What do you think?
Rate this book
The Angel of Forest Hill
A time of anticipation. A season of miracles.
Because of Joel’s impossible situation, twenty-one-year-old Rose must sacrifice everything. As days pass into years in the midst of the beautiful hills, the laughter of children, and God’s providence—is it too much for Rose to hope for love in return?
An amazing journey toward love and belonging, filled with the wonder of the season of Christ’s birth.
When Old Order Amish Rose Kurtz is asked to leave her family, travel deep into West Virginia, and help Joel Dienner with his children in the wake of tragedy, the quiet young woman recognizes a home where she might find kindness instead of criticism and hope replacing harsh words. She agrees to stay in Forest Hill and become Joel’s wife for the sake of his family needs, but their marriage is to be a partnership, one built from need, not love and affection.
As the years pass, Rose continues to beckon Joel to join life again, to take joy in his growing children, and to awaken his heart to the possibility of new love. Joel hopes that Rose can move beyond deep-rooted hurts to see the beautiful Christmas ahead, their season. But will the arrival of a beautiful widow and a series of misunderstandings reverse how far Rose and Joel have come?
Because of Joel’s impossible situation, twenty-one-year-old Rose must sacrifice everything. As days pass into years in the midst of the beautiful hills, the laughter of children, and God’s providence—is it too much for Rose to hope for love in return?
An amazing journey toward love and belonging, filled with the wonder of the season of Christ’s birth.
When Old Order Amish Rose Kurtz is asked to leave her family, travel deep into West Virginia, and help Joel Dienner with his children in the wake of tragedy, the quiet young woman recognizes a home where she might find kindness instead of criticism and hope replacing harsh words. She agrees to stay in Forest Hill and become Joel’s wife for the sake of his family needs, but their marriage is to be a partnership, one built from need, not love and affection.
As the years pass, Rose continues to beckon Joel to join life again, to take joy in his growing children, and to awaken his heart to the possibility of new love. Joel hopes that Rose can move beyond deep-rooted hurts to see the beautiful Christmas ahead, their season. But will the arrival of a beautiful widow and a series of misunderstandings reverse how far Rose and Joel have come?
208 pages, Hardcover
Published October 4, 2016
86 people are currently reading
963 people want to read
About the author
Cindy Woodsmall
68 books1,118 followersCINDY WOODSMALL is an award-winning, New York Times, and CBA best-selling author of twenty-five works of fiction and one nonfiction book. Coverage of Cindy’s Amish connections and her novels has been featured on ABC Nightline and the front page of the Wall Street Journal. She lives in the foothills of the North Georgia Mountains.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 160 reviews
October 18, 2016
I have never read an Amish romance before and now I am just enchanted by the lovely personalities, hearts, and traditions of the Amish. I felt for Rose as she was treated coldly by her mother and then sent away to help out a family in need. Once she arrived at the Dienner house, she faced an uncertain future. The mother of the children had passed away giving birth and she was asked to step into FLorence's place. The story continued as the family went along ion their life and picked up a few years later. Rose was still trying to find her place in the heart of the family and was giving her all to being a good mother to the children. for Grace, Rose was the only mother she had ever known. When strangers and family members begin to interfere it reopens a wound that Rose had thought she was passed.
This book had such a lovely spirit. It drew you in with the gentleness and kindness of the characters. I am so glad I read this book. It brought the spirit of Christmas to me a little early in the season. I was glad to have been provided this book for review by the publishers through Blogging for Books. This book has brought me joy and a sweet feeling for the holidays.
This book had such a lovely spirit. It drew you in with the gentleness and kindness of the characters. I am so glad I read this book. It brought the spirit of Christmas to me a little early in the season. I was glad to have been provided this book for review by the publishers through Blogging for Books. This book has brought me joy and a sweet feeling for the holidays.
November 15, 2016
This was a sweet story that was a quick read for me. There are a few time jumps in the book to move it along and not make it into a long novel. As the story moves forward the reader gets glimpses into how things are progressing with this unconventional family. I thought that the author did a very good job of filling in the reader on what had transpired within the passage of time by reflecting on certain events or the way that Joel and Rose had either moved closer together or farther apart.
I really enjoyed the deep emotions tucked into this book, especially after the point that Rose and Joel began to individually realize that they had grown to love their spouse. There were plenty of ups and downs and misunderstandings that came from misreading each other and from meddling family members.
The Angel of Forest Hill was an enjoyable story to read as we move closer to Christmas. The only thing I really would have loved in this book would have been for it to have had an epilogue allowing the reader a peek into how life was going for Joel and Rose…perhaps six months or so in the future.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
I really enjoyed the deep emotions tucked into this book, especially after the point that Rose and Joel began to individually realize that they had grown to love their spouse. There were plenty of ups and downs and misunderstandings that came from misreading each other and from meddling family members.
The Angel of Forest Hill was an enjoyable story to read as we move closer to Christmas. The only thing I really would have loved in this book would have been for it to have had an epilogue allowing the reader a peek into how life was going for Joel and Rose…perhaps six months or so in the future.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog at:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
Read
November 6, 2025Going in the books as one of my favorite Christmas novellas! Oh man....between characters I couldn't help but root for, a romance that was precious, and beautifully woven faith based threads, this book just really had me from the beginning. Not to mention the rich Christmas setting on an Amish farm. Insert the hearts coming out of my eyes emojis on this one. I wasn't crazy about how untraditional the Amish characters were, interactions were written and even how untraditional some of the scenes played out between Amish characters, bit I was still able to enjoy it. Enough so that I'm looking forward to reading more Christmas books by this author.
April 29, 2019
A lovely story of love growing from travesty, and a family forming from the ashes of loss. Great narration. Happy reading/listening!
November 24, 2020
Rose struggles with confidence after leaving her verbally abusive mother and accepting Joel proposal after he lost his wife. Joel and Rose go through a lot and take things slow in their relationship and this is one of the strengths of this story.
November 20, 2023
4.5 stars
I love Woodsmall’s older Amish books. This one had so much meaning weaved into the story.
A quick Christmas read that will leave you happy.
I love Woodsmall’s older Amish books. This one had so much meaning weaved into the story.
A quick Christmas read that will leave you happy.
November 30, 2022
My first Amish romance - Christmas romance 😊 it was sweet
November 12, 2016
MY THOUGHTS
I'm an avid fan of Amish books. Every time I find one I haven't read I try to get it and add it to my shelf. This book is coming at the right time of year with Christmas and the holidays coming. Amish books are so full of love and caring. Ms. Woodsmall is one of my favorite Amish authors. She always has that sweet, clean romance in her novels. I sat down with this book and read it in one evening, about 200 pages. The author always gives you food for thought in her books. The Amish usually have big families and Rose Kurtz is the only girl in a family of 12, yes 12. She hasn't had the happiest of childhoods so when she was old enough she asked to leave and go to help another family in a different community. She's looking for kindness instead of always being put down. She was granted her wish but when she arrived at the new home, the mother had just died and there were two small children and a baby, newborn with a mother. I was surprised when Rose stayed in Forest Hill and married Joel Dienner and became mother to the three motherless children. It definitely wasn't love that brought them together but the needs of both, different needs, but needs nevertheless. After years, their relationship stays the same. Then a pretty widow comes to town and Rose begins to feel her marriage may be in trouble. Rose isn't very self confident and I hope that she gets strong and stands her ground. My heart hurt for Rose. You can almost feel what she is feeling. What will happen to Rose? Will love step in and heal? Will she reach out to her faith to find the strength to stand her ground.? The author never fails to give the reader and entertaining, thought provoking and loving book. The books aren't always all goodness and perfection, but reality in the Amish life. Great read for the holiday season. Try it out!
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from the author and Blogging For Books and I voluntarily decided to review it.
I'm an avid fan of Amish books. Every time I find one I haven't read I try to get it and add it to my shelf. This book is coming at the right time of year with Christmas and the holidays coming. Amish books are so full of love and caring. Ms. Woodsmall is one of my favorite Amish authors. She always has that sweet, clean romance in her novels. I sat down with this book and read it in one evening, about 200 pages. The author always gives you food for thought in her books. The Amish usually have big families and Rose Kurtz is the only girl in a family of 12, yes 12. She hasn't had the happiest of childhoods so when she was old enough she asked to leave and go to help another family in a different community. She's looking for kindness instead of always being put down. She was granted her wish but when she arrived at the new home, the mother had just died and there were two small children and a baby, newborn with a mother. I was surprised when Rose stayed in Forest Hill and married Joel Dienner and became mother to the three motherless children. It definitely wasn't love that brought them together but the needs of both, different needs, but needs nevertheless. After years, their relationship stays the same. Then a pretty widow comes to town and Rose begins to feel her marriage may be in trouble. Rose isn't very self confident and I hope that she gets strong and stands her ground. My heart hurt for Rose. You can almost feel what she is feeling. What will happen to Rose? Will love step in and heal? Will she reach out to her faith to find the strength to stand her ground.? The author never fails to give the reader and entertaining, thought provoking and loving book. The books aren't always all goodness and perfection, but reality in the Amish life. Great read for the holiday season. Try it out!
I was given a complimentary copy of this book from the author and Blogging For Books and I voluntarily decided to review it.
April 15, 2017
“The Angel of Forest Hill” is a great Christmas book! I haven’t read very many books by Cindy Woodsmall, but this is, so far, my favorite. It had a nice, sweet story and the plot was good. :)
December 20, 2017
1.4; It's obvious that this story was written by a woman .
April 2, 2017
I really enjoy this author's Christmas stories, and this was no exception. Also, this was an emotional story, but it does have a happy ending.
I enjoyed reading the journey that these MCs took to get to know each other and fall in love. By the end of this story, I liked all of the characters, but there were a few that took a while for me to warm up to.
Also, I liked that this story took place in West Virginia. I don't read many books that take place there.
I enjoyed reading the journey that these MCs took to get to know each other and fall in love. By the end of this story, I liked all of the characters, but there were a few that took a while for me to warm up to.
Also, I liked that this story took place in West Virginia. I don't read many books that take place there.
March 7, 2022
I really enjoyed this book. This was a sweet read. A tragedy that turned into a loving family!
July 14, 2017
This story hits some hard life issues, like the death of a loved one and emotional abuse by family members. Not the usual fluff seen in much of Amish romance. It's a modern-day spin on the marriage of convenience theme that is both believable and relatable. Nothing fast or flashy here, but an illustration of the healing of time and steady faith. The ending was, admittedly, a little too neat and tidy for my tastes, but the story is well worth reading.
February 11, 2017
Original Review on: http://pastriesandnovelthoughts.weebl...
I requested this book because it was a Christmas book and I'm game for basically any Christmas book but I didn't expect such a cute novel. I'm so glad I requested this novel because it could potentially become one of my favorite holiday novels (I don't know yet, I'd have to read it again haha).
The Angel of forest hill is about a young woman who is asked to leave her home for a while in order to help a man, Joel, take care of his children in wake of a tragic event. Rose finds comfort in West Virginia and agrees to marry Joel to fill his families needs in hopes of finding a home without harsh critics. Their marriage is not of love but of a partnership is how they say it. Over the years Rose and Joel work together to raise the children and slowly get to know each other. In this two perspective novel you get to see that somewhere along the way, from Rose bringing Joel back to the land of the living and Joel showing Rose a kindness she's never known, find new love. But their coming together is not easy road.
Misunderstandings, lack of communication and a new widow who's come to town puts in more than a few bumps to make the ride all the more confusing for our young Rose and Joel.
What I didn't like: The only thing I didn't like about the book was the fast skipping of the years to get into the present time. I mean I get why Woodsmall did it but I'm nosy and want to know how Joel and Rose interacted during the years that were skimmed over. Then again I guess it wasn't really needed because the book flowed really well without it... You know what just ignore the curious, nosy person haha...
What I liked: You know what I liked about this book a lot? It's that even though this book would be considered a heavy topic, it's not a heavy book. Woodsmall gives Rose and Joel a light humor that lessens the weight of such a topic.
I found myself shaking my head at the many misunderstandings that Rose and Joel have throughout this book because, me as the reader, I know that if they just talked they could have solved their issues a lot faster. But alas, we wouldn't have a book if they actually understood each other now would we? O.o
The Angel of Forest Hill was a fast and refreshing read. I recommend this book to people who are looking for a holiday book and/or fast read. It's great really.
I received a free copy of the novel from the publishing company, through bloggingforbooks.com, in exchange for a honest review.
I requested this book because it was a Christmas book and I'm game for basically any Christmas book but I didn't expect such a cute novel. I'm so glad I requested this novel because it could potentially become one of my favorite holiday novels (I don't know yet, I'd have to read it again haha).
The Angel of forest hill is about a young woman who is asked to leave her home for a while in order to help a man, Joel, take care of his children in wake of a tragic event. Rose finds comfort in West Virginia and agrees to marry Joel to fill his families needs in hopes of finding a home without harsh critics. Their marriage is not of love but of a partnership is how they say it. Over the years Rose and Joel work together to raise the children and slowly get to know each other. In this two perspective novel you get to see that somewhere along the way, from Rose bringing Joel back to the land of the living and Joel showing Rose a kindness she's never known, find new love. But their coming together is not easy road.
"Why couldn't she stop believing in her lack of worth and believe Joel?"
Misunderstandings, lack of communication and a new widow who's come to town puts in more than a few bumps to make the ride all the more confusing for our young Rose and Joel.
What I didn't like: The only thing I didn't like about the book was the fast skipping of the years to get into the present time. I mean I get why Woodsmall did it but I'm nosy and want to know how Joel and Rose interacted during the years that were skimmed over. Then again I guess it wasn't really needed because the book flowed really well without it... You know what just ignore the curious, nosy person haha...
What I liked: You know what I liked about this book a lot? It's that even though this book would be considered a heavy topic, it's not a heavy book. Woodsmall gives Rose and Joel a light humor that lessens the weight of such a topic.
"What a story. I don't buy it."
"Good. Don't buy it. Stay angry..."
I found myself shaking my head at the many misunderstandings that Rose and Joel have throughout this book because, me as the reader, I know that if they just talked they could have solved their issues a lot faster. But alas, we wouldn't have a book if they actually understood each other now would we? O.o
The Angel of Forest Hill was a fast and refreshing read. I recommend this book to people who are looking for a holiday book and/or fast read. It's great really.
I received a free copy of the novel from the publishing company, through bloggingforbooks.com, in exchange for a honest review.
September 30, 2016
Rose Kurtz is the only girl in the family of twelve children, and if any parents should have had counseling Roses should have. So when the Bishop asks the family to have their daughter travel to West Virginia to a very small Amish community of fifteen families, to help a very ill mother whom had just given birth, the family does what the bishop asks.
Poor Rose arrives amidst the grieving of a family, a screaming new born, and two other young ones crying for their mom. What a heart breaker, and Rose is a tender young woman, despite her upbringing.
Joel Dienner is now desperate, what will he do, he is shattered and now responsible for three young children, and how will he support and take care of them? Rose is now the answer, and a quick, in name only, marriage takes place.
This book does become a page-turner, and it is a very fast read, but of course it is written like you are watching it unfold before your eyes. Once you pick this up you will be at the end in no time, and wanting more, it is that good!
I received this book through Blogging For Books, and was not required to give a positive review.
Poor Rose arrives amidst the grieving of a family, a screaming new born, and two other young ones crying for their mom. What a heart breaker, and Rose is a tender young woman, despite her upbringing.
Joel Dienner is now desperate, what will he do, he is shattered and now responsible for three young children, and how will he support and take care of them? Rose is now the answer, and a quick, in name only, marriage takes place.
This book does become a page-turner, and it is a very fast read, but of course it is written like you are watching it unfold before your eyes. Once you pick this up you will be at the end in no time, and wanting more, it is that good!
I received this book through Blogging For Books, and was not required to give a positive review.
January 6, 2017
I really enjoyed The Angel Of Forest Hill. Rose has grown up feeling unlovable & unworthy due to the constant criticism of her mother. When Joel's wife becomes ill after giving birth Rose travels to West Virginia to help care for their children. By the time Rose arrives Joel's wife has passed away leaving him to raise 4 small children alone. Rose enters into marriage with Joel strictly for the sake of the children & to keep from returning to her childhood home & the mental abuse she has grown up in. Rose helps Joel through the grief of loosing his wife & becomes MaMa to his children. They both slowly fall in love with each other, but Rose must learn that she is worthy & deserving of being love. Many things happen along the way before Rose is finally able to love & be loved freely. A Christmas miracle finally brings Rose & Joel together for good. I highly recommend this book & this author.
October 14, 2016
This is a perfect Christmas book. The cover is stunning and folks, even if you don't really like Amish, you might like this story! The setting is great and while this is a fairly short story, though spanning years, it captured my attention. There are two hurting people who end up thrown together in unusual circumstances. What I loved about this is they didn't fall in love and live happily ever after right away. There is no gushy over the top unrealistic romance. This is an honest story of people who actually need time to heal. Very well written and perfect to cuddle up and read with this winter.
Five stars.
I received this book for free. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
Five stars.
I received this book for free. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are my own.
January 2, 2017
My thoughts: First, the disclaimer. "I bought my own copy of this book. All opinions are my own." That done, I greatly enjoyed reading THE ANGEL OF FOREST HILL and getting to know Rose and Joel. I hurt for them as Rose dealt with impossible situations, a husband, numb with grief, the deceased wife's mother intent on destroying her life, her mother who listed everything she'd ever done wrong and called her worthless. I hoped Rose would find love and thrive in this story.
In some ways, the insecure Rose changed. She became strong and had thorns. But then something would set her back and she'd flounder. It was an adventure watching her take one step forward and two steps back, sometimes on the same day.
A good Christmas novella.
December 7, 2017
I really enjoyed how Joel and Rose were portrayed: very real characters who made very real mistakes, but who, ultimately, were trying to do what was best for their family and their relationship. I really identified with Rose's insecurities about her worth, and need to remember the lesson she learned about Jesus taking our pains upon Himself.
December 15, 2025
A great book for Christmas in July!!
December 15, 2016
Short story by Cindy Woodsmall, set in a West Virginian small close knit Amish community. A quick easy read, that brushes on many elements leading you to question Amish society, without delving in too deep. The authors approach leads me to wondering on her own personal outlook of this way of life. It's not always favorable and has a negative undertone in parts.
Rose, has grown up in a large family with only brothers, and high expectations and harsh, verbally abusive treatment from her mother. An opportunity arises to leave her Pennsylvania home & assist a young widower, in need of help with his 3 small children. I had expected this to be an arranged marriage set up, but since marriage isn't suggested for a while, it never really made sense to me why Rose was shipped off there so fast.
Joel, hard working and successful widower, must find a way to keep moving forward despite the tragic loss of the love of his life and agrees to marry Rose in order to provide childcare for his children. It's a marriage in name only, and even though as the years progress, their friendship blossoms, doubts pursue Rose constantly over the sadness of what she may never have. Joel is a likable kind character, who, fails to communicate his feelings well, though has patience galore for Rose and her overwhelming insecurities. Understandably Rose struggles to believe words of affirmation, in that she is loveable, and it's not helped along by the deceased wife's mother, or the new widow in town.
Some elements of this story fell flat, or presented the opportunity for good development, but didn't materialize. I liked that Rose had an 'Englisch' friend to provide supportive input on marriage, and kindly took care of her. Having someone she knew with a car proved helpful in the timeline of events, when buggy travel wouldn't have made the plot work.
Overall, it's a good story, of discovery, mostly for Rose of her true value. She must receive apologies though in order to finally work through it, which was a little disappointing. Often in life, we never receive that kind of remorseful grace offered by those who intentionally hurt us, and finding our way through it sometimes has to be figured out with only Christ as the source of peace. It was nice that Rose could get those apologies from her Mamm & Erma, but I would have liked for her to realise her value without it. She's written as a beautiful character, with so much love to give. I especially loved the gift from Erma though, and the message it sends to not only Rose but to the reader hopefully.
The cover is gorgeous, and is the reason I chose this book.
I received this complimentary copy from Blogging for Books & WaterBrook. This is my honest review.
Rose, has grown up in a large family with only brothers, and high expectations and harsh, verbally abusive treatment from her mother. An opportunity arises to leave her Pennsylvania home & assist a young widower, in need of help with his 3 small children. I had expected this to be an arranged marriage set up, but since marriage isn't suggested for a while, it never really made sense to me why Rose was shipped off there so fast.
Joel, hard working and successful widower, must find a way to keep moving forward despite the tragic loss of the love of his life and agrees to marry Rose in order to provide childcare for his children. It's a marriage in name only, and even though as the years progress, their friendship blossoms, doubts pursue Rose constantly over the sadness of what she may never have. Joel is a likable kind character, who, fails to communicate his feelings well, though has patience galore for Rose and her overwhelming insecurities. Understandably Rose struggles to believe words of affirmation, in that she is loveable, and it's not helped along by the deceased wife's mother, or the new widow in town.
Some elements of this story fell flat, or presented the opportunity for good development, but didn't materialize. I liked that Rose had an 'Englisch' friend to provide supportive input on marriage, and kindly took care of her. Having someone she knew with a car proved helpful in the timeline of events, when buggy travel wouldn't have made the plot work.
Overall, it's a good story, of discovery, mostly for Rose of her true value. She must receive apologies though in order to finally work through it, which was a little disappointing. Often in life, we never receive that kind of remorseful grace offered by those who intentionally hurt us, and finding our way through it sometimes has to be figured out with only Christ as the source of peace. It was nice that Rose could get those apologies from her Mamm & Erma, but I would have liked for her to realise her value without it. She's written as a beautiful character, with so much love to give. I especially loved the gift from Erma though, and the message it sends to not only Rose but to the reader hopefully.
The cover is gorgeous, and is the reason I chose this book.
I received this complimentary copy from Blogging for Books & WaterBrook. This is my honest review.
March 26, 2017
Review of The Angel of Forest Hill by Cindy Woodsmall
The Angel of Forest Hill by Cindy Woodsmall was a very real and yet very sweet Amish romance. One that will pull at your emotions, and yet leave you smiling and laughing at the turn of each page. It was a perfect read during these chilly days, where all you crave is a warm drink and a good book. I love when I can get my hands on these wintery Amish reads, and have yet to find myself disappointed, especially with Cindy Woodsmall’s Christmas romances.
Rose Kurtz grew up in an Old Order Amish household where she helped her mother tend to her father and eleven brothers. As back-breaking as her job was, and no matter how hard she worked, Rose was almost a ghost amongst her family. If she wanted to be noticed, she only need make a mistake and her mother would be there to scold her or put her in her place. Rose didn’t think things could get worse, but that was until she found herself being shipped away to Forest Hill, without even so much as a goodbye from her family.
Joel Dienner was in shock and unaware of the woman who was brought to help aide with the care of his children after the tragic loss of his wife. With a newborn to care for, a household to tend to, and a business to run, Joel was in over his head. When the proposal comes from his father to take in Rose and make her his wife, for the sake of his kids and their need for a mother, Joel finds himself with no choice but to agree to the partnership.
As the years pass, Joel and Rose find themselves content with their arrangement, so content they become unaware of the yearnings within themselves as their relationship starts to truly take root. Before either of them has the chance to explore these feelings further, a beautiful woman who was recently widowed shows up in Forest Hill and begins to stir things up between Rose and Joel.
With their favorite time of year fast approaching, Joel and Rose find themselves entangled in drama, and unable to free themselves from assumptions and misunderstandings that threaten to ruin their Christmas festivities. Will the ghosts of Joel an Rose’s past make it impossible for them to get past their insecurities and fears, or will they make the hard decision instead to face their problems head on?
This is a book that definitely grows on you the deeper you get into it. I found the emotional trials each character faces very relatable, especially Rose with her introverted manner of approach to everything. If you’re an introvert like me, you’ll totally relate to that inner voice that over-thinks too much, and that outer-voice that never says how it feels often enough. It makes the interactions between Rose and Joel adorably frustrating!
-I received this book for free through blogging for books in exchange for an honest review.
The Angel of Forest Hill by Cindy Woodsmall was a very real and yet very sweet Amish romance. One that will pull at your emotions, and yet leave you smiling and laughing at the turn of each page. It was a perfect read during these chilly days, where all you crave is a warm drink and a good book. I love when I can get my hands on these wintery Amish reads, and have yet to find myself disappointed, especially with Cindy Woodsmall’s Christmas romances.
Rose Kurtz grew up in an Old Order Amish household where she helped her mother tend to her father and eleven brothers. As back-breaking as her job was, and no matter how hard she worked, Rose was almost a ghost amongst her family. If she wanted to be noticed, she only need make a mistake and her mother would be there to scold her or put her in her place. Rose didn’t think things could get worse, but that was until she found herself being shipped away to Forest Hill, without even so much as a goodbye from her family.
Joel Dienner was in shock and unaware of the woman who was brought to help aide with the care of his children after the tragic loss of his wife. With a newborn to care for, a household to tend to, and a business to run, Joel was in over his head. When the proposal comes from his father to take in Rose and make her his wife, for the sake of his kids and their need for a mother, Joel finds himself with no choice but to agree to the partnership.
As the years pass, Joel and Rose find themselves content with their arrangement, so content they become unaware of the yearnings within themselves as their relationship starts to truly take root. Before either of them has the chance to explore these feelings further, a beautiful woman who was recently widowed shows up in Forest Hill and begins to stir things up between Rose and Joel.
With their favorite time of year fast approaching, Joel and Rose find themselves entangled in drama, and unable to free themselves from assumptions and misunderstandings that threaten to ruin their Christmas festivities. Will the ghosts of Joel an Rose’s past make it impossible for them to get past their insecurities and fears, or will they make the hard decision instead to face their problems head on?
This is a book that definitely grows on you the deeper you get into it. I found the emotional trials each character faces very relatable, especially Rose with her introverted manner of approach to everything. If you’re an introvert like me, you’ll totally relate to that inner voice that over-thinks too much, and that outer-voice that never says how it feels often enough. It makes the interactions between Rose and Joel adorably frustrating!
-I received this book for free through blogging for books in exchange for an honest review.
November 14, 2016
About the Book:
A time of anticipation. A season of miracles.
Because of Joel s impossible situation, twenty-one-year-old Rose must sacrifice everything. As days pass into years in the midst of the beautiful hills, the laughter of children, and God s providence is it too much for Rose to hope for love in return?
An amazing journey toward love and belonging, filled with the wonder of the season of Christ s birth.
When Old Order Amish Rose Kurtz is asked to leave her family, travel deep into West Virginia, and help Joel Dienner with his children in the wake of tragedy, the quiet young woman recognizes a home where she might find kindness instead of criticism and hope replacing harsh words. She agrees to stay in Forest Hill and become Joel s wife for the sake of his family needs, but their marriage is to be a partnership, one built from need, not love and affection.
As the years pass, Rose continues to beckon Joel to join life again, to take joy in his growing children, and to awaken his heart to the possibility of new love. Joel hopes that Rose can move beyond deep-rooted hurts to see the beautiful Christmas ahead, their season. But will the arrival of a beautiful widow and a series of misunderstandings reverse how far Rose and Joel have come?"
My Review:
If you have read this review blog for long you know I'm crazy about the Amish, and you also know that Cindy Woodsmall is my all time favorite author. She in my book, can write Amish like nobody's business.The story behind the title is such a sad one. I felt so sorry for the lead character Rose. She does seem so angelic and she just wants to help a family in need but then it turns into something more for her but it looks like at least from the naked eye that those feelings won't be returned.
Rose gets into a marriage out of convenience instead of love and she by all rights feels that Joel won't even honor that marriage if he happens to fall in love with someone else. But soon all the questions that Rose has had all these years will be answered and hopefully when they are Rose can be happy for once.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the author.
A time of anticipation. A season of miracles.
Because of Joel s impossible situation, twenty-one-year-old Rose must sacrifice everything. As days pass into years in the midst of the beautiful hills, the laughter of children, and God s providence is it too much for Rose to hope for love in return?
An amazing journey toward love and belonging, filled with the wonder of the season of Christ s birth.
When Old Order Amish Rose Kurtz is asked to leave her family, travel deep into West Virginia, and help Joel Dienner with his children in the wake of tragedy, the quiet young woman recognizes a home where she might find kindness instead of criticism and hope replacing harsh words. She agrees to stay in Forest Hill and become Joel s wife for the sake of his family needs, but their marriage is to be a partnership, one built from need, not love and affection.
As the years pass, Rose continues to beckon Joel to join life again, to take joy in his growing children, and to awaken his heart to the possibility of new love. Joel hopes that Rose can move beyond deep-rooted hurts to see the beautiful Christmas ahead, their season. But will the arrival of a beautiful widow and a series of misunderstandings reverse how far Rose and Joel have come?"
My Review:
If you have read this review blog for long you know I'm crazy about the Amish, and you also know that Cindy Woodsmall is my all time favorite author. She in my book, can write Amish like nobody's business.The story behind the title is such a sad one. I felt so sorry for the lead character Rose. She does seem so angelic and she just wants to help a family in need but then it turns into something more for her but it looks like at least from the naked eye that those feelings won't be returned.
Rose gets into a marriage out of convenience instead of love and she by all rights feels that Joel won't even honor that marriage if he happens to fall in love with someone else. But soon all the questions that Rose has had all these years will be answered and hopefully when they are Rose can be happy for once.
**Disclosure** This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review from the author.
Read
November 9, 2020Rose is used to hard work. She has eleven brothers. She is the only daughter, so keeping them all fed and clothed falls mostly to her and to her sharp-tongued mother. Rose’s mom is actually more than sharp-tongued. She’s more like emotionally abusive, and Rose emotionally traumatized. So when an opportunity comes to leave home, Rose takes it.
Joel’s wife Florence dies in childbirth. Joel is left with three some children, one of them a newborn. He can’t raise them himself because his canoe-building business supports the whole village, and no village ladies are available. So the church elders send for Rose. Could she come help out? She does. And when the arrangement seems to be working, Joel’s father, the pastor, suggests they should continue, but for decency’s sake, they should marry.
They do. It’s a marriage of convenience, with separate bedrooms. Joel hopes in time it will lead to more. But in the beginning he is overcome with his grief. And Rose is sensitive, afraid of criticism, and buries her feelings. How can these two wounded people find their way to each other, even as they perform acts of kindness for each other and sit at the same table?
This was a story unlike any I had read. I liked that the game was won by patience and kindness, as well as some prodding to be bold and stand up for oneself. I liked that the characters were willing to ask themselves if maybe they were wrong, and to dare to try new things. I also liked that the sweetness was tempered with flashes of humor.
This small book, which can be read in a day, is an Amish Christmas romance. As always, I was skeptical of details of Amish life. Do the Amish wrap Christmas presents? Maybe. But buying that paper seems like a waste and an affectation. Setting the story in an Amish community makes the plot device of the arranged marriage work, even though, as the book points out, arranged marriages among the Amish are not customary. The climax of the story unfolds over Christmas, but this book is as much an all-year-round story as a Christmas story, because the couple has lived together for four years, and their romance is built on friendship, admiration, a common love of the children, and a strong working partnership.
Joel’s wife Florence dies in childbirth. Joel is left with three some children, one of them a newborn. He can’t raise them himself because his canoe-building business supports the whole village, and no village ladies are available. So the church elders send for Rose. Could she come help out? She does. And when the arrangement seems to be working, Joel’s father, the pastor, suggests they should continue, but for decency’s sake, they should marry.
They do. It’s a marriage of convenience, with separate bedrooms. Joel hopes in time it will lead to more. But in the beginning he is overcome with his grief. And Rose is sensitive, afraid of criticism, and buries her feelings. How can these two wounded people find their way to each other, even as they perform acts of kindness for each other and sit at the same table?
This was a story unlike any I had read. I liked that the game was won by patience and kindness, as well as some prodding to be bold and stand up for oneself. I liked that the characters were willing to ask themselves if maybe they were wrong, and to dare to try new things. I also liked that the sweetness was tempered with flashes of humor.
This small book, which can be read in a day, is an Amish Christmas romance. As always, I was skeptical of details of Amish life. Do the Amish wrap Christmas presents? Maybe. But buying that paper seems like a waste and an affectation. Setting the story in an Amish community makes the plot device of the arranged marriage work, even though, as the book points out, arranged marriages among the Amish are not customary. The climax of the story unfolds over Christmas, but this book is as much an all-year-round story as a Christmas story, because the couple has lived together for four years, and their romance is built on friendship, admiration, a common love of the children, and a strong working partnership.
December 5, 2016
Rose Kurtz grew up following orders so when her father orders her to travel to West Virginia to serve as a mother’s helper, she packs a small case and goes – no questions, just obedient. She arrives at the home of Joel Dienner to discover that the mother she has travelled to help has died in childbirth leaving three children and a grieving husband to mourn her passing. Since the Amish community of Forest Hill is tiny, there is no one available to help Joel care for his children except the newcomer, Rose. He can hardly think straight as grief overwhelms his heart so when his father, the bishop, suggests that he marry Rose in order to secure a caretaker for his young family, Joel is at first repulsed by the idea. He cannot imagine replacing his wife so soon but he cannot keep the unmarried Rose as his helper unless he marries her.
Rose, on the other hand, sees a home where she is treated with respect and kindness. She has no desire to return home to a life of servitude where she is berated at every turn by her mother. And, three small children and one man are a whole lot different to care for than her 11 brothers and two parents! When Joel proposes a loveless marriage, she accepts. Her only requirements are that she and the children always be treated with kindness and that the children will never be beaten. Joel agrees and Rose steps into the role of Mama – not Maam – for his 2-year-old and 3-year-old boys and his infant daughter. As the years pass, Rose helps to draw Joel out of his grief and makes a home for herself with his family. She loves his children and she has fallen in love with him, too. Can Joel get past his grief to see the woman his wife has become? How long will he hold her at arm’s length when all she wants is to be held close to his heart?
If you are looking for a short Christmas read, this is the book for you! Joel and Rose are perfect together. I especially appreciated how gently he handled her fears when she first came to Forest Hill. I also loved how much more confidence Rose gained when she began caring for the Dienner family. Readers of Amish fiction will particularly enjoy this lovely, gentle, romantic Christmas story. I definitely recommend!
Rose, on the other hand, sees a home where she is treated with respect and kindness. She has no desire to return home to a life of servitude where she is berated at every turn by her mother. And, three small children and one man are a whole lot different to care for than her 11 brothers and two parents! When Joel proposes a loveless marriage, she accepts. Her only requirements are that she and the children always be treated with kindness and that the children will never be beaten. Joel agrees and Rose steps into the role of Mama – not Maam – for his 2-year-old and 3-year-old boys and his infant daughter. As the years pass, Rose helps to draw Joel out of his grief and makes a home for herself with his family. She loves his children and she has fallen in love with him, too. Can Joel get past his grief to see the woman his wife has become? How long will he hold her at arm’s length when all she wants is to be held close to his heart?
If you are looking for a short Christmas read, this is the book for you! Joel and Rose are perfect together. I especially appreciated how gently he handled her fears when she first came to Forest Hill. I also loved how much more confidence Rose gained when she began caring for the Dienner family. Readers of Amish fiction will particularly enjoy this lovely, gentle, romantic Christmas story. I definitely recommend!
December 3, 2016
Cindy Woodsmall's The Angel of Forest Hill is a sweet Amish Christmas romance that could be enjoyed at any time of the year.
Rose and Joel are both interesting characters with deep needs and concerns in which each can be of benefit to the other. Joel's difficulties surface in the form of extreme tragedy from the very beginning of the story. The fact that Rose has hurts and scars is evident early on, but the depth of her struggles comes to the surface at a little slower pace. Their story involves a slow-blossoming love born out of practical circumstances rather than any initial spark of romance.
There are themes in the story that are probably unique to the Amish way of life. Much of the plot, although in the Amish setting, has to do with personal issues that could come up in situations that any of us might face from time to time. Trust (or lack thereof), emotions (positive and negative), and communication are areas where Joel and Rose have to learn important lessons. Cindy Woodsmall hits those topics by way of a very engaging story.
If you are a fan of Amish fiction, and especially if you are already familiar with Cindy Woodsmall, you know to expect good things from her. You should not be disappointed with this quick Christmas read.
Thanks to Blogging for Books for providing a copy of this book. I was delighted to share my own thoughts in this review.
Rose and Joel are both interesting characters with deep needs and concerns in which each can be of benefit to the other. Joel's difficulties surface in the form of extreme tragedy from the very beginning of the story. The fact that Rose has hurts and scars is evident early on, but the depth of her struggles comes to the surface at a little slower pace. Their story involves a slow-blossoming love born out of practical circumstances rather than any initial spark of romance.
There are themes in the story that are probably unique to the Amish way of life. Much of the plot, although in the Amish setting, has to do with personal issues that could come up in situations that any of us might face from time to time. Trust (or lack thereof), emotions (positive and negative), and communication are areas where Joel and Rose have to learn important lessons. Cindy Woodsmall hits those topics by way of a very engaging story.
If you are a fan of Amish fiction, and especially if you are already familiar with Cindy Woodsmall, you know to expect good things from her. You should not be disappointed with this quick Christmas read.
Thanks to Blogging for Books for providing a copy of this book. I was delighted to share my own thoughts in this review.
April 4, 2018
Angel of Forest Hill by Cindy Woodsmall is a heartfelt book about heartache, mercy, and hope.
Rose lives with her father, mother, and a multitude of brothers. She is asked to go to Forest Hill to help a young mother who is not doing well after the birth of her daughter. When Rose arrives, the community is in grief as the young mother has passed. By divine intervention, Rose quickly knows what to do to help the new baby and young children.
Joel is struggling to get by after his wife’s sudden passing. He can’t take care of himself, let alone his children and business. When his father proposes an arranged marriage between him and Rose, he is unsure but knows she would be a good mother for his motherless children.
The story continues to tell how Joel and Rose cope with the arranged marriage and raising three children.
Cindy delivered again with a beautiful story. This was an easy read that I completed in one day. The characters were well-developed and easy to fall in love with.
I strongly recommend this book to anyone who loves Amish or Inspiration fiction.
I received a copy of from the netgalley and WaterBrook & Multonomah in return for my honest review.
Rose lives with her father, mother, and a multitude of brothers. She is asked to go to Forest Hill to help a young mother who is not doing well after the birth of her daughter. When Rose arrives, the community is in grief as the young mother has passed. By divine intervention, Rose quickly knows what to do to help the new baby and young children.
Joel is struggling to get by after his wife’s sudden passing. He can’t take care of himself, let alone his children and business. When his father proposes an arranged marriage between him and Rose, he is unsure but knows she would be a good mother for his motherless children.
The story continues to tell how Joel and Rose cope with the arranged marriage and raising three children.
Cindy delivered again with a beautiful story. This was an easy read that I completed in one day. The characters were well-developed and easy to fall in love with.
I strongly recommend this book to anyone who loves Amish or Inspiration fiction.
I received a copy of from the netgalley and WaterBrook & Multonomah in return for my honest review.
November 8, 2016
Anytime I can I read a Cindy Woodsmall book. The ANGEL of FOREST HILL is a Christmas Novella Romance that will not disappoint.
Rose Kurtz is sent by her District Bishop to assist with a family that is expecting a child and needs help with the older children. The young mother dies and leaves a baby with the grieving widower.
Joel Dienner is so consumed with grief and there is no one available to take care of the baby so his Daed suggests he marry Rose. They marry with no misconception of it being a real marriage.
Will they eventually realize they care for each other? Will they be able to get past their own doubts and insecurities?
I love Cindy’s ability to write of the Amish in such a way that you admire so much about them, even when you question some aspects of their lives.
I received a free copy from WaterBrook Publishing. No review, positive or otherwise, was required – all opinions are my own.
About these ads
Rose Kurtz is sent by her District Bishop to assist with a family that is expecting a child and needs help with the older children. The young mother dies and leaves a baby with the grieving widower.
Joel Dienner is so consumed with grief and there is no one available to take care of the baby so his Daed suggests he marry Rose. They marry with no misconception of it being a real marriage.
Will they eventually realize they care for each other? Will they be able to get past their own doubts and insecurities?
I love Cindy’s ability to write of the Amish in such a way that you admire so much about them, even when you question some aspects of their lives.
I received a free copy from WaterBrook Publishing. No review, positive or otherwise, was required – all opinions are my own.
About these ads
November 29, 2018
I read this book for a monthly group read. It was about Rose who left her family in Pennsylvania to help a widowed male, Joel, with his children in West Virginia. His wife had passed just before Rose arrived. Joel asks Rose to marry him for convenience of assisting him with the children and Rose accepts to stay away from her family in Pennsylvania. Years pass and both realized they have fallen in love for the other but don't know how to tell the other one. Then the Ex-mother-in-law intervenes and tells the Bishop that they have not consummated their marriage and everything goes up in an uproar and Joel and Rose finally tell each other their feelings about each other. But is it too late? Will there marriage have to be annulled by Amish Rules. Read the book to find out the ending to this Amish Romance.
July 6, 2018
This was such a sweet story that started out as a marriage of convenience and grew into so much more. Rose's self esteem is very low due to a childhood cut short and an overbearing mother with high expectations. When she is called away to help a widower with his 3 young children, she enjoys the escape. When he proposes marriage in order to avoid scandal, she readily agrees with a few small conditions. As time progresses, Rose and Joel fall into a pattern, grow closer, and help each other to heal. This was such a sweet love story - and a tale of healing, redemption, and forgiveness. It brought me to tears! I would highly recommend!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 160 reviews