What do you think?
Rate this book
Serenity's Plain Secrets #4
Hidden in Plain Sight
When a cold case heats up, Serenity won't stop until she discovers the truth.
In the fourth installment of the bestselling Serenity's Plain Secrets' series, Serenity must work with US marshals to uncover the truth behind a shockingly brutal fifteen-year-cold murder.
Desperate for answers, Serenity finds herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where she unravels secrets that threaten to tear her and Daniel apart. But digging up the past is dangerous, and the quaint Amish settlement isn't as safe as it seems.
If Serenity chooses to trust the man she's come to love, it could mean a happily ever after... or her final act.
Some mild language and romantic sexual situations.
In the fourth installment of the bestselling Serenity's Plain Secrets' series, Serenity must work with US marshals to uncover the truth behind a shockingly brutal fifteen-year-cold murder.
Desperate for answers, Serenity finds herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where she unravels secrets that threaten to tear her and Daniel apart. But digging up the past is dangerous, and the quaint Amish settlement isn't as safe as it seems.
If Serenity chooses to trust the man she's come to love, it could mean a happily ever after... or her final act.
Some mild language and romantic sexual situations.
217 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 7, 2016
1246 people are currently reading
1368 people want to read
About the author
Karen Ann Hopkins
43 books1,411 followersYou can visit Karen Ann Hopkins at her website: www.karenannhopkinsfiction.com.
"I loved joining Rose and Noah during their journey in the Temptation series by Karen Hopkins."-Katie McGarry, acclaimed YA author
Karen Ann Hopkins resides in northern Kentucky with her family on a farm that boasts a menagerie of horses, goats, sheep, peacocks, chickens, ducks, rabbits, pigs, dogs, and cats. Karen rescues and fosters a variety of pets and farm animals, but she also finds time to give riding lessons, coach a youth equestrian drill team, and of course, write. She was inspired to create her first book, Temptation, by the Amish community she lives in. The experiential knowledge she gained through her interactions with her neighbors drove her to create the story of the star-crossed lovers, Rose and Noah.
Karen grew up about a mile from Lake Ontario in Upstate New York. She was bitten by the horse bug at the age of five, and after diligently taking riding lessons for several years, she was rewarded with her first horse at the age of eleven. The feisty horse's name was Lady, a Quarter Horse-Thoroughbred cross, who became Karen's steadfast companion. Through the years, the constant force in her life was horses. Eventually, Karen found her place as a riding instructor herself. Before accepting her fate in the barnyard, she worked a short stint as a paralegal, traveled abroad, and guided tourists on horseback riding tours in the Smoky Mountains of Tennessee.
Karen is currently working on her two interconnecting mystery/crime fiction series, Serenity's Plain Secrets and Possum Gap, along with several new projects.
To learn more about Karen and her books, please visit her website.
"I loved joining Rose and Noah during their journey in the Temptation series by Karen Hopkins."-Katie McGarry, acclaimed YA author
Karen Ann Hopkins resides in northern Kentucky with her family on a farm that boasts a menagerie of horses, goats, sheep, peacocks, chickens, ducks, rabbits, pigs, dogs, and cats. Karen rescues and fosters a variety of pets and farm animals, but she also finds time to give riding lessons, coach a youth equestrian drill team, and of course, write. She was inspired to create her first book, Temptation, by the Amish community she lives in. The experiential knowledge she gained through her interactions with her neighbors drove her to create the story of the star-crossed lovers, Rose and Noah.
Karen grew up about a mile from Lake Ontario in Upstate New York. She was bitten by the horse bug at the age of five, and after diligently taking riding lessons for several years, she was rewarded with her first horse at the age of eleven. The feisty horse's name was Lady, a Quarter Horse-Thoroughbred cross, who became Karen's steadfast companion. Through the years, the constant force in her life was horses. Eventually, Karen found her place as a riding instructor herself. Before accepting her fate in the barnyard, she worked a short stint as a paralegal, traveled abroad, and guided tourists on horseback riding tours in the Smoky Mountains of Tennessee.
Karen is currently working on her two interconnecting mystery/crime fiction series, Serenity's Plain Secrets and Possum Gap, along with several new projects.
To learn more about Karen and her books, please visit her website.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 163 reviews
March 30, 2018
In the fourth installment of the bestselling Serenity’s Plain Secrets’ series, Serenity must work with US marshals to uncover the truth behind a shockingly brutal fifteen-year-cold murder.
Desperate for answers, Serenity finds herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where she unravels secrets that threaten to tear her and Daniel apart. But digging up the past is dangerous, and the quaint Amish settlement isn’t as safe as it seems.
Hidden in Plain Sight is apparently NOT going to be the last book in this series. I was afraid of that. That might sound odd coming from someone, who for the most part, enjoyed the series, but I just feel like I won't be able to keep reading this series without losing interest. The first two books were very compelling and the Amish felt somewhat sinister in the way they dealt with things. I liked that a lot about the first couple of books. Now that Serenity has gotten to know and understand them better they have lost that secretive, sinister feel. Now it just sort of feels like the mystery of the week kind of thing.
In this book Serenity's trust issues have abated somewhat, which I was very happy about. There was also less about how hot Daniel was and next to no stomach fluttering, which was an improvement. There is a point where Daniel hides something from Serenity that pertains to himself and the case she is working on. Serenity kind of freaks out over it, which I thought was silly since she knows Daniel well enough that she should realize there must be an explanation that doesn't involve him helping with the murder. I couldn't understand why she wouldn't have just asked him about it instead of pretending she didn't know. And Daniel surely would have known she was going to find out that he withheld the truth about something, so why do it? It was just manufactured drama that I could have done without.
There were some implausibilities in this book, like federal marshals asking a small town sheriff to accompany them to another state to investigate a cold case. I could see them consulting her about the part of the case that pertained to the Amish in her town, but there would surely be someone in that other state who would know the Amish there well enough to help them.
Mostly this book was dull compared to the other ones in the series. We only got Serenity's point of view in this one. I can understand why we didn't get a point of view from Daniel (the whole mystery about what he was hiding and all), but it just felt like something was missing without it.
I enjoyed reading these. I won't completely rule out reading another book in this series, but for now I feel like I've been there, done that and now I need to move on.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
Desperate for answers, Serenity finds herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where she unravels secrets that threaten to tear her and Daniel apart. But digging up the past is dangerous, and the quaint Amish settlement isn’t as safe as it seems.
Hidden in Plain Sight is apparently NOT going to be the last book in this series. I was afraid of that. That might sound odd coming from someone, who for the most part, enjoyed the series, but I just feel like I won't be able to keep reading this series without losing interest. The first two books were very compelling and the Amish felt somewhat sinister in the way they dealt with things. I liked that a lot about the first couple of books. Now that Serenity has gotten to know and understand them better they have lost that secretive, sinister feel. Now it just sort of feels like the mystery of the week kind of thing.
In this book Serenity's trust issues have abated somewhat, which I was very happy about. There was also less about how hot Daniel was and next to no stomach fluttering, which was an improvement. There is a point where Daniel hides something from Serenity that pertains to himself and the case she is working on. Serenity kind of freaks out over it, which I thought was silly since she knows Daniel well enough that she should realize there must be an explanation that doesn't involve him helping with the murder. I couldn't understand why she wouldn't have just asked him about it instead of pretending she didn't know. And Daniel surely would have known she was going to find out that he withheld the truth about something, so why do it? It was just manufactured drama that I could have done without.
There were some implausibilities in this book, like federal marshals asking a small town sheriff to accompany them to another state to investigate a cold case. I could see them consulting her about the part of the case that pertained to the Amish in her town, but there would surely be someone in that other state who would know the Amish there well enough to help them.
Mostly this book was dull compared to the other ones in the series. We only got Serenity's point of view in this one. I can understand why we didn't get a point of view from Daniel (the whole mystery about what he was hiding and all), but it just felt like something was missing without it.
I enjoyed reading these. I won't completely rule out reading another book in this series, but for now I feel like I've been there, done that and now I need to move on.
Review also posted at Writings of a Reader
May 27, 2018
This is probably more a 2.5 star than a 3 star. The story itself was fine, although a few too many people made things a bit confusing at times. What brings the rating down is the editing. It's the same issue I had with the first three books in this series. Missing words, incorrect words used, continuity issues with names and ages. The author needs a decent editor.
There's one more book in this series, which I will read. Then I think it's time to take a break from this author.
There's one more book in this series, which I will read. Then I think it's time to take a break from this author.
June 23, 2020
In book 4 of this dark, gritty, realistic mystery series set in the fictional Amish community of Blood Rock, Indiana, Sheriff Serenity Adams must work with two U.S. Marshalls to resolve a shockingly brutal 15-year old cold case murder. Serenity travels to Lancaster County, PA, where she unravels secrets that may be damaging to her relationship with ex-Amish boyfriend Daniel Bachman. Her professional and personal worlds collide.
Minus: Continued over-reliance on “smirked” to describe people’s facial expressions. Smirked is one of my pet peeves. If I had to be around that many people all smirking at each other constantly, I would have to line them up and start slapping.
Pluses: Excellent plot where Serenity’s professional obligations and personal life come together in difficult, challenging ways. Watching her struggle with her morals and her professional sense of duty was hard, but fascinating too. She seems very real to me. The U.S. Marshalls were interesting characters who I hope might be recurring in future books. Plus, a puppy gets introduced at the end of the book, and who doesn’t like puppies? I enjoy the pacing, the settings, and the dialogue in these books. I like how the relationship between Serenity and Daniel, her ex-Amish boyfriend, continues to grow.
I look forward to reading more in this series.
Minus: Continued over-reliance on “smirked” to describe people’s facial expressions. Smirked is one of my pet peeves. If I had to be around that many people all smirking at each other constantly, I would have to line them up and start slapping.
Pluses: Excellent plot where Serenity’s professional obligations and personal life come together in difficult, challenging ways. Watching her struggle with her morals and her professional sense of duty was hard, but fascinating too. She seems very real to me. The U.S. Marshalls were interesting characters who I hope might be recurring in future books. Plus, a puppy gets introduced at the end of the book, and who doesn’t like puppies? I enjoy the pacing, the settings, and the dialogue in these books. I like how the relationship between Serenity and Daniel, her ex-Amish boyfriend, continues to grow.
I look forward to reading more in this series.
February 27, 2020
Reading serial books back to back makes you notice certain differences like... the name of the mayor! I'm pretty sure it was Ed in book 3 but it's Fred in this book (#4). There were some other little things as well that I think this book will benefit for some editing/proofreading, preferably by the same person so they know the series well.
The main difference though is that in this book, it is only 1 POV (Serenity's) and I find that I'm missing Daniel's voice :/ I understood the change as it relates to the mystery in this novel but I just don't understand how you change number of POVs from book to book? Or is that just me?
A couple of US Marshalls approached Sheriff Serenity Adams for her assistance in approaching the Amish communities with their cold case queries. And not just in her area but also interstate so we see Serenity leaving home without Daniel (!) to flex her brainy muscles & save the day yet again.
I really enjoyed seeing her conquer her personal fears in this one and seeing her relationship with Daniel being strengthened from book to book.
The main difference though is that in this book, it is only 1 POV (Serenity's) and I find that I'm missing Daniel's voice :/ I understood the change as it relates to the mystery in this novel but I just don't understand how you change number of POVs from book to book? Or is that just me?
A couple of US Marshalls approached Sheriff Serenity Adams for her assistance in approaching the Amish communities with their cold case queries. And not just in her area but also interstate so we see Serenity leaving home without Daniel (!) to flex her brainy muscles & save the day yet again.
I really enjoyed seeing her conquer her personal fears in this one and seeing her relationship with Daniel being strengthened from book to book.
July 6, 2018
Great mystery
Great mystery story with believable characters. Enjoyed also learning more about the Amish. Fantastic mixture of reality and suspense woven into a great storyline.
Great mystery story with believable characters. Enjoyed also learning more about the Amish. Fantastic mixture of reality and suspense woven into a great storyline.
April 16, 2020
A very good plot and characters. It needs some editing to earn a higher rating.
April 15, 2019
I am sick of imperfect heroines who are overly self-deprecating. I’m not reading any more of this series. I like women who work on getting smarter like J. A. Jance’s Joanna Brady.
April 13, 2019
So, I've read 4 books in this series and I'm done. They were okay and they sparked my curiosity in the Amish so I did some research. That's always a good thing because I love my own little research projects. I live in Pennsylvania and thru research I realized that what I thought were the occasional group of Amish were in fact probably more sightings of Mennonites instead. This series was entertaining enough and quick to read. I just wasn't that impressed with the main character, Serenity. I am so tired of this type of heroine. Authors sets out to create a strong female but want her to be relatable and not too perfect. So then they give her human flaws like jealousy and pettiness. Not far behind is stubbornness, arrogance and childishness. Well, why stop there? Just give her a penis while you're at it! You could change the name to Sam and no one would know the main character wasn't a man. Then you turn all of the men around her into girly whining sidekicks. What you end up with is the same type of heroine you were trying to avoid. Quite frankly I was very uncomfortable with Serenity because by the fourth book she was little more than a murderer herself. I wasn't okay with her being the judge, jury and executioner. Then for all this to happen in today's society, in 2015! I was shocked every single time they mentioned a cellphone. I kept forgetting that the book wasn't set during the early 19th century, the way she was running around like it was the Ok Corral bringing them in dead or alive. She is a sheriff? Who has a sheriff (outside of a western)? I thought the sheriff's office drove around serving eviction notices for the court. Hahaha...This is why I enjoyed the series. I know the author didn't intend for this to be a comedy but it was funny.
Then the Amish teenagers were having more sex than the supposedly grown-up Englishers! The Amish elders only really had a problem with the sex when it was with an Englisher?! I was also a little perplexed about the way the Amish people were portrayed as well. Based on this series the only difference between the Amish and the rest of the world is a horse and buggy. There was no real mention of their religious beliefs, doctrine or history.
Are you telling me that the only man Serenity ever had before Daniel was Denton in high school? And she's still bitter about the breakup! Childish, but then the author never was too clear about Serenity's age. At one point she might be 32 then in the next book a few months later she's 34 or 35. Daniel was 29 then he aged to 35 within a couple of sentences. 😄
Then the Amish teenagers were having more sex than the supposedly grown-up Englishers! The Amish elders only really had a problem with the sex when it was with an Englisher?! I was also a little perplexed about the way the Amish people were portrayed as well. Based on this series the only difference between the Amish and the rest of the world is a horse and buggy. There was no real mention of their religious beliefs, doctrine or history.
Are you telling me that the only man Serenity ever had before Daniel was Denton in high school? And she's still bitter about the breakup! Childish, but then the author never was too clear about Serenity's age. At one point she might be 32 then in the next book a few months later she's 34 or 35. Daniel was 29 then he aged to 35 within a couple of sentences. 😄
September 3, 2018
I threatened to stop reading books in this series if this entry was more As the World Turns than A Study in Scarlet. Well, it was more A Study in Scarlet.
While the Amish are present in this book, for the first time they play mainly a secondary role, as Serenity helps investigate a cold case murder. And Hopkins tells the whole story from Serenity’s point of view. A small gripe here: the action flips between Indiana and Pennsylvania, but Hopkins never says how the characters get from one to the other, leaving the reader with the impression it’s just a short drive in a car. It isn’t until later in the book that she tells us Serenity and another character take a marathon overnight drive from PA to IN.
Serenity seems a little more mature and confident in her abilities than she did the prior books.
Hopkins has redeemed herself in my eyes, so this series is back on my ‘To Read’ list.
While the Amish are present in this book, for the first time they play mainly a secondary role, as Serenity helps investigate a cold case murder. And Hopkins tells the whole story from Serenity’s point of view. A small gripe here: the action flips between Indiana and Pennsylvania, but Hopkins never says how the characters get from one to the other, leaving the reader with the impression it’s just a short drive in a car. It isn’t until later in the book that she tells us Serenity and another character take a marathon overnight drive from PA to IN.
Serenity seems a little more mature and confident in her abilities than she did the prior books.
Hopkins has redeemed herself in my eyes, so this series is back on my ‘To Read’ list.
June 16, 2016
Decent novel
I enjoyed this story immensely albeit done aspects were a bit unrealistic. For instance, the premise that a small town sheriff be asked to help on a cold case committed in another state is difficult to believe. However, once you get past these small inconsistencies, the book is both heart warning and charming for a wide variety of audiences. I love this series, but as in the previous book, this book characterizes Serenity as being suspicious to a fault. In all though, I think it was a meaningful addition to the collection.
I enjoyed this story immensely albeit done aspects were a bit unrealistic. For instance, the premise that a small town sheriff be asked to help on a cold case committed in another state is difficult to believe. However, once you get past these small inconsistencies, the book is both heart warning and charming for a wide variety of audiences. I love this series, but as in the previous book, this book characterizes Serenity as being suspicious to a fault. In all though, I think it was a meaningful addition to the collection.
October 13, 2016
And now I'm saying goodbye to another set of characters whom I've grown to love. Serenity is drawn toward a cold case the FBI has asked her to help solve. Some of the details of this case involve three Amish boys who were working on a construction crew fifteen years ago. Tracking down these three stories shakes Serenity again. She and Daniel are taking their relationship to the next level but this case offers some frightening moments for the couple. These are four well done books - adventure, suspense, information about the Amish customs and very likable characters.
November 19, 2018
I could not put this book down.
I must go back to the beginning of the series and fill in some of the blanks.
Overall the mystery was good. I really wasn't certain who did it until the end. I felt a genuine sorrow for the victims of the perpetrator. Sorrow for the families as well.
The sociologist in me is curious if there is a problem in the real Amish communities like this and how is it addressed or if it is even addressed.
I must go back to the beginning of the series and fill in some of the blanks.
Overall the mystery was good. I really wasn't certain who did it until the end. I felt a genuine sorrow for the victims of the perpetrator. Sorrow for the families as well.
The sociologist in me is curious if there is a problem in the real Amish communities like this and how is it addressed or if it is even addressed.
January 4, 2024
recensione "a cura del blog Libri magnetici" by Anna M.
Salve a tutti Magnetici! Oggi vi parlo del nuovo capitolo di una serie dove ormai mi sento a casa, sin dal primo volume mi è sempre piaciuto tornare ad avventurarmi tra le pagine delle storie con protagonista Serenity e le sue indagini, non da meno ritrovare tutti i personaggi che la contornano, un posto sicuro dove passare del tempo.
Come i precedenti, anche questo nuovo libro non mi ha delusa, anzi forse è stato quello che ha creato più curiosità, perché al centro della storia, più che nelle altre, c’è proprio lei, Serenity, alle prese con un ‘indagine che la mette di fronte a momenti difficili che riguardano anche Daniel.
Siamo a Blood Rock, ritroviamo appunto Serenity e Daniel che ormai stanno insieme, affrontando le varie difficoltà, ma sono una coppia, dopo le varie peripezie del passato. Però all’orizzonte sta per arrivare un altro caso da risolvere, anche questo riguardante la comunità Amish, un caso accaduto quindici anni prima, un omicidio.
“Un’ascia si sollevò alta alla luce della luna prima di ricadere sulla sua testa.”
Niente di diverso dal solito penserete voi, ma stavolta nelle indagini vengono fuori delle cose che riguardano il passato di Daniel, le quali mettono Serenity in seria difficoltà facendole venire dei dubbi sull’uomo che ha accanto.
Ci troveremo a leggere di una situazione difficile, l’indagine al centro, e tutto ciò che viene scoperto a segnare i personaggi che ne fanno parte. Serenity è uno sceriffo tutto d’un pezzo, com’è giusto che sia, ma come si comporterà in questa situazione? Cos’ha scoperto? L’amore tra lei e Daniel è in pericolo?
“Anche se il suo tocco era caldo, rabbrividii. Presto avrei scoperto la verità su Daniel.”
Per rispondere a queste domande dovete leggere il libro, un libro che consiglio sicuramente, ho apprezzato che questa volta ci fosse al centro una parte di Serenity “diversa”, una parte che dovesse fare i conti con i propri sentimenti più profondi, lo sviluppo della trama è un crescendo perfetto di emozioni, ci si trova ad indagare e a sperare che tutto vada a finire bene. Ho trovato i personaggi evoluti ancora di più e faccio i complimenti all’autrice perché come ogni volta, col suo stile di scrittura, riesce a tenerti incollata alle pagine, facendoti dimenticare tutto il resto, oltre che per le descrizioni minuziose sulla comunità Amish sempre molto dettagliate. Concludo augurandovi buona lettura Magnetici, e consigliando ancora una volta di leggere questo libro, non sarà tempo perso.
“Per quanto volessi essere arrabbiata con Daniel, non riuscivo a trovare dentro di me un’emozione abbastanza forte.”
cinque petali
Salve a tutti Magnetici! Oggi vi parlo del nuovo capitolo di una serie dove ormai mi sento a casa, sin dal primo volume mi è sempre piaciuto tornare ad avventurarmi tra le pagine delle storie con protagonista Serenity e le sue indagini, non da meno ritrovare tutti i personaggi che la contornano, un posto sicuro dove passare del tempo.
Come i precedenti, anche questo nuovo libro non mi ha delusa, anzi forse è stato quello che ha creato più curiosità, perché al centro della storia, più che nelle altre, c’è proprio lei, Serenity, alle prese con un ‘indagine che la mette di fronte a momenti difficili che riguardano anche Daniel.
Siamo a Blood Rock, ritroviamo appunto Serenity e Daniel che ormai stanno insieme, affrontando le varie difficoltà, ma sono una coppia, dopo le varie peripezie del passato. Però all’orizzonte sta per arrivare un altro caso da risolvere, anche questo riguardante la comunità Amish, un caso accaduto quindici anni prima, un omicidio.
“Un’ascia si sollevò alta alla luce della luna prima di ricadere sulla sua testa.”
Niente di diverso dal solito penserete voi, ma stavolta nelle indagini vengono fuori delle cose che riguardano il passato di Daniel, le quali mettono Serenity in seria difficoltà facendole venire dei dubbi sull’uomo che ha accanto.
Ci troveremo a leggere di una situazione difficile, l’indagine al centro, e tutto ciò che viene scoperto a segnare i personaggi che ne fanno parte. Serenity è uno sceriffo tutto d’un pezzo, com’è giusto che sia, ma come si comporterà in questa situazione? Cos’ha scoperto? L’amore tra lei e Daniel è in pericolo?
“Anche se il suo tocco era caldo, rabbrividii. Presto avrei scoperto la verità su Daniel.”
Per rispondere a queste domande dovete leggere il libro, un libro che consiglio sicuramente, ho apprezzato che questa volta ci fosse al centro una parte di Serenity “diversa”, una parte che dovesse fare i conti con i propri sentimenti più profondi, lo sviluppo della trama è un crescendo perfetto di emozioni, ci si trova ad indagare e a sperare che tutto vada a finire bene. Ho trovato i personaggi evoluti ancora di più e faccio i complimenti all’autrice perché come ogni volta, col suo stile di scrittura, riesce a tenerti incollata alle pagine, facendoti dimenticare tutto il resto, oltre che per le descrizioni minuziose sulla comunità Amish sempre molto dettagliate. Concludo augurandovi buona lettura Magnetici, e consigliando ancora una volta di leggere questo libro, non sarà tempo perso.
“Per quanto volessi essere arrabbiata con Daniel, non riuscivo a trovare dentro di me un’emozione abbastanza forte.”
cinque petali
Read
June 4, 2021An investigation, a promise, and a lie
Serenity is called on again to help in an investigation outside of her jurisdiction, this time though it's the US Marshals needing her help on a cold case.
Years ago Buddy Prowes was found shot then bludgeoned to death with an axe. He was trouble personified but nonetheless he still deserves justice and when the original investigator passed away it was his only unsolved case. He'd recently annotated his copy of the case file and Marshals John and Toby are determined to finally crack this one.
Back then a few of the young Amish men from Blood Rock were working in Lancaster County for the dead man. He beat them, he treated them terribly and the question still remains as to whether or not he pushed them too far.
Daniel denies working in Lancaster but says he visited Lester Lapp and Seth Hershberger who also came from Blood Rock; Lester returned but Seth stayed on and settled there. Another Amish man, who has just moved to Blood Rock, Joshua Miller, has attracted Serenity's interest, but not in a positive way, does provide another name but it doesn't appear to help the case much.
It's going to be a difficult one to solve, hindered by the the victims ex-wife having become a lawyer herself in the intervening years, and far too aware to let anything slip. Daniel is hiding something from Serenity and she's not sure if she can trust him despite his proposal when the secret definitely involves him being in Lancaster County at the time of the crime.
But justice will come for the killer and their accomplice even if it takes another tragedy to reach it. And Serenity is not going to let go on her suspicion that Joshua is bringing trouble to Blood Rock, especially when her close friend CJ moves into the property he's renting out.
Serenity is called on again to help in an investigation outside of her jurisdiction, this time though it's the US Marshals needing her help on a cold case.
Years ago Buddy Prowes was found shot then bludgeoned to death with an axe. He was trouble personified but nonetheless he still deserves justice and when the original investigator passed away it was his only unsolved case. He'd recently annotated his copy of the case file and Marshals John and Toby are determined to finally crack this one.
Back then a few of the young Amish men from Blood Rock were working in Lancaster County for the dead man. He beat them, he treated them terribly and the question still remains as to whether or not he pushed them too far.
Daniel denies working in Lancaster but says he visited Lester Lapp and Seth Hershberger who also came from Blood Rock; Lester returned but Seth stayed on and settled there. Another Amish man, who has just moved to Blood Rock, Joshua Miller, has attracted Serenity's interest, but not in a positive way, does provide another name but it doesn't appear to help the case much.
It's going to be a difficult one to solve, hindered by the the victims ex-wife having become a lawyer herself in the intervening years, and far too aware to let anything slip. Daniel is hiding something from Serenity and she's not sure if she can trust him despite his proposal when the secret definitely involves him being in Lancaster County at the time of the crime.
But justice will come for the killer and their accomplice even if it takes another tragedy to reach it. And Serenity is not going to let go on her suspicion that Joshua is bringing trouble to Blood Rock, especially when her close friend CJ moves into the property he's renting out.
July 12, 2021
Lancaster County, PA. (Amish-community). 11/5/2000, Buddy Prowes (building contractor) had just come in out of the rain.
Samantha “Sammy” Prowes (Buddy’s ex-wife, bank teller) wanted to know what he was doing there.
She pulled a gun on him & told him to get out of her house.
11/6, Buddy had been murdered.
Blood Rock, IN. Amish Settlement. Sheriff Serenity Adams, U.S. Marshal Toby Bryant, & U.S. Marshal John Ruther (50+, single, partner) were working on a cold case.
Mr. Daniel Bachman (former Amish); Rebecca (mother); Lester Lapp (Daniel’s BMF); Seth Hershberger (furniture maker); Samantha “Sammy” Prowes (lawyer, JD); Tonya Sanders (Brent’s GF/mother, 3 kids); Miriam Coblenze (34, Amish, wife/mother); Isaiah Coblenze (husband/father, furniture, building contractor); Bobby Prowes (son); Jerimiah Suggs (aka Jerimiah Stoltzfus); & Josiah Miller were interviewed.
Will the murder mystery be solved & someone brought to justice?
An awesome book cover, great font & writing style. A very professionally written Amish who-dunnit murder mystery book. It was extremely easy for me to read/follow from start/finish & never a dull moment. There were no grammar/typo errors, nor any repetitive or out of line sequence sentences. Lots of exciting scenarios, with several twists/turns & a great set of unique characters to keep track of. This could also make another great Amish murder mystery movie, or better yet a mini-TV series. There is no doubt in my mind this is an amazingly easy rating of 5 stars.
Thank you for the free author; eBookDaily; Amazon Digital Services LLC.; book
Tony Parsons MSW (Washburn)
Samantha “Sammy” Prowes (Buddy’s ex-wife, bank teller) wanted to know what he was doing there.
She pulled a gun on him & told him to get out of her house.
11/6, Buddy had been murdered.
Blood Rock, IN. Amish Settlement. Sheriff Serenity Adams, U.S. Marshal Toby Bryant, & U.S. Marshal John Ruther (50+, single, partner) were working on a cold case.
Mr. Daniel Bachman (former Amish); Rebecca (mother); Lester Lapp (Daniel’s BMF); Seth Hershberger (furniture maker); Samantha “Sammy” Prowes (lawyer, JD); Tonya Sanders (Brent’s GF/mother, 3 kids); Miriam Coblenze (34, Amish, wife/mother); Isaiah Coblenze (husband/father, furniture, building contractor); Bobby Prowes (son); Jerimiah Suggs (aka Jerimiah Stoltzfus); & Josiah Miller were interviewed.
Will the murder mystery be solved & someone brought to justice?
An awesome book cover, great font & writing style. A very professionally written Amish who-dunnit murder mystery book. It was extremely easy for me to read/follow from start/finish & never a dull moment. There were no grammar/typo errors, nor any repetitive or out of line sequence sentences. Lots of exciting scenarios, with several twists/turns & a great set of unique characters to keep track of. This could also make another great Amish murder mystery movie, or better yet a mini-TV series. There is no doubt in my mind this is an amazingly easy rating of 5 stars.
Thank you for the free author; eBookDaily; Amazon Digital Services LLC.; book
Tony Parsons MSW (Washburn)
September 11, 2021
I've had it!
I've read three other Serenity books, and I barely made it through this. Now, there'll be no more for me. Hidden In Plain Sight is my last one for sure.
I don't object to the Amish setting, which I find intriguing and drew me to pick up this series in the first place. What I can't stand anymore is the relationship between Serenity and Daniel, her ex-Amish boyfriend. The author never allows them to grow up and develop as a real couple would have by Book 4. Instead, she keeps them on the same page forever, with Serenity always wary of her body and suspicious of Daniel's commitment. Daniel is always hurt by Serenity's mistrust and making it up to her. But enough is enough! How much doubt and distrust can one person take?
What the author describes here and has constantly described in the previous three books has nothing to do with a relationship, all to do with an inmate and his jailer. Worst, the two are getting nowhere except to a lonesome end despite the engagement and all the good intentions that come from it.
I've also got news for Mrs. Hopkins. This kind of behavior doesn't make Serenity look stronger as a woman and sheriff. It only makes her stupid, uncaring, or unaware of what's in front of her nose. Serenity ought to learn and grow from all her past experiences, not remain steadfastly the same with the person who should be her significant other. It also makes for a frustrating read, reason why I'm through with this series and don't recommend it.
I've read three other Serenity books, and I barely made it through this. Now, there'll be no more for me. Hidden In Plain Sight is my last one for sure.
I don't object to the Amish setting, which I find intriguing and drew me to pick up this series in the first place. What I can't stand anymore is the relationship between Serenity and Daniel, her ex-Amish boyfriend. The author never allows them to grow up and develop as a real couple would have by Book 4. Instead, she keeps them on the same page forever, with Serenity always wary of her body and suspicious of Daniel's commitment. Daniel is always hurt by Serenity's mistrust and making it up to her. But enough is enough! How much doubt and distrust can one person take?
What the author describes here and has constantly described in the previous three books has nothing to do with a relationship, all to do with an inmate and his jailer. Worst, the two are getting nowhere except to a lonesome end despite the engagement and all the good intentions that come from it.
I've also got news for Mrs. Hopkins. This kind of behavior doesn't make Serenity look stronger as a woman and sheriff. It only makes her stupid, uncaring, or unaware of what's in front of her nose. Serenity ought to learn and grow from all her past experiences, not remain steadfastly the same with the person who should be her significant other. It also makes for a frustrating read, reason why I'm through with this series and don't recommend it.
February 20, 2018
Interesting story set in Indiana Amish country
Having lived many years near a large Amish settlement in Indiana, I was intrigued by the story when I read the description of this book. The mystery isn't complicated, and there is violence in this book. The editing isn't the best as there are missing words frequently, but that wasn't too distracting. The main character, Serenity, goes back and forth between being a strong no nonsense sheriff and a bundle of emotions. The FBI men are competent most of the time, but fail when needed most. Security's fiance Daniel is a former Amish man shunned by his family when he went English but has moved back to his home town and has a bit of a relationship with his family now. The most interesting part of the book is about Amish customs. I read the Amish Cook column in our local paper for decades. It was more about daily life than cooking, although the recipes were delicious. It seems much of the depictions of Amish life in this novel match what I learned from the columns, although someone Amish may not agree. Anyway, its plusses outweigh the negatives and I look forward to reading more books in this series.
Having lived many years near a large Amish settlement in Indiana, I was intrigued by the story when I read the description of this book. The mystery isn't complicated, and there is violence in this book. The editing isn't the best as there are missing words frequently, but that wasn't too distracting. The main character, Serenity, goes back and forth between being a strong no nonsense sheriff and a bundle of emotions. The FBI men are competent most of the time, but fail when needed most. Security's fiance Daniel is a former Amish man shunned by his family when he went English but has moved back to his home town and has a bit of a relationship with his family now. The most interesting part of the book is about Amish customs. I read the Amish Cook column in our local paper for decades. It was more about daily life than cooking, although the recipes were delicious. It seems much of the depictions of Amish life in this novel match what I learned from the columns, although someone Amish may not agree. Anyway, its plusses outweigh the negatives and I look forward to reading more books in this series.
February 23, 2018
BACK OF THE BOOK BLURB
(copied from Amazon.com)
Some Amish communities aren't so cozy.
When a cold case heats up, Serenity won't stop until she discovers the truth.
In this installment of the bestselling Serenity's Plain Secrets' series. Serenity must work with US marshals to uncover the truth behind a shockingly brutal fifteen-year-cold murder.
Desperate for answers, Serenity finds herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where she unravels secrets that threaten to tear her and Daniel apart. But digging up the past is dangerous and the quaint Amish settlement isn't as safe as it seems.
If Serenity chooses to trust the man she's come to love, it could mean a happily ever after...or her final act.
MY REVIEW
This story didn't seem quite as good to me as the previous three, but still worth the read. This cold case may affect Serenity's personal life, just after she decided she could be happy spending the rest of it with Daniel. I have been enjoying this series for the most part, not crazy about some of the language and some sexual scenes.
(copied from Amazon.com)
Some Amish communities aren't so cozy.
When a cold case heats up, Serenity won't stop until she discovers the truth.
In this installment of the bestselling Serenity's Plain Secrets' series. Serenity must work with US marshals to uncover the truth behind a shockingly brutal fifteen-year-cold murder.
Desperate for answers, Serenity finds herself in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, where she unravels secrets that threaten to tear her and Daniel apart. But digging up the past is dangerous and the quaint Amish settlement isn't as safe as it seems.
If Serenity chooses to trust the man she's come to love, it could mean a happily ever after...or her final act.
MY REVIEW
This story didn't seem quite as good to me as the previous three, but still worth the read. This cold case may affect Serenity's personal life, just after she decided she could be happy spending the rest of it with Daniel. I have been enjoying this series for the most part, not crazy about some of the language and some sexual scenes.
February 26, 2018
“Hidden in Plain Sight” is the 4th book in the Serenity’s Plain Secrets series by Karen Ann Hopkins. Serenity Adams is the sheriff in Stone Mill, Pennsylvania. Amish communities are supposed to be placid and peaceful. But in Stone Mill, U.S. Marshals have re-opened a cold case murder. There are more secrets in this community than Serenity can unravel as quickly as she’d like.
Who killed Buddy Prowes? He was found shot and bludgeoned in the woods surrounding his ex-wife’s house some fifteen years previously. A fellow marshal worked the case at the time and couldn’t get the murder off his mind. After he passed from cancer, notes were found that brought these marshals to try to put the cast to rest in the memory of their friend. Working with Serenity, they did a lot of digging into the community to find the killer.
Lots of danger, mystery and thrills are in this novel. I’m sure the other books in Ms. Hopkins series are just as compelling as this one and look forward to reading more of her novels.
You can find this review on my blog at https://wp.me/p2pjIt-ub. Other reviews can be found at http://imhookedonbooks.wordpress.com.
Who killed Buddy Prowes? He was found shot and bludgeoned in the woods surrounding his ex-wife’s house some fifteen years previously. A fellow marshal worked the case at the time and couldn’t get the murder off his mind. After he passed from cancer, notes were found that brought these marshals to try to put the cast to rest in the memory of their friend. Working with Serenity, they did a lot of digging into the community to find the killer.
Lots of danger, mystery and thrills are in this novel. I’m sure the other books in Ms. Hopkins series are just as compelling as this one and look forward to reading more of her novels.
You can find this review on my blog at https://wp.me/p2pjIt-ub. Other reviews can be found at http://imhookedonbooks.wordpress.com.
June 22, 2018
Another brilliant mystery thriller with a strong Amish flavor!
It aroused my curiosity to the maximum to "see" what would happen when Sheriff Serenity is dragged off to help the U.S. marshals solve a fifteen year old murder case in Lancaster, PA.
The way Serenity rises to the occasion, adds her excellent deductive skills to the meager available facts, unearths more plausible witnesses to talk to and arrives at the correct conclusion leaves the reader amazed in a very positive way. The book has to be read to enjoy it to the fullest extent.
It is very heartening to note that the secretive, closed communities of the Amish people take Serenity to their hearts. When the Amish community of Lancaster offers her the Sheriff's job in PA, Amish bishop of Blood Rock, her own community who was antagonistic to her in the beginning tells the others that they intend keeping their Sheriff with them!
An amazing book which gave me an immense, pleasurable reading experience!
It aroused my curiosity to the maximum to "see" what would happen when Sheriff Serenity is dragged off to help the U.S. marshals solve a fifteen year old murder case in Lancaster, PA.
The way Serenity rises to the occasion, adds her excellent deductive skills to the meager available facts, unearths more plausible witnesses to talk to and arrives at the correct conclusion leaves the reader amazed in a very positive way. The book has to be read to enjoy it to the fullest extent.
It is very heartening to note that the secretive, closed communities of the Amish people take Serenity to their hearts. When the Amish community of Lancaster offers her the Sheriff's job in PA, Amish bishop of Blood Rock, her own community who was antagonistic to her in the beginning tells the others that they intend keeping their Sheriff with them!
An amazing book which gave me an immense, pleasurable reading experience!
February 27, 2018
I give this only 3 stars...too many characters. The plot twists kept me interested.
Before the last page, the author Karen Hopkins starts her next book. The adventures of Serenity, the sheriff, continue. She lives a complicated life...In my opinion , more complicated than it needs to be. There is a lot here about the Amish, in fact...most of it is about the Amish lifestyle. You'll learn here, if you didn't already know, that the Amish are human and being human they make mistakes , are tempted and give in...have tempers and can resort to violence. But they are to be admired in that they take care of their own. You don't find Amish in nursing homes nor do they accept government aid.
On the plus side, the twists and turns of the plot will keep you interested enough to keep turning the pages(or swiping the screen if you have a Kindle) If you haven't read the previous books in this series(I haven't , it might take you a while to figure out who is who .
Before the last page, the author Karen Hopkins starts her next book. The adventures of Serenity, the sheriff, continue. She lives a complicated life...In my opinion , more complicated than it needs to be. There is a lot here about the Amish, in fact...most of it is about the Amish lifestyle. You'll learn here, if you didn't already know, that the Amish are human and being human they make mistakes , are tempted and give in...have tempers and can resort to violence. But they are to be admired in that they take care of their own. You don't find Amish in nursing homes nor do they accept government aid.
On the plus side, the twists and turns of the plot will keep you interested enough to keep turning the pages(or swiping the screen if you have a Kindle) If you haven't read the previous books in this series(I haven't , it might take you a while to figure out who is who .
June 25, 2018
Another story in the Serenity's Plain series; this time, Serenity is asked for help to solve a cold case in another community, only to find that quite a number of residents from the Blood Rock Amish settlement seem to be involved. And is there something Daniel isn't telling her?
I really like this series, as it gives me quite an insight into Amish life - provided, as I assume, the author knows what she's talking about. The stories have unexpected twists and turns, and the protagonists have their own problems to deal with as well. The narration may not be fast paced and filled with explosive action, but it is by no means boring, the protagonists have a surprising depth, and the crimes to solve are well thought out and never quite black or white, and always have a hint of compassion, frustration and sometimes just plain joy.
Did I mention I love this series?
I really like this series, as it gives me quite an insight into Amish life - provided, as I assume, the author knows what she's talking about. The stories have unexpected twists and turns, and the protagonists have their own problems to deal with as well. The narration may not be fast paced and filled with explosive action, but it is by no means boring, the protagonists have a surprising depth, and the crimes to solve are well thought out and never quite black or white, and always have a hint of compassion, frustration and sometimes just plain joy.
Did I mention I love this series?
June 5, 2021
Average
Average for me but probably for most that would equate to four stars good or whatever four stars means on Goodreads and Amazon.
Especially if you like all the soap opera storylines and can keep track of all the Amish folks. Who had a loved one that was killed and who killed the loved one.
It is basically clean. The f-word is used a couple of times and for a curmudgeon, prude like me, a story gained nothing other than one can use it now without most readers going 😱for me it is more 🥱 and is used just because the author is an adult now and mommy can’t wash her mouth out with soap.
Reminds me of one line Daniel says paraphrasing ‘isn’t it great we’re adults now and can go home and have sex as much as we want.’ 🥱🥱🥱 Sounds more like the words of a teenager or an entire mature adult, but then again I’m just an old curmudgeon 🤨
Average for me but probably for most that would equate to four stars good or whatever four stars means on Goodreads and Amazon.
Especially if you like all the soap opera storylines and can keep track of all the Amish folks. Who had a loved one that was killed and who killed the loved one.
It is basically clean. The f-word is used a couple of times and for a curmudgeon, prude like me, a story gained nothing other than one can use it now without most readers going 😱for me it is more 🥱 and is used just because the author is an adult now and mommy can’t wash her mouth out with soap.
Reminds me of one line Daniel says paraphrasing ‘isn’t it great we’re adults now and can go home and have sex as much as we want.’ 🥱🥱🥱 Sounds more like the words of a teenager or an entire mature adult, but then again I’m just an old curmudgeon 🤨
March 15, 2023
Quick read, lots of intrigue
This fourth book in the series is a fast read. Serenity gets involved in yet another case involving the Amish when US Marshals come to town seeking her help in a cold case.
She is intrigued by their case and agrees to help which ends up taking her to Lancaster, PA. There are a lot of unanswered questions related to the 15 year old murder and there are elements that hit a bit too close to home for Serenity.
The crisis moment is chilling and the after effects will likely be long lasting. A huge piece of the case is left hanging and I was disappointed and irritated that it wasn’t dealt with. I felt like there were several scenes left to go on this book and the author just cut it off. It ended with me feeling like the book wasn’t really finished which was a disappointing feeling.
This fourth book in the series is a fast read. Serenity gets involved in yet another case involving the Amish when US Marshals come to town seeking her help in a cold case.
She is intrigued by their case and agrees to help which ends up taking her to Lancaster, PA. There are a lot of unanswered questions related to the 15 year old murder and there are elements that hit a bit too close to home for Serenity.
The crisis moment is chilling and the after effects will likely be long lasting. A huge piece of the case is left hanging and I was disappointed and irritated that it wasn’t dealt with. I felt like there were several scenes left to go on this book and the author just cut it off. It ended with me feeling like the book wasn’t really finished which was a disappointing feeling.
March 20, 2018
Poorly written, trite prose mars a solid mystery
The underlying whodunnit is fine. The reveal was neither a given, nor too far fetched to handle. But everything else was flat. Her characters lack depth, the exposition is tiring, Serenity ticks all the hardened outside heart of gold cliche boxes, and the narrative jumps around. It was a slog to read, even though it only took four hours to get through. She gave away the plot lines and endings for all her other books, so I couldn’t read those even if I wanted to. I’m not disappointed. The author has clearly lived among the Amish at some point, or has done a lot of research, so you can learn a little something. I’d suggest moving to central Pennsylvania for a few years instead. It’s much more enjoyable.
The underlying whodunnit is fine. The reveal was neither a given, nor too far fetched to handle. But everything else was flat. Her characters lack depth, the exposition is tiring, Serenity ticks all the hardened outside heart of gold cliche boxes, and the narrative jumps around. It was a slog to read, even though it only took four hours to get through. She gave away the plot lines and endings for all her other books, so I couldn’t read those even if I wanted to. I’m not disappointed. The author has clearly lived among the Amish at some point, or has done a lot of research, so you can learn a little something. I’d suggest moving to central Pennsylvania for a few years instead. It’s much more enjoyable.
May 19, 2018
My favorite of the series so far. The cold case was very engaging and the resolution emotional. Serenity continues to be a wonderful mix of tough and vulnerable though I think she may have been just a little too hard on Daniel. I like seeing her softer side poke through. I also like how these books are just the right length to tell the story and don’t drag on unnecessarily.
A very good series but I definitely recommend you start them from the beginning and go in order. Lots of repeating characters and relationship building between books. And the recent books tend to mention the previous ones and tell enough of what happened to make reading them out of order a bad idea (unless you like knowing the outcomes before you start).
A very good series but I definitely recommend you start them from the beginning and go in order. Lots of repeating characters and relationship building between books. And the recent books tend to mention the previous ones and tell enough of what happened to make reading them out of order a bad idea (unless you like knowing the outcomes before you start).
March 5, 2018
I'm not buying Serenity and Daniel's relationship! She constantly doubts her feelings and yet she's willing to commit to him? She think he may be involved somehow in a case she's working but can't even have a conversation about it? She seems to have the emotional maturity of a teenager, there's no passion between them and I just don't buy that Daniel would settle for that. Usual interesting mystery & settings that I've come to expect from Ms Hopkins but I'm finding my disbelief about the central characters relationship is affecting my overall enjoyment of the book. Despite that, I'll still continue to read the series.
June 8, 2021
Another Page Turner!
I continue to be impressed with the author's ability to keep me on the edge of my seat, and my inability to put the book down. I'm from an area that is rich with Amish communities, and have friends that grew up Amish but became English. It's refreshing to find an author that isn't afraid to tell the truth about the Amish -that even though they live a different lifestyle,their lives are fraught with the same trials,tribulations and issues that we Englisher's face....and they feel the same things we do. I can't wait to continue the journey with Serenity and Daniel!!
I continue to be impressed with the author's ability to keep me on the edge of my seat, and my inability to put the book down. I'm from an area that is rich with Amish communities, and have friends that grew up Amish but became English. It's refreshing to find an author that isn't afraid to tell the truth about the Amish -that even though they live a different lifestyle,their lives are fraught with the same trials,tribulations and issues that we Englisher's face....and they feel the same things we do. I can't wait to continue the journey with Serenity and Daniel!!
March 27, 2018
Fast paced, enjoyable whodunit!
I loved this book from the very first page. Had not read any of the previous books in the series, but this was not much of a drawback. It easily stood on its own merit. The characters are well drawn, the plot is intriguing, the dialog, social interaction, and personal thoughts are realistic. I found myself immediately caring about these people, especially Serenity and Daniel, and wanting to find out what would happen to them next. It kept me guessing right up to the end! I thoroughly enjoyed it!
I loved this book from the very first page. Had not read any of the previous books in the series, but this was not much of a drawback. It easily stood on its own merit. The characters are well drawn, the plot is intriguing, the dialog, social interaction, and personal thoughts are realistic. I found myself immediately caring about these people, especially Serenity and Daniel, and wanting to find out what would happen to them next. It kept me guessing right up to the end! I thoroughly enjoyed it!
May 13, 2018
Will secrets be revealed?
Serenity is a sheriff who has worked closely wit the Amish community so she is still wary go approach them with two US marshals but she has no choice. She has offered to help close a cold case but she is about to find out that her boyfriend has lied about his time away from the Amish. Will she be able to find the killer and get the answers that she needs. Daniel knows that he should have been honest but he didn't want Serenity to run from him. Can he be honest about the time that he was young and foolish and will she forgive? A great read.
Serenity is a sheriff who has worked closely wit the Amish community so she is still wary go approach them with two US marshals but she has no choice. She has offered to help close a cold case but she is about to find out that her boyfriend has lied about his time away from the Amish. Will she be able to find the killer and get the answers that she needs. Daniel knows that he should have been honest but he didn't want Serenity to run from him. Can he be honest about the time that he was young and foolish and will she forgive? A great read.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 163 reviews