joe adopts the same approach in his own life.
Joe marries Lillian, a beautiful young lady of Armenian and Greek descent who has a personality that combines a dry wit with a strong sense of family traditions. Both coming from large families, they follow suit and produce nine children of their own. Cathy is one of these. We learn through her young eyes about their turbulent upbringing with a father who works hard, drinks hard and often vents his violent passions on his wife and family. She also gives us an insight into her sibling relationships, one sister of whom is plagued by jealousy and treacherous inclinations which leads to dreadful consequences. But the book is not solely an account of family abuse.
Cathy gives an insight into the riotous experiences they have with other family members at clan reunions. With a multitude of eccentric cousins, aunts, uncles and grandparents it’s a time for socialising and fun. It’s time for singing, dancing, eating and telling stories. But it’s also a time for drinking. All too frequently they end up in a fistfight as Joe succumbs once again to the excesses of scotch whisky.
There are several intriguing questions in this book; will Cathy hate her father for the rest of her life? Will her mother eventually divorce Joe and take her brood of nine children away? Will the sibling rivalries and jealousies ever be resolved, and will Cathy adopt the very same behaviours handed down by her grand-father and her father?
This book has a number of themes which are richly woven together by an extremely gifted author. Cathy Curran describes events and emotions with such eloquence that I quickly engaged with each character. Some I disliked intensely, some made me laugh and others I admired and liked very much. I felt the pain that each child went through at the hands of their often cruel father and understood the anguish that Cathy must have felt having to stand up for herself and her siblings. There must have been times in her life when things seemed utterly hopeless.
But this book does not solely focus on pain and distress; it is also peppered with wry humour, examples of childhood courage and examples of the very special traditions that kept the family going.
To me it is as impressive as a comment on social history as it is personal memoir. I was gripped throughout and powerfully moved by the content. To that end I have no hesitation in recommending this book and giving it a 5* rating. It deserves to be a literary prize winner.
Cathy Curran's Eastern European ancestors travelled to America in search of better lives. In this harrowing and thought provoking memoir, she recounts the stories of both her parents and grandparents early years, which were traumatic on all sides. As the second child of Lillian and Joe Low, she was expected to look after her seven younger siblings, clean the house and not complain... However, the eldest daughter was treated quite differently, and seemed to show nothing but resentment and verbal abuse towards Cathy. Yet her parents did not interfere. Joe moves the family on a regular basis, even buying a home that is infested with bats in the attic! Although, he is living out his dream of becoming a millionaire, he becomes increasingly physically and verbally abusive towards Lillian and all his children bar the eldest. "Secondhand Scotch" is the scent left behind him due to his addiction to alcohol, which gets him involved in endless brawls and family altercations. Despite the regular dramas, beatings and abuse Cathy manages to embrace unconditional love for her parents, and ultimately learns to forgive. Her effervescent personality and wit shine throughout this well written and researched memoir.
This bitter-sweet coming of age story is a tribute to the good, the bad, and the ugly of growing up as a curious child in a dysfunctional family; and surviving the damage. One I can relate to because I was one of eight in an army of children and had a 'Father Knows Best' dad. Although my father didn't tip the bottle, he believed as head of the home he ruled the roost and all were at his mercy on a bad humor day. When my father lit into us, he quoted a scripture from the Bible, 'Spare the rod and spoil the child.' Fortunately for my mother and we children, he found religion and tried to control his quick temper. But the devil still made him do it often. And in the 50-60s people looked the other way regarding child-abuse. I enjoyed and highly recommend this honest, sensitive, and hopeful personal perspective of family life. Curran's devotion to her younger siblings is admirable, and her determination to learn from the familiar, family mistakes is key to breaking the mold and making a better life for future generations.
I could not have read this book at a better time in my life. I totally related to Cathy. I found myself very thankful she was brave to put it all into words. The hardest part isnt sharing your story with the world. But revisiting your life and memories all over again. Like forcing yourself to digest the hurt all over again. And the danger isnt from public reading it, it is your family members deciding that the version isnt their truth. Of course it isnt, its the authors. But that is the critical eyes you are most fearful of. Another thought is, most people were totally unaware what was going on. Because a family life like this is held in secret. Thats what makes it so hard to break out of.
Secondhand Scotch by Cathy Curran is probably better than Frank McCourt's Angela's Ashes. Similar story, different family, different nationality. Curran has an extraordinary knack of capturing her family's darkest moments, and her childish feelings and responses, causing the reader to gasp and applaud. I love this book and I thoroughly recommend it to anyone who LOVES memoir!
I was offered a beta copy of this book by a third party, to read prior to publication. The opening sentence of Chapter 1 "I was born wanting to live, but I lived wanting to die, and now that most of my life is gone, I want to live again." makes an interesting opening. It is suggestive of the content of the book, with greater understanding evolving for the reader as they begin to vicariously live the life of the author.
As an adult, the author has learned to make sense of the inter-generational family violence she witnesses, both the physical and emotional. Rising above the many negative experiences, Cathy Curran writes with empathy and understanding of her family and their history, and in the process, finds her own place within that history. While there is violence, there is humour within this story, some of it comical and some of it black humour. Fortunately this helps to lighten the experience for the reader, given the abusive nature of many family members.
This book is a well-documented inter-generational family history of negative behaviours. This is not a "poor me" story as the author writes of the struggles the author's forebears endured in their own homelands and also in their emigration and settling in the USA. Her struggles as a child seeking love and approval but more frequently receiving rejection, are also documented. In the midst of such a large extended family full of love for one another, it seems to be a contradiction in the midst of the emotional and physical abuse that frequently erupts amongst the adults. The same abuses regularly exist between the author and her father, and the author and her older sister, which invariably involves further punishment for the author, from her father.
Acknowledging the intensity of the physical and psychological abuse in this story, it is contained in great detail through approximately two-thirds of the book. The learnings from the author’s reflection of her life experiences as an adult, is not given a similar emphasis, yet she acknowledges in her writing, the importance of her reflections. It left me wondering whether the book was intended to be more about physical and psychological abuse as a child/teen/adult within a multi-generational family, or how reflection of intergenerational behaviour and abuses can offer a different perspective, with new meaning taken from those experiences and learnings? In my own mind, the scales have not been balanced however I would still recommend this book to readers.
I love reading memoirs, and "collecting" life stories. If someone has taken the time to write about their life, then I am keen to read about it. I was happy to receive a copy through Goodreads Giveaways, and this is my honest review.
In the style of "Glass Castle" and "Angela's Ashes," Cathy Curran's memoir describes growing up with an abusive, demanding, alcoholic and capricious father ("the Lion,” she calls him), and a mother struggling to keep her ever-expanding family together. Cathy loves her father despite his many flaws, and yearns for a kind word or a loving gesture from the man who seems to find a way to negate any goodhearted gesture he might offer in his sober moments. She grows up without books in the house, without birthday celebrations, without sufficient food or clothing as her father fritters away much of his income on booze. Her childhood is largely given over to caring for numerous younger siblings and housekeeping tasks, though the occasions when she connects with her colorful and lively relatives on special occasions allows her to experience a sense of normalcy. A sensitive soul, Cathy perceives that she and her mother serve as the scapegoats -- a familiar archetype in a dysfunctional family orbiting around an alcoholic abuser -- and that they receive more abuse than others. She provides a well-researched portrait of her immigrant ancestors and relatives, sharing frank conversations from an Armenian uncle about the brutality he experienced in Turkey. Her excavation of these stories -- including those reminiscences from her own father in his declining years -- help her understand the context for how her parents became the people they did.
As Cathy reaches adulthood, she finds herself replaying the unhealthy dynamics by marrying a man who mirrors the addiction and abuse she's grown up with. "I don't normally say this," says her counselor, "but you need to divorce him." How she ultimately grew to be a more healthy, educated and well-adjusted adult who could ultimately find common ground with her father, and some measure of reconciliation, had me in tears in the final chapters. This was a powerful and moving memoir.
Humour and hard times-a wonderful memoir experience.
This book was absolutely wonderful! It’s not only the author’s story but that of her ancestors too; her grandparents, and her parents, told mostly through the young Cathy’s voice. Such hard beginnings, some very tough times, but what a lot of fun bits to read too! I love how it is written, how the family members would speak and I love the word choices-I’ve certainly learnt plenty of new words reading this book, some great and fun expressions which had me howling with laughter!
The way it was written was a bit different to how I was expecting. Unusual, it reminded me of another memorable book for me, ‘Angela's Ashes’, where it's written in the present-‘so she does this, so he says that’ etc. I remember at the time of reading that, it was quite unlike anything I’d read before. I wasn’t expecting this book to be written in a similar way but once I settled into the style I was reading it eagerly.
I love the cover-I like how the author has used one of her personal, family photos. It looks so happy and hopeful, despite so many hard times in the book. It does reflect the careful balance the author has successfully created with regard to the hard times and the humour. More photos can be seen via a link in the book to Cathy’s website. I loved the different foods mentioned: Pierogi, Potato Pancakes, fried-up leftover Spaghetti Bolognese, Sugar Bread……she made it all sound so tasty, I really think she could make an accompanying recipe book with pictures of the foods-and maybe put the link in her book to her website.
There’s so much humour in here, and expressions different to anything I'd heard before. Unforgettable moments of her childhood. Unforgettable characters in her life. Yes, some very hard times, and so many amusing bits too.
It will make you howl with laughter and ‘get you right there’ too. Crying with laughter and moved to tears. A wonderful memoir experience.
I was given this book to beta read. The first 5 chapters of the book are an easy read---then we get the current story. The history of the family went back to Cathy’s great Grandfather, Grandfather and Dad as a child. Then, as we learn about Cathy’s upbringing I find myself getting very angry with her father—and wondering why she didn’t something about it. I had to backtrack and find out what year she was born, 1953, which told me a lot. I understand everyone doesn’t have this type of upbringing but I know that my mother used to beat me daily and told me if she didn’t know why I would but I don’t think I ever got beat the way Cathy did and her mother did nothing. Of course the mother was beaten also. There were many kids in the family and the Dad had a favorite that for years he never touched. The book also has plenty of fun stories of visits with extended family members but they always seem to end in a beating. Cathy also tried her best to keep the siblings as a loving group but her sister constantly told lies about Cathy to the others to the point that it would be much easier for Cathy to ignore them and go her own way, but she didn’t. Cathy’s love for her father is something else also—regardless of how he treated her she continued to love him unconditionally and when he really needed someone she was the one that was there for him. The book is well written so you don’t want to put it down and I actually felt like I was there with her. I would recommend this book.
I admit I did find this book a difficult read but I finished it in under a day as I simply couldn't put it down. I was immersed in the narrative, mostly told from the perspective of a young girl and later the grown woman, and also mesmerised by the degree of physical abuse and emotional damage suffered and chronicled by the author regarding her family.
Her well researched family history reveals intergenerational abuse and the overriding focus of this memoir is survival - of both the abused and the abuser. I am still bewildered by the word used so often and with such conviction - forgiveness. The premise is thought provoking and difficult to accept even as the pages are turning. This is a raw and revealing read but it is well worth it
Every one of us has a unique perspective on our family and our place within it. Cathy's tale is beautifully told with equal measures of pathos, love and humour, and I was gripped from the very first - arresting - sentence. The tales of abuse were not easy to read but, through it all, Cathy loved her parents and constantly sought their love and approval. Her relationship with her father, Joe, was a particularly tricky one, and her pleasure at their "rapprochement" before his death was palpable.
Such a large family - and the interpersonal dynamics - leave this story ripe for a sequel!
Such resilience through out the whole book. So much love and nurture for your siblings was felt between the pages. Awful abuse from a father. But the love you have for him is be admired. I loved the way you introduced your great grandparents down to your parents. Fantastic story telling. It brought back (good) memories of growing up with my siblings and parents. Without a doubt I'm sure your dad is proud of your book. Definitely worth the read. Keep dancing.
I loved this Memoir! I Laughed, I cried, my heart ached, and it rejoiced. This book was hard to put down and such an excellent read. I was even taken down memory lane to my own childhood with memories of playing at Duhernal Lake with my siblings in Old Bridge, NJ. 10 years of the Author's heart and soul went into the writing of this book and it shows. Well written and captivating. Must read.
This was a very difficult book for me to read because of the child/spouse abuse (physical and emotional). However, I have a lot of respect for the author who's love of her family is so strong that she stayed to help her mother and younger siblings rather than run away and escape. The book is hard to put down once you get into it. The best part is, the author keeps her POSITIVE attitude even after all she's been through.
I thought the writing brilliant, as it held my interest and was completed in three sittings. Ms Curran is to be admired for her indomitable spirit, fine writing, and willingness to share her life with us.
I was given this book by the author , it made hard reading at times , but what shone through was the love she had for her family ,even though many times it wasn't returned . A very well written book and honest and not sugar coated . Well worth reading
Faced with the brilliance of writing from the title to the content, the best review I could give this memoir is five stars and no words. I cannot match the author’s genius, nor can I render justice for the heartbreak and shatteredness that the book leaves behind. “Secondhand Scotch” is a manual for every parent on how NOT to raise children. Poverty, alcoholism, abuse, terror, and physiological scars get passed down in Cathy’s family as generational curses. She believes she is ugly, unloved, stupid, and worthless because her older sister and her father drill that into her from childhood. She finally realizes, “I’m a broken toy, inside and out, beaten down, shunted. Mere words had me believing things about myself that aren’t true. Why didn’t I understand the power words can wield?” After her father’s death, Cathy realized, “Dad never intended for his family to be split in half. His partiality, untamed emotions, sense of entitlement, and many other negative characteristics overshadowed the greatness in him. He seemed to have a clear view of his father’s shortcomings, the ones that burdened him with a lifetime of resentments, yet he repeated many of the same offenses that offended him.” Wisely, the author concludes, “It’s up to us who bury the dead to learn from them. We can stumble along the course of their legacy and walk among the ruins, or muster the courage to take a new path.” This book both points out the vain bitterness of traveling a wrong path through abuse, bullying, crime, and alcoholism—or staying the path with someone else who is on it—and the wisdom of exercising courage to forge ahead on a new path that is clean and right…even if one must go alone.
‘My family was split in half like the North and South, engaged in our own civil war.’
New Jersey author Cathy Curran is a baby boomer who ‘graduated from the school of Do-As-I-Say-Not-As-I-Do and went on to study at the University of What’s-Your-Problem.’ SECONDHAND SCOTCH is her debt novel – a memoir of a life fully lived – and still dancing!
From the opening lines of this memorable memoir Cathy Curran demonstrates she has not only the capacity for an exacting memory but also the gift of storytelling that glues the reader to this hilarious and torching tale. An aperitif is offered as the book opens – ‘I was born wanting to live, but I lived wanting to die, and now that most of my life is gone, I want to live again. I’m the second of nine children, a baby boomer—old enough to remember adjusting the wire hanger on my father’s television while doubling as his human remote control. By age nine I could chew gum, change diapers, and sing “Hello, Dolly” all at once. I was quickly pegged as the family caregiver, and there was no escaping my duties. After all, my father was the family czar who thought nothing of curing me with a good dose of medicine, whether I needed it or not. So by the time I was little more than ten, my spirit was chiseled down to its bones, and I wished that I had never been born. I appeared to be an average, lower class, all-American kid, but I was stuck in a Russian time warp without a Cossack’s hat to keep my head warm. In school, when the air raid bell sounded, all of the children scrambled beneath their desks; and while they were hiding from the Russians, I was hiding from myself. As an adult, I was expected to maintain my role as family caregiver, even as I created and cared for my own family. I stayed the course with uncommon devotion until I was forty-six years old—that’s when my father disowned me for a disagreement I had with my older sister. It wasn’t just the dispute that got me canned; it was because I finally stood up for myself in a way that was long overdue, and by doing so, I had stepped out of the role my father had assigned me. It never mattered to Dad whether or not my sister was right. She was one of Dad’s favored children, and that was the deciding factor in every squabble we had throughout our lives. My family was everything to me. Being rejected devastated me to the core, but in order to be accepted, I’d have to jump back into the box where I would always be a loser at the game my father and sister played. If I wasn’t willing to do that, I could just sit at the curb and wait to be scooped up by the shit-wagon. I crawled into a dark corner, fetal, the way I did as a child, so no one would see my sadness. For the longest time I was numb and hollow until a few simple words, evolved from a poem by Henry David Thoreau, swooped into my void and echoed: “Most men lead lives of quiet desperation and go to the grave with the song still in them.” The words funneled through a familiar voice, one that I’d heard only in my head, one that never shouted or cursed like my father. But this time it bellowed, making me feel as though I’d been rapped on the side of my head by Dad’s huge hand. I was stunned into thinking: If I don’t stand up for myself, I might as well die. Throughout my childhood my older sister audibly wished that I’d drop dead, and the words would shoot off her tongue with passion and contempt. I adored her as much as I loved my father, and somewhere along the way I embraced their sentiments of me. I believed that I just wasn’t good enough for this world. Since I never had the courage to do myself in, I languished in my subservient role for almost half a century before finally realizing that my flexibility would never satisfy my sister, nor would it ever save me from my father’s injustice. From as far back as my memory stretches, my life was steeped in turmoil. What else could I expect? A high-strung man who thrived on controversy raised me. Joe Low was no graceful butterfly; he came flapping at me like a three-hundred-pound barfly leaving behind a path of destruction.’
Cathy’s succinct synopsis distills the ‘spirits’ of this terrific book: ‘When your grandparents make bathtub gin and go shopping with funny money, and your dad flaunts his degree from the school of hard knocks, you grow up learning that "life ain't no picnic." These lessons are handed down to Cathy Curran by Eastern European immigrants who learned how to survive caring little for aesthetics. Lucky for Curran, her mother is a gentle soul with a dry wit. Lillian Low's homespun values--people come in all flavors just like ice cream--bring joy and humor into the Low house. When restless Joe Low ditches one suburb for another just because he wants a do-over, Lillian tells him, "How many do you need? Don't you know that wherever you go, you've got to take yourself with you?" Along for the ride is the colorful Low clan, who turn up to celebrate the arrival of Joe and Lillian's army of kids. They eat, drink, sing, Joe gets plastered, and all too often scotch-fired arguments lead to some good old-fashioned fistfights, which are immediately forgiven with an unspoken rule--shut up and forget it, then it all gets swept under the rug. But when Curran pulls up the carpet, pandemonium emerges from hell with a vengeance. Through the vision of a sensitive young girl with a wickedly funny voice, "Secondhand Scotch" uncorks some harsh realities, but never ceases to warm and entertain.’
A well-scribed memoir from a lady with a hefty dose of talent! Read and Enjoy.
Well written, really enjoy how she goes back into her family history along with the events of the time and her own memories, all seamlessly told together.
I was very excited to receive this book. I was a goodreads winner. What made this win especially special was that I received a hand written letter from the author as well as second hand scotch bookmarks. Very cool. I have to say I did like the book. I enjoyed hearing about joojies and dzidees. Some constructive feedback... I wish the book was written more cohesively. It seemed like there were chapters within chapters... I did appreciate the break up to signal me to realize ok this is another topic. It just seemed a bit choppy at times. Also the ending did not seem to fit. The whole book seems to be around childhood and early adulthood, and there's just so much that would have happened that was left out. I think the book was well written. It's very relatable, but this book is very personal like being welcomed into someone else's family. I loved that right from the beginning there was attitude in the author's note. This is your memoir and if anyone who disagrees can write their own memoir. It would be very interesting to read another perspective. I plan to pass this book along for others to enjoy. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to read it.
Where to begin? This story takes you from the very beginnings of an immigrating family to the present day. We hear the story and laugh as it is told by a child of 3-7. We hear another version as an adult being abused, mentally and physically. We hear the woman accepting her life being guided by a poor opinion of herself instilled by others and the horror of her sister whose hatred knows no bounds. We hear of the never dying love for her Mother (a real saint) and her father (a real bastard.) In spite of all of this and because of her life's lessons and love of family, she learns to become the person she always was deep down; loving, forgiving and someone who can continue to live and try to keep her family strong. It is an amazing story of love that is deep and willing to put up with unhappiness because of patience and perseverance reminding herself that there is beauty and love around the corner, you just have to look and understand.
This must be the saddest memoir I have ever read and yet it is full of moments of joy. The author's resilience and love for her siblings in spite of the terrible life she lived as a child are truly amazing. These days it is generally difficult to believe that families can be so dysfunctional and that the father could rule with a rod of iron even though he was a flawed human being. Hats off to the author for winning through and providing such a memorable memoir.
An incredible rendition of the indomitable human spirit and the high and lows which shape one. A humbling reminder of how adversity shapes us often at the beautifully chaotic cost of love, regret and time. Thank you Cathy for telling your story. You indeed inherited your father's storytelling abilities.
This book made me laugh and cry in equal parts and sometimes at the same time. A testimony to the strength of love and family. And also the physical, mental and spiritual damage that can result from when that love is denied and repressed. Cathy Curran is a hero.
This book was well written. It had humor mixed with pathos. Hard to believe that the author had such a dysfunctional childhood and was able to get to the other side despite her family. You will laugh and cry along with her.
Tough book to read because of the abuse, physical and mental, this family and the generations before them, endured. I loved how Cathy wanted to change and figure out her life, and in the end her father admitted his wrongs to her.