Thirteen years have passed since the war began, the bombs fell and the Central States were wiped off the map. When the fighting stopped, a massive wall was built to separate the surviving states from the devastated ones, altering life as humanity knew it forever. River lives in a small fishing town, and for the past thirteen years she has been responsible for raising and providing for her younger brothers. Their mother neglects them and despises River in particular, constantly calling her evil and different. River is different, but she does her best to hide it from everyone — even her own family.
Once a year, military personnel visit her town to gather volunteers for the war that still rages beyond the wall. Although military service offers certain benefits for family members, River has never volunteered; she’s needed at home, and the last thing she wants is to leave her brothers in the care of their abusive and uncaring mother. But this year, the military is looking specifically for recruits with special abilities — and her mother immediately turns her in. Forced to leave everything behind, River is conscripted to serve on the wall, unaware of what truly awaits her. Rumors circulate, but the truth is far more terrifying than anything she could have imagined.
The beginning is slow, but the world-building is strong, and I appreciated how gradually the setting unfolded. However, once River arrives at the wall (around page 100), the story shifts into heavy info-dumping. Instead of blending exposition naturally, many scenes read like repetitive Q&A sessions or interviews. The conversations often felt stiff and inorganic, which was disappointing — especially given how fascinating Kobal’s and the demons’ backstories could have been.
Midway through the book, entire days and weeks are suddenly summarized in a few sentences before another round of Q&A begins, which felt odd and unsatisfying. I also struggled with Kobal’s character arc: his shift from being reserved and distant to suddenly overly affectionate toward River felt unconvincing, lacking emotional depth and coming across as rushed — driven too much by lust rather than genuine development. I’m hoping book two will offer more nuance.
As for the supporting cast, there’s potential, but we learn very little about the other demons or about Mac. We’re given brief glimpses, but not enough to make them feel fleshed out, which left me wanting more.
While I appreciated the absence of a dramatic cliffhanger, I couldn’t fully understand River’s thoughts and behavior at the end of the first book. I sympathize with her anger, doubts, and desire to escape her circumstances, but the hurtful back-and-forth felt childish and unnecessary. It came across as drama for the sake of drama. I would have preferred more emotional maturity from her — though to be fair, the book has a strong YA tone overall.
However, I still enjoyed the book and plan to continue the series. I’m intrigued by the direction of the plot and curious to see how the characters develop. And despite its flaws, the story had some standout moments that genuinely surprised me. I especially liked the post-apocalyptic setting and the freshness of the premise — it felt unlike anything I’ve read so far.
Story: 3 ⭐️
Spice: 2 🌶️