A unique YA dystopian fantasy set in a future world ravished by war, where humans live tentatively side-by-side with ‘superhumans,’ those who possess special powers and abilities. Two cities slowly building to a tense conflict that could destroy what little there is left of their world.
The story was easy to enjoy right from the beginning as Withers enticed you with a character who was a bit of a rebel, not easily swayed by the worldview of those in power. It was entertaining, with good pace, and elicited emotional responses throughout. Like many dystopian novels, the story begins in a distant future, where a war has already ravaged the world and the survivors scavenge and fight for rations. Where the factions have divided into the haves and the have nots, and rebellion is simmering below the surface. While there is much that intrigued me about this book, what happened before—how this dystopian world came to be, the circumstances that created these characters and this situation—are just as intriguing. Withers has set up a world that has its own backstory yet to be revealed.
While I liked the main characters, there wasn’t one that grabbed my attention to the point where I was invested deeply into their individual story. The first-person viewpoint, told from three different characters was a little distracting at first, as their voices were similar and I often had to remind myself which character was speaking, which may have taken away from the character development and the reader’s investment in a singular protagonist. But they were well rounded and once the storyline began to flow and pick up speed, the viewpoint issue became less disruptive. I would have preferred the story be driven through one character; a protagonist whose character arc maintained a trajectory that encompassed the other characters thus making the flow of the story less jarring.
The settings in South Africa were interesting, a different place for a dystopian viewpoint, and a welcome reprieve from the normal American city settings. The author defined her settings well, and brought to life visual representations of the places the characters existed within in but I would have liked her world building to be more obvious. While there was much of it that was enticing I often found it restrained, not providing the reader enough description and information about South Africa for them to visual that part of the real world.
The story had a good concept, highlighting such human failings as greed, ignorance, intolerance, and fear combining within a simmering power struggle between those who thought they were worthier and those they deemed inferior. An interesting look at the human condition through the eyes of an apocalyptic society and one that often echoed our own societal failings.
Withers writing is interesting and stylized and I appreciate how she tries to pull in the reader with her thought-provoking subject matter, the idea that her fiction may not be as fantastical as it seems leaves the reader slightly on edge at the possibly of what our own future may hold.
A solid, well thought out story that will certainly appeal to dystopian sci-fi readers, both YA and NA audiences. A good debut from a talented emerging author.