In the present day, Dr. Kennedy Plain is a sleep disorder researcher who is dying of a brain tumor. One of her patients, Mac (Arthur) claims to be able to dream himself back in time after long periods of sleeplessness, and in the past, he is free of his disability and completely whole. He also suspects that if he could be allowed to die, in the present, while in one of his dreams, he'd be allowed to stay in the past permanently. Nedy thinks he's lost his grasp of reality, but when he dies and she's put on medical leave, she continues the research by attempting to dream herself back into the past, in the same history story that Mac has been involved in. She's surprised to find herself in medieval England with Fulke Wynland, who history proved had murdered his young nephews in order to claim their title of Earl and who had also apparently murdered Lady Lark, the woman he believes Nedy to be. At first, Nedy honestly believes that Fulke is the villain in this story, but as she and Fulke become closer, she realizes that history has it wrong and tries to figure out who the real villain is. But Nedy's constant disappearances and interference between Fulke and his adversary, Arthur (Mac), lose her much of Fulke's trust. And when he learns that she is only pretending to be Lady Lark, he becomes convinced she is a villain. And so, Nedy has to do what she can to save Fulke, now that history has changed and he will die, to save his nephews and to stay in the past to claim her love.
I really liked this story as a whole. I liked the time travel theory of being able to dream your way back in time through sleep deprivation, having never seen that one before. I also liked the mystery story in the past, as Fulke and Nedy/Lark try to figure out who the villain is and how they interact together. There is some time-travel humor that Nedy uses to keep things light hearted, but I wasn't a huge fan of that. But a great deal of that came from Nedy's refusal to believe that she was actually in the past and not just dreaming. And I struggled quite a bit with this refusal to believe, since nothing she was experiencing was remotely dream like, all the characters had very in-depth personalities and lived, existed and experienced realities while she was away from them and she even noted that the story (as she had it in the present) kept changing everytime she went back.
I don't understand why it was so dificult for her to grasp that reality, and besides, what did she have to lose in believing in it? Where this book really shines is with the emotional aspect - particularly with the relationship between Fulke and Nedy and the relationship between Nedy and her mother. Goodness, but that final sleep scene was enough to get me teary-eyed. So kudos to the other for infusing quite a bit of emotion and even passion in this story (despite it being a clean romance).
Now I should note that I have an overly analytical mind that almost always latches on to some small detail and won't let it go. As much as I love time travel stories, this is one genre that almost always has an event or happening that makes me sit up and go "No! That's against the rules of time travel!" For example, a character goes back in time, changes something and then returns to the present with absolutely no change to the present. That's kinda/sorta what happened here. In this story, there's the question of actual action vs. intent - when Nedy intends to return to the past to save the nephews, shouldn't that have automatically changed the course of history since she's then already done it (in the past)? For that matter, since the only reason she went to the past was to save Fulke's life, once she'd already done that she'd then eliminated her reason for going to the past and then all should have been null and void. Unless we're working with the theory of alternate versions of reality and she simply time traveled to a different reality (in which case, Fulke wouldn't be able to sense the previous version having happened, which he did). You see what happens to me when I read time travel? Finally, there's the big, mother kahuna mistake in my book. The last time that Nedy travels back to the past, she aims to arrive BEFORE she originally left. This means that there should have been two of her there at the same time...because she hadn't yet left for the present. But when Fulke goes to see her (where she'd been before she left), she's no longer there. And Mac is all, "she returned to the present" and knew exactly what she'd done before they ever had the conversation about what she was going to do. But how was that possible? Originally she hadn't left until after the fire, so she should still be sitting in that cell until after the fire, even as her future self gallivants around the castle. Yes, I know, most people will tell me to stop taking this stuff so seriously or lighten up or to even stop reading time travel romance, but sometimes it's done right and I'm not left with those questions. And sometimes the mistakes are so small that I can let them go, but this was a lot for me to think on and this kind of mistake takes me out of the story quite quickly.
So overall a good story and these time travel issues do not stop me wanting to read more of Tamara Leigh's stories. She seems to be an excellent writer and I'll look for more from her.