3/4 They saved the world stars
I took a gamble on this book because Grace Draven mentioned as it went up on Amazon and I really liked the cover, then I was intrigued by the blurb. Nothing unheard of, but there was just something, both characters seemed so strong. I hoped the author would pull it off, enemies to lovers, convincing magic. I was not disappointed.
The author opens the door to her world all at once, no slow introductions. All is there and all is believable. Neighbouring kingdoms whose hostilities have dangerously escalated, a bastard warrior princess who can never stop proving how formidable and useful she is in a typical backstabbing court, a powerful shadow mage who is nothing like we expect him to be, caught in between duties, trying to stay neutral and trying to save the world from an otherwordly danger. The writing is precise, almost flawless, the worldbuilding vivid and simple to grasp, the fantasy and magic utterly convincing. The description of Gethen's Citadel Ranith and its polar opposite, sunny, insular Or-Halee are some of my favourite parts. I was transported instantly, feeling like I was actually walking up and down both structures, either fighting not to be frozen to death or languidly getting high on perfumes, light and warmth. All characters are well defined, easy to relate to. Gethen's servants were just perfect even if a bit stereotypical, the villains were villains gloating about their own cruelty.
It was a bit of a slow beginning but then the story really sucks you in. I could not put it down, it kept growing on me. It's the dark magic, the danger, the mystery to solve running against the clock, the political games and of course, the relationship between the main characters. Alina is a warrior. An experienced, ferocious, skilled, take-no-prisoners warrior. Proud, liberal with her body, not with her affections, loyal to her denizens and even her evil father. She is scarred, unashamed of her body, she knows its strength and respects its limits. Throughout the book she never whines, she's never lost, afraid of being sexual or helped when needed. Damn, that was a refreshing female fighting lead. She's not perfect in any way, but she's not your typcal snarky kick-ass wanna-be. She kicks ass, period. She knows her value and once she accepts a charge she's all in, her life on the line. Gethen is a shadow mage on the brink of transforming into something else, his powers depleting, unsure of what his new magic will entail and how he will be able to wield it, worried about the safety of the world more than his own, unwilling to serve anyone but his own values. More of a healer and a safeguard against crossovers from the Void than an evil necromancer, because that's who he chose to be despite the life that had been decided for him and how they tried to mold him. He might not want to mingle with petty human quarrels, but he's rooted in nature, in animals, in life. He deeply cares.
For those of you who love adventure and suspense to lead instead of romance, you will be happy. The romance is a thin red line, something subtle and precious blooming amongst all the perils they have to face, but is not the main focus. Dangers and creeping evil are coming from all sides. This couple of opposites will mistrust each other for almost three quarters of the story and there is only ONE sex scene. The growing UST and slowburn, though, were magnificent . So many little and big things were driving them towards each others and apart at the same time, the admiration, the yearning, the intensity of every little physical contact scorching due to their brevity. These two had dead Shadow Mages, Rime Witches, all kind of demons, magical monsters and natural disasters to fight, they had their priorities straight. The only sex scene we got was sensual more than descriptive, it came as the very much needed confirmation of their bond and desire, but it also had a purpose in the development of the plot, in Gethen's future. And I loved that till the end in that scene, he checked on her, sought permission. He could have beguiled her a million times but no. He wanted all of her, he wanted to be wanted just as much. Still...I would have liked more steam, I had been waiting for that one scene for SOO LOOONG ...sigh....
Why not give 4 full stars or even 5 stars if so many elements were so good? Because, after much thinking, some of the good things were also the same I had to (slightly) criticize:
- both Gethen and Alina have strong cores, they had to fight to survive, they were both abused and/or ignored growing up and they literally had to build themselves, physically and mentally, to survive and grow in their skills. They made choices even when all choices had been taken away from them. I liked that the author didn't decide to play little-shrink and heavily refer to their past, the little photographs she drops here and there about their past are very neat, yet I feel that more could be done with it. Especially with Alina, it could have been much less vague. I understood much more Gethen and his way of being/thinking than I did Alina, and I mostly felt for him.
- Gethen is a vegetarian and the way he touches and handles his wolves (and all the other forest's animals) made me fall for him like a block, yet when the Rime Witch commits the biggest atrocity against all his animals, we didn't get the emotional response that I would expect from his character. They were hunted and hunting, pressed for time and he was enraged...but I missed some pain...strangely, Alina was more moved in this situation than he seemed.
- Alina is amazingly strong, maybe too much. She never once says I love you. I don't think this is a sign of independence or strength. Not being able to say it, or openly feel it, is actually a big problem in my opinion. Perhaps she was unfamiliar with the emotion, but still. I know there are different thinking schools about it, I need to say it, I need to hear it, even if just once. We know she cares and worries, we see she loves him, but she never opens up. Gethen on the contrary is so straightforward with her, declaring his desire, admiration and love without a second thought, no matter the dire situations they were in. Sometimes a funny comeback is all that's needed, some other times both characters need to be on the same emotional wavelength, without it meaning melassafilled lines, for the scene to be really gripping and to make me cheer for the couple. I missed some of this with Alina. Even before his transformation, I found Gethen so much warmer than her. It detracted even from the best moments for me.
- I liked the danger, the horror and the magic so much I wanted more angst, the fight scenes were so good!
- The hints the author gave us before something bad was about to happen or someone was about to turn were SO transparent to me that I wondered a bit about the sharpness of the characters in certain moments, I would have preferred to be completely surprised and shocked. Also, some adjectives and decriptions were too repetitive.
Even with these remarks, I thoroughly enjoyed this reading and I would recommend it to anyone in search of a strong, non-bitchy female lead, a hot, sensitive non-self-centered mage and light but perfectly constructed magic fantasy. Some elements will remind you of Grace Draven. I will certainly continue with this serie, I hope to read more about these formidable two as well.