What do you think?
Rate this book
Volg je hart
Lula Bowman is vastbesloten om na het ontvangen van de prestigieuze Donally Award haar masterdiploma wiskunde te behalen. Daarmee zal ze haar vader een onuitsprekelijke vreugde bezorgen. Maar wie moet haar zus Jewel bijstaan, als die haar man verliest en zwanger blijkt te zijn? Lula keert terug naar haar geboorteplaats Dunn. Noodgedwongen gaat ze aan de slag als lerares op de plaatselijke middelbare school. Het is echter niet mogelijk om wiskundelessen te geven. En haar nieuwe baan heeft nog een andere consequentie, die haar in nauw contact brengt met de aantrekkelijke Chet Vaughn. Gelukkig kan Lula te midden van alle verwarring en onduidelijkheid rust vinden in het bespelen van de piano in de kerk. Zal haar hart uiteindelijk de juiste wegen vinden?
367 pages, Paperback
First published September 9, 2014
37 people are currently reading
1096 people want to read
About the author
Anne Mateer
10 books278 followersPLEASE NOTE: I HAVE RETURNED TO MY GIVEN NAME FOR ALL WRITING AND SOCIAL MEDIA. TO SEE WHAT I'M READING THESE DAYS, PLEASE FRIEND/FOLLOW D'ANN MATEER. THANK YOU!
While I have been writing for what feels like my whole life, I began seriously studying the craft in 2000. Since then I have completed five novels, had several pieces published in local periodicals, attended six writing conferences and managed to final in ACFW's Genesis contest in 2006, 2008, and 2009. My first historical novel, Wings of a Dream, released in September 2011. My second, At Every Turn, is available now. But writing is only a piece of my life.
I am mostly just a woman trying to live her life in a manner pleasing to the Lord. That involves being a wife to Jeff and a mother to my three young adult children. Neither role has come easily, but both have stretched me, requiring me to press in closer to Jesus. And because of this, Jesus has taken an insecure, fearful, sometimes angry girl and is turning her into a more trusting, peaceful, grace-filled woman. At least some of the time. There is still such a long way to go!
https://www.facebook.com/DMateer
While I have been writing for what feels like my whole life, I began seriously studying the craft in 2000. Since then I have completed five novels, had several pieces published in local periodicals, attended six writing conferences and managed to final in ACFW's Genesis contest in 2006, 2008, and 2009. My first historical novel, Wings of a Dream, released in September 2011. My second, At Every Turn, is available now. But writing is only a piece of my life.
I am mostly just a woman trying to live her life in a manner pleasing to the Lord. That involves being a wife to Jeff and a mother to my three young adult children. Neither role has come easily, but both have stretched me, requiring me to press in closer to Jesus. And because of this, Jesus has taken an insecure, fearful, sometimes angry girl and is turning her into a more trusting, peaceful, grace-filled woman. At least some of the time. There is still such a long way to go!
https://www.facebook.com/DMateer
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 179 reviews
July 10, 2016
Another author I am just trying for the first time. If I could give this book more than 5 stars I would . I just loved the story and how it ended. I need to read more of her books.
April 29, 2021
I really enjoyed this story. It was easy to want to cheer for both Lula and Chet as they navigated through the ups and downs of their lives in Oklahoma during WWI. I also really enjoyed the part that basketball played in the story, and especially thrilled to the vivid description of one of the games, which brought me back to my own years of playing basketball as a teen.
What really shone for me was how the story showed how faith in Christ alone was the Rock that both Chet and Lula needed to build upon. Everything else is sand when compared to Him. He will never fail us, and is faithful to meet all our needs in His sovereign timing.
What really shone for me was how the story showed how faith in Christ alone was the Rock that both Chet and Lula needed to build upon. Everything else is sand when compared to Him. He will never fail us, and is faithful to meet all our needs in His sovereign timing.
June 4, 2017
{3.5 stars}
This was such a unique storyline...basketball in 1917!? So many fun characters and events, although I never really felt like I knew Chet that well. It would have been nice to know more about his interaction with his brother, Clay, and maybe some letters they would have exchanged. Also, I felt like it was a bit silly that both Lula and Chet would act so surprised when the school board "found them out". I enjoyed the second half of the book better than the first half.
Romance wise, there were a few kisses, a couple slightly detailed. Spiritual content was good, although stronger in the second half and there were lots of great quotes!
I still liked this book overall, and I've enjoyed all three books I've read by her, especially Wings of a Dream. Lots of good lessons and reminders!
This was such a unique storyline...basketball in 1917!? So many fun characters and events, although I never really felt like I knew Chet that well. It would have been nice to know more about his interaction with his brother, Clay, and maybe some letters they would have exchanged. Also, I felt like it was a bit silly that both Lula and Chet would act so surprised when the school board "found them out". I enjoyed the second half of the book better than the first half.
Romance wise, there were a few kisses, a couple slightly detailed. Spiritual content was good, although stronger in the second half and there were lots of great quotes!
I still liked this book overall, and I've enjoyed all three books I've read by her, especially Wings of a Dream. Lots of good lessons and reminders!
February 21, 2022
This was the first book I have read by this author and I really enjoyed it. I haven't read many books set around WWI in Oklahoma, this is probably the first! It was refreshing and interesting. Math, Basketball, Music and a Tornado. The characters have some challenges to overcome, but I like how it turned out.
February 6, 2016
About this book:
“Lula Bowman has finally achieved her dream: a teaching position and a scholarship to continue her college education in mathematics. But when she receives a shocking telephone call from her sister, Jewel, everything she's worked for begins to crumble.
After the sudden death of Jewel's husband, Jewel needs Lula's help. With a heavy heart, Lula returns to her Oklahoma hometown to do right by her sister. But the only teaching job available in Dunn is combination music instructor/basketball coach. Neither subject belongs anywhere near the halls of academia, according to Lula!
Lula commits to covering the job for the rest of the school year, determined to do well and prove herself to the town. Reluctantly, she turns to the boys' coach, Chet, to learn the game of basketball. Chet is handsome and single, but Lula has no plans to fall for a local boy. She's returning to college as soon as she gets Jewel back on her feet.
However, the more time she spends in Dunn, the more Lula realizes God is working on her heart--and her future is beginning to look a lot different than she'd expected.”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Lots of Church going; A few hymns are played & sung with a couple written out; Talks about God, Him seeing us, and Having Hope; Many Prayers and strong Faiths; A little boy is mad at God for taking his daddy (it’s only mentioned once).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: five forms of ‘stupid’ and a man is called a “cuss”; That man hits another man (semi-detailed); Mentions of war (This book is set in WWI) and a mention of a man who commented suicide.
Sexual Content- A detailed kiss; Lula gets called a looker; Love, falling in Love, the emotions and staring at the lover’s face.
-Lula Bowman
-Chet Vaughn
First person P.O.V. switches between them
Set in 1917-1918 {It’s not mentioned at the beginning}
314 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star {Because of the romance}
New Teens- Three Stars
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Five Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
I know next-to-nothing about Basketball, so this was an educational book! Just like all the other Anne Mateer books I’ve read, there were plot twists I didn’t see coming! It was really neat to read both P.O.V.s in First person, as I don’t see many guy’s P.O.V. in first.
And I’d like to share with y’all the Best. Quote. Ever.
‘”I’ve often had to stand on the firm ground of my convictions when others thought I ought to be doing differently.’”
I can’t tell y’all how much I love this quote. Lately, this has been my life!
Link to review:
http://booksforchristiangirls.blogspo...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Publisher (Bethany House) for this review.
February 1, 2017
This was a very sweet love story.
I loved the setting. It is set during WWI and it was really great to learn about this time, not from a war perspective, but through the eyes of US civilians. Also, I'm not a big fan of sports and I liked seeing how it has evolved. I hadn't realized girls and boys games were so different back then.
Lula and Chet were great characters. I really appreciated seeing their story unfold. I also loved the other characters such as Jewel, JC, Blaze, Nannie and even Bo. All made for a great book!
I loved the setting. It is set during WWI and it was really great to learn about this time, not from a war perspective, but through the eyes of US civilians. Also, I'm not a big fan of sports and I liked seeing how it has evolved. I hadn't realized girls and boys games were so different back then.
Lula and Chet were great characters. I really appreciated seeing their story unfold. I also loved the other characters such as Jewel, JC, Blaze, Nannie and even Bo. All made for a great book!
March 11, 2019
I was interested in reading this story since it takes place during the first world war instead of the second, and I had read one other book by this author and enjoyed it.
The chapters alternate between Lula’s perspective and Chet’s, which makes things slightly different as both are first person. Both characters were likable and were dealing with almost the same problem essentially.
Lula had been doing something she loved, but it was also a way to hide from problems, so she didn’t want to teach music and basketball. Her interactions with her nephew are sweet, but most of her siblings were awful! I was thankful they weren’t around much. I was glad when Lula realized that just because someone you love wants you to do something, that doesn’t mean God is directing you that way.
Chet was torn between wanting to go to war with his brother, and staying home to take care of his mother. One thing near the beginning just bugged me. All the single young ladies in the town want to “capture” Chet and make him theirs. However, Chet doesn’t enjoy the attention and tries to avoid it, but when Lula arrives, she isn’t interested in him but he stares at her “with a wolfish gaze” or something like that. It just didn’t seem to fit him.
While there was some kisses and some physical “emotions” between Chet and Lula, it was all borderline description wise. Nothing went beyond kissing and holding hands other than a few hugs during emotional times.
Learning how the women played basketball back in the early 1900s was quite interesting, and it added a different feel than many typical books.
The Christianity was much stronger than I had anticipated, which was a plus for me. Overall I enjoyed this story and look forward to reading more by this author.
The chapters alternate between Lula’s perspective and Chet’s, which makes things slightly different as both are first person. Both characters were likable and were dealing with almost the same problem essentially.
Lula had been doing something she loved, but it was also a way to hide from problems, so she didn’t want to teach music and basketball. Her interactions with her nephew are sweet, but most of her siblings were awful! I was thankful they weren’t around much. I was glad when Lula realized that just because someone you love wants you to do something, that doesn’t mean God is directing you that way.
Chet was torn between wanting to go to war with his brother, and staying home to take care of his mother. One thing near the beginning just bugged me. All the single young ladies in the town want to “capture” Chet and make him theirs. However, Chet doesn’t enjoy the attention and tries to avoid it, but when Lula arrives, she isn’t interested in him but he stares at her “with a wolfish gaze” or something like that. It just didn’t seem to fit him.
While there was some kisses and some physical “emotions” between Chet and Lula, it was all borderline description wise. Nothing went beyond kissing and holding hands other than a few hugs during emotional times.
Learning how the women played basketball back in the early 1900s was quite interesting, and it added a different feel than many typical books.
The Christianity was much stronger than I had anticipated, which was a plus for me. Overall I enjoyed this story and look forward to reading more by this author.
November 14, 2015
I think my favorite thing about this book is that it takes place very near where I live and at a time when my great-grandpa would have been about 10 or so years old. Things like that just really make a book that much more interesting for me.
Other than that, though, I did really enjoy this book. I thought it was well written and I really liked the characters. Perhaps it was the time at which I read the book, but I was able to connect with these characters quite a bit and I like that. I think the only thing I actually didn't like about this book was that the ending felt very abrupt, and because of that I only gave it 4 stars instead of 5.
This is the first book I've read by Anne Mateer, but I will certainly be looking for more of her books in the future!
Other than that, though, I did really enjoy this book. I thought it was well written and I really liked the characters. Perhaps it was the time at which I read the book, but I was able to connect with these characters quite a bit and I like that. I think the only thing I actually didn't like about this book was that the ending felt very abrupt, and because of that I only gave it 4 stars instead of 5.
This is the first book I've read by Anne Mateer, but I will certainly be looking for more of her books in the future!
September 16, 2014
Age Appropriate For: 13 and up for mild romance
Best for Ages: 13 and up
My friend and fellow author, Alicia Willis, has been telling me what a talented writer Mateer is. So, when I was given the opportunity to review one of her books, I was eager to try. Sure enough, I found that she is an excellent story teller.
At first, I thought this book was going to be very typical. Girl in man’s world shows everybody that she is even better than the men in her field. However, this book was far from typical. The twists and turns of this sweet story made me feel very happy.
Lula is a very smart girl who loves math. Mateer made her feel very real and pulled me into her inner struggle. Chet also was very well developed, with his own struggles and heat aches. Their romance was a big part of the story and was very honorable. Together, they kept me reading their story with a happy sigh at the end.
The setting was also so nice and different. High school basketball in during the world war? I don’t think I have even heard of another book like that. I really loved that some of the story was even based on the author’s family history.
This was my first book by Mateer, but it will not be my last. Her style is so sweet and God-honoring. It is the kind of book that leaves you feeling good, as well as causes you to examine your own life and faith.
I highly recommend this book for those who love historical fiction, sweet stories, and unique plots.
I received this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review. I was under no obligation to write a positive review. The opinions in this review are entirely my own.
Best for Ages: 13 and up
My friend and fellow author, Alicia Willis, has been telling me what a talented writer Mateer is. So, when I was given the opportunity to review one of her books, I was eager to try. Sure enough, I found that she is an excellent story teller.
At first, I thought this book was going to be very typical. Girl in man’s world shows everybody that she is even better than the men in her field. However, this book was far from typical. The twists and turns of this sweet story made me feel very happy.
Lula is a very smart girl who loves math. Mateer made her feel very real and pulled me into her inner struggle. Chet also was very well developed, with his own struggles and heat aches. Their romance was a big part of the story and was very honorable. Together, they kept me reading their story with a happy sigh at the end.
The setting was also so nice and different. High school basketball in during the world war? I don’t think I have even heard of another book like that. I really loved that some of the story was even based on the author’s family history.
This was my first book by Mateer, but it will not be my last. Her style is so sweet and God-honoring. It is the kind of book that leaves you feeling good, as well as causes you to examine your own life and faith.
I highly recommend this book for those who love historical fiction, sweet stories, and unique plots.
I received this book from Bethany House in exchange for my honest review. I was under no obligation to write a positive review. The opinions in this review are entirely my own.
June 19, 2016
Can I give this ten stars?
This book was like a breath of fresh air...new scenery, new time period, new subject. For once the man tries unsuccessfully to get the attention of the woman who really doesn't care if she ends up a spinster or not. Actually, that's her plan, until life–in the form of the sudden death of her brother-in-law–interferes.
Lulu intends to do her father proud and become the first woman from Oklahoma to obtain a doctorate. After her sister's husband dies suddenly, though, she answers her sister's plea and goes to live with her in the town she grew up, where she was known as Fruity Lu because of her flighty, fun loving ways before her mother's death broke her heart and ignited her ambition. Her siblings see it as natural for her to help out, not conceiving of the bravery it will take for her to prove herself in the small town. And, added to that, her sister's finances require her to get a job; the only one available is one teaching at the local high school. Music is bad enough, but–girls' basketball??
The family aspect is huge in this story. The depth of the Christian lesson is also wonderful. What's a girl to do when it looks like she must give up her greatest hopes and dreams and future?
Loved it!
This book was like a breath of fresh air...new scenery, new time period, new subject. For once the man tries unsuccessfully to get the attention of the woman who really doesn't care if she ends up a spinster or not. Actually, that's her plan, until life–in the form of the sudden death of her brother-in-law–interferes.
Lulu intends to do her father proud and become the first woman from Oklahoma to obtain a doctorate. After her sister's husband dies suddenly, though, she answers her sister's plea and goes to live with her in the town she grew up, where she was known as Fruity Lu because of her flighty, fun loving ways before her mother's death broke her heart and ignited her ambition. Her siblings see it as natural for her to help out, not conceiving of the bravery it will take for her to prove herself in the small town. And, added to that, her sister's finances require her to get a job; the only one available is one teaching at the local high school. Music is bad enough, but–girls' basketball??
The family aspect is huge in this story. The depth of the Christian lesson is also wonderful. What's a girl to do when it looks like she must give up her greatest hopes and dreams and future?
Loved it!
July 6, 2017
Lulu has put herself on the back burner to help her sister and her family after an unfortunate accident. She becomes a music teacher and a basketball coach where she meets Chet. I enjoyed seeing a glimpse of history in Lulu and Chet's story and seeing some tense but wonderful moments between them.
This book has been on my TBR shelf for awhile now but am I glad that I have taken it of the shelf and have now read it. Anne Mateer is a new author to me and one that I will continue to read. I enjoyed Anne's writing style in this book.
This book has been on my TBR shelf for awhile now but am I glad that I have taken it of the shelf and have now read it. Anne Mateer is a new author to me and one that I will continue to read. I enjoyed Anne's writing style in this book.
February 1, 2015
Review on Amazon: http://www.amazon.com/review/RIRZ47TR...
Review on my blog (to be posted 2/11): http://christianbookshelfreviews.blog...
Playing By Heart was a unique story for me, as I don't think I've ever read a story quite like it. The main character, Lula, had to return to her hometown to help her sister and she ends up taking a teaching job as a music instructor and becomes the girls' basketball coach (even though she doesn't know anything about the sport!). It was really interesting to see how she tackled the new jobs.
While the book did take me a little bit to get into (because I didn't know any of the characters or backstory, so when new characters were mentioned I was trying to figure out who everyone was), I ended up loving the story so much! The characters were great and I enjoyed the sweet romance story. There were some unexpected events towards the end of this book that made me care about the characters even more than I already did.
All in all, Playing By Heart was a very good historical romance and I recommend it! This is my first Anne Mateer read, but it won't be the last.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
Review on my blog (to be posted 2/11): http://christianbookshelfreviews.blog...
Playing By Heart was a unique story for me, as I don't think I've ever read a story quite like it. The main character, Lula, had to return to her hometown to help her sister and she ends up taking a teaching job as a music instructor and becomes the girls' basketball coach (even though she doesn't know anything about the sport!). It was really interesting to see how she tackled the new jobs.
While the book did take me a little bit to get into (because I didn't know any of the characters or backstory, so when new characters were mentioned I was trying to figure out who everyone was), I ended up loving the story so much! The characters were great and I enjoyed the sweet romance story. There were some unexpected events towards the end of this book that made me care about the characters even more than I already did.
All in all, Playing By Heart was a very good historical romance and I recommend it! This is my first Anne Mateer read, but it won't be the last.
*Disclosure of Material Connection: I received one or more of the products or services mentioned above for free in the hope that I would mention/review it on my blog. I was not required to give a positive review, only my honest opinion - which I've done. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe will be good for my readers. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission's 16 CFR, Part 255: "Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.*
October 10, 2014
An exceptional historical novel that had mr cringing and fuming and cheering! I love being steeped in history and Mateer is known for her excellent research. In an interesting author's note, she reveals that basketball coaching aspect of Playing By Heart was inspired by both of her grandmothers. That adds yet another dimension to this fantastic story.
I felt for both Lula and Chet as they tried to balance following their own dreams with family responsibilities and God's will. Both have critical families quick to tear down instead of build up...in a 'loving' way of course. Lula's siblings in particular -- so dismissive. Argh! My blood pressure shot through the roof every time they were in a scene. And her battle to take her place in a man's world. Oy. More gnashing of teeth on my part. She's on a journey of discovery -- figuring out what motives lie behind her dreams and how to mesh old dreams with new ones.
Chet is duty bound. Intense. Deliberate. He has an inner core of strength that stands him in good stead but he has dreams too. Duty and hope for the future are a constant internal conflict.
Sparks fly whenever Lula and Chet get together and their rocky romance makes for an engrossing read. Another exceptional novel from an exceptional writer.
"Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. Available at your favourite bookseller from Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group".
I felt for both Lula and Chet as they tried to balance following their own dreams with family responsibilities and God's will. Both have critical families quick to tear down instead of build up...in a 'loving' way of course. Lula's siblings in particular -- so dismissive. Argh! My blood pressure shot through the roof every time they were in a scene. And her battle to take her place in a man's world. Oy. More gnashing of teeth on my part. She's on a journey of discovery -- figuring out what motives lie behind her dreams and how to mesh old dreams with new ones.
Chet is duty bound. Intense. Deliberate. He has an inner core of strength that stands him in good stead but he has dreams too. Duty and hope for the future are a constant internal conflict.
Sparks fly whenever Lula and Chet get together and their rocky romance makes for an engrossing read. Another exceptional novel from an exceptional writer.
"Book has been provided courtesy of Baker Publishing Group and Graf-Martin Communications, Inc. Available at your favourite bookseller from Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group".
September 11, 2014
I am always eagerly awaiting Anne's new releases, (which are not as often as I would like, but if they were, poor Mrs Mateer would never get a break! :)) and they never disappoint!
Playing By Heart is a lovely story of friendship, relying and leaning on God through struggles and tragedies, and trusting that His will is best for our lives- even if (in the moment) we don't understand how.
I'm not much of a sports fan, and I never thought I would enjoy reading about basketball techniques and the game itself; however, Anne has a way of writing that has me captivated by any subject she chooses, and turn-of-the-century athletics was no exception. :)
This entire cast of characters was so charming and welcoming! Lula & Chet were a super sweet couple - though their friendship was a long time coming and I found myself wanting them to hurry along and stop reading into every word and action of the other. (Though it just made the ending sweeter.) (It's also a good reminder to everyone to stop doing that in real life situations, because it's annoying. Lol) A host of other friends keep the story interesting and Anne's talent for drawing you in makes you feel like you're in Dunn, Oklahoma right along-side of them!
Mateer's novels just get better and better- you don't want to miss this!
Playing By Heart is a lovely story of friendship, relying and leaning on God through struggles and tragedies, and trusting that His will is best for our lives- even if (in the moment) we don't understand how.
I'm not much of a sports fan, and I never thought I would enjoy reading about basketball techniques and the game itself; however, Anne has a way of writing that has me captivated by any subject she chooses, and turn-of-the-century athletics was no exception. :)
This entire cast of characters was so charming and welcoming! Lula & Chet were a super sweet couple - though their friendship was a long time coming and I found myself wanting them to hurry along and stop reading into every word and action of the other. (Though it just made the ending sweeter.) (It's also a good reminder to everyone to stop doing that in real life situations, because it's annoying. Lol) A host of other friends keep the story interesting and Anne's talent for drawing you in makes you feel like you're in Dunn, Oklahoma right along-side of them!
Mateer's novels just get better and better- you don't want to miss this!
August 27, 2019
This book was a major disappointment for me, and that’s about all I remember about it. ;) I immediately went and read another book after it so I didn’t have to stay depressed. XD I was probably a bit too invested in it, come to think of it. ;)
I did really like some of the messages earlier in the story as Lula struggled with following God’s calling on her life, but her family’s attitude was really stressful to read. And relational miscommunication = ARGH. I was also very disappointed with Chet’s character inconsistency. The way he thought about Lula’s appearance constantly was not something I like reading about at all and didn’t really fit with his upstanding, good guy reputation. Also, clear out of the blue at the end, he made an irrevocable decision that went completely against what he was striving to believe throughout the entire book. Not very triumphant. I know real life is sometimes like that, but I don’t remember this being discussed afterward, and it seemed to be going in the opposite direction of Lula’s character growth which isn’t a good thing in a relationship.
Be sure to read some positive (and more thought out!) reviews of this book, because as I said before, I don’t remember it very well. ;)
I did really like some of the messages earlier in the story as Lula struggled with following God’s calling on her life, but her family’s attitude was really stressful to read. And relational miscommunication = ARGH. I was also very disappointed with Chet’s character inconsistency. The way he thought about Lula’s appearance constantly was not something I like reading about at all and didn’t really fit with his upstanding, good guy reputation. Also, clear out of the blue at the end, he made an irrevocable decision that went completely against what he was striving to believe throughout the entire book. Not very triumphant. I know real life is sometimes like that, but I don’t remember this being discussed afterward, and it seemed to be going in the opposite direction of Lula’s character growth which isn’t a good thing in a relationship.
Be sure to read some positive (and more thought out!) reviews of this book, because as I said before, I don’t remember it very well. ;)
July 21, 2016
I loved it! Anne Mateer is on my favorite author list! For starters, the setting was small town, patriotic America. I always connect with Americana and patriotism. The time period takes you to the turn-of-the-century, when people, as a whole, put others needs before there own. Their families, their neighbors and their country. I love that you can feel that in this story! Lula is a lovable character. Chet is brave and true. The side characters were also fun and lovable! The romance was sweet and innocent. I like that Mateer doesn't always put a feminist slant to her heroines, as it seems to me, most "Christian fiction" books have. Marriage and family is a wonderful life goal. I highly recommend this book! I would love to read a follow up of Lula and Chet's story.
May 15, 2022
To do right by her sister and help take care of her mother, Lula Bowman gives up her dream of a PhD in mathematics and returns home to Oklahoma. She knows she has enough education to teach, but it's the middle of the school year. Because so many men have been drafted for World War 1, the only opening at the high school is a Choral Music class. Since Lula is a good pianist and singer, she takes the position and then discovers that she was also have to coach the girls' basketball team which she knows nothing about. Will Chet Vaughn the mathematics teacher and boy's basketball coach help her out in more ways than one?
This is a sweet, endearing read with wonderful main characters, humor and romance. I love how Lula now matter how much she wanted to return and finish her college degree stuck by her family and gave her best in both her music class and girls' basketball coaching. She learned lessons from both of them and found out that there were other things in life beyond math. Chet was an adorable hero and his kindness, care, and understanding helped Lula become a better person.
This is a sweet, endearing read with wonderful main characters, humor and romance. I love how Lula now matter how much she wanted to return and finish her college degree stuck by her family and gave her best in both her music class and girls' basketball coaching. She learned lessons from both of them and found out that there were other things in life beyond math. Chet was an adorable hero and his kindness, care, and understanding helped Lula become a better person.
July 10, 2017
It's 1917 and Lula Bowman is now a Mathematics graduate student and teaching a freshman class when her brother-in-law dies from blood poisoning. There is no one else who can help her newly widowed sister, nieces and nephew. Reluctantly, Lula asks if her scholarship can be put on hold while she gets a job and helps her sister for a few months.
Chet is torn because his mother is unhappy with him because he hasn't enlisted the way his brother did and she won't believe him when he tells her that his brother insisted one of them stay home to care for her. He is a math teacher and basketball coach with no desire to settle down and get married.
This is a romance, so I don't really need to tell you that they are attracted to each other. Romance isn't my cup of tea (I read this for a group discussion), but I did like this one.
Chet is torn because his mother is unhappy with him because he hasn't enlisted the way his brother did and she won't believe him when he tells her that his brother insisted one of them stay home to care for her. He is a math teacher and basketball coach with no desire to settle down and get married.
This is a romance, so I don't really need to tell you that they are attracted to each other. Romance isn't my cup of tea (I read this for a group discussion), but I did like this one.
April 10, 2016
Set on the Homefront of World War One, Anne Mateer's novel captures the changing times in a fascinating story.
Written in an uncommon style, the story is told entirely in first person, but the viewpoint trades back and forth between Lula and Chet. I was surprised when the viewpoint switched over in the second chapter, though not confused since the change is denoted in the chapter headings. I like how the style makes the characters' feelings more personal, and it offers a pleasant change from the more traditional points of view.
Family dynamics and family dysfunction, grief and loss, healing, chasing dreams - all play a role in this deep novel, molding together in a rich story without overwhelming the reader. Neither Lula nor Chet is perfect, and like in real life, their lives are hardly ideal. An afterthought in a large family, Lula feels she will never grow up in the eyes of her older siblings, and by their standards she can never do anything right. Chet's father died in scandal years ago, and his mother has long favored his brother over him. Both Lula and Chet have chosen an unconventional path, and in that similarity they form a connection.
Lula has fallen into the trap of seeking the approval of man - her only remaining parent - over God, inadvertently building a house on sand instead of the solid rock. New dreams, designed to capture her father's heart and approval, shoved aside the old dreams that her mother had encouraged. Now back in her hometown, Lula is forced to confront what she left behind years ago and, more importantly, to face that the foundation she built is crumbling.
With such a wealth of inspiration in this story, it was hard to choose just a few topics to write about. It was fun to discover that this story has a basis in the author's family history - that a grandmother really did get stuck coaching basketball with almost no knowledge of the game. This is the first book that I have read by Anne Mateer, and I am impressed by her solid work. 5 out of 5 stars!
Thank you Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free e-copy for the purpose of review; I was not required to make it positive, and all opinions are my own.
Written in an uncommon style, the story is told entirely in first person, but the viewpoint trades back and forth between Lula and Chet. I was surprised when the viewpoint switched over in the second chapter, though not confused since the change is denoted in the chapter headings. I like how the style makes the characters' feelings more personal, and it offers a pleasant change from the more traditional points of view.
Family dynamics and family dysfunction, grief and loss, healing, chasing dreams - all play a role in this deep novel, molding together in a rich story without overwhelming the reader. Neither Lula nor Chet is perfect, and like in real life, their lives are hardly ideal. An afterthought in a large family, Lula feels she will never grow up in the eyes of her older siblings, and by their standards she can never do anything right. Chet's father died in scandal years ago, and his mother has long favored his brother over him. Both Lula and Chet have chosen an unconventional path, and in that similarity they form a connection.
Lula has fallen into the trap of seeking the approval of man - her only remaining parent - over God, inadvertently building a house on sand instead of the solid rock. New dreams, designed to capture her father's heart and approval, shoved aside the old dreams that her mother had encouraged. Now back in her hometown, Lula is forced to confront what she left behind years ago and, more importantly, to face that the foundation she built is crumbling.
With such a wealth of inspiration in this story, it was hard to choose just a few topics to write about. It was fun to discover that this story has a basis in the author's family history - that a grandmother really did get stuck coaching basketball with almost no knowledge of the game. This is the first book that I have read by Anne Mateer, and I am impressed by her solid work. 5 out of 5 stars!
Thank you Bethany House and NetGalley for providing a free e-copy for the purpose of review; I was not required to make it positive, and all opinions are my own.
September 28, 2014
Although she has tried long and hard to correct her former flighty ways it would seem Lula Bowman's family and friends are determined not only to bring up those old flaws but to have Lula stay in that past. And it's something she doesn't aim to do comply with. In a world where college education for females is not a popular thing Lula has excelled in her studies and is about to go beyond that proving once and for all that she is steadfast and responsible. But when family tragedy strikes Lula is called back home with the prospect of giving up her dreams. Not willing to give up and seemingly confirm to everyone who knew her as a girl that she cannot stick with anything yet not wanting to leave her grieving sister to soldier on alone, Lula has a tough choice to make.
Hm what to say. Well first off let's get this out in the open: I read ANYTHING by Anne Mateer. I've read several of her books already and loved everyone of them. Playing by Heart was a really sweet story of personal sacrifice and rising above the criticism others would seek to drown one in. If you have been having a rough week and can't seem to please anyone then you will want to read this story soon if just to realize that it's gonna get better. Lula was a great character. The inner struggles were very interesting to observe as she struggled to do the right thing while attempting to ward off the negativity. There's a lot to empathize with in Lula. I daresay anyone would find this a story worth reading. And while I wasn't too much into the whole sports things it was still a good read.
ISCLAIMER: In accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising” we would like to note that we received an electronic copy of “Playing by Heart” provided by the publishers, Bethany House, through Netgalley.com in exchange for our honest review.
reetchampionbookreviews.wordpress.com
Hm what to say. Well first off let's get this out in the open: I read ANYTHING by Anne Mateer. I've read several of her books already and loved everyone of them. Playing by Heart was a really sweet story of personal sacrifice and rising above the criticism others would seek to drown one in. If you have been having a rough week and can't seem to please anyone then you will want to read this story soon if just to realize that it's gonna get better. Lula was a great character. The inner struggles were very interesting to observe as she struggled to do the right thing while attempting to ward off the negativity. There's a lot to empathize with in Lula. I daresay anyone would find this a story worth reading. And while I wasn't too much into the whole sports things it was still a good read.
ISCLAIMER: In accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising” we would like to note that we received an electronic copy of “Playing by Heart” provided by the publishers, Bethany House, through Netgalley.com in exchange for our honest review.
reetchampionbookreviews.wordpress.com
September 13, 2014
5 Stars
13+ for mild romance.
Where to begin? I LOVED this book! As always, Mateer delivered a fresh take on history, sparkling with faith in Almighty God, sweet and clean romantic relationships, and every-day realness that is refreshing and uplifting.
This was my favorite Mateer book yet. I loved that you had Chet's perspective as well as Lulu's. Both characters were very well portrayed. There was wonderful character growth and a realness that made it easy to connect to both Chet and Lulu. Lulu's growth as a Christian and Chet's wonderful servant leadership and godly example to the young men around him was positively inspirational. I fell in love with both characters from the start.
I don't even care for basketball, but I found myself drawn into the coaching and games. And, as a church pianist and music teacher myself, I really connected with the piano-playing aspects!
The historical accuracy was great. It wasn't overbearing, but I still learned a few new historical facts from the tale.
And, as always with Mateer's books, the romance was more of a enhancement than the theme of the whole book. It was a natural process of two people discovering God's will for their lives and falling slowly into wholesome and honorable love. There was nothing inappropriate or suggestive in this book. I would hand it over to a younger sibling in a moment, which was most refreshing. I love how sweet, clean, and faith-filled Mateer's books are.
The only thing I disliked was the usual amount of frustrating misunderstandings and lack of communication. Just once, I'd like to see a literary man and woman who actually openly communicate their hearts. But it always makes for an exciting and anticipation-filled read when the characters don't communicate, now doesn't it? So I can't complain too much.
Highly recommended.
13+ for mild romance.
Where to begin? I LOVED this book! As always, Mateer delivered a fresh take on history, sparkling with faith in Almighty God, sweet and clean romantic relationships, and every-day realness that is refreshing and uplifting.
This was my favorite Mateer book yet. I loved that you had Chet's perspective as well as Lulu's. Both characters were very well portrayed. There was wonderful character growth and a realness that made it easy to connect to both Chet and Lulu. Lulu's growth as a Christian and Chet's wonderful servant leadership and godly example to the young men around him was positively inspirational. I fell in love with both characters from the start.
I don't even care for basketball, but I found myself drawn into the coaching and games. And, as a church pianist and music teacher myself, I really connected with the piano-playing aspects!
The historical accuracy was great. It wasn't overbearing, but I still learned a few new historical facts from the tale.
And, as always with Mateer's books, the romance was more of a enhancement than the theme of the whole book. It was a natural process of two people discovering God's will for their lives and falling slowly into wholesome and honorable love. There was nothing inappropriate or suggestive in this book. I would hand it over to a younger sibling in a moment, which was most refreshing. I love how sweet, clean, and faith-filled Mateer's books are.
The only thing I disliked was the usual amount of frustrating misunderstandings and lack of communication. Just once, I'd like to see a literary man and woman who actually openly communicate their hearts. But it always makes for an exciting and anticipation-filled read when the characters don't communicate, now doesn't it? So I can't complain too much.
Highly recommended.
July 7, 2015
For some reason, I didn't enjoy "Playing by Heart" as much as I had Wings of a Dream and At Every Turn. I found the transition between Chet and Lula very interesting and done at just the right times. The time period is one that I have come to love: World War II. Lula's conflict in the beginning to stay or go brought me into her character immediately. So there are many points in the book that I DID like.
But...I found a little too much emphasis on the "feelings" side. Probably because it was a double-wham with both Chet AND Lula's feelings being portrayed. I didn't detect quite so much with the other two of Mateer's books I have read. I also think that some of the reason I didn't enjoy it as much was because of the writing style. Like this. Stated. Reemphasized. It is personally a style that I can take in doses but found a little overused.
Overall, it was an enjoyable read, just not my favorite of Mateer's.
But...I found a little too much emphasis on the "feelings" side. Probably because it was a double-wham with both Chet AND Lula's feelings being portrayed. I didn't detect quite so much with the other two of Mateer's books I have read. I also think that some of the reason I didn't enjoy it as much was because of the writing style. Like this. Stated. Reemphasized. It is personally a style that I can take in doses but found a little overused.
Overall, it was an enjoyable read, just not my favorite of Mateer's.
December 6, 2017
Writing was a bit slow and lackluster. I didn't really get into any of the characters (except the 10 year old nephew JC). I forced myself to finish it because t wasn't bad, I just found the storyline and characters boring. I was annoyed at the fact that the author never mentions what year it is, but mentions soldiers and war. About a quarter in I realized this book was set in 1917 (WWI). I just wished the author had mentioned that somewhere, instead of tacking it in partway, it makes a difference in the life of the characters. Also my biggest annoyance was Chet not realizing that being seen with Lula could cost her her job. HELLO. She is a teacher in rural Oklahoma in 1917. Chet is also a teacher (AT THE SAME SCHOOL) in rural Oklahoma in 1917. He should have known that and .
I wouldn't recommend this one although judging from the reviews on here I am in the minority. So maybe it's just me?
I wouldn't recommend this one although judging from the reviews on here I am in the minority. So maybe it's just me?
March 8, 2015
This was my first Anne Mateer novel. I enjoyed getting to know the main characters Lula, Chet, Blaze and Nannie. The life changing decisions made by all of them were difficult ones. A solid historical novel.
January 22, 2018
I actually really enjoyed this story. The characters were good, not overly exciting or anything but generally interesting and unique enough. I loved the faith message aspect of the story...it just truly hit home with me in many ways. I struggled with the writing style a bit, as the reading didn't have a good flow to the story or the characters thought patterns and reactions. I found myself re-reading quite a bit, especially in the first half of the book. The historical aspects were great, fabulous even. There aren't many fiction books about girl's basketball in the early 1900's! :D So that was fun and creative. Overall I couldn't decide if it was a 3 or 4 star rating, so stuck with average of 3. I might read this again, but it's not going to be a favorite, as it was dull in spots and I didn't like the writing style.
October 24, 2020
A story set at home from the war, with a woman attempting to get her PhD, this book took me somewhere I didn't expect and I was pleasantly surprised. I had no idea basketball was the theme of this book! The characters, set on a journey to prove themselves, one and all, will capture your heart and maybe cause you to be a bit frustrated with the social convention of the time.
Read
August 11, 2023Heel mooi boek! Wiskunde, muziek, studeren, familiebelang, prioriteiten, etc.
September 14, 2017
I absolutely loved this book! The characters were likeable and the situations they found themselves in were intriguing. Recommended for anyone who likes historical fiction.
October 26, 2014
This is Anne Mateer's fourth book and the first book I have read from the author. This book is about a young woman named Lula Bowman who puts college on hold to help out her sister. After her sister Jewel's family suffers a terrible tragedy she gets a job at the local school to support them, but the only subjects available to teach at the school are music and basketball! Not her ideal subjects whatsoever, especially basketball. Since she knows nothing about the newfangled game she turns to the boys head coach Chet Vaughn for help. The history and information about the game of basketball back when it first started was very interesting and I enjoyed it very much. I adored Lula's walk back to her faith, watching her become stronger and trusting God once again fully with her life. One of my favorite quotes from her would be this one, "On Christ the solid rock I stand, all other ground is sinking sand. That rock would hold me firm, even if everything else my heart desired washed away with the storm." (Lula Bowman, page 305) As the story progressed she realized that she was trying to please others with her life and trying to earn acceptance rather than being herself and being who God wanted her to be, Chet learned this as well, which is why Lula and Chet understood each other so much. Her journey was beautiful and has something I believe we could all learn from.
Though the book was very encouraging and faith filled (which I loved) I did have some things that I didn't care for as much. The main characters didn't really start to get to know each other until around chapter twenty, which I thought was a bit much, it seemed for the most part just based on physical attraction until said chapter when they finally started to get better acquainted. I felt they would start to get closer and become good friends then other things would happen to separate them. It wasn't annoying I must say but I would have rather seen them get to know each other a bit quicker even though I know why the author postponed it. Also, the secondary characters did get on my nerves a bit, not Jewel (the one she was staying with) but the other brothers and sisters whom degraded Lula a lot. Their rudeness certainly wasn't appealing, thankfully they weren't in a lot of the book. I also thought the book ended a bit quickly, I would have liked more detail of their life in the epilogue. My last thing that I wanted to address, this book is in first person. I understand some people may not mind this or they may even enjoy first person but it wasn't for me so much. But those last couple are personal preferences.
I personally give this book 3.5 stars. I did enjoy this book a lot and I found it strengthened my faith by the end and I loved the main characters. I do recommend this book if you enjoy good, clean and encouraging, historical romances! I received this book from The Book Club Network Inc for my honest review, which I have given. I was not required to write a positive review and have not been compensated for it in any way. All opinions expressed are mine.
Though the book was very encouraging and faith filled (which I loved) I did have some things that I didn't care for as much. The main characters didn't really start to get to know each other until around chapter twenty, which I thought was a bit much, it seemed for the most part just based on physical attraction until said chapter when they finally started to get better acquainted. I felt they would start to get closer and become good friends then other things would happen to separate them. It wasn't annoying I must say but I would have rather seen them get to know each other a bit quicker even though I know why the author postponed it. Also, the secondary characters did get on my nerves a bit, not Jewel (the one she was staying with) but the other brothers and sisters whom degraded Lula a lot. Their rudeness certainly wasn't appealing, thankfully they weren't in a lot of the book. I also thought the book ended a bit quickly, I would have liked more detail of their life in the epilogue. My last thing that I wanted to address, this book is in first person. I understand some people may not mind this or they may even enjoy first person but it wasn't for me so much. But those last couple are personal preferences.
I personally give this book 3.5 stars. I did enjoy this book a lot and I found it strengthened my faith by the end and I loved the main characters. I do recommend this book if you enjoy good, clean and encouraging, historical romances! I received this book from The Book Club Network Inc for my honest review, which I have given. I was not required to write a positive review and have not been compensated for it in any way. All opinions expressed are mine.
December 27, 2014
I've read all of Anne Mateer's books, except for At Every Turn, and really enjoyed them. I was excited when I found out that she had a new book that was to be released soon, and eagerly took the opportunity to review it. Sadly thought, this book just wasn't for me.
One of the things that made me such a fan of Mateer's previous novels was her simple stories that had a very Janette Oke feel, with close knit families and endearing characters. This book was no exception, and had a very sweet but simple story. I was rather surprised when my high expectations for this novel were not met, and in fact got to the point to where I really didn't like the novel at all. I think the reason this novel wasn't for me was due to the simple storyline, which I personally felt was shallow and lacked depth. I found the storyline to be rather simple and often felt that the story was slow.
I didn't really have a good idea of the book's storyline prior to requesting it, since I was so sure I'd love it and didn't bother to really look into what it was about. Once I started reading it I realised it involved quite a bit of basketball, and being that this particular sport doesn't interest me, I think it just added to the fact that I was quickly looking interest in the story. I read the first half of the novel, but after that I lost interest rather quickly and just skimmed over the rest of the novel. If I wouldn't have been required to finish this novel to review it, I probably wouldn't have completed it on my own.
While I've really loved this author's other novels, this novel sadly wasn't a good match for me. However I don't want to discourage you from giving it a go yourself! Since everyone has different taste, I know there are many people out there who would love this book, sadly though I wasn't one of them. So please don't let my experience with this novel keep you from reading it yourself!
DISCLAIMER: I received a complementary copy of Playing by Heart for the purpose of this review. I was not paid to write this review, and all thoughts expressed are my own, completely honest and unbiased.
One of the things that made me such a fan of Mateer's previous novels was her simple stories that had a very Janette Oke feel, with close knit families and endearing characters. This book was no exception, and had a very sweet but simple story. I was rather surprised when my high expectations for this novel were not met, and in fact got to the point to where I really didn't like the novel at all. I think the reason this novel wasn't for me was due to the simple storyline, which I personally felt was shallow and lacked depth. I found the storyline to be rather simple and often felt that the story was slow.
I didn't really have a good idea of the book's storyline prior to requesting it, since I was so sure I'd love it and didn't bother to really look into what it was about. Once I started reading it I realised it involved quite a bit of basketball, and being that this particular sport doesn't interest me, I think it just added to the fact that I was quickly looking interest in the story. I read the first half of the novel, but after that I lost interest rather quickly and just skimmed over the rest of the novel. If I wouldn't have been required to finish this novel to review it, I probably wouldn't have completed it on my own.
While I've really loved this author's other novels, this novel sadly wasn't a good match for me. However I don't want to discourage you from giving it a go yourself! Since everyone has different taste, I know there are many people out there who would love this book, sadly though I wasn't one of them. So please don't let my experience with this novel keep you from reading it yourself!
DISCLAIMER: I received a complementary copy of Playing by Heart for the purpose of this review. I was not paid to write this review, and all thoughts expressed are my own, completely honest and unbiased.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 179 reviews