What do you think?
Rate this book
A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold
For six hundred years I have dwelt in this prison. Trapped. Helpless. Unliving and undying.
For six hundred years I have watched as cursebreakers come and go. Brave young women all, gifted with powers beyond mortal understanding.
I have watched them die. I have watched them wish to die.
Once again the Family of Night invades this country to claim its dues, and this generation’s
cursebreaker has her chance to break the endless chain of torment. To save me. To save her sisters.
But how can a peasant child scarcely fourteen years of age discover the three-part key and
liberate the captives? Will she too be doomed to join the Death Dance binding us all to the
Family of Night?
For six hundred years I have watched as cursebreakers come and go. Brave young women all, gifted with powers beyond mortal understanding.
I have watched them die. I have watched them wish to die.
Once again the Family of Night invades this country to claim its dues, and this generation’s
cursebreaker has her chance to break the endless chain of torment. To save me. To save her sisters.
But how can a peasant child scarcely fourteen years of age discover the three-part key and
liberate the captives? Will she too be doomed to join the Death Dance binding us all to the
Family of Night?
459 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 1, 2016
44 people are currently reading
2210 people want to read
About the author
Anne Elisabeth Stengl
20 books806 followersAnne Elisabeth Stengl makes her home in Raleigh, North Carolina, where she lives with her husband, Rohan, a passel of cats, and one long-suffering dog. When she's not writing, she enjoys Shakespeare, opera, and tea, and studies piano, painting, and pastry baking. She studied illustration at Grace College and English literature at Campbell University. She is the author of the TALES OF GOLDSTONE WOOD, which currently includes seven novels and two novellas, with plenty more works due to release over the next few years. Her novels HEARTLESS, VEILED ROSE, and DRAGONWITCH have each been honored with a Christy Award, and STARFLOWER was voted winner of the 2013 Clive Staples Award.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews
June 29, 2016
Before there can be a beginning, there must first be an end.
It was a sad day for fans when Anne Elisabeth declared she must pause the Tales of Goldstone Wood series for a few years….it seemed new journeys into the Between were at an end, at least for a time. But lo and behold, a new beginning awaited! The first book of a four part series set WITHIN Goldstone Wood….not part of the series itself, but part of the very same world. So what joy, what excitement!
For me, it did not disappoint. True, the style of writing is a shade different…the plot takes its own sweet time in building up pace, and description can feel a bit repetitive at times. When I say the description is repetitive, I do not mean that it uses the same descriptions over and over, but that she finds a new and unique way to depict something. And that is a power all of its own as it creates a reality of mortal worlds and faerie horrors with high skill and grounded knowledge.
As always with Anne Elisabeth’s writings, if you know history or culture, you may recognize the inspired genius…apparently a certain important element in this book is directly inspired from a freakish ballet called “Le Sacre du primtempts." Who knew? I sure wouldn’t have without being told by a friend. But even if you don’t know what Anne Elisabeth may be using as reference, you can just feel the authenticity.
I think, perhaps, this plot is more confusing than previous Goldstone novels…both the cause and cure of the faerie curse is very complex, but really, what else can we expect from the fey kind? Don’t worry, if you are patient, your questions will be answered when all is said and done. This book is an excellent example of the art of withholding information from the reader to create mystery and suspense.
And the characters! Oh the characters! Heloise may be a little difficult at first for some people, being a headstrong young teenage girl (much like Meirda from Brave, actually), but she truly has excellent development through this book. And Benedict! My! He starts off seemingly simple, and oh, how much he hides! Such a sweetheart, such a knight, such a tragedy. *excuse me as I go sniffle, snork, and blow my nose* Then there is a sylph. We’ve had sylph in the tales before, but this sylph is the BEST EVER. Cutest little stinker, I would hug it if sylphs could be hugged.
Then there is the Family of Night. Very. Interesting. And disturbing. And more complicated than at first impressions. And above all, readers of Goldstone Wood have heard of them before. Or at least of one member or two.
This is the beginning of a great thing for fantasy or fairy-tale readers. Three more books await, so take heart and prepare to continue the journey! If you are have wandered the Wood before, prepare to be swept off on a sylph wind as you return to the Between you love and encounter loved ones and new faces alike! If you are new, perhaps seeking a retelling of Twelve Dancing Princesses…you will find a beautiful and unique version…and so. much. more.
It was a sad day for fans when Anne Elisabeth declared she must pause the Tales of Goldstone Wood series for a few years….it seemed new journeys into the Between were at an end, at least for a time. But lo and behold, a new beginning awaited! The first book of a four part series set WITHIN Goldstone Wood….not part of the series itself, but part of the very same world. So what joy, what excitement!
For me, it did not disappoint. True, the style of writing is a shade different…the plot takes its own sweet time in building up pace, and description can feel a bit repetitive at times. When I say the description is repetitive, I do not mean that it uses the same descriptions over and over, but that she finds a new and unique way to depict something. And that is a power all of its own as it creates a reality of mortal worlds and faerie horrors with high skill and grounded knowledge.
As always with Anne Elisabeth’s writings, if you know history or culture, you may recognize the inspired genius…apparently a certain important element in this book is directly inspired from a freakish ballet called “Le Sacre du primtempts." Who knew? I sure wouldn’t have without being told by a friend. But even if you don’t know what Anne Elisabeth may be using as reference, you can just feel the authenticity.
I think, perhaps, this plot is more confusing than previous Goldstone novels…both the cause and cure of the faerie curse is very complex, but really, what else can we expect from the fey kind? Don’t worry, if you are patient, your questions will be answered when all is said and done. This book is an excellent example of the art of withholding information from the reader to create mystery and suspense.
And the characters! Oh the characters! Heloise may be a little difficult at first for some people, being a headstrong young teenage girl (much like Meirda from Brave, actually), but she truly has excellent development through this book. And Benedict! My! He starts off seemingly simple, and oh, how much he hides! Such a sweetheart, such a knight, such a tragedy. *excuse me as I go sniffle, snork, and blow my nose* Then there is a sylph. We’ve had sylph in the tales before, but this sylph is the BEST EVER. Cutest little stinker, I would hug it if sylphs could be hugged.
Then there is the Family of Night. Very. Interesting. And disturbing. And more complicated than at first impressions. And above all, readers of Goldstone Wood have heard of them before. Or at least of one member or two.
This is the beginning of a great thing for fantasy or fairy-tale readers. Three more books await, so take heart and prepare to continue the journey! If you are have wandered the Wood before, prepare to be swept off on a sylph wind as you return to the Between you love and encounter loved ones and new faces alike! If you are new, perhaps seeking a retelling of Twelve Dancing Princesses…you will find a beautiful and unique version…and so. much. more.
September 10, 2016
I cried ... again. Don't I always with Anne Elisabeth Stengl's novels? A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold, the first book to her new series, THE FAMILY OF NIGHT, was no different for me. It made me cry. And it was mind-blowingly amazing, of course!
This epic new novel from Anne Elisabeth is fantasy, like her other books. In fact, it even takes us to the Woods Between, and the beautiful Starflower's lovely Haven (if you didn't know, these are both from TALES OF GOLDSTONE WOOD). So these two series connect! Which is absolutely delightful! I was missing TALES OF GOLDSTONE WOOD a great deal, and so was beyond happy to find so many familiar things and people and places in A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold. This new novel is also a fairy tale retelling. It retells The Twelve Dancing Princesses in a wild and original way. We follow the journey of a fourteen-year-old peasant girl named Heloise, and a dying noble called Benedict ... and hear the giggles of a silly, mad sylph ... and watch the dreadful dance of night ... and all those complex, intriguing things!
As I crept into this dear, imaginative world, I found myself quickly wondering: "Why did I take so long to pick up another one of Anne Elisabeth's books?" They are oh so captivating! With her beautiful, lyrical writing style, this talented author takes us to fantastic worlds where strange creatures lurk and heroes & heroines are awkward, unassuming girls and boys. Lessons and thought-provoking messages are woven throughout the pages; a soul-tugging allegory etched into the core. That's why I cry. The way God and His Light and Love are portrayed touches my heart so profoundly, I never fail to feel my eyes welling up with tears at one point or another.
Though there is humor and fun aplenty, the story can be rather dark. The Family of Night, though I've yet to have them all figured out, a bit gruesome. It's only in the end, at the break-through, that you see the message more clearly, and the Light shines brightly, and you realize that, all along, darkness was not as powerful as it wanted you to think. I do recommend caution for a younger or sensitive audience. Though I didn't feel it went overboard, there were some parts that were intense/gruesome. Nothing like most YA books these days, though. I feel Anne Elisabeth does a good job at keeping the balance.
As always, the characters are splendid. I loved Heloise (though sometimes I wanted to shake her), and I LOVED Benedict! And when they were together, I was absolutely delighted! *grins* They are just so funny together. So adorable in their awkwardness and grumpiness and fierceness, some how. They made each other better, as a team. They made me laugh! And touched my heart with their sincerity (this particularly coming from Benedict). And I just ... *huggles them* They were both amazing characters. The sylph was way too much fun as well. And all the other characters, good and not-so-good, interesting. And the Dame! It was so, so good to see her again! *squeals* And visit her Haven! And ... everything! I can't wait to see what happens next in this new series!
The mystery. The complexity. The adventure. It was intense. It was amazing. A bit frightening at times, but not overly so. I love that there were so many layers, so many stories told. There were reasons for actions. There was sorrow and loss and pain and anger. There was vengeance. And then there was love. And hope. And forgiveness and healing and victory! And a future.
I simply need this big epic novel on my bookshelf now. I want Heloise and Benedict added to my collection! *winks and grins* I'm so happy that I decided to pick up A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold ... and now I eagerly await Book Two! Or Poison Crown, from the TALES OF GOLDSONE WOOD. Which ever comes first! ^_^
This epic new novel from Anne Elisabeth is fantasy, like her other books. In fact, it even takes us to the Woods Between, and the beautiful Starflower's lovely Haven (if you didn't know, these are both from TALES OF GOLDSTONE WOOD). So these two series connect! Which is absolutely delightful! I was missing TALES OF GOLDSTONE WOOD a great deal, and so was beyond happy to find so many familiar things and people and places in A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold. This new novel is also a fairy tale retelling. It retells The Twelve Dancing Princesses in a wild and original way. We follow the journey of a fourteen-year-old peasant girl named Heloise, and a dying noble called Benedict ... and hear the giggles of a silly, mad sylph ... and watch the dreadful dance of night ... and all those complex, intriguing things!
As I crept into this dear, imaginative world, I found myself quickly wondering: "Why did I take so long to pick up another one of Anne Elisabeth's books?" They are oh so captivating! With her beautiful, lyrical writing style, this talented author takes us to fantastic worlds where strange creatures lurk and heroes & heroines are awkward, unassuming girls and boys. Lessons and thought-provoking messages are woven throughout the pages; a soul-tugging allegory etched into the core. That's why I cry. The way God and His Light and Love are portrayed touches my heart so profoundly, I never fail to feel my eyes welling up with tears at one point or another.
Though there is humor and fun aplenty, the story can be rather dark. The Family of Night, though I've yet to have them all figured out, a bit gruesome. It's only in the end, at the break-through, that you see the message more clearly, and the Light shines brightly, and you realize that, all along, darkness was not as powerful as it wanted you to think. I do recommend caution for a younger or sensitive audience. Though I didn't feel it went overboard, there were some parts that were intense/gruesome. Nothing like most YA books these days, though. I feel Anne Elisabeth does a good job at keeping the balance.
As always, the characters are splendid. I loved Heloise (though sometimes I wanted to shake her), and I LOVED Benedict! And when they were together, I was absolutely delighted! *grins* They are just so funny together. So adorable in their awkwardness and grumpiness and fierceness, some how. They made each other better, as a team. They made me laugh! And touched my heart with their sincerity (this particularly coming from Benedict). And I just ... *huggles them* They were both amazing characters. The sylph was way too much fun as well. And all the other characters, good and not-so-good, interesting. And the Dame! It was so, so good to see her again! *squeals* And visit her Haven! And ... everything! I can't wait to see what happens next in this new series!
The mystery. The complexity. The adventure. It was intense. It was amazing. A bit frightening at times, but not overly so. I love that there were so many layers, so many stories told. There were reasons for actions. There was sorrow and loss and pain and anger. There was vengeance. And then there was love. And hope. And forgiveness and healing and victory! And a future.
I simply need this big epic novel on my bookshelf now. I want Heloise and Benedict added to my collection! *winks and grins* I'm so happy that I decided to pick up A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold ... and now I eagerly await Book Two! Or Poison Crown, from the TALES OF GOLDSONE WOOD. Which ever comes first! ^_^
June 17, 2016
Have you ever read a book that was so utterly satisfying that when you finished it you closed it, sighed happily and hugged the book? That was this book for me. (I'm not even joking, I seriously did hug this book.)
This review will not contain much detail about the actual story because I am afraid to spoil people, and being able to go into this story completely blind, not having anything but the vaguest idea of the general plot premise was part of the magic of it for me. I was able to let it completely sweep me away into a world of mystery and surprise. A place where faeries are real, trees move, and reflections have lives of their own. But more than that, it is a place where sacrifice and familial love, even across generations, can be seen in their purest, most beautiful forms.
All I can really say is, wow. Just wow. I am so very much looking forward to future stories.
This review will not contain much detail about the actual story because I am afraid to spoil people, and being able to go into this story completely blind, not having anything but the vaguest idea of the general plot premise was part of the magic of it for me. I was able to let it completely sweep me away into a world of mystery and surprise. A place where faeries are real, trees move, and reflections have lives of their own. But more than that, it is a place where sacrifice and familial love, even across generations, can be seen in their purest, most beautiful forms.
All I can really say is, wow. Just wow. I am so very much looking forward to future stories.
January 19, 2017
I'm a bit questionable about this book...in some ways I really enjoyed it, but then there was a lot that turned me off.
I especially didn't like how things turned out with Ben.
I don't know...I think the only way I can explain it is that I finished the book but didn't feel complete or that something was lacking.
Maybe there will be another book to see what happens next.
I especially didn't like how things turned out with Ben.
I don't know...I think the only way I can explain it is that I finished the book but didn't feel complete or that something was lacking.
Maybe there will be another book to see what happens next.
March 23, 2016
I'm really disappointed. I absolutely LOVEEEED all of Anne's other books. But the characters fell flat for me in this one. It seem to move so, so slowly, and I was bored most of the time. The beginning seemed random and a lot of unnecessary conversations could have been cut. *shrug* Just my opinion. I wanted to like this book. :/
// 1.5
// 1.5
March 22, 2016
4.5 stars
When it comes to pleasure reading, Anne Elisabeth Stengl is a favorite. I'm not normally a huge fantasy reader (although over the past couple of years I find that I'm definitely being converted into one) but her Tales of Goldstone Wood novels were, aside from C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien's works, a major hook getting me into the genre. Heartless was the first modern fantasy that I actually enjoyed.
Her books are so deliciously thick, with layers of meaning to ponder and contemplate. Look, I'm even getting poetic about it. A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold is no exception. While it takes place within the world of Goldstone Wood, I do think it could be read as a standalone; that being said, I do think having background knowledge about those books gives the reader a greater appreciation for the story. However, I wouldn't say that it's strictly necessary.
Though this is a loose retelling of "The Twelve Dancing Princesses," it's not so far off as one can't see the influences of the original tale. It's not a fast book-it's one that may take the reader awhile to get through, and some parts do lag. Of course, that didn't stop me from reading it during every spare moment and thus finishing it in a day. I haven't looked in the mirror lately, but I suspect my eyes are a bit red.
Heloise is an interesting character, at times flawed to the point of frustrating, but her journey was one I was sincerely invested in. (And I loved Benedict. Very much.) A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold, like many of Stengl's books, doesn't always necessarily take the paths that I expect (or want, for that matter) but it still leaves the reader with a sense of satisfaction.
Overall, another worthwhile novel from one of my favorite modern authors.
When it comes to pleasure reading, Anne Elisabeth Stengl is a favorite. I'm not normally a huge fantasy reader (although over the past couple of years I find that I'm definitely being converted into one) but her Tales of Goldstone Wood novels were, aside from C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien's works, a major hook getting me into the genre. Heartless was the first modern fantasy that I actually enjoyed.
Her books are so deliciously thick, with layers of meaning to ponder and contemplate. Look, I'm even getting poetic about it. A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold is no exception. While it takes place within the world of Goldstone Wood, I do think it could be read as a standalone; that being said, I do think having background knowledge about those books gives the reader a greater appreciation for the story. However, I wouldn't say that it's strictly necessary.
Though this is a loose retelling of "The Twelve Dancing Princesses," it's not so far off as one can't see the influences of the original tale. It's not a fast book-it's one that may take the reader awhile to get through, and some parts do lag. Of course, that didn't stop me from reading it during every spare moment and thus finishing it in a day. I haven't looked in the mirror lately, but I suspect my eyes are a bit red.
Heloise is an interesting character, at times flawed to the point of frustrating, but her journey was one I was sincerely invested in. (And I loved Benedict. Very much.) A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold, like many of Stengl's books, doesn't always necessarily take the paths that I expect (or want, for that matter) but it still leaves the reader with a sense of satisfaction.
Overall, another worthwhile novel from one of my favorite modern authors.
April 23, 2016
I just finished this book a few minutes ago. I'm shell-shocked. Awestruck. It's just...I feel like I've stepped back into the mortal realm from faerie and I still can't see straight.
Like all of Anne Elisabeth Stengl's books, this one started off slow. I didn't particularly like Heloise at first. I wasn't sure I'd like it.
Then, I did. Not sure when it happened. Some time between mirror magic and silver and gold forests, it happened. The book builds and builds until I spent this evening reading the last 30% because I could do nothing but finish it.
This is a retelling of the Twelve Dancing Princesses, but it's so much more than that. All the pieces are there, but they are woven in such a greater, deeper story.
Stengl's books always astound me with the world she's created. It's so vast with so much history. She can add whole countries, centuries of history, and it still feels like she's captured just a piece of the whole.
All to say, this book is amazing!
Like all of Anne Elisabeth Stengl's books, this one started off slow. I didn't particularly like Heloise at first. I wasn't sure I'd like it.
Then, I did. Not sure when it happened. Some time between mirror magic and silver and gold forests, it happened. The book builds and builds until I spent this evening reading the last 30% because I could do nothing but finish it.
This is a retelling of the Twelve Dancing Princesses, but it's so much more than that. All the pieces are there, but they are woven in such a greater, deeper story.
Stengl's books always astound me with the world she's created. It's so vast with so much history. She can add whole countries, centuries of history, and it still feels like she's captured just a piece of the whole.
All to say, this book is amazing!
January 6, 2019
2018 reread ~ I felt a little friendlier to this book the second time through. The theme caught me a little harder and drew me in a little deeper. I still struggled with my complaints from my original review, but eh, let's just settled the strait and go for four stars.
Three stars or four? I'm still in a strait betwixt which to choose. I have actually never read the story of the Twelve Dancing Princesses, so was able to dive into Anne Elisabeth Stengl's latest release with just the joyous expectation of a brand new story. And Stengl delivered amazingly as she always does. The layers, the worlds, the humor and the characters were all brilliant and enjoyable (though one character teetered very close in a lot of ways to another one of her famous male protagonists). But overall, the "story" itself was as excellent a work as we've come to expect from Stengl.
However.
The presentation of the story itself, the way it was crafted to be delivered...was disappointing. It halted and dragged and stalled so many times that if it had not been for my drive of "I have never not read a Stengl book and I'm not going to start now," I would not have had the patience to endure, no matter how much the story itself intrigued me. Perhaps I am alone in my frustration with the story presentation. But years ago, I was drawn to Stengl's ability to say the most brilliant, descriptive things in the tightest way possible and deliver a story that was never rushed, never dragging, just one body of precisely timed and crafted brilliance. And this story did not flow like that. At all. I can only hope very much this is not a new trend with Stengl.
But all that aside, if you want a great story and are not as particular as I am and don't mind a bit of tedium. Enjoy.
Three stars or four? I'm still in a strait betwixt which to choose. I have actually never read the story of the Twelve Dancing Princesses, so was able to dive into Anne Elisabeth Stengl's latest release with just the joyous expectation of a brand new story. And Stengl delivered amazingly as she always does. The layers, the worlds, the humor and the characters were all brilliant and enjoyable (though one character teetered very close in a lot of ways to another one of her famous male protagonists). But overall, the "story" itself was as excellent a work as we've come to expect from Stengl.
However.
The presentation of the story itself, the way it was crafted to be delivered...was disappointing. It halted and dragged and stalled so many times that if it had not been for my drive of "I have never not read a Stengl book and I'm not going to start now," I would not have had the patience to endure, no matter how much the story itself intrigued me. Perhaps I am alone in my frustration with the story presentation. But years ago, I was drawn to Stengl's ability to say the most brilliant, descriptive things in the tightest way possible and deliver a story that was never rushed, never dragging, just one body of precisely timed and crafted brilliance. And this story did not flow like that. At all. I can only hope very much this is not a new trend with Stengl.
But all that aside, if you want a great story and are not as particular as I am and don't mind a bit of tedium. Enjoy.
March 22, 2016
Anne Elisabeth has created a book with amazing characters. I couldn't help liking all the main characters, hating the despicable ones and feeling sorry for others.
The plot was intriguing and unputdownable. A bit creepy at times, but I like that.
All together, it was an excellent book and probably my favourite by the author.
(Just saying, I loved the Sylph :) )
The plot was intriguing and unputdownable. A bit creepy at times, but I like that.
All together, it was an excellent book and probably my favourite by the author.
(Just saying, I loved the Sylph :) )
March 23, 2016
This book is so very close to a five star review: I loved so much about it. There was just the right amount of humor and spook to make the story deliciously engaging without being too much of either. I loved, loved, LOVED the sylph and Benedict. They were fantastically done. Some of the best characters I have encountered in a long while. Heloise took a little longer to warm up to, which is very common for strong, flawed heroines, but in the end I loved her strength and spirit and relationship with her sisters. Her sisters--gasp--I can't say anymore without causing spoilers, but there are some fantastic details involving them that will stir you to tears.
The world building is superb. Although this is a much more "local" story than many of Ms. Stengl's other Goldstone Wood novels, I think I liked this one the best. I really felt like I had become immersed in this small estate community and grew to love the people who lived there, which made me root all the more for Heloise on her dangerous quest.
I did think the title was a little long--being an author who loves one or two word titles, I would have gone with something punchier like "Branches" or "Branch of Silver" or something, but the chosen title looks so beautiful on the cover I can forgive this longness with ease.
One thing that saddened me slightly about the story is Heloise's relationship with the rest of her family. I won't say anything more about that, lest I spoil something, but the relationships here are strained and painful and will move you to tears. Again.
Don't get me wrong--there is so much about this story that will have you grinning and smirking and outright laughing. Although many of the plot twists are predictable, as is the ending (there was one twist I did NOT see coming, which having read almost every book in Ms. Stengl's Tales of Goldstone Wood series, I applauded with embarrassing enthusiasm and eagerly await, what will hopefully be, a continued story) but the twists are handled in such an imaginative and fresh way that you still feel surprised and awed. All in all, this was a refreshingly deep and honest fairy tale retelling that will stir all of your emotions and leave you thinking about it much later.
The world building is superb. Although this is a much more "local" story than many of Ms. Stengl's other Goldstone Wood novels, I think I liked this one the best. I really felt like I had become immersed in this small estate community and grew to love the people who lived there, which made me root all the more for Heloise on her dangerous quest.
I did think the title was a little long--being an author who loves one or two word titles, I would have gone with something punchier like "Branches" or "Branch of Silver" or something, but the chosen title looks so beautiful on the cover I can forgive this longness with ease.
One thing that saddened me slightly about the story is Heloise's relationship with the rest of her family. I won't say anything more about that, lest I spoil something, but the relationships here are strained and painful and will move you to tears. Again.
Don't get me wrong--there is so much about this story that will have you grinning and smirking and outright laughing. Although many of the plot twists are predictable, as is the ending (there was one twist I did NOT see coming, which having read almost every book in Ms. Stengl's Tales of Goldstone Wood series, I applauded with embarrassing enthusiasm and eagerly await, what will hopefully be, a continued story) but the twists are handled in such an imaginative and fresh way that you still feel surprised and awed. All in all, this was a refreshingly deep and honest fairy tale retelling that will stir all of your emotions and leave you thinking about it much later.
May 12, 2017
4.5 stars
This book was absolutely amazing. And, *sighs*, Anne Elisabeth has such a gift for worldbuilding. :)
This book was absolutely amazing. And, *sighs*, Anne Elisabeth has such a gift for worldbuilding. :)
May 8, 2019
Update: Reread May 5-6, 2019. Still an excellent book. I had less patience with the beginning than I did before; Heloise kind of rubbed me the wrong way there. But I enjoyed the ending more this time around. Glad I reread it; certainly will again.
---------
When I heard that Anne Elisabeth Stengl was releasing a loose retelling of one of my favorite fairytales of all time, Twelve Dancing Princesses, I was naturally ecstatic. It seemed there was no way A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold could not be awesome.
And, as it turns out, I was right.
The Good:
-The world of Goldstone Wood is always a favorite place of mine to visit, wherever the story happens to take place. While this story doesn't take place in any of the eras we've mostly seen so far, and there are next to no familiar characters (with a few exceptions- hello, Dame Imraldera! It's wonderful to see you again! You seem to be doing well!), it's still the same world, with the same almost-fairytale feel and familiar Otherness. And it's rather fun, at least for me, to try to figure out exactly when and where the book takes place. It's obviously long after Golden Daughter, given how far along the culture is, but well before Heartless, as Parumvir doesn't seem to exist yet (I don't think?) and Corrilond is still around. I've an idea that the location might be in Beauclair (which I probably spelled wrong . . .) based on some of the French-sounding names and such. (At first I thought it might be in southern Parumvir, as it's obviously not northern Parumvir- we've seen quite a bit of that, and I'd know it if I saw it again here!- but then I remembered that, hey, Beauclair exists too.)
-This book did have a more mysterious feel to it than other Goldstone Wood books do, though. And I loved it! It made the story seem a little darker than normal, a bit creepier- but in a good way.
-Benedict is basically my favorite character in this book. He reminds me of someone, though I can't put my finger on who . . . In any case, he's remarkably patient with Heloise and her quest (even when it makes no sense to him), surprisingly sweet when he's of a mind to be, and surprisingly funny on his frequent cycle of "Say/do something, probably out of annoyance -- realize it was a stupid thing to say/do -- turn red and apologize."
-Did I mention that this is a Twelve Dancing Princesses retelling? And even if it is a slightly loose retelling, it still has all the essential elements- just mixed up from what they generally would be.
-From what I'd heard in reviews, I thought that the one weak point in the story would be Heloise . . . but I actually liked her quite a bit! People had compared her to Merida (of Brave) and so I was prepared for a "Buck ALL THE EXPECTATIONS do what I want pfffff femininity is lame" sort- the type of character who tends to be hit or miss for me. But she wasn't so extreme as all that; she's simply a girl who wants more than the life before her (which I can certainly relate to), who feels guilty for something that's not her fault (which I can also relate to, in a significantly more minor way), who makes impulsive decisions, who feels like her sister is Practically Perfect In Every Way and tends to be annoyed with that feeling, and who, despite her fear, puts everything on the line for one who she cares for. All in all, an excellent character.
-Hello, Prince of Night. Aka Imoo-Tau. Haven't I seen you somewhere before? Or, rather, somewhere later? I think I have. And while I'm not as star-struck by your . . . something . . . as other girls, I do still look forward to seeing you later and finding out where your path takes you and how you get where I think you're going.
-Everblooming crazy. I need to start using this. It's fabulous. Ok?
The Bad:
-*thinks*
-*thinks some more*
-*continues thinking*
-Um. Wasn't 100% on the ending. But I was 97%, so that's ok. Other than that, I got nothing.
Overall, A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold is an excellent addition to the world of Goldstone Wood (even if it is in a different series) and an absolutely gorgeous- though dark and sometimes creepy- story. Yes, it's expensive. But it's well worth the price!
---------
When I heard that Anne Elisabeth Stengl was releasing a loose retelling of one of my favorite fairytales of all time, Twelve Dancing Princesses, I was naturally ecstatic. It seemed there was no way A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold could not be awesome.
And, as it turns out, I was right.
The Good:
-The world of Goldstone Wood is always a favorite place of mine to visit, wherever the story happens to take place. While this story doesn't take place in any of the eras we've mostly seen so far, and there are next to no familiar characters (with a few exceptions- hello, Dame Imraldera! It's wonderful to see you again! You seem to be doing well!), it's still the same world, with the same almost-fairytale feel and familiar Otherness. And it's rather fun, at least for me, to try to figure out exactly when and where the book takes place. It's obviously long after Golden Daughter, given how far along the culture is, but well before Heartless, as Parumvir doesn't seem to exist yet (I don't think?) and Corrilond is still around. I've an idea that the location might be in Beauclair (which I probably spelled wrong . . .) based on some of the French-sounding names and such. (At first I thought it might be in southern Parumvir, as it's obviously not northern Parumvir- we've seen quite a bit of that, and I'd know it if I saw it again here!- but then I remembered that, hey, Beauclair exists too.)
-This book did have a more mysterious feel to it than other Goldstone Wood books do, though. And I loved it! It made the story seem a little darker than normal, a bit creepier- but in a good way.
-Benedict is basically my favorite character in this book. He reminds me of someone, though I can't put my finger on who . . . In any case, he's remarkably patient with Heloise and her quest (even when it makes no sense to him), surprisingly sweet when he's of a mind to be, and surprisingly funny on his frequent cycle of "Say/do something, probably out of annoyance -- realize it was a stupid thing to say/do -- turn red and apologize."
-Did I mention that this is a Twelve Dancing Princesses retelling? And even if it is a slightly loose retelling, it still has all the essential elements- just mixed up from what they generally would be.
-From what I'd heard in reviews, I thought that the one weak point in the story would be Heloise . . . but I actually liked her quite a bit! People had compared her to Merida (of Brave) and so I was prepared for a "Buck ALL THE EXPECTATIONS do what I want pfffff femininity is lame" sort- the type of character who tends to be hit or miss for me. But she wasn't so extreme as all that; she's simply a girl who wants more than the life before her (which I can certainly relate to), who feels guilty for something that's not her fault (which I can also relate to, in a significantly more minor way), who makes impulsive decisions, who feels like her sister is Practically Perfect In Every Way and tends to be annoyed with that feeling, and who, despite her fear, puts everything on the line for one who she cares for. All in all, an excellent character.
-Hello, Prince of Night. Aka Imoo-Tau. Haven't I seen you somewhere before? Or, rather, somewhere later? I think I have. And while I'm not as star-struck by your . . . something . . . as other girls, I do still look forward to seeing you later and finding out where your path takes you and how you get where I think you're going.
-Everblooming crazy. I need to start using this. It's fabulous. Ok?
The Bad:
-*thinks*
-*thinks some more*
-*continues thinking*
-Um. Wasn't 100% on the ending. But I was 97%, so that's ok. Other than that, I got nothing.
Overall, A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold is an excellent addition to the world of Goldstone Wood (even if it is in a different series) and an absolutely gorgeous- though dark and sometimes creepy- story. Yes, it's expensive. But it's well worth the price!
September 11, 2017
Review to come! (maybe)
March 19, 2016
This book is billed as a loose retelling of "The Twelve Dancing Princesses." It's also tied into another fantasy series, "The Tales of Goldstone Wood." I've read lots of retellings of "The Twelve Dancing Princesses", and none of the Goldstone Wood books, so I was simultaneously on familiar and foreign ground--rather like the book's heroine, now that I think about it.
For a "loose" retelling, it has far more pieces of the original fairy tale than I expected. All the necessary elements, like the gold and silver trees, the twelve dancing girls, and the older woman mentor, were present, just mixed around. It has the underworld/death elements that pervade so many tales of this type. It even contains similarities to the"Katie Crackernuts" variant of the tale (one of my favorites), including a bond between two sisters, an ill prince, and a girl as the one to break the curse (though no one gets the head of a sheep, sadly). Thus, I found it a fun and satisfying retelling. I had a lot of fun picking out the various references and seeing them used in surprising ways that were much more satisfying than they are in some closer retellings.
I had a little more difficulty with the fantasy world. Since it's tied into such a large series, there are a [i]lot[/i] of names, concepts, creatures and magical rules thrown about without much explanation. A lot can be gleaned from context clues, but this is a vast and complex fantasy universe with a lot of history, and I have a feeling I missed out on some of it. I don't usually read epic fantasy, so I'm not used to sorting out so many magic systems and rules and creatures and realms all at once. That said, I enjoyed most elements of the universe, even if it took me a while to understand them.
I found the book immensely readable. The plot kept me turning the pages to find out what happened. The characters were charming, layered and lovable. I loved the sisterly bond between Heloise and Evette, that combination of love and frustration and misunderstanding that only exists among family. I loved Grandmem's spunk and abrasiveness, and the heartbreak in her history. I loved Benedict's combination of rash temper and good manners, and how he was both frustrated with and completely supportive of Heloise's quest (and I always love aristocrats with painful pasts). And I loved, loved, loved the sylph. I also liked that the villains were sympathetic, even though their very non-human nature gave them different motivations and morality.
Overall, a satisfying book, and I'm glad that the story ends with the promise of more. I'll gladly follow these characters on more adventures.
For a "loose" retelling, it has far more pieces of the original fairy tale than I expected. All the necessary elements, like the gold and silver trees, the twelve dancing girls, and the older woman mentor, were present, just mixed around. It has the underworld/death elements that pervade so many tales of this type. It even contains similarities to the"Katie Crackernuts" variant of the tale (one of my favorites), including a bond between two sisters, an ill prince, and a girl as the one to break the curse (though no one gets the head of a sheep, sadly). Thus, I found it a fun and satisfying retelling. I had a lot of fun picking out the various references and seeing them used in surprising ways that were much more satisfying than they are in some closer retellings.
I had a little more difficulty with the fantasy world. Since it's tied into such a large series, there are a [i]lot[/i] of names, concepts, creatures and magical rules thrown about without much explanation. A lot can be gleaned from context clues, but this is a vast and complex fantasy universe with a lot of history, and I have a feeling I missed out on some of it. I don't usually read epic fantasy, so I'm not used to sorting out so many magic systems and rules and creatures and realms all at once. That said, I enjoyed most elements of the universe, even if it took me a while to understand them.
I found the book immensely readable. The plot kept me turning the pages to find out what happened. The characters were charming, layered and lovable. I loved the sisterly bond between Heloise and Evette, that combination of love and frustration and misunderstanding that only exists among family. I loved Grandmem's spunk and abrasiveness, and the heartbreak in her history. I loved Benedict's combination of rash temper and good manners, and how he was both frustrated with and completely supportive of Heloise's quest (and I always love aristocrats with painful pasts). And I loved, loved, loved the sylph. I also liked that the villains were sympathetic, even though their very non-human nature gave them different motivations and morality.
Overall, a satisfying book, and I'm glad that the story ends with the promise of more. I'll gladly follow these characters on more adventures.
April 12, 2016
Wowzers. I am pretty sure I burned calories reading this book. It was so intense.
Heloise, a spunky peasant girl lives a regular life full of routine and predictable events. But when she wakes up on the morning of her 14th birthday, everything changes. She suddenly finds herself whisked away on a frightening adventure where she discovers a doorway into a different world. A world which somehow holds power over her and her loved ones. When her sister, Evette, disappears during an enchanted dance, it takes all of Heloise's strength and courage to find her, even when her own family denies Evette's very existence. Despite all the questions regarding Heloise's sanity, she seeks the reasons behind the disappearance and unearths a terrible curse. With the help of an apologetic son of the Marquis, Heloise navigates her way though the Faerie realm and endeavors to break the curse which has enslaved hers and generations of forgotten sisters.
I started reading this in the evening and once I got started, it was nearly impossible to put it down. Even when I had to eat dinner with my family, my mind was not in the present world, but in the world of Goldstone Wood. The story was a balance of colorful personality, clever humor, and eerie terror. It is a tale of bravery! Of Sacrifice! It is also a tale of immortality; even though our bodies die, our souls live on.
There were a few moments where it dragged and I skimmed a little bit, but even the slow parts were so beautifully written that, if you had the patience, you would enjoy it if just for the pure art of it.
It was a bit dark and gruesome at some points, and sometimes just generally creepy. So keep that in mind if you are sensitive to the dark side. ;P
If you've read Twelve Dancing Princesses, then you will see slivers of the classic story weaved creatively into this amazingly strange book.
Heloise, a spunky peasant girl lives a regular life full of routine and predictable events. But when she wakes up on the morning of her 14th birthday, everything changes. She suddenly finds herself whisked away on a frightening adventure where she discovers a doorway into a different world. A world which somehow holds power over her and her loved ones. When her sister, Evette, disappears during an enchanted dance, it takes all of Heloise's strength and courage to find her, even when her own family denies Evette's very existence. Despite all the questions regarding Heloise's sanity, she seeks the reasons behind the disappearance and unearths a terrible curse. With the help of an apologetic son of the Marquis, Heloise navigates her way though the Faerie realm and endeavors to break the curse which has enslaved hers and generations of forgotten sisters.
I started reading this in the evening and once I got started, it was nearly impossible to put it down. Even when I had to eat dinner with my family, my mind was not in the present world, but in the world of Goldstone Wood. The story was a balance of colorful personality, clever humor, and eerie terror. It is a tale of bravery! Of Sacrifice! It is also a tale of immortality; even though our bodies die, our souls live on.
There were a few moments where it dragged and I skimmed a little bit, but even the slow parts were so beautifully written that, if you had the patience, you would enjoy it if just for the pure art of it.
It was a bit dark and gruesome at some points, and sometimes just generally creepy. So keep that in mind if you are sensitive to the dark side. ;P
If you've read Twelve Dancing Princesses, then you will see slivers of the classic story weaved creatively into this amazingly strange book.
June 20, 2016
Anne Elisabeth Stengl is a master of world building, which many of her fans (myself included) have witnessed time and time again throughout her Goldstone Wood series. This is a new book which doesn't veer too far away from the Path of the Wood, but is just different enough to satisfy any cravings for a fresh look at Stengl's writing.
A Branch of Silver a Branch of Gold is beautiful. It's hilarious. It's great fun, but most of all, it still has that deep message each book written by Stengl possesses. Just like every good faery-story, Stengl weaves in powerful thoughts, suspenseful moments, numerous witty lines, and unforgettable characters! For anyone who enjoys a powerful tale of love, vengeance, and excitement, grab your copy of A Branch of Silver a Branch of Gold...you won't be disappointed!
*ONE COMPLAINT*
I really, really, really want a story from Anne Elisabeth Stengl that is totally disconnected from Goldstone Wood! How cool would that be?! Who knows...I think (hope) she might be planning one such story...but we Imps will simply have to wait to find out!
A Branch of Silver a Branch of Gold is beautiful. It's hilarious. It's great fun, but most of all, it still has that deep message each book written by Stengl possesses. Just like every good faery-story, Stengl weaves in powerful thoughts, suspenseful moments, numerous witty lines, and unforgettable characters! For anyone who enjoys a powerful tale of love, vengeance, and excitement, grab your copy of A Branch of Silver a Branch of Gold...you won't be disappointed!
*ONE COMPLAINT*
I really, really, really want a story from Anne Elisabeth Stengl that is totally disconnected from Goldstone Wood! How cool would that be?! Who knows...I think (hope) she might be planning one such story...but we Imps will simply have to wait to find out!
November 8, 2017
I felt like I had to plod through most of the over-wrought and many times confusing and convoluted plot just to see what happened at the end. This book is quite lengthy and I feel it could have been a much more enjoyable read had it been edited down quite a bit. The main character was tough and real and she was probably the only reason I stayed slightly interested. I might consider looking into the sequal but if it drags on like this one did I will probably abandon it before I finish.
May 18, 2020
Anne Elisabeth Stengl is one of my all time favorite writers. This is the last book she has written, which I didn't get to read when it first came out, but have now finally read.
This book was nothing like I expected it would be, but it in a really great way! I thought that this was a stand alone 12 dancing princesses retelling. It is actually the first book in a Tales of GoldstoneWood spin-off series, that is only loosely based on the fairytale.
I loved that this book showed a different side of the many worlds in the Tales of GoldstoneWood multiworld. It makes this book have some of the same feels as the original series, while still making it feel separate and unique.
I also loved that this book was losely based on the 12 dancing princesses fairytale. I have read 2 or 3 retellings, that were somewhat similar to each other. Ms. Stengl took a really different approach of incorporating elements of the original fairytale into this book.
The only thing I didn't like about this book was that it ended on a cliff hanger and that there doesn't seem to be any sequel coming out anytime soon :(
Despite that, I did still really love the story, the characters, and the plot twists. If Ms. Stengl decides to continue this series in the future I will definitely be reading the rest!
This book was nothing like I expected it would be, but it in a really great way! I thought that this was a stand alone 12 dancing princesses retelling. It is actually the first book in a Tales of GoldstoneWood spin-off series, that is only loosely based on the fairytale.
I loved that this book showed a different side of the many worlds in the Tales of GoldstoneWood multiworld. It makes this book have some of the same feels as the original series, while still making it feel separate and unique.
I also loved that this book was losely based on the 12 dancing princesses fairytale. I have read 2 or 3 retellings, that were somewhat similar to each other. Ms. Stengl took a really different approach of incorporating elements of the original fairytale into this book.
The only thing I didn't like about this book was that it ended on a cliff hanger and that there doesn't seem to be any sequel coming out anytime soon :(
Despite that, I did still really love the story, the characters, and the plot twists. If Ms. Stengl decides to continue this series in the future I will definitely be reading the rest!
January 1, 2019
Very well-written and vibrantly "alive". I could really feel like I was in the story and found the motivations and situation of Heloise to be something I could relate too. I felt bad for poor Benedict since she never really seemed to properly appreciate him or be especially kind.
But I had a hard time putting this down because the plot was so engaging. There's a thread of danger throughout that comes through nicely and I definitely felt like Heloise was on the edge of not making it.
But I had a hard time putting this down because the plot was so engaging. There's a thread of danger throughout that comes through nicely and I definitely felt like Heloise was on the edge of not making it.
May 24, 2016
I admit I was wary when getting this...
I mean, some fairytale retellings are really well done, and others are... well. They're kind of average and predictable. However, as you can tell from the premise Goodreads so gives us, A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold really is loosely based on the fairytale.
I've only read one book by Stengl before, it was OK, and passed the time. This book is absolutely fantastic. Her writing, although I'm sure has improved over time, fits perfectly in this book. It's ridiculous. And by ridiculous I mean wonderfully awesome!
Heloise and Benedict have definitely reached my favorite heroines and heroes of the year.
Heloise is so kick-butt and doesn't give a pickle about being ladylike or proper. Rather surly and unapproachable, Heloise guards herself. Dwarfed by her older sister Evette (who makes even insults sound kind), tormented by her twin's death, and bitter from her family's own bitterness towards her, makes Heloise far from 2D. Despite her rough exterior, Heloise's attentions are sincere, and she is unfailingly loyal to those who help her in her quest.
And Benedict...
Ah. Benedict. Poor Benedict. Where do I possibly begin?
While Heloise is more of the "act now think later- no apologies," Benedict is more the "act now think... I shouldn't have done that. Why did I do that?! I am so sorry." Half of the time I really truly felt sorry for the guy. Here he is, working with this seemingly crazy girl, and most of the time he's left in the dark. That being said, he's not the secondary character turned main protagonist. His tempers followed by swift apologies were so comical, and his growing admiration for Heloise was cute. Not to mention give the aristocrat his own sad past and he becomes as endearing as Heloise is. The picturesque proper gentleman, he definitely provides some stability to Heloise's character.
Don't you just love good archetypes?
I hope this isn't a standalone. For multiple reasons that would reveal a few spoilers. It doesn't appear the series will be continued (there is no series name next to the title), but I suppose that is all well and good. Imagining the ending you want is part of the fun, right?
Overall, five glittering stars.
All my friends, read this! It's magnificent!
I mean, some fairytale retellings are really well done, and others are... well. They're kind of average and predictable. However, as you can tell from the premise Goodreads so gives us, A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold really is loosely based on the fairytale.
I've only read one book by Stengl before, it was OK, and passed the time. This book is absolutely fantastic. Her writing, although I'm sure has improved over time, fits perfectly in this book. It's ridiculous. And by ridiculous I mean wonderfully awesome!
Heloise and Benedict have definitely reached my favorite heroines and heroes of the year.
Heloise is so kick-butt and doesn't give a pickle about being ladylike or proper. Rather surly and unapproachable, Heloise guards herself. Dwarfed by her older sister Evette (who makes even insults sound kind), tormented by her twin's death, and bitter from her family's own bitterness towards her, makes Heloise far from 2D. Despite her rough exterior, Heloise's attentions are sincere, and she is unfailingly loyal to those who help her in her quest.
And Benedict...
Ah. Benedict. Poor Benedict. Where do I possibly begin?
While Heloise is more of the "act now think later- no apologies," Benedict is more the "act now think... I shouldn't have done that. Why did I do that?! I am so sorry." Half of the time I really truly felt sorry for the guy. Here he is, working with this seemingly crazy girl, and most of the time he's left in the dark. That being said, he's not the secondary character turned main protagonist. His tempers followed by swift apologies were so comical, and his growing admiration for Heloise was cute. Not to mention give the aristocrat his own sad past and he becomes as endearing as Heloise is. The picturesque proper gentleman, he definitely provides some stability to Heloise's character.
Don't you just love good archetypes?
I hope this isn't a standalone. For multiple reasons that would reveal a few spoilers. It doesn't appear the series will be continued (there is no series name next to the title), but I suppose that is all well and good. Imagining the ending you want is part of the fun, right?
Overall, five glittering stars.
All my friends, read this! It's magnificent!
June 14, 2016
A two-word summary: Fairly Cool. There was the 'fairly' parts that weren't as good as the rest, but overall I LOVED it. I will never look at mirrors the same way again.
The characters were pretty good. At times some didn't feel quite realistic but most of the story they were okay. Benedict was a favourite, though I was getting concerned that he wouldn't survive to the end. His whole attitude to everything was so cool, and I just loved him. Heloise was a grouchy kind of character but nicely not-perfect and, even if I got annoyed at her every now and then, she did do some pretty cool stuff. And the Sylph was great.
I couldn't help but find that the story dragged a bit at times. Things were a bit predictable, and I kept feeling that Heloise succeeded with the first half too easily. I would've liked a bit more conflict and tension but A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold somehow managed to be very page-turning without that.
The whole actual idea of the three sisters working together to save everyone is epic, not many books have good sister relationships. The bond between Evette and Heloise was perfect. There are some many beautifully true things woven into the story, glimpses of wonder. I love Anne's writing style, the whole world is so amazingly crafted, the magic and The Between are complex but simply understandable.
I didn't like this as much as the few Tales of Goldstone Wood that I've read, but there is still the familiar sense of beauty to return to the same world. I hugely recommend this book.
The characters were pretty good. At times some didn't feel quite realistic but most of the story they were okay. Benedict was a favourite, though I was getting concerned that he wouldn't survive to the end. His whole attitude to everything was so cool, and I just loved him. Heloise was a grouchy kind of character but nicely not-perfect and, even if I got annoyed at her every now and then, she did do some pretty cool stuff. And the Sylph was great.
I couldn't help but find that the story dragged a bit at times. Things were a bit predictable, and I kept feeling that Heloise succeeded with the first half too easily. I would've liked a bit more conflict and tension but A Branch of Silver, a Branch of Gold somehow managed to be very page-turning without that.
The whole actual idea of the three sisters working together to save everyone is epic, not many books have good sister relationships. The bond between Evette and Heloise was perfect. There are some many beautifully true things woven into the story, glimpses of wonder. I love Anne's writing style, the whole world is so amazingly crafted, the magic and The Between are complex but simply understandable.
I didn't like this as much as the few Tales of Goldstone Wood that I've read, but there is still the familiar sense of beauty to return to the same world. I hugely recommend this book.
September 14, 2019
I found this book to be beautiful, haunting, and layered with emotion and evocative imagery. It is quite seriously, in my opinion, one of the two best books I have read this year. In other words – I love it. Somehow it drew my eye out of a great number of books that I have entered a giveaway for, and though I did not win the giveaway, I felt moved to look up the book and read it. I am so glad that I did.
The story is simple on the surface, but like most of the books I love, there are undercurrents that tell a great deal of the story. Young Heloise is dissatisfied with her life, though she does not understand why, but it is not until an ancient story becomes part of her life that she is pushed to confront the dark history of her village and her family. Suffering, sacrifice, and the love of sisters all connect in this lush tale about the dangers of the fairy realm and a curse that spans centuries. The ending is ultimately satisfying without being pat; those who see beyond the ordinary are also changed by it.
In a time when bad writing can easily find an audience, it is good to see a book which is strong on all levels – character, plot, imagery, theme, writing quality, and world-building. The mix of originality and universality of the story is also one of its strengths, though finding a weakness is hard in this beautiful work. I wholeheartedly recommend it for anyone who grew up on fairy tales and classic fantasy.
The story is simple on the surface, but like most of the books I love, there are undercurrents that tell a great deal of the story. Young Heloise is dissatisfied with her life, though she does not understand why, but it is not until an ancient story becomes part of her life that she is pushed to confront the dark history of her village and her family. Suffering, sacrifice, and the love of sisters all connect in this lush tale about the dangers of the fairy realm and a curse that spans centuries. The ending is ultimately satisfying without being pat; those who see beyond the ordinary are also changed by it.
In a time when bad writing can easily find an audience, it is good to see a book which is strong on all levels – character, plot, imagery, theme, writing quality, and world-building. The mix of originality and universality of the story is also one of its strengths, though finding a weakness is hard in this beautiful work. I wholeheartedly recommend it for anyone who grew up on fairy tales and classic fantasy.
July 3, 2016
I am in love with Stengl's characterization. While there were many aspects of this book that I savored (it's certainly the best retelling of The Twelve Dancing Princesses that I've ever read), the characters were my favorite part. Heloise is brilliant, and the interactions between all of the characters are incredibly lifelike. The contradictory nature of the love-hate bond between the sisters was spot-on, and even the character who initially seemed relatively bland (Evette) turned out to be multi-faceted and intriguing. I confess, as a result of my love for the characters and their interactions, I preferred the parts of the book that dealt more with the character development/Near World and less of the sections that dealt more with allegory/Faerie. As with Golden Daughter, there were a few parts that felt wordy to me--I like the more pared-down prose of Starflower or Dragonwitch--but my affection for the characters easily carried me through the slower parts. I ate this door-stopper book right up in just a couple days and couldn't put it down!
April 27, 2016
I really enjoy this book, it(alike to most books) was rather predictable, aside from the end. The bond between the sisters and the double meaning of the quest made the side path possibly more interesting then the villains, who were helping her succeed.
I liked the magic in normality concept (The hilarious Sylph, "Yes... No... Maybe?") Although I was confused by the character changes in the start.
This book reminded me vaguely of Alice in the Looking Glass, but was good nonetheless.
Over all, it was a great book and I would like to see how some of her others play out.
I liked the magic in normality concept (The hilarious Sylph, "Yes... No... Maybe?") Although I was confused by the character changes in the start.
This book reminded me vaguely of Alice in the Looking Glass, but was good nonetheless.
Over all, it was a great book and I would like to see how some of her others play out.
December 31, 2016
Such an enjoyable new tale set in the familiar but always different Wood in Between. These new characters were spectacular and I can't wait to explore the rest of the series!
Want to read
March 18, 2016Ahhhhhh!!! I need this! I hope it will be available in paper back too.
July 10, 2016
4.5 stars
December 27, 2018
Gorgeous, gorgeous, GORGEOUS, BREATHTAKING book!
Review to come when I'm more coherent. :)
Review to come when I'm more coherent. :)
June 5, 2024
Simply put, A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold is a beautiful novel.
It is a high fantasy fairy tale, inspired by an old story (The Twelve Dancing Princesses), full of lovely prose. It has lords and ladies, kings and queens; faeries which range from menacing to motherly; and a most unlikely cast of heroes and heroines. Heloise, a 14-year-old peasant girl wracked by guilt and her parents' frequently dismissive attitude toward her; Cerise, her elderly grandmother, who most think is crazy but is, in reality, an excellent mentor and motivator to Heloise; Master Benedict, the ruler of the estates's young son, doomed to die within the year; and Sylph, a talking, living, breathing wind spirit. The story follows these characters on an incredible, impossible journey I don't dare spoil. For the plot, though important, is not what I'd like to emphasize in this particular review.
What I like possibly most of all about A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold, is how it shows truths about mortality. It is seldom (never?) that one finds a series that weaves Christian spirituality with high-fantasy as well as Tales of Goldstone Wood. This book in particular tackles life and death in a fascinating way: it deals extensively with the the idea of "mortal magics"; the beauty of living and dying; the gift of beginnings and endings; of being a part of history. And, oh, of that land beyond the Final Water, Farthestshore, where the Lumil Eliasul dwells! For it is only through him that mortals may find their true meaning.
It is a high fantasy fairy tale, inspired by an old story (The Twelve Dancing Princesses), full of lovely prose. It has lords and ladies, kings and queens; faeries which range from menacing to motherly; and a most unlikely cast of heroes and heroines. Heloise, a 14-year-old peasant girl wracked by guilt and her parents' frequently dismissive attitude toward her; Cerise, her elderly grandmother, who most think is crazy but is, in reality, an excellent mentor and motivator to Heloise; Master Benedict, the ruler of the estates's young son, doomed to die within the year; and Sylph, a talking, living, breathing wind spirit. The story follows these characters on an incredible, impossible journey I don't dare spoil. For the plot, though important, is not what I'd like to emphasize in this particular review.
What I like possibly most of all about A Branch of Silver, A Branch of Gold, is how it shows truths about mortality. It is seldom (never?) that one finds a series that weaves Christian spirituality with high-fantasy as well as Tales of Goldstone Wood. This book in particular tackles life and death in a fascinating way: it deals extensively with the the idea of "mortal magics"; the beauty of living and dying; the gift of beginnings and endings; of being a part of history. And, oh, of that land beyond the Final Water, Farthestshore, where the Lumil Eliasul dwells! For it is only through him that mortals may find their true meaning.
“It is the way of mortality. It is our burden and it is our gift. The Faerie folk don’t understand it. They can’t because their lives go on and on and on.” She squeezed Heloise’s fingers, urging her to an understanding she could not grasp. “Before there can be a Beginning, Heloise, there must first be an End. I’ve suffered my End. I’ve entered into my Beginning.”
September 1, 2016
This is a beautifully written fairy tale retelling, and one that I will not easily forget. I am always looking for a fairy tale that can surprise me (in good ways) and this one did so, not perhaps in its plot or resolution, but in its depth and details.
I won't rehash the plot here, but I will caution the reader who prefers their fairy tales light and fluffy -- there is a great deal of darkness in this story. This will not surprise anyone who has read the original, as the Twelve Dancing Princesses has never been particularly nice. In this version, however, the darkness is woven into the story not simply for the sake of being grim or shocking -- it is the simple and familiar darkness of life as frail mortal creatures, made all the more striking by being set in the midst of the fey and the fantastic.
The characters are just the sort that I adore: the kind of complex, irritating, unpredictable and multi-faceted people who make you remember them (I was particularly fond of Evette). No one is precisely what you expect, and everyone's motivations are deeply felt, whether you like them or not, whether you agree with them or not.
Perhaps what I appreciated the most was the author's ability to weave truth into a magical narrative. The darkness and the shadows serve as perfect contrast to the beautiful absurdities of hope, faith and love, making the story not so much escapist as poignant, which is, I believe, what fairy tales are truly all about.
I definitely recommend this (though it is on the long side) and look forward to reading more by this author.
I won't rehash the plot here, but I will caution the reader who prefers their fairy tales light and fluffy -- there is a great deal of darkness in this story. This will not surprise anyone who has read the original, as the Twelve Dancing Princesses has never been particularly nice. In this version, however, the darkness is woven into the story not simply for the sake of being grim or shocking -- it is the simple and familiar darkness of life as frail mortal creatures, made all the more striking by being set in the midst of the fey and the fantastic.
The characters are just the sort that I adore: the kind of complex, irritating, unpredictable and multi-faceted people who make you remember them (I was particularly fond of Evette). No one is precisely what you expect, and everyone's motivations are deeply felt, whether you like them or not, whether you agree with them or not.
Perhaps what I appreciated the most was the author's ability to weave truth into a magical narrative. The darkness and the shadows serve as perfect contrast to the beautiful absurdities of hope, faith and love, making the story not so much escapist as poignant, which is, I believe, what fairy tales are truly all about.
I definitely recommend this (though it is on the long side) and look forward to reading more by this author.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 73 reviews