Mackenzie and Fire Dancer have an immediate attraction and connection to each other, but after Fire Dancer discovers Mackenzie has painted his face against his wishes he decides he must take her captive back to his village because he believes she possesses a piece of his soul. While he tries to escape with her a white soldier accidentally shoots her. Mackenzie’s father tells Fire Dancer to give her back to him and he’ll let him leave, but of course he is lying and tries to shoot Fire Dancer, forcing Fire Dancer to shoot him in self-defense. Mackenzie wakes up after several weeks and the village’s holy man orders her and Fire Dancer to marry since she painted him.
There is a Shawnee woman named Mary who desperately wants to marry a white man and live as a white woman. Her brother Okonsa is mentally unstable and murders Fire Dancer’s nephew Tall Moccasin to prevent the boy from spying on him, kicks Mary in the stomach and causes her to miscarry, and kidnaps Mackenzie because he believes she actually loves him. He confesses to her that he was raped by Englishmen as a child. He falls off a cliff and appears to have been eaten by wolves… but in the epilogue, Mackenzie seems to imply that he actually wasn’t.
Fire Dancer eventually tells Mackenzie that her father is dead but doesn’t admit that he was the one who killed him until she asks him why Okonsa would say that he did. She decided to leave Fire Dancer in anger, but when the Shawnee and other tribes attack the fort again, unrelated to her leaving, she tells him of her pregnancy and returns to him.
The prologue and epilogue take place about 40 years after all of this. Fire Dancer is 79 and he and Mackenzie have at least one daughter and a granddaughter.
Overall, I really enjoyed this!