This story introduces Texas Ranger Sergeant John Quarrie, also knows as John Q, in 1967, during the height of the Vietnam War, and during which he is called upon to cover a complex murder spree on the other side of Texas, because so many of his fellow rangers are involved with demonstrations. He doesn't like having to be so long away from him son ten-year-old James. His wife Mary Clare died a year after James was born. But James has a composite family including Pious Noon, a black man who Quarrie saved from a life sentence after being accused wrongly of cowardice during the Korean War, Pious's mother and his sister Eunice, Mrs. Feeley and Nolo, the ranch manager. It is one under which James is thriving, and getting help from when doing a history project that gets connected to the case that John Q is working.
A former soldier apparently commits suicide though John thinks not. A woman is murdered violently and then a police officer is also found beaten to death. What follows is series of killings all tied to a burned hospital, Trinity, which was a sanitorium for the criminally insane. The suicide of Icarus Bowen, the homecoming of his son Isaac, from Vietnam, and the disappearance of his "twin" brother, Ishmael, unaccounted for after the fire are all perplexing issues for John, who is driving back and forth between places all the poor souls who got in the way, were murdered. He seeks out Dr. Beale, a psychiatrist, who was trying out a theory of his regarding Dissociative Identity Disorder, which Ishmael suffered from, and Nancy, the nurse helping and Orderly Briers, also attending the patients of the hospital, especially a particularly violent one, Miss Annie.
While swimming for catfish near a train wreck of 1903, John and Pious discover the bones of what appears to be a young person. They report the body, but all believe that it is one of people who perished when a bridge went out and the conductor was unaware. James is moved by the story that he is using for his project. It is after John gets the tragic information about the Bowen family that he realizes that the bones are that of Isaac Bowen, drowned when he was ten, while he and Ishmael were looking for catfish. The accident resulted in Ishmael being mentally ill and the subsequent agreement of his father to try a new technique to get him out of his mind's trap. It backfired, however, and Ishmael goes on the killing spree, after those he blames for his pain and betrayal. Isaac only exists now in his mind. His mother had left the "boys" with their father unable to stand the disappearance of Isaac, who they thought had been abducted, and the ever increasing probelm of Ishmael. The twist of the story is that Ishmael is the son of Miss Annie who had been married to Ike Bowen, who had been unfaithful, with her best friend. Miss Annie had stabbed him three times when she discovered them together, and while he survived to divorce her and marry her friend, she became lost in her mind. She was pregnant with Ishmael, and when the baby was taken from her she lost it completely, constantly playing with a doll as if it a real baby, and very violent if anyone tries to take it from her. Isaac was the son by the Ike's new wife, Clara (Carla Simpson), who has been living near. The boys had overheard a drunken conversation of their father and his friend one day, when they were ten, and Ishmael had taunted Isaac about the issue. It had resulted in his not paying attention at the river, and losing count, with his brother getting his foot caught and Ishmael unable to get him freed in time. The title The Long Count, refers to how long one could hold a breath when going after the fish.
This was a sad and compelling story, one I could not put down. Gulvin does a commendable job of putting out small pieces of the story (At one point I thought Isaac was involved in the killings but could not figure out how, not at all expecting the outcome.) building the suspense but not revealing the true horror of pain and betrayal. I actually expected that the new theory Dr. Beale was trying was something that inflicted more physical pain. I loved the comparing of John Q's family life and that of the Bowens', and the longing in John Q to be with his son as he faces the events of the Bowen family. The friendship of Pious and John is particularly compelling given the times and the place when blacks did not associate with whites as friends, or close family. The unusual makeup of John's entire "family" makes for a richer and more sympathetic picture.