What do you think?
Rate this book
Erased #8
Erased - Boku Dake ga Inai Machi, tomo 8
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews
March 16, 2020
What a ride, my friends. I HIGHLY recommend Erased! Great ending to a great story
August 9, 2016
This manga is amazing. From all the stories that I have read so far, this one's unique and unpredictable. There's depth in the characters, and there are lessons to be learned.
December 16, 2017
5/5 estrellas.
GRITÉ DE EMOCIÓN CON TODO Y ME DESHICE EN LÁGRIMAS CON ESE FINAAAAL ♥♥♥♥♥
Siento que todo lo que viví a lo largo de estos ocho tomos, y ver a mis niños hacerse adultos, me pudo muchísimo y por eso se lleva la calificación máxima.
Lo termino feliz con saber que todos los personajes femeninos relevantes son una maravilla para mi corazón ♥
GRITÉ DE EMOCIÓN CON TODO Y ME DESHICE EN LÁGRIMAS CON ESE FINAAAAL ♥♥♥♥♥
Siento que todo lo que viví a lo largo de estos ocho tomos, y ver a mis niños hacerse adultos, me pudo muchísimo y por eso se lleva la calificación máxima.
Lo termino feliz con saber que todos los personajes femeninos relevantes son una maravilla para mi corazón ♥
February 23, 2018
Il futuro è sempre un foglio bianco. E solo la nostra volontà può imprimerci le nostre impronte.
August 10, 2018
3.5
La conclusión me pareció medio apresurada, perdió un poco de intensidad y suspenso.
Los primeros tomos me parecieron re atrapantes pero como que cerca del final empezó a decaer.
La conclusión me pareció medio apresurada, perdió un poco de intensidad y suspenso.
Los primeros tomos me parecieron re atrapantes pero como que cerca del final empezó a decaer.
September 9, 2024
No bc why ts got me tearing up 🥲
July 20, 2016
10/10
May 15, 2017
uno dei manga migliori che ho letto fino ad ora.
March 21, 2021
Si hay algo que me hace muy feliz en cualquier historia relativamente larga es que tenga un buen final y esta, por fortuna, lo consigue. Desde que vi la adaptación animada, tenía mis problemas con ese último episodio, su drama forzado y su falta de sutileza en ciertas partes. El manga, en cambio, hace algo totalmente distinto y, en mi opinión, mucho más adecuado para el tono de la obra. No solo es un tomo entero de enfrentamiento entre Satoru & Co. y el asesino; también es un cierre a una investigación de veinte años.
Reconozco que Sanbe no las tenía todas consigo. Resultaba complicado dar verosimilitud a varios elementos de la trama y, al mismo tiempo, resolver la situación en apenas un par de capítulos, de ahí que esa dedicación absoluta del volumen al plan para vencer al asesino funcione tan bien. La resolución total, aunque me haya parecido floja, ha venido precedida de una conversación interesante, realista y bien escrita. Es un permiso triste, pero cómo me alegro de que Sanbe aporte el realismo que necesita la industria del manganime para hacer a este tipo de villanos creíbles y no una caricatura maniática. Todo resulta más tenso y más cercano gracias a este acercamiento casi naturalista al thriller.
A pesar del merecido final y una tensión palpable hasta el último capítulo, el manga sigue teniendo sus problemillas: el dibujo, aunque a mí me convenza, puede tirar fácilmente para atrás si uno se fija en la estética antes que en el paneling o la narrativa que se deriva de él (algo, por otra parte, natural: el manga es un medio que entra por los ojos); Sachiko, la MVP de todo el manga y la Creadora de los sugus de piña en mi head-canon, se merecía más tiempo en pantalla durante los últimos volúmenes; algunas japonesadas son de alzar una ceja mínimo, y en cierto modo he echado en falta la presencia de los medios en los tomos 6 y 7.
Por lo demás, ha estado guay. Si se le perdonan un par de cosas, el producto termina siendo bastante sólido y una muestra clara de que el thriller japonés ni ha muerto ni tiene ganas de morir. No lo pondría al nivel de Urasawa, pero que aquí me caiga muerto si no tiene un notable de manual.
Reconozco que Sanbe no las tenía todas consigo. Resultaba complicado dar verosimilitud a varios elementos de la trama y, al mismo tiempo, resolver la situación en apenas un par de capítulos, de ahí que esa dedicación absoluta del volumen al plan para vencer al asesino funcione tan bien. La resolución total, aunque me haya parecido floja, ha venido precedida de una conversación interesante, realista y bien escrita. Es un permiso triste, pero cómo me alegro de que Sanbe aporte el realismo que necesita la industria del manganime para hacer a este tipo de villanos creíbles y no una caricatura maniática. Todo resulta más tenso y más cercano gracias a este acercamiento casi naturalista al thriller.
A pesar del merecido final y una tensión palpable hasta el último capítulo, el manga sigue teniendo sus problemillas: el dibujo, aunque a mí me convenza, puede tirar fácilmente para atrás si uno se fija en la estética antes que en el paneling o la narrativa que se deriva de él (algo, por otra parte, natural: el manga es un medio que entra por los ojos); Sachiko, la MVP de todo el manga y la Creadora de los sugus de piña en mi head-canon, se merecía más tiempo en pantalla durante los últimos volúmenes; algunas japonesadas son de alzar una ceja mínimo, y en cierto modo he echado en falta la presencia de los medios en los tomos 6 y 7.
Por lo demás, ha estado guay. Si se le perdonan un par de cosas, el producto termina siendo bastante sólido y una muestra clara de que el thriller japonés ni ha muerto ni tiene ganas de morir. No lo pondría al nivel de Urasawa, pero que aquí me caiga muerto si no tiene un notable de manual.
June 28, 2020
This was so good! I really enjoyed this and this was great ending (?) at least that what Kei Sanbe called it, but what are we gonna do in the "last volume" now when the story ended? Maybe it is own story. Anyway i have loved the time i have spend with this series!
March 7, 2019
El futuro siempre será una hoja en blanco, solo mi voluntad puede dejar huellas en él.
May 30, 2019
Mi è piaciuto tanto il fine.
December 17, 2019
No me gusto el final, pero en si, un excelente manga.
Gracias Manu.
Gracias Manu.
October 23, 2021
NECESITO PONERLE MAS ESTRELLAS
February 22, 2023
best volume from the series👌
November 21, 2019
Okay, this was a fine ending for the story (there's still a bonus stories volume but the main story ends here). It wasn't a flashy one, neither the confrontation between Satoru and the killer nor "the life after" chapter but that's not a bad thing here. Especially the final chapter had some nice scenes.
There were some twisty plotting with Satoru and Kenya as they made a trap for the killer which was fun to see unfold. The sentiment of close friends and family was lovely.
The MVP of this manga definitely was Sachiko. She kinda only lived for her son and didn't seem to have much life outside that but she was genuinely happy to be there for Satoru (and later Kumi too), so if she's happy doing it, that's fine. Kumi was lovely character too. I didn't care so much about Satoru at any point but fortunately he was surrounded by more interesting characters.
Art is ugly as ever, and that's why I'm dropping a star. Well, the backgrounds etc. are good but the characters' looks are just... yuck.
It was okay as a whole, the mystery was interesting, there were good twists and some of the characters were nice but the character art was unappealing. Other readers might be able to look past weird noses etc. and like this even more.
There were some twisty plotting with Satoru and Kenya as they made a trap for the killer which was fun to see unfold. The sentiment of close friends and family was lovely.
The MVP of this manga definitely was Sachiko. She kinda only lived for her son and didn't seem to have much life outside that but she was genuinely happy to be there for Satoru (and later Kumi too), so if she's happy doing it, that's fine. Kumi was lovely character too. I didn't care so much about Satoru at any point but fortunately he was surrounded by more interesting characters.
Art is ugly as ever, and that's why I'm dropping a star. Well, the backgrounds etc. are good but the characters' looks are just... yuck.
It was okay as a whole, the mystery was interesting, there were good twists and some of the characters were nice but the character art was unappealing. Other readers might be able to look past weird noses etc. and like this even more.
July 20, 2017
Well it was certainly different from the anime ending, but good nevertheless.
Actually, it was great with lots of flaws.
Story -was a little failure in my opinion. The time travel aspect was never explained. The mystery part was rather obvious. But the storytelling was beautiful and engaging.
The characters - I liked them all, even the bad guy. Satoru was likable, Airi was brave, Mother was badass, Kenya was clever (too clever for his age), Kayo was sweetheart, Sensei was too nice to be true.
And I liked killer's motives, he was a real psychopath. The only unlikable character was Kayo's abusive mother.
The art - though I didn't liked the character designs that much the art was smooth and clear, so that's a plus.
Overall, I enjoyed the manga very much. 4.25 stars
Actually, it was great with lots of flaws.
Story -was a little failure in my opinion. The time travel aspect was never explained. The mystery part was rather obvious. But the storytelling was beautiful and engaging.
The characters - I liked them all, even the bad guy. Satoru was likable, Airi was brave, Mother was badass, Kenya was clever (too clever for his age), Kayo was sweetheart, Sensei was too nice to be true.
And I liked killer's motives, he was a real psychopath. The only unlikable character was Kayo's abusive mother.
The art - though I didn't liked the character designs that much the art was smooth and clear, so that's a plus.
Overall, I enjoyed the manga very much. 4.25 stars
March 19, 2018
That is a great ending!
It wrapped up pretty well, the final panel was amazing!
And as a whole it was a pretty good story with great characters.
I stopped watching the anime after the first episode; to check the manga and when I saw the differences I decided to finish the manga first, before going back in to the anime, after that ending I think I do not have to, because it is a very good ending, but I will check the anime with an open mind.
Great series and a very good read.
It wrapped up pretty well, the final panel was amazing!
And as a whole it was a pretty good story with great characters.
I stopped watching the anime after the first episode; to check the manga and when I saw the differences I decided to finish the manga first, before going back in to the anime, after that ending I think I do not have to, because it is a very good ending, but I will check the anime with an open mind.
Great series and a very good read.
March 16, 2020
The intensity and suspense of this volume gets me going to read the rest of the pages hungrily. I can’t get enough of the story, especially now since we’re on the last volume already.
It’s exciting to finally join along Satoru and Kenya in unveiling the mysteries behind the killings and be there for them until the very end. Not to mention, a possible new beginning for everyone to compensate with.
Update: I just finished the ending, I can now put my mind at ease.
It’s exciting to finally join along Satoru and Kenya in unveiling the mysteries behind the killings and be there for them until the very end. Not to mention, a possible new beginning for everyone to compensate with.
Update: I just finished the ending, I can now put my mind at ease.
December 22, 2020
I didn't like the events of the end of the manga as much I did for the anime. They were completely different...and I'm glad the anime didn't adapt it. The end, end was the same as the anime. The anime may have been a little rushed...but it was still better than the ending of the manga!
March 13, 2016
Good thriller
May 12, 2020
Need to mull over this ending before deciding on a rating
December 21, 2021
Reseña completa: https://paseandoentrepaginas.blogspot...
July 7, 2023
Akhirnya sampai di akhir cerita dari komik ini. Akhir yang pantas untuk Yashiro. Untung aja Kei Sanbe-sensei nggak buat si Yashiro langsung mati pas dia bunuh diri. Jadi diadili dulu untuk kasus-kasusnya. Setelah targetnya dulu bocah-bocak kesepian, pas makin liar malah bunuh orang-orang remaja/dewasa. Beneran serem banget orang kayak gini 'gentayangan' selama 20 tahun lebih sebagai pembunuh, tapi nggak ada yang tahu *bergidik ngeri*.
Perjuangan Satoru untuk mengubah takdir teman-teman dan ibunya pun berakhir bahagia. Di masa sekarang dia jadi komikus yang terkenal. Ibunya masih hidup. Teman-temannya juga mendampingi. Sayangnya, kekasih hati nggak dilanjutkan ceritanya sampai akhir XD. Yahh, akhir begitu pun sudah oke juga sih.
Senang banget mood baca lagi bagus. Jadinya bisa selesai cepat. Tergantung genre juga kali, ya karena thriller gitu memang harus dibaca berdekatan, biar nggak hilang euforianya ^^.
Terjemahannya oke sih. Nggak ada yang bikin bingung. Cuma ada 1 kata yang kupikir typo, tapi sepertinya memang ditulis gitu :D
Overall, 5/5 bintang untuk komik ini. Arigatou, Kei Sanbe-sensei telah membuat cerita yang bikin emosi ikut terbawa juga ^_^
Perjuangan Satoru untuk mengubah takdir teman-teman dan ibunya pun berakhir bahagia. Di masa sekarang dia jadi komikus yang terkenal. Ibunya masih hidup. Teman-temannya juga mendampingi. Sayangnya, kekasih hati nggak dilanjutkan ceritanya sampai akhir XD. Yahh, akhir begitu pun sudah oke juga sih.
Senang banget mood baca lagi bagus. Jadinya bisa selesai cepat. Tergantung genre juga kali, ya karena thriller gitu memang harus dibaca berdekatan, biar nggak hilang euforianya ^^.
Terjemahannya oke sih. Nggak ada yang bikin bingung. Cuma ada 1 kata yang kupikir typo, tapi sepertinya memang ditulis gitu :D
Overall, 5/5 bintang untuk komik ini. Arigatou, Kei Sanbe-sensei telah membuat cerita yang bikin emosi ikut terbawa juga ^_^
June 23, 2020
Erased è un opera molto carina. I suoi personaggi sono tutti ben caratterizzati, coerenti e nel corso della storia crescono e maturano. Il punto forte dell'opera sono senza dubbio i legami che si creano tra i personaggi, davvero belli, ben costruiti e dolci. Il difetto più grande, però è il fatto che sia davvero facile capire chi sia il colpevole. Tuttavia bisogna dire che , solitamente, quando per il lettore è evidente chi sia il colpevole, ciò che da più fastidio è la stupidità dei protagonisti, che nonostante l'evidenza non riescono a fare 2+2, in questo caso, però il fatto che i protagonisti non capiscano chi sia il colpevole non mi ha dato fastidio, perche è proprio questo cio che voleva dire l'autore: ossia che questi tipi di criminali sono persone davvero brave a relazionarsi con gli altri e a indurli a fidarsi di loro; perciò è credibile che i personaggi non pensino a lui come colpevole. Ho trovato quindi questo errore non cosi insuperabile. Per il resto le cose sono logiche e ben spiegate,quindi nel complesso un opera molto carina.
July 6, 2021
Did i read four mangas in a day? yes, i did. Do i regret it? Not at all. My lord, my heart is aching so bad<\3. I didn't want to finish this, but I needed to know what was going to happen. I really hope the professor gets the penalty he deserves, he was disgusting and awful, he was a monster. I'm happy with the ending, i guess? I'm still really sad because all of the years he wasted and how he was willing to sacrifice almost his whole life for the sake of the people he loved.
I think the art is great, truly amazing. There were some funny parts (really really few ones, but let's treasure them) that I loved. The story is very well developed, and it has wonderful characters.
I could rant so much more about this series, but I don't want to be repetitive, so let's end this here. In conclusion, I loved this series and it became one of my favourites mangas! ^^ I'm really excited to start watching the anime:]
I think the art is great, truly amazing. There were some funny parts (really really few ones, but let's treasure them) that I loved. The story is very well developed, and it has wonderful characters.
I could rant so much more about this series, but I don't want to be repetitive, so let's end this here. In conclusion, I loved this series and it became one of my favourites mangas! ^^ I'm really excited to start watching the anime:]
October 8, 2017
3.5*
En general me gustó... Aunque tengo que decir que algunas cosas no funcionaron como deberían: el “misterio” es algo muy obvio, por ejemplo. Los dibujos son de buena calidad, pero tengo un problema con los rostros, para mi todos los personajes se parecen; Kei Sanbe tampoco es muy bueno dibujando expresiones. Me refiero a que estas no son únicas en cada personaje, todos lloran igual, todos se enojan igual... Tampoco me gustó que el final sea un poco cursi. Satoru empezó siendo un pesimista y un solitario, y al final solo faltaba que se agarraran todos de la mano y se pusieran a cantar... Parecía una historia cruda, pero le faltó eso mismo, crudeza jaja. Creo que podría haber visto solo el anime tranquilamente, porque el manga no es tan genial. Lo recomiendo pero hasta ahí.
En general me gustó... Aunque tengo que decir que algunas cosas no funcionaron como deberían: el “misterio” es algo muy obvio, por ejemplo. Los dibujos son de buena calidad, pero tengo un problema con los rostros, para mi todos los personajes se parecen; Kei Sanbe tampoco es muy bueno dibujando expresiones. Me refiero a que estas no son únicas en cada personaje, todos lloran igual, todos se enojan igual... Tampoco me gustó que el final sea un poco cursi. Satoru empezó siendo un pesimista y un solitario, y al final solo faltaba que se agarraran todos de la mano y se pusieran a cantar... Parecía una historia cruda, pero le faltó eso mismo, crudeza jaja. Creo que podría haber visto solo el anime tranquilamente, porque el manga no es tan genial. Lo recomiendo pero hasta ahí.
August 9, 2017
Increíble. Me lo he pulido enseguida porque ha sido empezar y no poder dejarlo hasta terminarlo. Me atrajo porque soy muy fan de los viajes en el tiempo y la novela negra. Por otro manga suyo que he leído, puedo afirmar que Kei Sanbe sabe manejar temas tan serios como el maltrato y el abuso infantil, que nos ponen los pelos de punta, combinándolos con momentos cálidos de esperanza, amistad y amor...en su justa medida y sin saturar. Aunque la resolución del misterio es predecible, este manga no te soltará hasta el final.
May 29, 2017
La historia es bellisima, aun con su toque tristongo y emotivo. Me fascinan las reflexiones del personaje principal; las palabras que usa para expresar sus sentimientos y sus pensamientos no son solo adecuadas sino que son reales, no suenan forzadas, lo que logra un diálogo muy bello acompañado de unos dibujos hermosos.
Lo único que me molestó es que fuera bastante predecible... O quizás yo leo demasiados policiales...
Lo único que me molestó es que fuera bastante predecible... O quizás yo leo demasiados policiales...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 89 reviews