John Prebble makes no bones about his affiliations, and his books on the Clearances and Culloden are classics. I picked this up expecting a lot of bias, but I should have known better. Though this is not without its opinions (which I really like) it's also as 'fair' an interpretation of a bizarre political stunt as you're likely to get.
George IV came to Scotland by default, due to a host of other political goings on and some issues with his current mistress's acceptability. And he didn't actually visit 'Scotland', he visited Edinburgh. And though he was there for just over two weeks, he spent the greater part of it hanging out in Dalkeith House, and very little of it on display. He was a comical figure in a variety of costumes, from admiral to Highland chieftan, and yet he seems to have had some kingly dignitas that endeared a great many people to him and brought the people of Scotland, high and low, to the capital to take a look at him.
Prebble chronicles the visit from beginning to end in glorious colour, giving a blow by blow account of each of the events and (for me more fun) the many and varied participants. There are any number of eccentric Highlanders vying for a key role, but Glengarry, who disrupted a few of the set pieces with his demands to be given precedent, was my favourite (and I'm definitely giving him a walk-on role in my own story set in Edinburgh at the time). There's tragedy, for the whole thing took place against a backdrop of clearances and residual bitterness over the last failed Jacobite uprising. Prebble draws a poignant and impossible to refute conclusion, that it wiped the slate clean, by presenting (with Walter Scott's conniving) George IV as a true Jacobite king, and that the vast array of tartanalia and so-called Highland traditions allowed the landowners doing the clearing to salve their conscience with the preservation of the culture, if not the people.
I like Prebble's style, and I enjoy his penchant for a good spectacle. Sadly, the edition of the book I got (second hand from Amazon) was missing about 50 pages, which included the Caledonian Hunt ball, and which I was looking forward to reading on account of it being the pinnacle of the tartan-fest. So I'll need to get another copy.
But that aside, this was an excellent read, and it's given me an appetite for going back and finding out a great deal more about the various characters, not least the Sutherlands, leaders of the Clearances.