Still reading. About 30% in.
I appreciate this course, but there is some effort to paint the Arabic/Islamic conquests is a light that diminishes how horrible they were. I understand not wanting to sell a narrative of Arab world bad/Europe good, but training the whole conquest of North Africa and Spain as lucky raiding, glossing over the Jizya taxation hat forced many to convert is a little far.
I love his passion for the subject though, and I've learned things I didn't know before, like the Fatimids Shias in North Africa and the Norman kingdom in Sicily.
___
50% in.
Sometimes, the writer seems very scornful of the Christian lands the muslims displaced and makes it seem like they deserved it. The Visigoths in Spain, the North African Christians, the Byzantine empire...whenever he mentions them, he never fails to observe that they were either weak or corrupt. Whenever he mentions an atrocity committed by Muslim conquerors, he mentions something comparable that Christians did, almost like an excuse. Where there’s nothing comparable, he glosses over it. It’s one thing to want to leave readers aware of the glories of the middle eastern empires, but it’s another thing entirely to promote a mean view of the European Christian world.
___
You can mention that the Arabs were racist toward black people without trying to excuse it by drawing parallels with the British empire.
___
Dude, you just said a Christian crusader army invaded Constantinople and wreaked untold havoc, bloodshed, and rape. Paragraphs later, you're poking holes in the stories of carnage at the fall of Constantinople to the Ottomans. "The Ottomans had no reason to rape and pillage and murder because they would have needed the ransoms more." Really? It starts to look like the mention of the raping crusaders was groundwork to make the Ottoman slaughter less jarring.
______
Finally finished this, and I feel like I’ve learned a lot! Spanning centuries and very easy to listen to, this has given me many things to think about and ideas for other books to read. The last chapter about the end of the Ottoman caliphate saddened me, especially with the expulsion of the Ottomans from their home country.