Danny is a rent boy, an architecture student, a waiter, and hot! Working his way through school seemed pretty he serves ego-obsessed writers their cocktails at the Emerson Club; he has his toes and other appendages sucked by horny businessmen; and he escorts anyone - male, female, or otherwise - who can afford him. But then his liaison with another rent boy gets him involved with an organ theft ring centering around a crazy old doctor and a crackpot nurse. A relentless stream of social commentary, careening between sex, comedy, and murder, Rent Boy is a hysterical romp through the worlds of contemporary culture and crime.
Gary Hoisington, known as Gary Indiana, was an American writer, actor, artist, and cultural critic. He served as the art critic for the Village Voice weekly newspaper from 1985 to 1988. Indiana is best known for his classic American true-crime trilogy, Resentment, Three Month Fever: The Andrew Cunanan Story, and Depraved Indifference, chronicling the less permanent state of "depraved indifference" that characterized American life at the millennium's end. In the introduction to the recently re-published edition of Three Month Fever, critic Christopher Glazek has coined the phrase 'deflationary realism' to describe Indiana's writing, in contrast to the magical realism or hysterical realism of other contemporary writing.
The first part of this underground classic is just amazing: Danny, the title-giving rent boy, studies architecture at Rutgers, earns his money as a waiter at a celebrity hot spot called "Emerson Club"and, sure, as a sex worker. Indiana does an amazing job evoking 1980's New York, and Danny's voice is so smart and fresh that it's just a joy to read his thoughts, which are presented in an epistolary style, hence as letters to a former client... lover? .... friend? There is a confessional feel to it, and the intimacy between the two correspondents effectively leads to ellipses for the reader, for instance regarding Danny's family background, which is only hinted at. And sure, we never read the responses he receives.
Danny is highly perceptive and matter-of-fact about his job as a sex worker, relating again and again to his fears around AIDS and the economic forces that rule the field. But then, for some reason, Indiana seems to lose faith in the fact that the usual daily routines of Danny can carry the text - and they absolutely could have, because they are so well-rendered. Instead, he suddenly brings in an organ theft plot around a client of a colleague who is a shady, elderly doctor. I was pondering whether there is a supposed to be some connection between renting out your body and selling organs, or whether this is a statement about capitalism, or AIDS and bodily disintegration, etc. - but the whole thing just does not work out, it feels like an author adding a criminal story line as an afterthought. I didn't care about this at all, I wanted to hear more about Danny and his triple life as a student, bartender and sex worker, and what he learnt about people on the way.
How unfortunate, this could easily have been a 5-star-read!
Fantastic voice in this one. There’s something deeply satisfying about how fast and loose it plays with genre – the first chunk feels like sleazy autofiction, all gritty vignettes and disconnected hook-ups narrated in a deadpan tone, and then suddenly we’re in full-blown noir-thriller mode. I liked this genre switch, which only serves to emphasise the book’s ‘Less Than Zero by way of David Cronenberg’ thing. Despite all that it’s not overly stylised but rather very lived-in: believably disaffected, full of offhand confidence, with the occasional weird little aesthetic tic to remind you this is the 80s. Cruel and horny and unwell. A great short book for hot days when everything has an unreal sheen.
sliding from social realism to horror over the course of 128pp w/ no clear transition point between the two is the literary equiv of going over niagara falls in a barrel. respect
Much like the male prostitutes who populate this novel, I was quickly in and out of this in one night.
And it's a good thing too, because I would not have wanted to spend a single second longer in this bleak and grimy world of New York City's seedy gay nightclubs, soulless male hustlers (aka "rent boys"), lonely johns, and desperate junkies in the early 1990's. Let's just say this turned out to be a "Happy Pride Month" selection only in the most grimly ironic sense.
Those who've been following me for a while know I'm far from a pearl-clutching prude. But I found this to be FILTHY in every sense of the word. If this were a movie, the ushers would have been handing out barf bags at the front door.
There are some "trashy" reads that are deliciously raunchy and pulpy and fun, even titillating at times. And then there are those "trashy" reads that are just vile and gross, reveling in their nihilism and ability to shock and disgust. This book was very much an example of the latter.
It's too bad, too, because author Gary Indiana (not his birth name - ha!) definitely knows his way around a sentence. There is some blistering satire and pithy writing scattered throughout, and I can appreciate his ambitious attempt to examine the lives of male sex workers with a candid and empathetic eye, while also questioning and condemning a capitalistic society in which everything and everyone becomes a crude commodity to be bought and sold.
Indiana displays an acerbic wit that probably made/makes him a provocative and engaging essayist. But as a novel, this is a meandering mess, dragged down by weak character development and poor pacing. We don't even get a hint of a plot until well past the halfway point, and even then it's pretty far-fetched and absurd. NOT RECOMMENDED.
I think I've overheard a million john life stories and another million whore life stories and once you plow off the bullshit the john's story's always "I'm lonely" and the whore's story's always "I came from a dysfunctional family."
The titular rent boy is writing letters; the recipient is largely unknown. The voice here is brilliant, free flowing and smooth. The details from this young man’s life are salacious and quirky.
So far so good. Then the plot veers off into an organ donor crime drama. What? Is the organ donor motif a metaphor for a rent boy — where money forces people to part with precious aspects of themselves? Who knows. I was distracted looking for some relevance, and would much rather have learned more about Chip, and Danny.
This was an intense novella. Told in first person in a letter to a former lover, Danny/Mark/Billy depending on who he was with, chronicles his life as a waiter at the nightclub for the rich and famous where drugs and sex were plentiful, and as male prostitute, or rent boy, in 1981 in NYC. Danny shares the sometimes repulsive details of his trick’s fetishes and desires, and the addictions and excesses of patrons and friends without judgement, aware always of the emptiness and meaninglessness of their lives. This is a raw book and about halfway through I almost put it down, but it was about halfway through that the story took a shocking, dark turn and I’m glad I kept with it.
This is not a book for everyone, sensitive readers might not like it, but Danny is a voice that will stay with me.
I DO NOT understand the conversation around this book. Almost every review i've read about Rent Boy in some way points back to how disgusting and vile this book is and/or how low brow it is. What was grotesque about this book? the descriptions of sex? Are the people reading it 13 years old? If anything it was an honest potrail of what rent boys likely had to go through. IF YOU DIDN'T WANT CRUDE DESCRIPTIONS OF SEX WHY TF DID YOU READ A BOOK CALLED RENTBOY?? And to call it lowbrow is for some reason giving homophobic. Was it 'lowbrow and nasty' because of the content, or because it was about queer people. GAG IT.
Anyways, I thought the writing was just so unique and was full of character. I laughed often and truly enjoyed the experience of reading it because I had no idea what would happen next. I think it might be my top read so far this year :)
"saltburn was fucking CRAZY" what is fucking CRAZY is that you clearly have never picked up a gary indiana book ?????? SO shallow and SO fucking pointless and just SO fucking weird and i LOVED every second of it. seriously the most disgusting shit that i have ever read and yet i reread it at least once a month gary indiana you have radicalised me . Beautiful. genuinely PERFECT. if i could direct any film adaptation of a book i would fuck Rent Boy UP !!!!!!!!! Quentin tarantino would have absolutely NAILED a rent boy film though jesus christ. so what is my takeaway from this book??? Nothing!!! Is there any meaning?? Nope!!!! Was it sick??? EXTREMELY!!!! Such a disturbingly beautiful book. my inspo genuinely gary you are a GENIUS except when i think abiut it youre just fucking troubled. will write a readable review that isnt just me vomiting words out when i am up because this changed my life. for the better????? No!!! It has made me worse!!! i still love it though. this is such a word barf but theres no other way to capture this fucking book. do i recommend it ???? Not proudly!!!!! said with Love
— "I can tell you what the cocktail lounge at the Ramada's like, think of dark Formica and grainy indirect lighting and emotions collecting in front of you in the little puddles formed by your cocktail glass, islands and continents of feelings you don't know how to place any more, and voices, the so-called human element, that remind you you're chained to the earth by a million little details: the world has fancy intellectual names for all these manacles and torture devices holding you down, but they might as well be called Mavis and Stanley and Chip, or the boy who ran away from home to learn fear, or the boy you love beyond anything who brings you a souvenir from his trip to Easter Island with the one he wants to fuck instead of you, or just a client whose loneliness and despair jut out on his face in the seconds before he comes: to me they were faces scribbled in watercolor drooling down the window, drizzling into Eighth Avenue and puddling up with all the human wreckage stashed in waterlogged corners of construction scaffolds."
While in San Francisco last week on a search for collectible gay fiction I found this at Bolerium Books, the world's largest inventory of used gay books for sale. It looked like a quick read covering the male hustler scene in contemporary (1990s) New York. The first half of the book is exactly that, and it was so funny and bitchy and real and deeply-felt that I was actually laughing out loud. The rent boy Danny (or Mike, or Billy, or whatever) drifts through his self-realized meaningless life, offering hilarious observations about his tricks, the bar scene, NY living, and sex. The graphic passages on sex are some of the best I've read anywhere not because of their explicit eroticism---nicely done thank you very much---but in the way the author non-judgmentally presents sex as a healthy normal activity, in all its kinky forms. This is fresh, not often seen in serious gay literature, in contrast to pornography let's say.
Then at halfway through the book Danny hooks up with another hustler and is drawn into a criminal situation involving organ theft. This is quite an unexpected and unforeshadowed shift in direction. Unfortunately it doesn't really work re: plot development, but it does effectively provide an opportunity for Danny to change his life---if he wants to. I won't spoil the plot with further details. For a few pages (this is a short book after all) there is true suspense.
In the second half you will also find plenty of social and political commentary which, if you are a liberal anti-Republican, like me, will warm your heart. A shadowy former trick of Danny's also partially emerges as a recipient of his letters of which the book itself appears to be a compilation made sometime after...well, no plot spoilers here.
I look forward to reading two or three more of Gary Indiana's books; his style is a toned down Dennis Cooper and doesn't cause as much brain damage as Cooper does.
One of the most disturbing things I’ve ever read??? I could not, in good conscience, recommend this to anyone without having like a very long conversation beforehand. Maybe when I gather my thoughts I’ll write an actual review, but I’ll leave this for now.
Rereading this for my book club. Insanely amazing. Indiana really makes some greay observations about life and the state of society.
An exciting experience that I was very happy to have had. I was expecting the crazy, wild experiences of a Rent Boy which I got. It was really funny and over the top. But then about halfway through the novel takes a turn and becomes an insane crime novel. And it worked so well!! Highly recommend and look forward to reading more Gary Indiana.
Completamente folle. Noir a tinte omo ricchissimo di contenuto vietato ai minori e anche ai deboli di stomaco, sembra voler ricalcare Dennis Cooper (che pure nomina! Il protagonista dice di aver acquistato un suo libro) e finirò anche io per mettervi presto le mani sopra, mi sa. Spero. This is my cup of tea.
SCREAMING CRYING THROWING UP!!!! I have been craving a transgressive masterpiece like this for so long and Rent Boy delivers. I was captivated after a few pages and read it in one day. The ending will literally have you staring at the wall trying to process what just happened. If you are searching for a disturbing, fucked up book that still has a plot and a POINT, this is a perfect candidate.
Highly recommend for fans of Bret Easton Ellis or Dennis Cooper (latter he mentions in the book!)
A fast-paced, fairly interesting look into a world filled with sex, violence and murder.
Unfortunately, despite the subject matter, a lot of this book felt fairly bland to me. Perhaps I'm just not easily shocked, but I felt a lot of the content was included just for the "shock factor" and the main character just didn't feel authentic to me.
What begins as a look at the queer scene of the city soon diverges into an unexpected organ heist plot, and while parts of this were more entertaining and I found the end very impactful, as a whole the novel just didn't really work for me.
Still, I'm glad I read it and I enjoyed the journey - I just wish I'd really loved it as I went in with high hopes.
At first I was like this is soooo crass and there’s no plot and then at the half way mark I was like ok what the actual hell have I gotten myself into???? No one is talking about this? I’d like to compare this to the shards by Bret Easton Ellis if I may. Plz hit up my line to discuss that further. Actually imagine my surprise after reading his memoir expecting something similar. Me and all my girls hate Kathy ackers.
Riveting! Released in 1994, it’s a non-stop journey about a rent boy from NYC, his love for a fellow rent boy, and a high-stakes drug-fuelled mess they’ve gotten into
Edgy: What can I say. It’s sexually edgy in a noir and ambiguous manner. It’s rough around the edges with an emotional sensibility deep within. The characters, the setting, and the workplaces are all morally cynical.
Dark humor: Dark or ire. However you want to describe the humor, there is one thing absolutely true: you will laugh. And when you are done laughing you will notice the graphic word play, the shame, the romanticism of narcotics and sexual taboos, and the grit within the words.
Ruthless: There’s a verbal spitfire that is inescapable. Not that you’re trying to run away anyways. You probably should, but you don’t because it’s electrifying and now you’re addicted to the candor.
Sensational: With its play on sophistication. The linguistic visual Indiana creates is transformative. I am sitting here and then I am all of a sudden back in time, in the throes of the forbidden and dangerous. I feel uncomfortable and I like it.