I found this book while looking for another in the library. Since just about every person has ADD/ADHD these days, including myself, i thought it could provide some insight into the subject.
Alas, I was wrong. This book is just floating around in its own little mental landscape, postulating one absurdity over the other as we flip through the pages. Lara Honos-Webb is a licensed clinical psychologist and is apparently considered to be one of the leading authorities on ADHD and depression. As the title suggests, she presents ADHD as a gift rather than a handicap. She considers people with the diagnosis to be misunderstood and that they actually are creative, sensitive, intuitive, warm, and loving people. And the way the book puts it, it seems to apply to just about every single individual with the disorder. Which doesn't seem particularly realistic to me. I have seen people with ADHD, who truly suffer from it, and it is clearly not a blessing for them. I have seen children consistently unable to brush their teeth or even put their clothes on due to distractibility (is that a word?), as well as adults for that matter. This is a matter of pathology, not a GIFT for fuck's sake. It's bit like the people saying schizophrenia is actually a hidden blessing; that schizophrenics have awakened into a spiritual reality and are thusly not properly understood by the rest of us.
The problem is that the book romanticizes just about all of the ADHD-symptoms into assets. When a person with ADHD is wrong about something, she interprets it as not being wrong at all, but rather like missing the target because of some factor the diagnosee left out. For instance, being wrong about a person is attributed as being able to pick up on the energy of the group rather than the individual. Things like that. It couldn't be as simple as the person actually being wrong about the situation. No, because since they have ADHD, they obviously have hidden superhuman gifts. Some of the attributes of ADHD, as presented in the book, are:
- Being able to delve deeper than others
- Establishing contact on a level most people avoid
- Being driven by an intriguing curiosity
- Being courageous
- Being at one with nature (yes, there is a lot of emphasis of that in the book)
- Being sensitive to the emotions around you
- Being intuitive
- Being creative
Now, the book does indeed state that its main focus is to emphasize the positive aspects of ADHD rather than the negative ones. The general attitude it expresses is to emphasize the positive aspects and to develop them instead of improving one's soft spots and weaker sides. I'm dubious to the efficiency of this method. Imagine a golfer, for instance, wanting to improve his/her game. The person hits many fairways, has a driving average of 275 yards, hits many greens in regulation, but fails miserably at scrambling. Then the best idea might be to emphasize short game-practice, while maintaining the strengths. Apply the attitude of the author of this book, which then would be to practice driving, approach shots and so on, leaving the short game detrimental. What good is a person's area of expertise if all else fails? I don't think that's the best way to improve life. People with ADHD have definite problems, particularly social problems, and not giving the effort to improve those problems in favor of improving whatever one is already good at seems a bit arrogant, if not autistic.
This book is what happens when you stray too far from the accepted views of a subject while failing to provide a solid foundation for your own arguments. It seems to me that the book is the author's fantasy of what ADHD is, and not surprisingly, we learn that she herself has the disability. She seems a bit reluctant to the idea of medication for most sufferers, and implies that her own therapeutic methods are to prefer instead. Turning the disability into something arbitrary and intangible. Making us wonder one thing: is ADHD in our minds or does it exist in the objective sense? The book presents ADHD as a personality trait rather than a disability, so we are left wondering. I think of the "indigo child" thing that everyone was talking about some years ago. We're really just speculating and musing here. In contrast, the psychiatric consensus is that ADHD-suffers have a lack of dopamine (and norepinephrine?), so proper medication increases dopamine concentration in a sample of plasma. The book is way too subjective and romanticizes the condition too much. It also appears to be misdirected. An example from the book itself (translated into English by me, since mine is in another language):
"As an adult with ADHD, you have to ability to mediate the thoughts and emotions of others. You are likely a highly emotional person and can read other people with brilliance. Your contact with your surroundings is an intuitive one - you will often successfully predict what others are going to say - and you are extremely sensitive for the interplay among people. You can even discover that you yourself experience the emotions of other people."
Is this really ADHD? Or is it more along the lines of an intuitive person who is also emotionally sensitive? It seems to me the former. And so, many of the tips and tricks in this book is something that could be applicable for most people on the planet, rather than specifically for ADHD. It is too broad. It doesn't focus on the specifics of advantages and troubles of people with ADHD, but rather, the advantages and troubles of a certain kind of personality. It misses the point. It is however, not completely devoid of good points. One such point is to follow one's strengths and let them be a guiding force in life, rather than letting one's weaknesses get in the way of fulfilling one's dreams.
To sum things up, it swiftly becomes evident that the person who wrote this book suffers lamentably from a hefty case of ADHD. As a result, the book is diffuse, off the point, indecicive, vague, and unreliable. It is written exactly how one would imagine an unmedicated person with ADHD writes a book about his or her condition. If you want to read a self help book with some good tips and pointers for developing a positive outlook on life, then this book might be of some value. If you want to better understand ADHD, and the real curses and blessings thereof, then I'd suggest you read something else.
1.5/5