Really more like a 2.5, but I'm feeling generous this morning.
I'm a big advocate of a plant-based diet (although I'm not 100% there). Rip does a decent job talking about why you should eat plant-based and why you should avoid processed foods. I give him a lot of credit for that. However, I had some issues with the tone of this book as well as the lack of references. The book reads like you're being yelled at by one of those paid commercials for Product X. That's the best way I can describe it. Also, some of the examples and such that he give could have been much better/more science based. Three of my biggest issues:
1) As an example of bad, processed foods, he targets Pop-Tarts and then talks about how yes, they are vegan, but they are full of all sorts of processed stuff. However, only a few varieties of Pop-Tarts are vegan. There is gelatin in many of them, so a lot of them aren't even vegetarian. Sure, this might be nit-picking on my part, but when I went vegetarian, this is one food I almost had to give up. And based on my glance at the grocery store the last time I went, finding the few varieties that are vegan (the non-frosted ones) is really hard.
2) Rip talks about how most processed foods have way too much sodium in them (agreed) and then gives a basic formula to use to help you select foods (I believe it was a 1:1 ratio or less of calories per serving to sodium per serving). And then he suggests a recipe for soup from the book to use instead. Except, if you put the recipe into a nutrition analysis program, his own recipe doesn't meet the guideline.
3) Trans fat. During his rant on trans fats (which yes, are horrible for you) he decides to single out ALL meat and dairy as foods as huge culprits in this instead of focusing on other common foods like frozen pizza, margarine, or even peanut butter. Now, depending on where you look, meat and dairy contain no to trace or very small amounts of trans fats. Also, there is science that says that natural trans fats in foods are not nearly as bad as the manufactured ones, and they might actually be beneficial in some ways. I feel Rip should have focused more on other big health concerns around consuming meat and dairy (antibiotics, hormones, environmental impact, fat in general, etc.) instead of this minimal potential risk.
Finally, the recipes. There were a few decent-looking ones, and the overall plan was fine, but none of this seemed as good as what I saw in The Whole Foods Diet. There was also an over-emphasis on his personal line of products.