At the time of this review, I have already read omnibus volume 4 (volumes 7 and 8).
There were highs and lows with this volume, which is to be expected. The game that set the tone for the rest of the volume is comparable to Karasuno's first official game with Bluecastle. Just like how Kageyama and Hinata got a wake-up call in that game Kagami and Kuroko got a wake-up call in this game. That is all I am really going to say about this volume, because it is just too much of a spoiler minefield. What I am going to talk about is Slam Dunk vs. Kuroko's Basketball and realism.
Slam Dunk vs. Kuroko's Basketball
Based on comments on Youtube and a coworker, people seem to put Slam Dunk as top tier basketball manga and some very praise-worthy. Then there is Kuroko's Basketball, which seems to be deemed as entertaining and not very realistic. Then there is me.
I saw bits and pieces of Kuroko's Basketball in its anime form before I read Slam Dunk and the manga form of Kuroko's Basketball. I actually enjoyed Kuroko's Basketball. You still learn something about the sport and they do practice. Then I decided to give Slam Dunk a try. Slam Dunk is not bad, but I am not sure if it is anything noteworthy. Before I get criticize for that comment, let me give you some of my background that I am basing these comments on. Before I read Slam Dunk and I think after I saw bits and pieces of Kuroko's Basketball, I read Haikyu!! and saw Grease.
Grease? What does a movie starring John Travolta has to do with sports manga? Well, I saw this movie WAY before Haikyuu!!, Slam Dunk, and Kuroko's Basketball. This is important detail. Haikyuu!! was amazing for me! It had everything that I could possibly want in a series. It had great lines, group dynamics, inspiration, and exciting games. For me, this is what a sports movie or book should be about. That is why I like the movie Miracle, which is about the 1980 male American Olympic Hockey team. Then I got into Slam Dunk and Kuroko's Basketball.
At this point, I am reading Slam Dunk and Kuroko's Basketball concurrently. My main stumbling block when deciding which manga presents a better view of basketball is I keep viewing Slam Dunk as Grease, if Grease was about a bad boy becoming an athlete. Sakuragi's story is similar to Danny Zuko's story when it comes being involve with a sport. Yes, Slam Dunk moves away from the fighting aspects, but that still kind of threw me. There is no slug fests in Haikyuu!!. Lots of tugging of shirts when the characters are mad, but there are no full on punches. Kuroko's Basketball deals a lot with prodigies, but that is not exactly new for Haikyuu!! is LITTERED with prodigies. Personally, I cannot compare Kuroko's Basketball to many things. I can make connections with Haikyuu!!, but it is still different enough. I am also not a basketball person. It was not the sport that I did in school, which means I am not sure about how plausible Kuroko's Basketball is.
Realism
I will admit out of all the characters so far in Kuroko's Basketball Midorima's abilities seem the most otherworldly and does not seem possible on Earth. Yet, they do make the effort to ground him in reality. Those shots he does take time to set-up, which means if you rush him or disrupt the shot it is not going to make it. His shots are possible, due to the shock value. In theory, Kise is possible. Some people are really good at copying whether voices or moves. Now the rate at he which he does it is questionable on its reality. Yet, there is a line that I am going to talk about a bit later. Aomine is also possible. If someone is practically introduce to a sport as a child and keeps up with it they are going to be GOOD. We already seen that with Kageyama. Haikyuu!! Volume 44 shows Kageyama's backstory and my point. Now some people who may read this review would ask me "Okay, that is all good and fine, but how can you say it is possible or even realistic?"
Good point! Now we get to the point I alluded to with Kise. In Haikyuu!! volume 21, there is a line from a volleyball coach who basically said who is to say the sport won't change in the future or new plays would be possible. That is what we are seeing here in Kuroko's Basketball and we already have examples of this in real life: The Olympics. World records get broken maybe not all the time, but they do. We have seen Ladecky do amazing things in her events. Michael Phelps got 8 golds in the 2008 Olympics. The only people who can put limits on what we can do is ourselves. If we believe something is impossible then it will be impossible. To paraphrase Bokuto from Haikyuu!!, things are not impossible just in improbable.
Verdict: I like this series and I am excited to see what happens. Whether Slam Dunk is better than Kuroko's Basketball, I have to pause on that debate. These two manga are framed differently, especially how I am viewing them. While Slam Dunk's summary is about trying to win nationals for Captain Akagi, I keep seeing it as Grease. Kuroko's Basketball is about a boy trying to prove to his former teammates that the way he plays basketball is valid and maybe superior to their way. While I say I want to pause the debate, I will leave you with the thought of why do we have to decide on what's better?