What do you think?
Rate this book
Rose Gardner Mystery #9
Thirty-Six and a Half Motives
Rose Gardner should be celebrating the arrest of her fiercest enemy, J.R. Simmons. But problems are like weeds — pluck one and five more spring up. Rose’s boyfriend is on the verge of leaving her for good, her best friend, Neely Kate, is grappling with marriage problems, and her sister has a devastating secret. To make matters worse, she discovers J.R. Simmons has not been neutralized. His network of allies and henchman extends further than she suspected, and J.R.’s so intent on revenge, his lackeys might just destroy Fenton County to get it for him.
But the girl who once spent her days alone and afraid is now a strong, independent woman with a network of her own, including Neely Kate, Skeeter Malcolm — the reigning king of the Fenton County underworld — and other loyal friends on both sides of the law. Racing against time, they must dig up J.R.'s empire by the roots, unmasking his allies and unearthing his secrets, both the behind-the-scenes manipulation he’s been orchestrating in Fenton County for decades and the dark stains of his personal life.
If Rose succeeds, she tells herself the quiet and peaceful life she once dreamed of will be at the end of the tunnel. But her quest to destroy J.R. will require her to explore the person she has become.
But the girl who once spent her days alone and afraid is now a strong, independent woman with a network of her own, including Neely Kate, Skeeter Malcolm — the reigning king of the Fenton County underworld — and other loyal friends on both sides of the law. Racing against time, they must dig up J.R.'s empire by the roots, unmasking his allies and unearthing his secrets, both the behind-the-scenes manipulation he’s been orchestrating in Fenton County for decades and the dark stains of his personal life.
If Rose succeeds, she tells herself the quiet and peaceful life she once dreamed of will be at the end of the tunnel. But her quest to destroy J.R. will require her to explore the person she has become.
403 pages, ebook
First published May 17, 2016
1045 people are currently reading
1229 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 353 reviews
![Profile Image for Carol [Goodreads Addict].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1626057011i%2F10717098._UX200_CR0%2C33%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
July 28, 2016
Thirty-Six and a Half Motives is book nine in the Rose Gardner Mystery series by Denise Grover Swank.
In every book of this series, Rose’s life has been full of love, loss, chaos, danger, friendship and laughter. In every book the situation becomes more intense, dangerous and the evil, sinister J.R. Simmons finds new ways to shock us with his black heart. This book is the finale to the series and is chock full from the start to the finish. Surprisingly, the biggest part of it takes part over one day but what a day it is.
“Rose, I suspect chaos will find you wherever you go-and unfortunately for you, that chaos tends to be criminal in nature.”
J.R. is in jail but does Rose get a break? No, she does not. The chaos of her life continues as J.R. finds a way to threaten her even from behind bars. But he isn’t the only threat. There are so many unanswered questions that have stacked up throughout this series and I assure you, every single one of them will be explained.
Neely Kate’s life is in turmoil as well and she is currently staying at the farm with Rose. She is separated from her husband and doesn’t even know where he is. In my opinion, she is better off. We know that the attorney, Carter Hale, is interested in Neely Kate and I also thought I detected a little spark between she and Jed. Could this be a future romantic interest for her? We’ll see I suppose.
Of course there is Hilary. Is her baby really Joe’s? Is it even possible that maybe Hilary has turned over a new leaf?
There is also Kate, Joe’s sister. More and more evidence piles up against her. Has she teamed up with their father? What is she really after?
Then there is the man who I think has become my favorite male character of the book, James (Skeeter) Malcolm. It’s been obvious for awhile that he harbors feelings for Rose and she definitely has a good influence on him. And above all of them, Joe and Mason, Skeeter is the one who really seems to respect Rose for the strong woman she has grown in to. And he is also the one that does the best job of protecting her when the going gets rough. He never holds her back but encourages her. I just love that guy.
Then there is Mason and Joe. These have been the two loves of Rose’s life throughout this series. What role will they play in the final showdown with J.R. and let me warn you, it is a showdown worth waiting for. It is epic. And what role will these two play in Rose’s future?
Now I have to voice my personal feelings. I have loved this series from the start as I also have anything Denise Grover Swank has written. And this book is no exception. It is well written and kept me on the edge of my seat. I have loved Rose, cried with her and for her over the course of this series. She probably took up way too much space in my heart and brain. But these are all symptoms of a well written series, to become emotionally attached to the characters. Rose’s two love interests, Mason and Joe, have been a huge part of the story line in each and every book. The fans of this series are strongly opinionated, team Joe or team Mason. SPOILER ALERT
There is going to be a final novella to this series, Sins of the Father. And a new series, a spin off called Rose Gardner Investigations, the first book being Family Jewels. Will I read these? I don’t think I could resist anything that has Rose involved. I know I’m not the only fan of this series who feels the way I do and I hope the author understands where we are coming from. If she didn’t write the character of Rose Gardner so well, we wouldn’t care, would we?
In every book of this series, Rose’s life has been full of love, loss, chaos, danger, friendship and laughter. In every book the situation becomes more intense, dangerous and the evil, sinister J.R. Simmons finds new ways to shock us with his black heart. This book is the finale to the series and is chock full from the start to the finish. Surprisingly, the biggest part of it takes part over one day but what a day it is.
“Rose, I suspect chaos will find you wherever you go-and unfortunately for you, that chaos tends to be criminal in nature.”
J.R. is in jail but does Rose get a break? No, she does not. The chaos of her life continues as J.R. finds a way to threaten her even from behind bars. But he isn’t the only threat. There are so many unanswered questions that have stacked up throughout this series and I assure you, every single one of them will be explained.
Neely Kate’s life is in turmoil as well and she is currently staying at the farm with Rose. She is separated from her husband and doesn’t even know where he is. In my opinion, she is better off. We know that the attorney, Carter Hale, is interested in Neely Kate and I also thought I detected a little spark between she and Jed. Could this be a future romantic interest for her? We’ll see I suppose.
Of course there is Hilary. Is her baby really Joe’s? Is it even possible that maybe Hilary has turned over a new leaf?
There is also Kate, Joe’s sister. More and more evidence piles up against her. Has she teamed up with their father? What is she really after?
Then there is the man who I think has become my favorite male character of the book, James (Skeeter) Malcolm. It’s been obvious for awhile that he harbors feelings for Rose and she definitely has a good influence on him. And above all of them, Joe and Mason, Skeeter is the one who really seems to respect Rose for the strong woman she has grown in to. And he is also the one that does the best job of protecting her when the going gets rough. He never holds her back but encourages her. I just love that guy.
Then there is Mason and Joe. These have been the two loves of Rose’s life throughout this series. What role will they play in the final showdown with J.R. and let me warn you, it is a showdown worth waiting for. It is epic. And what role will these two play in Rose’s future?
Now I have to voice my personal feelings. I have loved this series from the start as I also have anything Denise Grover Swank has written. And this book is no exception. It is well written and kept me on the edge of my seat. I have loved Rose, cried with her and for her over the course of this series. She probably took up way too much space in my heart and brain. But these are all symptoms of a well written series, to become emotionally attached to the characters. Rose’s two love interests, Mason and Joe, have been a huge part of the story line in each and every book. The fans of this series are strongly opinionated, team Joe or team Mason. SPOILER ALERT
There is going to be a final novella to this series, Sins of the Father. And a new series, a spin off called Rose Gardner Investigations, the first book being Family Jewels. Will I read these? I don’t think I could resist anything that has Rose involved. I know I’m not the only fan of this series who feels the way I do and I hope the author understands where we are coming from. If she didn’t write the character of Rose Gardner so well, we wouldn’t care, would we?
May 19, 2016
Oh My Stars and Garters!!!!! What a Finale!!!!!
If you have been a fan of the Rose Gardner Series, or a DGS fanatic like me, you are not going to want to miss this 9th book in the series. Everything is wrapped up for us in this instalment. We get so many answers, it's like a cheats book. So much happens with twists and turns, I could not put it down for the life of me.
This book starts only five days after the last one finished. And poor Rose is still reeling from Mason needing to take some time to process all that he learnt in Thirty-Five. But unfortunately she hasn't the luxury of curling up in bed and giving herself a huge pity party, there are deadlines to meet. The other characters all have major parts in this conclusion, some I predicted, but honestly, most will give you a gasp reaction. We finally get the insight of Violet's secret, Neely Kate has some sole searching to do, Skeeter, or as I will now be calling him, James takes on a new partner. Joe learns some amazing family secrets and Mason will stop at nothing to protect Rose.
There is not too much more that I can add, without giving away any spoilers. Did Denise do a good job on this completion, of course! Are you going to be happy with the outcomes, most certainly. Am I going to read the new series, The Rose Gardner Investigations, hell yes! Thank you Denise for creating a character that has developed so well over the last nine books (plus novellas), thank you for not completely closing off Rose to us, and producing a new and fun series for her and Neely Kate. And thank you for allowing us the chance to dream with Rose. One of my favourite all time series that I am going to read again and again and again. <3
If you have been a fan of the Rose Gardner Series, or a DGS fanatic like me, you are not going to want to miss this 9th book in the series. Everything is wrapped up for us in this instalment. We get so many answers, it's like a cheats book. So much happens with twists and turns, I could not put it down for the life of me.
This book starts only five days after the last one finished. And poor Rose is still reeling from Mason needing to take some time to process all that he learnt in Thirty-Five. But unfortunately she hasn't the luxury of curling up in bed and giving herself a huge pity party, there are deadlines to meet. The other characters all have major parts in this conclusion, some I predicted, but honestly, most will give you a gasp reaction. We finally get the insight of Violet's secret, Neely Kate has some sole searching to do, Skeeter, or as I will now be calling him, James takes on a new partner. Joe learns some amazing family secrets and Mason will stop at nothing to protect Rose.
There is not too much more that I can add, without giving away any spoilers. Did Denise do a good job on this completion, of course! Are you going to be happy with the outcomes, most certainly. Am I going to read the new series, The Rose Gardner Investigations, hell yes! Thank you Denise for creating a character that has developed so well over the last nine books (plus novellas), thank you for not completely closing off Rose to us, and producing a new and fun series for her and Neely Kate. And thank you for allowing us the chance to dream with Rose. One of my favourite all time series that I am going to read again and again and again. <3
May 17, 2016
So disappointing .. No HEA. Nine books and I can't believe it ended this way. I really wish I wouldn't have read the series
May 17, 2016
It's hard to put into words how much I love this book, this series, this author.
I stayed up waiting until midnight for its release. Knowing full well that sleep wasn't a possibility when this beauty was in my kindle waiting for me! I am an avid reader and I have NEVER done that for another authors book.
If you have read this far into Rose Gardner you will relate to how I'm feeling right now! This book was phenomenal. I won't give away any spoilers, I know I would have been pretty devastated if I had seen spoilers before the big release.
It has been one of the best Rose Gardner books I have read yet, and that was a tough act to follow. I am so so glad we get more in the new separate series! And the teaser was juicy!
Thank you so much Denise! Rose's first book, Twenty-Eight and a half wishes, was the book that brought me back reading again, something I had lost after a too long time spent in academics. I will forever be in your debt.
I hope this series receives the recognition it truly deserves.
Five sparkling stars for this absolute beauty.
I stayed up waiting until midnight for its release. Knowing full well that sleep wasn't a possibility when this beauty was in my kindle waiting for me! I am an avid reader and I have NEVER done that for another authors book.
If you have read this far into Rose Gardner you will relate to how I'm feeling right now! This book was phenomenal. I won't give away any spoilers, I know I would have been pretty devastated if I had seen spoilers before the big release.
It has been one of the best Rose Gardner books I have read yet, and that was a tough act to follow. I am so so glad we get more in the new separate series! And the teaser was juicy!
Thank you so much Denise! Rose's first book, Twenty-Eight and a half wishes, was the book that brought me back reading again, something I had lost after a too long time spent in academics. I will forever be in your debt.
I hope this series receives the recognition it truly deserves.
Five sparkling stars for this absolute beauty.
May 15, 2017
Oh what to say, what to say. I've been looking forward to this book for awhile. I pre-ordered it after I finished the last one (something I NEVER do). In fact, I even held off reading it for a few days so I could give it my full attention. I had so many questions and couldn't wait to dive in. It did not disappoint. There is so much going on, I had to read it all slowly just to make sure I got everything right. I really liked it and for the most part it ended how I thought it should. (Seriously- where is a real life Neely Kate?? LOVE that girl!!)
......HOWEVER......
............
...........
..........
..........
***************spoiler alert- don't read if you hate spoilers*************
I can see where other reviewers are upset at the no happily ever after ending. (HEA- in case you didn't know what that acronym means. I had to look it up myself).
While this series is obviously about Rose and her maturity ... a LOT of the plot is also based on her relationships with Joe and Mason. So much of each of the books are weaved around those guys and their relationships with Rose. Us readers are brought into their lives, we cry when they cry, we smile when they smile. I've been team Joe from day one. But I also really like Mason, so I could have gone with him too. I just wanted the decision to be made. So to go through ALL of these books (12 now, including the novellas) and still no answer- in some ways I feel cheated by the author. Like she was afraid to make a decision so she just made no decision. Up until now I felt my heart strings tug like crazy for each guy but now, to be left with nothing, I feel let down... almost cheated.
I get why- I know this series will continue and I'm sure we'll see the characters jump in there too. But after 12 books, I think the author owed to the dedicated readers (seriously- 12 books! and a lot of sleepless nights!) to give us something. Even if it doesn't last or someone changes their mind or whatever, Joe or Mason should have had more of a romantic role in the finale of this book. Granted that may just be me and my love of happily Ever After's. There is another novella coming out this summer and I pray that it has a few chapters from Joe (and/or Mason's) perspective. I will buy that one, but as for the rest of the series- I highly doubt I will pre-order or anxiously await anything. After 12 books, my life needs to move on.
I wish I could give this a glowing review and I really, really wanted to. But I was really let down by the ending. I get that the author wants to continue the series, but I think she could have done that with a romantic decision.
......HOWEVER......
............
...........
..........
..........
***************spoiler alert- don't read if you hate spoilers*************
I can see where other reviewers are upset at the no happily ever after ending. (HEA- in case you didn't know what that acronym means. I had to look it up myself).
While this series is obviously about Rose and her maturity ... a LOT of the plot is also based on her relationships with Joe and Mason. So much of each of the books are weaved around those guys and their relationships with Rose. Us readers are brought into their lives, we cry when they cry, we smile when they smile. I've been team Joe from day one. But I also really like Mason, so I could have gone with him too. I just wanted the decision to be made. So to go through ALL of these books (12 now, including the novellas) and still no answer- in some ways I feel cheated by the author. Like she was afraid to make a decision so she just made no decision. Up until now I felt my heart strings tug like crazy for each guy but now, to be left with nothing, I feel let down... almost cheated.
I get why- I know this series will continue and I'm sure we'll see the characters jump in there too. But after 12 books, I think the author owed to the dedicated readers (seriously- 12 books! and a lot of sleepless nights!) to give us something. Even if it doesn't last or someone changes their mind or whatever, Joe or Mason should have had more of a romantic role in the finale of this book. Granted that may just be me and my love of happily Ever After's. There is another novella coming out this summer and I pray that it has a few chapters from Joe (and/or Mason's) perspective. I will buy that one, but as for the rest of the series- I highly doubt I will pre-order or anxiously await anything. After 12 books, my life needs to move on.
I wish I could give this a glowing review and I really, really wanted to. But I was really let down by the ending. I get that the author wants to continue the series, but I think she could have done that with a romantic decision.
June 18, 2016
Rose and Skeeter brought JR Simmons' criminal empire crashing down. And now he's escaped from custody and has nothing to live for except revenge. With a final confrontation inevitable Rose and her friends find themselves scrambling to fit all the puzzle pieces together, to sort out friend from foe.
She knows people are going to die, one of her visions showed that to her. What she doesn't know is who or what she can do to prevent it.
Thirty-Six and a Half Motives is book nine of the Rose Gardner Mystery series and in some ways it's also the last book. What started out as very cute and fluffy has progressively gotten darker over the series until this final confrontation between the forces of good and evil.
As a series it's great. It's not like so many other mystery series' which are basically the same book with a different cover and title –– the Rose Gardner series develops and evolves right along with the reader and that's really what sets it apart. Denise Grover Swank might be one more Southern Woman writing about a female sleuth but there is no forgetting her, she shines a little brighter, stands a little taller. When I'm looking for a book to read hers is one of the names I type into a search engine in the hope that she has something new.
She knows people are going to die, one of her visions showed that to her. What she doesn't know is who or what she can do to prevent it.
Thirty-Six and a Half Motives is book nine of the Rose Gardner Mystery series and in some ways it's also the last book. What started out as very cute and fluffy has progressively gotten darker over the series until this final confrontation between the forces of good and evil.
As a series it's great. It's not like so many other mystery series' which are basically the same book with a different cover and title –– the Rose Gardner series develops and evolves right along with the reader and that's really what sets it apart. Denise Grover Swank might be one more Southern Woman writing about a female sleuth but there is no forgetting her, she shines a little brighter, stands a little taller. When I'm looking for a book to read hers is one of the names I type into a search engine in the hope that she has something new.
May 18, 2016
Ya know... I really hate doing this but that ending.... I hated it. I hate it. So disappointed right now.
May 31, 2016
This was a really hard one to rate. As a story, it was an absolute 5, as a finale to a series, well.... that's why it's an overall four. Because it is the finale to the completely addictive and totally endearing Rose Gardner Mysteries, however, I have to review it as such.
This series has been one of the most superbly written and completely enjoyable series I have honestly ever read. It is at the very top of my list of recommended reading! Ms. Swank has taken a character (Rose) and so eloquently woven her from an insecure, naive but lovable young lady to a strong, confident yet compassionate woman. The character development grew so perfectly with each new installment that I stand in awe of the author! This was accomplished while still keeping readers on the edge of their seats and adoringly turning every page in each individual book. The mysteries were always engrossing with twists and turns that not even the best could figure out. Bravo, Denise!!!
With each of the books, the romantic relationships Rose has carry just as strong a thread as do the mysteries, however. We absolutely fall in love with the men in her life! We ache with her, we struggle with her as she learns to love and grow from that love. That is the reason for the one star drop in the finale, though. Although, I completely understand (and even agree with) Ms. Swank's decision to end the series as she did, as it was the most believable choice and the one that stayed true to Rose's character, to be that invested in the romance side through all 9 books and then end the entire series without an HEA for her was a complete let-down from a readers stand-point.
We love Rose, we want her to be happy. We have invested years in her life. To end it with no happiness.... UGH!! Luckily, we will get to see Rose in her spin-off series and, hopefully, Ms. Swank will incorporate her continued growth in those relationships and find a happy ending for her there.
This series has been one of the most superbly written and completely enjoyable series I have honestly ever read. It is at the very top of my list of recommended reading! Ms. Swank has taken a character (Rose) and so eloquently woven her from an insecure, naive but lovable young lady to a strong, confident yet compassionate woman. The character development grew so perfectly with each new installment that I stand in awe of the author! This was accomplished while still keeping readers on the edge of their seats and adoringly turning every page in each individual book. The mysteries were always engrossing with twists and turns that not even the best could figure out. Bravo, Denise!!!
With each of the books, the romantic relationships Rose has carry just as strong a thread as do the mysteries, however. We absolutely fall in love with the men in her life! We ache with her, we struggle with her as she learns to love and grow from that love. That is the reason for the one star drop in the finale, though. Although, I completely understand (and even agree with) Ms. Swank's decision to end the series as she did, as it was the most believable choice and the one that stayed true to Rose's character, to be that invested in the romance side through all 9 books and then end the entire series without an HEA for her was a complete let-down from a readers stand-point.
We love Rose, we want her to be happy. We have invested years in her life. To end it with no happiness.... UGH!! Luckily, we will get to see Rose in her spin-off series and, hopefully, Ms. Swank will incorporate her continued growth in those relationships and find a happy ending for her there.
May 30, 2016
Spoilers ahead:
Finished reading the book in just two days and my head is reeling with questions.
1. This book had fewer visions of future which is good for a change. But, wasn't Rose supposed to blurt out everything she sees? How could she have kept the secret to herself when she saw the vision of Jed's future?
2. Kate is seeking revenge on her father. And planted a bomb in the Atchinson factory. But, what was the need to invite her brother(Joe) whom she loves and Mason(who did not harm her in any way)?
3. Towards the climax, Hillary makes some allegations about Mason, which are left unexplained! Are the readers supposed to assume they're just false?
4. A lot of talking about Ronnie(Neely Kate's husband) siding with the bad guys. No explanation of the situation.
5. Also, Joe got hold of Dora's Journal(in Thirty-five and a half...) which played absolutely no role in bringing JR down.
However, I liked the book about how the author has developed the characters throughout the series.
But, these people seem to eat out a lot :P. Also, the author seemed to have been in a hurry to wrap-up the series.
Finished reading the book in just two days and my head is reeling with questions.
1. This book had fewer visions of future which is good for a change. But, wasn't Rose supposed to blurt out everything she sees? How could she have kept the secret to herself when she saw the vision of Jed's future?
2. Kate is seeking revenge on her father. And planted a bomb in the Atchinson factory. But, what was the need to invite her brother(Joe) whom she loves and Mason(who did not harm her in any way)?
3. Towards the climax, Hillary makes some allegations about Mason, which are left unexplained! Are the readers supposed to assume they're just false?
4. A lot of talking about Ronnie(Neely Kate's husband) siding with the bad guys. No explanation of the situation.
5. Also, Joe got hold of Dora's Journal(in Thirty-five and a half...) which played absolutely no role in bringing JR down.
However, I liked the book about how the author has developed the characters throughout the series.
But, these people seem to eat out a lot :P. Also, the author seemed to have been in a hurry to wrap-up the series.
May 18, 2016
I'm also giving this book 5 <3 and 5 crying emogis.
This was a wonderful, loving, suspenseful, heartbreaking, emotional, heartwarming love story. It didn't have the ending I expected or wanted - but Denise Grover Swank wrote the perfect ending for "Thirty-Six and a Half Motives." I'm crying as I write this review, I loved this book so much. My heart is full.
I'm not writing anymore because then my review would contain spoilers. Read the book, you will love it!!
This was a wonderful, loving, suspenseful, heartbreaking, emotional, heartwarming love story. It didn't have the ending I expected or wanted - but Denise Grover Swank wrote the perfect ending for "Thirty-Six and a Half Motives." I'm crying as I write this review, I loved this book so much. My heart is full.
I'm not writing anymore because then my review would contain spoilers. Read the book, you will love it!!
May 22, 2016
After 9 books, I think the author should have given the readers and Rose a HEA. I am very disappointed at wasting my time and money on this series.
Edit: This review is not requesting a refund, and it's extremely poor form to call out reviews on social media.
Edit: This review is not requesting a refund, and it's extremely poor form to call out reviews on social media.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 24, 2016
4.5 stars. What a great finale to a fantastic series! I can't wait for the Rose and NK spinoff! :)
March 24, 2018
5 Explosive Stars.... This series encompassed many elements including romance, mystery, and a touch of the supernatural, however, the essence of this series is Rose's journey to becoming the woman she is meant to be... I have stated before, that the character of Rose begins this journey as a naive, frightened, young girl; as we traveled through each book with her we watched her evolve into a strong willed, brave woman who followed her instincts in order to protect those she loved and endured the painful consequences of her choices... this finale continues in that same respect; the players are identified, secrets are revealed, and the clues are connected for an explosive finale that certainly had me holding my breath and shaking my head in astonishment... expect the unexpected as you travel this last leg of the journey with Rose and her friends to the heartbreaking but heartfelt conclusion... I feel strongly, that Denise Grover Swank has a beautiful gift, in that she creates characters that we adore but also respect; each character in this series makes realistic and authentic choices that have powerful consequences but also keep the story feeling genuine; Denise Grover Swank has brilliantly left some doors open and some questions unanswered going forward into her spinoff series that has me eagerly awaiting my journey through those novels...looking forward to the next adventure with Rose, Neely Kate, and Skeeter and all of the shenanigans they will undoubtedly create:)
May 20, 2016
~~~~~~~~~WARNING, THIS REVIEW CONTAINS SPOILERS. IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THIS BOOK YET, DO NOT CONTINUE WITH THIS REVIEW~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I don't know where to even begin with this review. Let me start at the feelings part. OK, this book is way more than 5 stars. I took my time reading this book. I didn't fly through the book like I normally do. I wanted to make sure that I read everything, that I got what was going on, and made sure that I was feeling what was being portrayed. What I am feeling from this book, is relief, sadness, happy, confusion. There was still one question that I felt never got answered. Maybe it did and I read over it, but I felt that it wasn't answered. She swears it was Joe's but, Kate was adamant that it wasn't. There was also Hilary's and Mason's connection, other than that Denise did an amazing job with finishing the series and wrapping it up perfectly.
Thirty- Six will leave you in a major book hangover. Just when you think you may recover, you think about it again, then the hangover hits you. There is so many things that I want to write about, but that would totally defeat the purpose of you reading the book. You NEED to read this book. You NEED to finish the series. You WILL love this book and how it ends.
Denise poured her heart, soul, body, mind, love and whatever else you can think of, she put it in this book. She loves her characters, she makes them her children, her best friend etc. She wants you to love them just as much as she loves them. If you have started this series, at the very beginning with 28 and a Half Wishes, then you need to finish the series! You will not be disappointed at all!!
I don't know where to even begin with this review. Let me start at the feelings part. OK, this book is way more than 5 stars. I took my time reading this book. I didn't fly through the book like I normally do. I wanted to make sure that I read everything, that I got what was going on, and made sure that I was feeling what was being portrayed. What I am feeling from this book, is relief, sadness, happy, confusion. There was still one question that I felt never got answered. Maybe it did and I read over it, but I felt that it wasn't answered. She swears it was Joe's but, Kate was adamant that it wasn't. There was also Hilary's and Mason's connection, other than that Denise did an amazing job with finishing the series and wrapping it up perfectly.
Thirty- Six will leave you in a major book hangover. Just when you think you may recover, you think about it again, then the hangover hits you. There is so many things that I want to write about, but that would totally defeat the purpose of you reading the book. You NEED to read this book. You NEED to finish the series. You WILL love this book and how it ends.
Denise poured her heart, soul, body, mind, love and whatever else you can think of, she put it in this book. She loves her characters, she makes them her children, her best friend etc. She wants you to love them just as much as she loves them. If you have started this series, at the very beginning with 28 and a Half Wishes, then you need to finish the series! You will not be disappointed at all!!
January 5, 2017
I didn’t enjoy this one for several reasons. First and foremost because Rose & Mason don’t end up together. Noting that the author is writing a spin off series about Rose seems to be the main motivation for that rather and a number of other things that bugged me such as the transformation of Neely Kate from Rose’s bubbly happily married friend into a tortured woman with a hidden past, Ronnie’s sudden elevation to the criminal element and disappearance and the revelation the Joe & Neely Kate are related. And my lord does DGS hate babies or something. She killed off four of them before they were even born. Now onto the plot of this one which I also found lacking. The previous book was tense and exciting and we finally get resolution of the JR storyline and then suddenly we have to go back and do it all again. I must say I thought the mysterious female villain behind everything would be Hilary (based I my reasoning that she is the woman mostly likely to want Rose dead) and the more everything pointed to Kate the more convinced I was it was Hilary so I was surprised that Kate actually was a crazy person trying to kill everyone. And that brings me to some other majorly annoying plot holes and co-incidences that bugged me:
1. Kate’s omniescent knowledge of abso- fucking-lutley everything that was and had gone on in everyone’s lives. I mean this woman had copies of police report, photos of people at various times, knowldge and case reports for Mason's old cases, knew about Neely Kate, knew Rose was going to be arrested within minutes of that decision etc. I mean from the level of her knowledge I was kind of expecting her to work for the CIA or something not just be a crazy pants stalker who managed tofind out every single detail of everyones’ lives without anyone (including her own relatives) noticing she was there.
2. That Neely Kate basically becomes a different character with her mysterious past and that she chucks a frickin tanty every time Rose doesn’t instantly inform her of everything happening in Rose’s life yet tells Rose her supposed BFF soulmate nothing about her own life and gets cross with her for asking.
3. The Neely Kate turns out to be JR’s daughter.
4. Kate’s crazy pants plans to kill everyone. I get her wanting to kill JR and maybe even Hilary although killing her cause they didn’t get along as kids seems excessive but I could see no reason for her desire to include Rose & Mason in her plans.
1. Kate’s omniescent knowledge of abso- fucking-lutley everything that was and had gone on in everyone’s lives. I mean this woman had copies of police report, photos of people at various times, knowldge and case reports for Mason's old cases, knew about Neely Kate, knew Rose was going to be arrested within minutes of that decision etc. I mean from the level of her knowledge I was kind of expecting her to work for the CIA or something not just be a crazy pants stalker who managed tofind out every single detail of everyones’ lives without anyone (including her own relatives) noticing she was there.
2. That Neely Kate basically becomes a different character with her mysterious past and that she chucks a frickin tanty every time Rose doesn’t instantly inform her of everything happening in Rose’s life yet tells Rose her supposed BFF soulmate nothing about her own life and gets cross with her for asking.
3. The Neely Kate turns out to be JR’s daughter.
4. Kate’s crazy pants plans to kill everyone. I get her wanting to kill JR and maybe even Hilary although killing her cause they didn’t get along as kids seems excessive but I could see no reason for her desire to include Rose & Mason in her plans.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 22, 2016
“It all started when I saw myself dead.” That’s how the Rose Gardner Mysteries began in Twenty-Eight and a Half Wishes. How could it possibly end well for Rose Gardner and her cohorts? It’s not easy to write a review for such a phenomenal story without revealing spoilers, but I’m going to do my best. I was given the task of summing up this final installment with one word: explosive.
Denise Grover Swank is at the top of her game in Thirty-Six and a Half Motives. She holds nothing back, makes some bold decisions, and by the end the fallout is unavoidable. You get the finish every character deserves in the JR Simmons saga that has ruined so many lives. All the dirty secrets and lies come to a head in one heck of a finale.
Plans explode. Relationships explode. There’s even literal explosions. Every character’s true colors shine through. While you don’t get answers to everything, there are answers for:
Mason’s relationship with Rose
The identity of Rose’s father
Kate’s real reason for pestering everyone in Fenton County
Why Hilary Wilder would follow Joe Simmons to the end of the world
JR Simmons’ endgame
The identity of Anna and what role she plays in the bigger picture
…and much more!
I normally give some sort of “MVP” of the book, but in this instance everyone who mattered was most valuable. Skeeter Malcolm is swoon worthy. Jed Carlisle is one heck of a fearless protector. Joe Simmons is the guy you always want at your back. Mason is the boyfriend everyone wishes they could have. Neely Kate is the bestest of the best friends a girl could ever hope for. Maeve Deveraux is the mother all of these characters have been missing from their lives.
The pacing is fast. I read the entire book in a handful of hours. There’s even a fair share of surprises that I’m not going to reveal here. I’m keeping this spoiler-free after all! Let me just say that I laughed, cried, and was left in shock MANY times throughout this 117K word masterpiece.
One of my favorite quotes expresses just how I feel about the Rose Gardner Mysteries and Denise Grover Swank’s writing as a whole: “She’s taught me life is meaningless without people to share it with.” I want to share this book with the world. Where can a story like this end? You’ll just have to read it for yourself.
Denise Grover Swank is at the top of her game in Thirty-Six and a Half Motives. She holds nothing back, makes some bold decisions, and by the end the fallout is unavoidable. You get the finish every character deserves in the JR Simmons saga that has ruined so many lives. All the dirty secrets and lies come to a head in one heck of a finale.
Plans explode. Relationships explode. There’s even literal explosions. Every character’s true colors shine through. While you don’t get answers to everything, there are answers for:
Mason’s relationship with Rose
The identity of Rose’s father
Kate’s real reason for pestering everyone in Fenton County
Why Hilary Wilder would follow Joe Simmons to the end of the world
JR Simmons’ endgame
The identity of Anna and what role she plays in the bigger picture
…and much more!
I normally give some sort of “MVP” of the book, but in this instance everyone who mattered was most valuable. Skeeter Malcolm is swoon worthy. Jed Carlisle is one heck of a fearless protector. Joe Simmons is the guy you always want at your back. Mason is the boyfriend everyone wishes they could have. Neely Kate is the bestest of the best friends a girl could ever hope for. Maeve Deveraux is the mother all of these characters have been missing from their lives.
The pacing is fast. I read the entire book in a handful of hours. There’s even a fair share of surprises that I’m not going to reveal here. I’m keeping this spoiler-free after all! Let me just say that I laughed, cried, and was left in shock MANY times throughout this 117K word masterpiece.
One of my favorite quotes expresses just how I feel about the Rose Gardner Mysteries and Denise Grover Swank’s writing as a whole: “She’s taught me life is meaningless without people to share it with.” I want to share this book with the world. Where can a story like this end? You’ll just have to read it for yourself.
May 19, 2016
I have never been so addicted to a series. This one had me from the first book. I have never anticipated the release of a book like I did this one, book 9. I rearranged my life around it so I could binge read! That is how much I loved this series! I loved Rose and watching her grow and change and develop real friendships and love relationships. From being alone in the world and beaten down she moved on to having a whole host of really sincere friends and developed into a very strong, smart, independent woman. I love that her friendships include such a variety of characters. Who doesn't love Skeeter, Jed, Neely Kate, Jonah and Bruce Wayne? And that's all credit to Rose. She brings out the best in those around her and gives even an underdog a chance. This is the last book in the JR series and it was a real page turner. I lost some sleep with this book because I couldn't put it down! We went into this final book in the series with so many questions. The answers came but along with them lots of twists and turns. What a wild ride! I cried and laughed and held my breath. It's a little mystery, a little romance, a little suspense, a little something for everyone. And I am so grateful that Rose is continuing on in a new series "Family Jewels." I am not ready to say goodbye to her just yet. It is just so amazing to me how Denise Grover Swank brings these characters to life. Everyone needs a best friend like Neely Kate or a protector like Jed. I feel like I know them all. I guess that is a good indication of a truly great author! Thank you DGS for ALL of your great books! I can't wait to see how Rose continues on and all of her friends are along for the ride.
May 20, 2016
Wow!! Amazing!! Truly incredible.
***** "Thirty-Six and a Half Motives" by Denise Grover Swank
Wow!! Amazing!! Incredible!!
The author uses this last book of the series to put an end to the loose pieces and larger parts. Almost every piece of the puzzle has been placed. It is complete. She brigs it all to a close with a punch!!
Fast moving and sometimes complicated there is not a stone unturned. Engaging isn't an adequate word. Ensnaring might be strong enough. It pulls the reader in and in and in again, until we are fully submerged in the novel. It is truly a book the reader can't/won't put down. The author has written a one of a kind gem.
It is a hard concept for lovers of this series to accept that this is the last book, the finale, never another to follow...
What now??? Rose isn't done. She is blooming and changing and growing more everyday; and so are many of the characters. These threads need to continue to be seen until there is nothing left but a true masterpiece.
So, it turns out we can grieve and mourn a series that so many waited (im)patiently for the next book to be released over the last five years... We can do so knowing Rose's story will continue. It will do so via a spin off: "Rose Gardner Investigators." Oh and there will be one last novella this summer for the Rose Gardner Mystery series.
This is a monumental book. An end we all knew was coming...but just couldn't believe. Denise Grover Swank wrote a finale like no other. A true and powerful ending!! An amazing, incredible, and wow finale.
*** Note: Do not read this one if you haven't read others. Lots of spoilers in the final novel. But well worth the wait.
***** "Thirty-Six and a Half Motives" by Denise Grover Swank
Wow!! Amazing!! Incredible!!
The author uses this last book of the series to put an end to the loose pieces and larger parts. Almost every piece of the puzzle has been placed. It is complete. She brigs it all to a close with a punch!!
Fast moving and sometimes complicated there is not a stone unturned. Engaging isn't an adequate word. Ensnaring might be strong enough. It pulls the reader in and in and in again, until we are fully submerged in the novel. It is truly a book the reader can't/won't put down. The author has written a one of a kind gem.
It is a hard concept for lovers of this series to accept that this is the last book, the finale, never another to follow...
What now??? Rose isn't done. She is blooming and changing and growing more everyday; and so are many of the characters. These threads need to continue to be seen until there is nothing left but a true masterpiece.
So, it turns out we can grieve and mourn a series that so many waited (im)patiently for the next book to be released over the last five years... We can do so knowing Rose's story will continue. It will do so via a spin off: "Rose Gardner Investigators." Oh and there will be one last novella this summer for the Rose Gardner Mystery series.
This is a monumental book. An end we all knew was coming...but just couldn't believe. Denise Grover Swank wrote a finale like no other. A true and powerful ending!! An amazing, incredible, and wow finale.
*** Note: Do not read this one if you haven't read others. Lots of spoilers in the final novel. But well worth the wait.
June 18, 2016
Holy Hell, this book was everything. I was yelling and screaming and running around my apartment with all that went on. Denise Grover Swank crafted a brilliant final chapter, that was full of danger, intrigue and shock.
It's bitter sweet to see this chapter end in the lives of these characters that have become my extended family. It was so easy to get caught up in the story of Rose Gardner. A girl who was beaten down by the one person who was meant to love her. She had no life, no friends and no hope for a future. Her whole life changes the day she gets vision of her own death. She went from having nothing to having a full and happy life through the course of the series.
Rose became a strong independent women, able to stand on her own two feet. She went from being the victim, to taking control of her life and refusing to let anyone keep her down. She stood up to the forces that were trying to take her and her loved ones down. Refusing to back down or cower in the corner.
Rose truly found her on HEA in the book. It may not be what some people want, but it is true to the story and to her character. This was the end of one chapter in Rose's life, but not the end. The book tied the whole series together and set up the next stage in Rose's life.
I can't wait to see what the future holds for Rose, Neely Kate, Skeeter and Joe as they begin to navigate the fallout from this book into the spinoff series. In Ms. Swanks hands, the new chapter will not disappoint
It's bitter sweet to see this chapter end in the lives of these characters that have become my extended family. It was so easy to get caught up in the story of Rose Gardner. A girl who was beaten down by the one person who was meant to love her. She had no life, no friends and no hope for a future. Her whole life changes the day she gets vision of her own death. She went from having nothing to having a full and happy life through the course of the series.
Rose became a strong independent women, able to stand on her own two feet. She went from being the victim, to taking control of her life and refusing to let anyone keep her down. She stood up to the forces that were trying to take her and her loved ones down. Refusing to back down or cower in the corner.
Rose truly found her on HEA in the book. It may not be what some people want, but it is true to the story and to her character. This was the end of one chapter in Rose's life, but not the end. The book tied the whole series together and set up the next stage in Rose's life.
I can't wait to see what the future holds for Rose, Neely Kate, Skeeter and Joe as they begin to navigate the fallout from this book into the spinoff series. In Ms. Swanks hands, the new chapter will not disappoint
June 8, 2016
Did I devour this book in one day? Heck yes. Was there twists and unexpected revelations? You betcha. Did I appreciate Rose's transformation? Absolutely. So why not 5 stars? Well, because I'm a big cry baby who doesn't like my heart shattered and that's what happened with all that happened to Joe.
I am perfectly alright with Rose not ending up with someone, so this was not a problem for me, at all. People will say she didn't get her HEA, but she is just beginning her life, so I can handle that. Plus, she is happy; she's just not settled down and having to rely or check in on a man. Good for Rose for taking a lyric from Beyoncé and being all independent woman. I can appreciate the fact that she needs to be on her own for a bit. I like that she is going to find her own happy.
I think what I really just cannot get over is the lack of closure with Joe's character. I'm sorry I just love him too much. I know, it's not his story. I know the fact that I want it all makes me a greedy bitch. I just cannot help it. I'm sorry. We met Joe in book twenty eight, which is book one. I get that we get the story from Rose's POV, but this series was also very much about him growing and stepping out from under his father. Yea, there is some resolution between him and Rose in this book and a step towards a friendship (Did I mention I hated the friend zoning of them?) Yea, yea, I'm a brat.
So yea, I really did love the book. I'm just dropping that 1 little star because I'm a spoiled brat.
I am perfectly alright with Rose not ending up with someone, so this was not a problem for me, at all. People will say she didn't get her HEA, but she is just beginning her life, so I can handle that. Plus, she is happy; she's just not settled down and having to rely or check in on a man. Good for Rose for taking a lyric from Beyoncé and being all independent woman. I can appreciate the fact that she needs to be on her own for a bit. I like that she is going to find her own happy.
I think what I really just cannot get over is the lack of closure with Joe's character. I'm sorry I just love him too much. I know, it's not his story. I know the fact that I want it all makes me a greedy bitch. I just cannot help it. I'm sorry. We met Joe in book twenty eight, which is book one. I get that we get the story from Rose's POV, but this series was also very much about him growing and stepping out from under his father. Yea, there is some resolution between him and Rose in this book and a step towards a friendship (Did I mention I hated the friend zoning of them?) Yea, yea, I'm a brat.
So yea, I really did love the book. I'm just dropping that 1 little star because I'm a spoiled brat.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 23, 2016
This is hard for me to give this book four stars because the series as a whole is five but not this book. It defiantly was a great, can't put you down read. I felt like the last fourth of the book was rushed without enough explanation with the twists and turns we've all grown to love in this series. This book just seemed lacking at the end. I understand that the Rose story is continuing but this book wasn't up to the others standards. I didn't need a HEA. I am glad she didn't settle but cut the cord. He's 33 wanting a family, he not that into her if he isn't wanting that without her. I love how she's grown. I can't wait to read what's next. I have been secretly team Skeeter for a few books now but would have been happy Mason. All the "I love you but love isn't enough" was total BS to me. Just rubbed me the wrong way. I would have rather them been more like "we're better as friends" than "the timing isn't right." I'm looking forward to who her next love interest is and for goodness sakes, she can fall for the wrong guy a few times without it being a relationship. I would love to she her next relationship be Skeeter but I like her to not jump into another love of her life right away. And I kinda don't like her going for a man whose already somewhat confessed his love. I would have rather had that sexual tention turn into something more.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 17, 2016
Book 9 when all the questions would be answered, all the secrets would be revealed and Rose would live Happily Ever After???????
Um yeah nope, not even close there are shocks, surprises and I'm not giving any spoilers :-) this is a must read series final that will leave you wishing you could read it all over again for the first time.
I have loved Rose from book 1 she was sweet naive and just the kindest person you couldn't help but love her, by the end of book 9 I am still loving her even though she has changed and evolved, Rose is now stronger, smarter, sassier and just plain wonderful, when you read these 9 books and realise everything she has been through in just a year, you think omg how is this woman holding all together well that there just shows her strength of character and her never say die attitude and that's what makes Rose who she is one amazing awesome person.
Rose and NK's friendship is amazing I love the way Denise writes her female friendships, they are special they go beyond family it's more a soulmate connection without the romance side of things it's a deeper connection that will stand the test of time.
I can see Rose, NK, Jed and Skeeter being very active together solving mysteries in the new series I am so looking forward to that.
Um yeah nope, not even close there are shocks, surprises and I'm not giving any spoilers :-) this is a must read series final that will leave you wishing you could read it all over again for the first time.
I have loved Rose from book 1 she was sweet naive and just the kindest person you couldn't help but love her, by the end of book 9 I am still loving her even though she has changed and evolved, Rose is now stronger, smarter, sassier and just plain wonderful, when you read these 9 books and realise everything she has been through in just a year, you think omg how is this woman holding all together well that there just shows her strength of character and her never say die attitude and that's what makes Rose who she is one amazing awesome person.
Rose and NK's friendship is amazing I love the way Denise writes her female friendships, they are special they go beyond family it's more a soulmate connection without the romance side of things it's a deeper connection that will stand the test of time.
I can see Rose, NK, Jed and Skeeter being very active together solving mysteries in the new series I am so looking forward to that.
May 17, 2016
It's not over yet...
I just finished this book so I need to get my review out while it's still fresh in my mind. I fell in love with Rose in Twenty Eight and a Half Wishes and love her still through her many predicaments, loves and losses and evolution from a scared beat down girl to a strong force to be reckoned with young woman. Thirty Six and a Half Motives answers many questions and signifies the end of some key characters but we know this is not the end for Rose. I have never felt such emotion as I do when I read Rose Gardner books and this was no exception. It was an emotional roller coaster to say the least. So many OMG moments! As much as I am sad to see this series end, I am excited to see what the future brings for Rose and her motley crew of friends and family. There are still some unanswered questions which I hope will be addressed in her new series as well. Denise Grover Swank is a wonderful author and I am thankful that she shares her talent with the world.
I just finished this book so I need to get my review out while it's still fresh in my mind. I fell in love with Rose in Twenty Eight and a Half Wishes and love her still through her many predicaments, loves and losses and evolution from a scared beat down girl to a strong force to be reckoned with young woman. Thirty Six and a Half Motives answers many questions and signifies the end of some key characters but we know this is not the end for Rose. I have never felt such emotion as I do when I read Rose Gardner books and this was no exception. It was an emotional roller coaster to say the least. So many OMG moments! As much as I am sad to see this series end, I am excited to see what the future brings for Rose and her motley crew of friends and family. There are still some unanswered questions which I hope will be addressed in her new series as well. Denise Grover Swank is a wonderful author and I am thankful that she shares her talent with the world.
July 5, 2024
I finished this book over 24 hours ago and am still in a book hangover fog. I know that I will be this way for days. Denise has a way of pulling you into the story and making the characters feel so real that you are right there with them.
This book wraps up the JR storyline that has been going on for quite sometime. Denise does an excellent job of drawing out the suspense and keeping you guessing as to what is going to happen. There are some shocking and ah-ha moments that I did not see coming. The major storylines are addressed and answers revealed. And yes, some things are left open ended; however, I believe that the important ones will carry over to the Rose Gardner Investigation Series.
I'm so glad I took the chance and downloaded the free copy of Twenty-Eight and a Half Wishes over 2 1/2 years ago. It's been exciting be along Rose's journey as she had grown from the timid, innocent girl she was to the strong, independent, loving and fight for what she believes in woman she has become. I will be continuing this journey with her as long as Denise keeps writing them.
This book wraps up the JR storyline that has been going on for quite sometime. Denise does an excellent job of drawing out the suspense and keeping you guessing as to what is going to happen. There are some shocking and ah-ha moments that I did not see coming. The major storylines are addressed and answers revealed. And yes, some things are left open ended; however, I believe that the important ones will carry over to the Rose Gardner Investigation Series.
I'm so glad I took the chance and downloaded the free copy of Twenty-Eight and a Half Wishes over 2 1/2 years ago. It's been exciting be along Rose's journey as she had grown from the timid, innocent girl she was to the strong, independent, loving and fight for what she believes in woman she has become. I will be continuing this journey with her as long as Denise keeps writing them.
July 19, 2022
The writing is great as always. Another suspenseful story. But I must admit that I'm very disappointed with the ending, especially since its the last book of the series.
I was upset when Joe broke up with Rose originally and I hoped that they would get back together, but then I fell in love with the idea of Rose and Mason together. But to end this series with Mason ending things with Rose (though a possibility of a future for them eventually) was just sad.
I'm just hoping that with the new Rose Gardner series we will see Rose and Mason get back together. And it would be nice to know what happened to Ronnie as well. Maybe some of the things that weren't resolved, like where Neely Kate learned how to use a gun and maybe whatever else she seems to be hiding from Rose about her past, will be sorted out in the new series. At least I can hope for that.
I was upset when Joe broke up with Rose originally and I hoped that they would get back together, but then I fell in love with the idea of Rose and Mason together. But to end this series with Mason ending things with Rose (though a possibility of a future for them eventually) was just sad.
I'm just hoping that with the new Rose Gardner series we will see Rose and Mason get back together. And it would be nice to know what happened to Ronnie as well. Maybe some of the things that weren't resolved, like where Neely Kate learned how to use a gun and maybe whatever else she seems to be hiding from Rose about her past, will be sorted out in the new series. At least I can hope for that.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 22, 2016
What a roller coaster this series has been. I wish I had enjoyed the end more. Plot-wise, everything is mostly tied up nicely. Relationship-wise, not so much, and I found I really wanted that after all the chaos in Rose's journey. I am unsure if I will continue on to the next series. I have enjoyed watching Rose grow, but the ending (no spoilers) was difficult. True to the characters, but not very fun to read. Such is life?
July 26, 2019
Knowing that the Rose Gardner Mystery series is coming to an end, is absolutely heartbreaking. However, knowing that Denise has written another Rose Gardner series, makes me ecstatic. I have absolutely loved the series and enjoyed seeing the characters grow into independent strong characters. Each brings something to the table and Denise does an amazing job of making you feel that you are there with them, that you are their friend, and feeling for each character as they go through things.
Of course, book #9 might be the most emotional/ mind-blowing book of the series. There were so many twist and turns. I was on pins and needles most of the book, to the point that I ended up having to read some reviews just to make sure that certain characters lived!
So I guess I start off with the back and forth of Mason and Rose... Clearly, the two love each other... but as it's brought up multiple times throughout the book, their lives are in two different places. Do I hope that Mason and Rose end up together in the future? I'm kind of torn! Part of me wants her to be with Mason, but then part of me wants her to move on to Skeeter! I guess the only way to tell how things go, is to read the next series! :)
Joe and Rose... finally there was the peace and closure needed.
James/Skeeter... he grew SOO MUCH in this book. You see the positive effect that Rose has had on him and I'm actually glad to see him changing. I know that his character will continue to grow and become a bigger part of the new series.
Joe... while Joe wasn't a huge focus in this book, he still played some critical roles/spots. The ending, of course, was the best and I'm actually glad he was the one who ended things. My heart does break for him though, he had a lot of gut-punching news given to him all at once. To realize that your father ruined your life, not once, but multiple times just sucks.
Hilary... I actually thought that she was changing, but of course, she wasn't. I still question if the baby really was Joe's or if it was his fathers.
Kate.... of course, Denise makes you think that Kate is behind all of this throughout the whole book. So the ending does come as some shock. I'm sure that we will learn more about her and her character in the next series.
Neely Kate... that poor girl. Her life has completely been turned upside down in this book... but I know that she will come out on top. I'm interested to see how her character will change/ how she will grow from the new information. I also would love to learn more about her past.
Rose... Rose has grown so much as a character through the whole series. In this book, we see not only how much she has grown, but how she is growing into her own. I will miss the Rose Gardner Mystery series but look forward to the Rose Gardner Investigations!!!!
So in ending this review, I just want to give a shout out and thank you to Denise for bringing Rose and the Rose Gardner Mystery to life.... and for continuing her adventures and the characters I've grown to love, in the new series, Rose Gardner Investigations!!!!!!
Of course, book #9 might be the most emotional/ mind-blowing book of the series. There were so many twist and turns. I was on pins and needles most of the book, to the point that I ended up having to read some reviews just to make sure that certain characters lived!
So I guess I start off with the back and forth of Mason and Rose... Clearly, the two love each other... but as it's brought up multiple times throughout the book, their lives are in two different places. Do I hope that Mason and Rose end up together in the future? I'm kind of torn! Part of me wants her to be with Mason, but then part of me wants her to move on to Skeeter! I guess the only way to tell how things go, is to read the next series! :)
Joe and Rose... finally there was the peace and closure needed.
James/Skeeter... he grew SOO MUCH in this book. You see the positive effect that Rose has had on him and I'm actually glad to see him changing. I know that his character will continue to grow and become a bigger part of the new series.
Joe... while Joe wasn't a huge focus in this book, he still played some critical roles/spots. The ending, of course, was the best and I'm actually glad he was the one who ended things. My heart does break for him though, he had a lot of gut-punching news given to him all at once. To realize that your father ruined your life, not once, but multiple times just sucks.
Hilary... I actually thought that she was changing, but of course, she wasn't. I still question if the baby really was Joe's or if it was his fathers.
Kate.... of course, Denise makes you think that Kate is behind all of this throughout the whole book. So the ending does come as some shock. I'm sure that we will learn more about her and her character in the next series.
Neely Kate... that poor girl. Her life has completely been turned upside down in this book... but I know that she will come out on top. I'm interested to see how her character will change/ how she will grow from the new information. I also would love to learn more about her past.
Rose... Rose has grown so much as a character through the whole series. In this book, we see not only how much she has grown, but how she is growing into her own. I will miss the Rose Gardner Mystery series but look forward to the Rose Gardner Investigations!!!!
So in ending this review, I just want to give a shout out and thank you to Denise for bringing Rose and the Rose Gardner Mystery to life.... and for continuing her adventures and the characters I've grown to love, in the new series, Rose Gardner Investigations!!!!!!
July 15, 2022
I really had to sit on this review…on one hand I didn’t mind the ending and really love how it’s set us up for the spin-off series. But on the other hand, I’m really disappointed that Rose had almost no visions in this book…I mean come on that’s her thing I kept waiting for her random visions to hit and they just didn’t.
December 6, 2022
Secrets and Solutions
Mason and Joe, Rose and Neely Kate, Hilary and Kate S., Skeeter and Jed, and JR Simmons. A complex and challenging story to end this series, and it isn't just the series that ends.
I have loved every word of these books, loved the characters and the humour, and even though the last two have had a lot of darkness and sadness, I have loved that too.
Sometime in the future, I will catch up with Rose again.
Mason and Joe, Rose and Neely Kate, Hilary and Kate S., Skeeter and Jed, and JR Simmons. A complex and challenging story to end this series, and it isn't just the series that ends.
I have loved every word of these books, loved the characters and the humour, and even though the last two have had a lot of darkness and sadness, I have loved that too.
Sometime in the future, I will catch up with Rose again.
February 9, 2019
This entire series was wonderful!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 353 reviews