Starset is my favourite band. They make cinematic nerd rock into art form. This book only gets 3 stars due to the fact it is part of their origin backstory. If it was stand alone, it'd get 1.
I won't list the plot of the story, that's listed already in the book description on the main page, and you've probably read it.
Let's start with what bothered me. I'll skip the bad editing, and Italic font where it shouldn't be etc etc and just cut to the actual writing. Basic at best; filled with misogynistic, shallow men.
Dr Aston Wise is described as "an asshole with a heart of gold." The guy has zero redeemable qualities. Rich, frat boy type, alcoholic, genius. Think Tony Stark but with zero of the charm. By the end he straight up kills someone and doesn't seem to have any remorse about it.
All the women are put there purely to be sexualised. You work for NASA? You won't get to NASA AT ALL - you're just there for protagonist Steven Browning to lust after and admire the way your ass jiggles while you go cook him eggs.
Now Dana's back story is that she's a single mum, who-rather than go pick her daughter up from the baby daddy's place-instead drives across country with a man she just met after they've been shot at (and in doing so got the man who they'd gone to see who'd been successfully under the radar for decades killed-again, no remorse there). That kinda back story is infuriating. No mention if she called the baby daddy to make other arrangements for her daughters care. That kinda thing would raise custody issues. Also no mention of where her job thinks she is all this time.
Why would someone who is "Audrey Hepburn" type of beautiful, who works for NASA, and a single mother find anything about Stephen-a still married, jobless, alcoholic-attractive?? Especially since his back story essentially boils down to "I got over the death of my new born baby in two months, but when my wife left me, I lost my shit and spiralled into a black hole of whiskey, turning up to work drunk or just not turning up at all." Those two reactions don't really line up.
Plus, everything out of her mouth comes off as bitchy, which goes to show that weak men will put up with being treated like shit if the woman is hot. Which makes your protagonist shallow, spineless, and one dimensional.
Now turns out she wasn't on the good team - so I understand the context of the bullshit love interest angle of the story. But your protagonist should've seen the red flags about all of this. The author doesn't really understand single mothers, or intelligent women, or attractive (or not so attractive) women, or women in general.
To be fair, he doesn't paint men in a brilliant light either. They're all cheating, playboy, alcoholic, murderers who are all very shitty people.
At 249 pages, I should've read this in a day. I wanted to throw it against the wall so many times that I stopped and started it a lot. It took far too long for the book to start to Prox Transmission.
The last ten or so chapters (from about when they're in New York & get separated) did pick up the pace a bit - this is mostly because the bs "romantic" storyline wasn't there-and I did enjoy it when it started to get into the actual science of it all. The only exception of this was at the end under Aston's voice, as once again a woman character is introduced just to be sexy and that's it. Oh and if you're not an attractive women in this story, then you'll be shamed for your size, and any attempt at being nice will be perceived as unwanted flirting (hey Stephen, you're not a catch, maybe stop leering at Dana & stay on point with the mission and cook your own fucking eggs).
Do you get more questions raised than answers from this book? yes. But what you do get by the end is a little more of the understanding of how the themes in the music videos and music are interwoven.
I look at this book as the Downplay (Dustin's former band) of novels. I'm hoping the next one will be elevated in terms of content, the way Dustin's song writing and musical composition went from average radio rock in Downplay to cinematic art in Starset.
Will I be buying the graphic novel? No, this story with pictures doesn't sound at all appealing.
I applaud the concept. I applaud a band that is multi-dimensional and engaging audiences across different platforms. It's a big endeavour, one which is in need of more time and attention to work out the kinks.
Starset is still my favourite band, even if I may have lost a little bit of respect for the author after reading the limited portrayal of women in this book. But like I once told him, I'm very forgiving, and very patient in the waiting game for answers which comes with the territory for any Starset fan.