Once again Mr. Iggulden has written a very, very good historical novel. This entry in his Wars of the Roses series covers the time from just after the Battle of Wakefield to when Richard Neville, the Earl of Warwick AKA the King Maker, decides to throw his lot in with Lancastrian cause, roughly from 1460 – 1469. The novel is divided into two parts. The first part covers the time for just after the Battle of Wakefield to the Battle of Towton. I felt this section had some of the best and most evocative scenes in the novel. They included to impaling of the heads of the losers at Wakefield on the Micklegate Bar-one of the Gates of the City of York, the Lancastrian forces recovering Henry VI after the 2nd Battle of St. Albans, the refusal of the City of London to open its gates and welcome Henry and his queen and finally the authors depiction of the Battle of Towton.
The second part of the novel opens about 4 yrs after Towton and is more of a political potboiler than an adventure story. Mr. Iggulden tells the story of the fall of the Earl of Warwick. While it too has some excellent sequences, it moves much slower pace than the first part. In this half of the novel, the author looks at how Edward IV’s Queen, Elizabeth Woodville, moves to neutralize influence of the house of Neville and how that eventually drives Warwick into exile. The picture drawn of Warwick as he tries to figure out just what is happening to him and his family is very well done. Some of the events included in this section of the novel include John Neville’s, Warwick’s brother, “legal” executions of the Queen’s father and brother after being stripped of the Earldom of Northumberland, the embarrassment of Warwick at the King of France’s court as he is trying to negotiate a commercial treaty with France. In this scene Warwick is actually meeting the French King when he is told that Edward has concluded a treaty with Burgundy, France’s wayward Dukedom, totally embarrassing him in front of the French Court. The romance between Warwick’s daughter and the Kings brother is also well done as its consequences when the King forbids the wedding between the two.
As far as the characters go, most of those written about in the novel are actual historical figures. The main exception to this is Derry Brewer. He makes his return after being almost totally absent in the second novel of the series. His is depicted almost as Margaret’s, Henry VI's Queen and de facto leader of the Lancastrian cause, right hand man. He is always there to give advice and pass on intelligence. Sometimes the advice is good and sometimes it isn’t, but he still remains high in her esteem.
I felt that Warwick is portrayed fairly sympathically, especially in the second half of the novel. He is shown as feeling that he has earned his position as the most powerful non royal in England. He feels wronged by the Queen as she attempts to distance his family from the King and put her numerous relatives in place of the Nevilles. It all comes to a head when the Queen basically vetoes the marriage of Warwick’s daughter, Isabel, to Edward’s brother George, Duke of Clarence. The relationship between the two is portrayed as a love match. Warwick is depicted as not quite understanding why the King won’t approve the union. He sees it as a natural match – good for both the young people involved and at the same time cementing his family’s relationship with the Royal family. I thought the author did a good job a explaining the Queen’s reasons for strongly suggesting that the Edward not approve the match. The novel ends on Warwick and the two young lovers fleeing England and going ahead with the wedding despite Edward’s disapproval.
King Edward is the other main character of the novel. In the first half he is depicted as a head strong youth wanting revenge on those who killed his father. In the second half is pictured as totally infatuated with his wife and as willingly going along with her plans to disentangle the crown from the Nevilles in general and Warwick in particular. Obviously this back fires when Warwick flees England.
If there is a villain in the novel it is definitely Edward’s Queen, Elizabeth. She is portrayed as scheming and underhanded. She is not above using her influence on the King to get what she wants. That is usually displacing some Neville relative with one of her own family.
I thought the battle scenes, while not particularly gruesome where very well done, esp Towton. The movement of York’s army through the snow was really brought to life. In his author’s note, Mr. Iggulden says that if the high estimates are to be believed, Towton was even more deadly the first day of the Somme in 1916. In in contrast to the Somme and its machine guns and artillery, all the deaths at Towton were with arrows, swords, axes, billhooks, halberds and other edged weapons – hand to hand combat.
In summary, this is a very good historical novel. Mr. Iggulden brought me into the times and minds of those who experienced the chaos and uncertainty of those ten years. This just might be the best of the series and one of his best novels. I would give this 4.25 stars so I’ve rounded down for good reads.